UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: stephen25000 on July 11, 2014, 05:10:33 PM

Title: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: stephen25000 on July 11, 2014, 05:10:33 PM
The mccanns have already admitted there are people on the net acting on their behalf.



Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Jean-Pierre on July 11, 2014, 05:33:27 PM
"The mccanns have already admitted there are people on the net acting on their behalf."

Stephen - could you remind me of where this appears and the context?
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Wonderfulspam on July 11, 2014, 05:38:45 PM
"The mccanns have already admitted there are people on the net acting on their behalf."

Stephen - could you remind me of where this appears and the context?

The first witness of the session is Michael Wright, an administrator, whose wife is Kate McCann's cousin. He has known Kate since she was ten years of age and Gerald McCann since 2001. They used to have regular contact.

ID - Did the McCanns learn about these forums? How?
MW They learned through me, the family members who monitored the activity and their support group.

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=2335.0


Kate Healy - The reactions were less negative than in Portugal, due to the newspapers in England who were sued for defamatory articles, those articles weren't based on evidence. We have people that monitor the internet and there are groups of people, like the 'Madeleine Foundation' who have caused us great distress by publishing Mr. Amaral's theories on the internet, which has compounded to our vilification.

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=4745.msg172157#msg172157
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: gilet on July 11, 2014, 05:47:10 PM
The first witness of the session is Michael Wright, an administrator, whose wife is Kate McCann's cousin. He has known Kate since she was ten years of age and Gerald McCann since 2001. They used to have regular contact.

ID - Did the McCanns learn about these forums? How?
MW They learned through me, the family members who monitored the activity and their support group.

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=2335.0


Kate Healy - The reactions were less negative than in Portugal, due to the newspapers in England who were sued for defamatory articles, those articles weren't based on evidence. We have people that monitor the internet and there are groups of people, like the 'Madeleine Foundation' who have caused us great distress by publishing Mr. Amaral's theories on the internet, which has compounded to our vilification.

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=4745.msg172157#msg172157

Are you posting that as evidence for the claim that Stephen made about "'posters' on the net, acting on behalf of the mccanns" (sic)?

If so you really are being very silly.

Are you not aware that the two verbs "monitor" and "post" have different meanings?


Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Wonderfulspam on July 11, 2014, 05:53:18 PM
Are you posting that as evidence for the claim that Stephen made about "'posters' on the net, acting on behalf of the mccanns" (sic)?

If so you really are being very silly.

Are you not aware that the two verbs "monitor" and "post" have different meanings?



I have absolutely no doubt that they only monitor & never, ever, post a single thing.

I also believe in father christmas, fairies at the bottom of the garden & that Madeleine McCann was abducted.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: pegasus on July 12, 2014, 05:26:28 PM
Would it be naive to imagine that the relevant lawyers are not already looking at the "right to be forgotten" ruling?
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Mr Gray on July 12, 2014, 05:37:05 PM
Stephen has read one thing and understood it to mean something else...as has been said...monitoring and posting are two completely different things
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: pegasus on July 12, 2014, 05:54:32 PM
A warning from the bench?
"... There are other forums and chatrooms which are totally a free-for-all, and I'm afraid they are a real cesspit of speculation innuendo and downright defamation. Our lawyers are aware of that, I'm aware of it, and there are ways and means of dealing with that too, so if we need to, we will ..."
http://youtu.be/F9wzbzivUTk?t=2m30s
BTW "bench" was my attempt at a double-entendre 8)--))
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: stephen25000 on July 13, 2014, 07:38:17 AM
The sheer absurdity that some people 'think' there aren't people acting on behalf of the mccanns on the net posting on certain sites is sublimely ridiculous.

As has been visible on here, the depths of illogic which some go to back them is simply staggering.

Also, mccann supporters, including at least one here openly has admitted to meeting them.

Enough said.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Eleanor on July 13, 2014, 07:58:24 AM

Good Morning, Stephen.

What exactly do you mean by, "Acting on behalf of The McCanns?"  I support The McCanns, but I don't act on behalf of them.

There is a Specific Support Group, who as far as I am aware, are supporting The McCanns for the same reasons that I do. Because we think that The McCanns are innocent, at least until proven guilty.

There might be family members in the support group, and why should there not be?  Should they in some way be barred from commenting or reading in the same way that you and I do?
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: stephen25000 on July 13, 2014, 08:07:28 AM
Good Morning, Stephen.

What exactly do you mean by, "Acting on behalf of The McCanns?"  I support The McCanns, but I don't act on behalf of them.

There is a Specific Support Group, who as far as I am aware, are supporting The McCanns for the same reasons that I do. Because we think that The McCanns are innocent, at least until proven guilty.

