Author Topic: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment  (Read 42776 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

icabodcrane

  • Guest
What is remarkable here, I think,  is that the Express have given the front page  ( and a striking headline ) to a story which cannot be called  'helpful' to the McCanns and their campaign

What does it matter what Robert Murat thinks Scotland Yard  should  be doing, afterall  ... why make a front page headline expressing his opinion on the matter ?

"Bring them all back to Portugal"  implies that the McCanns and their mates should be  'brought' back whether they like it or not

I'm wondering if this could be a shot across the bows to Gerry, post Leveson ...  a message that they  ( the press )  can be  'unhelpful'  in ways that are not directly addressed by the proposed Royal Charter

There is nothing remarkable about it - it's a way of selling papers and about as far as the Express dares go to publish a story with an angle that will appeal to those with an appetite for McCann-related scandal, gossip and intrigue.

Well it is remarkable Martha ...  the fact that you are  'remarking' on it is testimony in itself

Something else that I find remarkable is that having already spent four and a half million pounds on this review, Scotland Yard have not even spoken to Robert Murat

Four and a half  million pounds later  ...  and they havn't even spoken to the man who was an official suspect and Arguido !

Offline DCI

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 2585
  • Total likes: 6
  • Why are some folks so sick in the head!!!
What is remarkable here, I think,  is that the Express have given the front page  ( and a striking headline ) to a story which cannot be called  'helpful' to the McCanns and their campaign

What does it matter what Robert Murat thinks Scotland Yard  should  be doing, afterall  ... why make a front page headline expressing his opinion on the matter ?

"Bring them all back to Portugal"  implies that the McCanns and their mates should be  'brought' back whether they like it or not

I'm wondering if this could be a shot across the bows to Gerry, post Leveson ...  a message that they  ( the press )  can be  'unhelpful'  in ways that are not directly addressed by the proposed Royal Charter

Does seem odd, doesn't it?

Considering how scared he was of the PJ, Amaral mainly, seems odd he's opened his mouth now, when he's got to live there.
Kate's 500 Mile Cycle Challenge

https://www.justgiving.com/KateMcCann/

Offline Eleanor


Since there is absolutely no chance of anyone being forced back to Portugal, this is all a bit of a waste of time.

I recall having a biit of a dust-up with Sans on that point. 

I thought there was (at least a theoretical) chance they could be; he insisted there wasn't.

Sans is seldom wrong ...

Let's put it this way.  It ain't going to happen.

Offline DCI

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 2585
  • Total likes: 6
  • Why are some folks so sick in the head!!!

Since there is absolutely no chance of anyone being forced back to Portugal, this is all a bit of a waste of time.

I recall having a biit of a dust-up with Sans on that point. 

I thought there was (at least a theoretical) chance they could be; he insisted there wasn't.

Sans is seldom wrong ...

Let's put it this way.  It ain't going to happen.

There is something not sitting right with me about that interview - after all, why would the Yard interview Murat? He wasn't there, he saw nothing due to being in his mum's kitchen. So how could he be in a reconstruction?
 
IMO, he's acting almost as he did 6 years ago when he ended up being likened to Ian Huntley.
 
He's been cleared, he SHOULDN'T have been able to see anything, so why is he attracting attention to himself again?
Kate's 500 Mile Cycle Challenge

https://www.justgiving.com/KateMcCann/

icabodcrane

  • Guest

Since there is absolutely no chance of anyone being forced back to Portugal, this is all a bit of a waste of time.

I recall having a biit of a dust-up with Sans on that point. 

I thought there was (at least a theoretical) chance they could be; he insisted there wasn't.

Sans is seldom wrong ...

Let's put it this way.  It ain't going to happen.

There is something not sitting right with me about that interview - after all, why would the Yard interview Murat? He wasn't there, he saw nothing due to being in his mum's kitchen. So how could he be in a reconstruction?
 
IMO, he's acting almost as he did 6 years ago when he ended up being likened to Ian Huntley.
 
He's been cleared, he SHOULDN'T have been able to see anything, so why is he attracting attention to himself again?