There might be family members in the support group, and why should there not be?  Should they in some way be barred from commenting or reading in the same way that you and I do?

Good morning Eleanor.

I have no problems if people wish to support the mccanns.

What I don't believe is when people say there are not others posting on their behalf.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Eleanor on July 13, 2014, 08:16:16 AM
Good morning Eleanor.

I have no problems if people wish to support the mccanns.

What I don't believe is when people say there are not others posting on their behalf.

What does "Behalf" mean in your understanding?

There have been rumours abounding for seven years now that we are all getting paid to do this.  Personally, I do it for free.

Are Amaral supporters getting paid?  I shouldn't think so.  But some members of his family could be posting on his behalf.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: stephen25000 on July 13, 2014, 08:18:55 AM
What does "Behalf" mean in your understanding?

There have been rumours abounding for seven years now that we are all getting paid to do this.  Personally, I do it for free.

Are Amaral supporters getting paid?  I shouldn't think so.  But some members of his family could be posting on his behalf.

I've heard the rumours to.

As you know rumours are difficult to prove.

and I agree it could well be possible Amaral's relations could post on his behalf.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Eleanor on July 13, 2014, 08:33:58 AM
I've heard the rumours to.

As you know rumours are difficult to prove.

and I agree it could well be possible Amaral's relations could post on his behalf.

All I can say to the rumours, Stephen, is that I would be a very wealthy woman if they were true.  And I wouldn't be sitting around posting on an Internet Forum for very much longer.

Watch this space.

You still haven't told me what you think "Behalf" is.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Benice on July 13, 2014, 08:37:56 AM
The sheer absurdity that some people 'think' there aren't people acting on behalf of the mccanns on the net posting on certain sites is sublimely ridiculous.

As has been visible on here, the depths of illogic which some go to back them is simply staggering.

Also, mccann supporters, including at least one here openly has admitted to meeting them.

Enough said.


If you believe that Stephen -  then surely by the same token anyone could claim that there are people on the net who are obviously posting on behalf of the abductors and whose remit is to spend their time repeatedly trying to persuade the world to blame the McCanns - in order to deflect attention away from the monsters who took Madeleine.

Having read sites where the posters often discuss amongst themselves the various types of violence they would 'love' to inflict on the McCanns - then I think it would be very unwise NOT to monitor them.   IMO it is obvious there are some very nasty and seriously unhinged people out there.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: stephen25000 on July 13, 2014, 08:45:10 AM

If you believe that Stephen -  then surely by the same token anyone could claim that there are people on the net who are obviously posting on behalf of the abductors and whose remit is to spend their time repeatedly trying to persuade the world to blame the McCanns - in order to deflect attention away from the monsters who took Madeleine.

Having read sites where the posters often discuss amongst themselves the various types of violence they would 'love' to inflict on the McCanns - then I think it would be very unwise NOT to monitor them.   IMO it is obvious there are some very nasty and seriously unhinged people out there.

There are some seriously unhinged people who belong to both camps Benice.

As to 'abductors', you already know i don't believe that.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Mr Gray on July 13, 2014, 09:11:52 AM
There are some seriously unhinged people who belong to both camps Benice.

As to 'abductors', you already know i don't believe that.

and we know that SY do
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Benice on July 13, 2014, 09:46:41 AM
There are some seriously unhinged people who belong to both camps Benice.

As to 'abductors', you already know i don't believe that.


With hand on heart I have never read any threats to kick, punch, waterboard or shoot Amaral anywhere on the net.    And those are just a few of the threats of violence I've read made against the McCann family.

Whether you believe in the abduction or not  - as a family man yourself - wouldn't you expect those sadistic, hate filled posters who openly advocate violence against one family to be monitored?

Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: stephen25000 on July 13, 2014, 09:50:56 AM

With hand on heart I have never read any threats to kick, punch, waterboard or shoot Amaral anywhere on the net.    And those are just a few of the threats of violence I've read made against the McCann family.

Whether you believe in the abduction or not  - as a family man yourself - wouldn't you expect those sadistic, hate filled posters who openly advocate violence against one family to be monitored?

Read around a bit more.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Benice on July 13, 2014, 10:04:31 AM
Read around a bit more.

Please could you answer my question:

quote
''Whether you believe in the abduction or not  - as a family man yourself - wouldn't you expect those sadistic, hate filled posters who openly advocate violence against one family to be monitored?''
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: stephen25000 on July 13, 2014, 11:19:14 AM
Please could you answer my question:

quote
''Whether you believe in the abduction or not  - as a family man yourself - wouldn't you expect those sadistic, hate filled posters who openly advocate violence against one family to be monitored?''

If you had read any of any of my posts in the past, I abhor violence or threats of violence, from whereever it comes, mccann supporter or not.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on July 13, 2014, 01:06:54 PM
And then there was our dear friend "Laffin Assassin"

Sean Hyland, 50, was cautioned last year over hateful remarks he made about Kate and Gerry McCann and their spokesman.

http://www.dailystar.co.uk/news/latest-news/248474/Vile-troll-s-warning-to-McCanns
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: faithlilly on July 13, 2014, 01:15:16 PM
And then there was our dear friend "Laffin Assassin"

Sean Hyland, 50, was cautioned last year over hateful remarks he made about Kate and Gerry McCann and their spokesman.

http://www.dailystar.co.uk/news/latest-news/248474/Vile-troll-s-warning-to-McCanns

So one harassment warning but for messages left on Mitchell's answerphone and comments left on forums, actions that are not to be condoned but falling very short of ' threats of violence'.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Brietta on July 13, 2014, 01:32:12 PM
No she wasn't. She contacted the police and explained what had happened and basically they said she had been foolish and not to do it again.

Just 'normal' behaviour applauded by like minded chums ... no need for me to add anything ... trying to excuse people intent on organising such sick actions shows up everyone involved for exactly what they are.

 - SNIP - Under a link to a newspaper story on the event, the weirdo wrote: "Well I am going. Anyone got a gun? BBBanggggg!"

Other trolls, who have made Kate and husband Gerry's lives hell with smears, piled in with further sick comments.

One warped user wrote: "What would really spook her is if she is surrounded by a group all wearing Madeleine face masks."

A few made jokes about entering police sniffer dogs into the event to chase after Kate.
http://www.mccannfiles.com/id438.html
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: faithlilly on July 13, 2014, 02:04:55 PM
Just 'normal' behaviour applauded by like minded chums ... no need for me to add anything ... trying to excuse people intent on organising such sick actions shows up everyone involved for exactly what they are.

 - SNIP - Under a link to a newspaper story on the event, the weirdo wrote: "Well I am going. Anyone got a gun? BBBanggggg!"

Other trolls, who have made Kate and husband Gerry's lives hell with smears, piled in with further sick comments.

One warped user wrote: "What would really spook her is if she is surrounded by a group all wearing Madeleine face masks."

A few made jokes about entering police sniffer dogs into the event to chase after Kate.
http://www.mccannfiles.com/id438.html

For someone who has been the victim of a supporter's campaign to find where I worked in order to inform my employers of my McCann-sceptic posts, and in the meantime contacting the employers of a poor woman with the same name as myself, I think it's rather rich of you to take the moral high ground.

In my time I have seen supporters use deaths in the family, sexual abuse, disability and mental health problems as subjects with which to harangue sceptics. I have seen one woman driven nearly mad by threats from supporters when they managed to obtain her phone number. I have seen sceptic's children targeted by supporters by the posting their photographs on their blogs.

So please don't pretend that there aren't lunatics on both sides and further don't pretend for one minute that the harassment that the McCanns suffer at the hands of a very few idiots is any more frightening than the harassment that many sceptics suffer at the hands of their supporters.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on July 13, 2014, 03:07:14 PM
Bearing in mind the sheer volume of abuse and regular threats to harm (and who is to say which of these threats is just "having a laugh"  versus the ravings of a violent, obsessed mind?) directed at these parents of a missing child, who can blame them for having people that monitor this online abuse?  What does monitoring the internet for threats to your safety and well-being mean with regard to your own integrity and honesty?  Does it make you a bad person?  Should you be criticised for having people who monitor the internet for you, and if so why? 
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Wonderfulspam on July 13, 2014, 03:26:02 PM
Bearing in mind the sheer volume of abuse and regular threats to harm (and who is to say which of these threats is just "having a laugh"  versus the ravings of a violent, obsessed mind?) directed at these parents of a missing child, who can blame them for having people that monitor this online abuse?  What does monitoring the internet for threats to your safety and well-being mean with regard to your own integrity and honesty?  Does it make you a bad person?  Should you be criticised for having people who monitor the internet for you, and if so why? 

I wonder if monitoring the internet counts as searching for their missing daughter.

Maybe she'll turn up in a forum one day.

Perhaps if the McCanns were less concerned about what people thought of them & were genuinely searching for Madeleine, instead of having people monitoring the internet for them, they could employ them to get off their arses & do a bit of searching instead, who knows, maybe she'd be home in time for Christmas.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: stephen25000 on July 13, 2014, 03:34:30 PM
For someone who has been the victim of a supporter's campaign to find where I worked in order to inform my employers of my McCann-sceptic posts, and in the meantime contacting the employers of a poor woman with the same name as myself, I think it's rather rich of you to take the moral high ground.