Maybe  he isn't attracting attention to himself ...  maybe  he was actively persued by Express reporters  ( the reporter was in Murat's mother's home afterall  )

Maybe the Express wanted to  'get it out there'  that the Yard have spent a fortune and not even done the most fundemental investigation on the ground to justify that expense

Maybe they  used Murat to get that  critisism into the public domain,  and  through him suggest that the Yard should have done a reconstruction

Redblossom

  • Guest
Perhaps he is expressing an opinion on the case and its current status. He was after all made an arguido at the time, and was in the thick of everything for months if not more, he has as much right as anyone else to do so and probably more right than scores of outside  commentators who probably knew diddly squat.
« Last Edit: May 05, 2013, 03:35:43 PM by Redblossom »

Offline DCI

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 2585
  • Total likes: 6
  • Why are some folks so sick in the head!!!

Maybe  he isn't attracting attention to himself ...  maybe  he was actively persued by Express reporters  ( the reporter was in Murat's mother's home afterall  )

Maybe the Express wanted to  'get it out there'  that the Yard have spent a fortune and not even done the most fundemental investigation on the ground to justify that expense

Maybe they  used Murat to get that  critisism into the public domain,  and  through him suggest that the Yard should have done a reconstruction

Maybe  he isn't attracting attention to himself ...  maybe  he was actively persued by Express reporters  ( the reporter was in Murat's mother's home afterall  )

If he was pursued by the Express, why not decline comment, like he has for 6 years. Being in his mothers villa, makes it even more suspect. Murray would have to have been invited in, its like Fort Knox, getting into that villa.

Maybe they  used Murat to get that  critisism into the public domain,  and  through him suggest that the Yard should have done a reconstruction

Do you think Murat, is that dumb?  Unless the Euro's were high, why would the Express need him as their mouth piece. Have you thought that maybe SY have been denied being allowed to do a reconstruction

Maybe they  used Murat to get that  critisism into the public domain,  and  through him suggest that the Yard should have done a reconstruction.

Somehow I don't think Murat, would be needed, to get that critisism into the public domain. Can you see SY, taking the slightest bit of notice, of what Murat says? Who is he, to tell them what to do?
Kate's 500 Mile Cycle Challenge

https://www.justgiving.com/KateMcCann/

Redblossom

  • Guest
Somehow I don't think Murat, would be needed, to get that critisism into the public domain. Can you see SY, taking the slightest bit of notice, of what Murat says? Who is he, to tell them what to do?
******
No different to the Mccanns telling them what to do, both are trying to get to the truth arent they? Does anyone have a monopoly here? There are still lots of people who suspect Robert Murat, so its totally within his rights to express his opinions.

Murat  was involved in the searches, in helping translate witness statements, liaising with police, was made arguido, I would think SY would take some notice, dont you think? The way you portray him is as if he is some non entity. Rather silly.
« Last Edit: May 05, 2013, 04:21:04 PM by Redblossom »

icabodcrane

  • Guest

 

If he was pursued by the Express, why not decline comment, like he has for 6 years. Being in his mothers villa, makes it even more suspect. Murray would have to have been invited in, its like Fort Knox, getting into that villa.



Why on earth should Robert Murat   'decline'  an invitation from the press to offer his opinion ?

Is he expected to keep his mouth shut for some reason ?

...  and what is 'suspicious'  about him having taken the opportunity to express an opinion on a suject that has so affected his life ?

Redblossom

  • Guest

Offline Benice

Somehow I don't think Murat, would be needed, to get that critisism into the public domain. Can you see SY, taking the slightest bit of notice, of what Murat says? Who is he, to tell them what to do?
******
No different to the Mccanns telling them what to do, both are trying to get to the truth arent they? Does anyone have a monopoly here? There are still lots of people who suspect Robert Murat, so its totally within his rights to express his opinions.

Murat  was involved in the searches, in helping translate witness statements, liaising with police, was made arguido, I would think SY would take some notice, dont you think? The way you portray him is as if he is some non entity. Rather silly.

Just because SY haven't seen him yet doesn't mean they don't intend to at some stage.   However, they are hardly going to give advance notification to the public (or the press) of any such intentions are they?   We shall have to wait and see.


The notion that innocence prevails over guilt – when there is no evidence to the contrary – is what separates civilization from barbarism.    Unfortunately, there are remains of barbarism among us.    Until very recently, it headed the PJ in Portimão. I hope he was the last one.
                                               Henrique Monteiro, chief editor, Expresso, Portugal

Offline DCI

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 2585
  • Total likes: 6
  • Why are some folks so sick in the head!!!

 

If he was pursued by the Express, why not decline comment, like he has for 6 years. Being in his mothers villa, makes it even more suspect. Murray would have to have been invited in, its like Fort Knox, getting into that villa.



Why on earth should Robert Murat   'decline'  an invitation from the press to offer his opinion ?

Is he expected to keep his mouth shut for some reason ?

...  and what is 'suspicious'  about him having taken the opportunity to express an opinion on a suject that has so affected his life ?

One answer to your 3 questions, Why now?  8-)(--)
Kate's 500 Mile Cycle Challenge

https://www.justgiving.com/KateMcCann/

icabodcrane

  • Guest
Somehow I don't think Murat, would be needed, to get that critisism into the public domain. Can you see SY, taking the slightest bit of notice, of what Murat says? Who is he, to tell them what to do?
******
No different to the Mccanns telling them what to do, both are trying to get to the truth arent they? Does anyone have a monopoly here? There are still lots of people who suspect Robert Murat, so its totally within his rights to express his opinions.

Murat  was involved in the searches, in helping translate witness statements, liaising with police, was made arguido, I would think SY would take some notice, dont you think? The way you portray him is as if he is some non entity. Rather silly.

Just because SY haven't seen him yet doesn't mean they don't intend to at some stage.   However, they are hardly going to give advance notification to the public (or the press) of any such intentions are they?   We shall have to wait and see.

Well they found time to see that crooked shower, Metado 3,  many months ago ... surely interviewing key witnesses/former Arguidos should have been prioritized over that ? 

Offline DCI

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 2585
  • Total likes: 6
  • Why are some folks so sick in the head!!!
Somehow I don't think Murat, would be needed, to get that critisism into the public domain. Can you see SY, taking the slightest bit of notice, of what Murat says? Who is he, to tell them what to do?
******
No different to the Mccanns telling them what to do, both are trying to get to the truth arent they? Does anyone have a monopoly here? There are still lots of people who suspect Robert Murat, so its totally within his rights to express his opinions.

Murat  was involved in the searches, in helping translate witness statements, liaising with police, was made arguido, I would think SY would take some notice, dont you think? The way you portray him is as if he is some non entity. Rather silly.

Just because SY haven't seen him yet doesn't mean they don't intend to at some stage.   However, they are hardly going to give advance notification to the public (or the press) of any such intentions are they?   We shall have to wait and see.

Well they found time to see that crooked shower, Metado 3,  many months ago ... surely interviewing key witnesses/former Arguidos should have been prioritized over that ?

Yes and apparently Metado3 gave them some good info, that was not acted upon, by Amaral.

But he's not a key witness, is he? He wasn't there, remember!
So if he suddenly knows something, that might help SY now, he's lied for 6 years. He can't have it both ways!
Kate's 500 Mile Cycle Challenge

https://www.justgiving.com/KateMcCann/

icabodcrane

  • Guest
Somehow I don't think Murat, would be needed, to get that critisism into the public domain. Can you see SY, taking the slightest bit of notice, of what Murat says? Who is he, to tell them what to do?
******
No different to the Mccanns telling them what to do, both are trying to get to the truth arent they? Does anyone have a monopoly here? There are still lots of people who suspect Robert Murat, so its totally within his rights to express his opinions.

Murat  was involved in the searches, in helping translate witness statements, liaising with police, was made arguido, I would think SY would take some notice, dont you think? The way you portray him is as if he is some non entity. Rather silly.

Just because SY haven't seen him yet doesn't mean they don't intend to at some stage.   However, they are hardly going to give advance notification to the public (or the press) of any such intentions are they?   We shall have to wait and see.

Well they found time to see that crooked shower, Metado 3,  many months ago ... surely interviewing key witnesses/former Arguidos should have been prioritized over that ?

Yes and apparently Metado3 gave them some good info, that was not acted upon, by Amaral.

But he's not a key witness, is he? He wasn't there, remember!
So if he suddenly knows something, that might help SY now, he's lied for 6 years. He can't have it both ways!

He acted as translator in those early police interviews didn't he ?  ...  he knows plenty

And as to the criminal Metado 3 crew ...  whatever they turned over to Scotland Yard wasn't that  good was it ?  ...  certainly not good enough to get the case re-opened in Portugal