In my time I have seen supporters use deaths in the family, sexual abuse, disability and mental health problems as subjects with which to harangue sceptics. I have seen one woman driven nearly mad by threats from supporters when they managed to obtain her phone number. I have seen sceptic's children targeted by supporters by the posting their photographs on their blogs.

So please don't pretend that there aren't lunatics on both sides and further don't pretend for one minute that the harassment that the McCanns suffer at the hands of a very few idiots is any more frightening than the harassment that many sceptics suffer at the hands of their supporters.

Excellent post. It puts pay to the rubbish from mccann supporters that the abuse is one way traffic.

 8@??)( 8@??)( 8@??)(
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on July 13, 2014, 03:48:57 PM
I wonder if monitoring the internet counts as searching for their missing daughter.

Maybe she'll turn up in a forum one day.

Perhaps if the McCanns were less concerned about what people thought of them & were genuinely searching for Madeleine, instead of having people monitoring the internet for them, they could employ them to get off their arses & do a bit of searching instead, who knows, maybe she'd be home in time for Christmas.
Firstly, what does having people monitoring the internet for you have to do with searching for your missing child?  It is possible to have people monitoring the internet  while you get on with other activities, is it not?
Secondly, what searching would you expect the McCanns to be doing at this stage, bearing in mind that there is a 30 strong team investigating their child's disappearance currently?
Thirdly, how about actually answering some of the questions I posed in my post all of which you ignored?
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Brietta on July 13, 2014, 04:41:29 PM
For someone who has been the victim of a supporter's campaign to find where I worked in order to inform my employers of my McCann-sceptic posts, and in the meantime contacting the employers of a poor woman with the same name as myself, I think it's rather rich of you to take the moral high ground.

In my time I have seen supporters use deaths in the family, sexual abuse, disability and mental health problems as subjects with which to harangue sceptics. I have seen one woman driven nearly mad by threats from supporters when they managed to obtain her phone number. I have seen sceptic's children targeted by supporters by the posting their photographs on their blogs.

So please don't pretend that there aren't lunatics on both sides and further don't pretend for one minute that the harassment that the McCanns suffer at the hands of a very few idiots is any more frightening than the harassment that many sceptics suffer at the hands of their supporters.

I note that you fall far short of condemning the insanity and volume of the abuse directed at the Drs McCann, who I may remind you are the parents of a missing child.

I also note that what you are describing is the situation being suffered day and daily but multiplied thousands fold by the McCann family. 

It says a lot about you that while you condemn isolated incidents you fail to condemn organised campaigns against people you do not know but have decided views about. Why is that?
You ignore the danger implicit in goading seriously disturbed individuals into action against the targets of this organised vitriol.  Why is that? 

What kind of mind is it that would even think of putting on a ‘madeleine’ face mask … a child who is missing ... and surrounding her mother while she is running to raise money for the charity set up to assist in publicising missing people and assisting their families?   
IMO a very disturbed mind indeed.

Yet in a certain section of society ... it met with universal approval ... and I note you do not distance yourself from it.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: DCI on July 13, 2014, 04:58:52 PM
The mccanns have already admitted there are people on the net acting on their behalf.

And Amaral hasn't?
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: jassi on July 13, 2014, 05:00:41 PM
And Amaral hasn't?


I don't know. Do you know or are you just speculating?
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: stephen25000 on July 13, 2014, 05:15:45 PM

I don't know. Do you know or are you just speculating?

The 1-dimensional nature of some mccann supporters only reinforces the distinct impression that they only care about the parents, on whom the responsibility for this whole case falls.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on July 13, 2014, 05:17:01 PM
I note that you fall far short of condemning the insanity and volume of the abuse directed at the Drs McCann, who I may remind you are the parents of a missing child.

I also note that what you are describing is the situation being suffered day and daily but multiplied thousands fold by the McCann family. 

It says a lot about you that while you condemn isolated incidents you fail to condemn organised campaigns against people you do not know but have decided views about. Why is that?
You ignore the danger implicit in goading seriously disturbed individuals into action against the targets of this organised vitriol.  Why is that? 

What kind of mind is it that would even think of putting on a ‘madeleine’ face mask … a child who is missing ... and surrounding her mother while she is running to raise money for the charity set up to assist in publicising missing people and assisting their families?   
IMO a very disturbed mind indeed.

Yet in a certain section of society ... it met with universal approval ... and I note you do not distance yourself from it.
Everything "Faithlilly" describes as having been suffered by herself and fellow sceptics applies also to many McCann supporters so that kind of cancels that argument out, leaving the daily victimisation and abuse of  the McCanns and their family as the subject of discussion here.  Her argument is typical "sceptic" deflection from the point of the thread - i.e:  is there anything intrinsically wrong or suspicious about the McCanns having people monitoring the net for them?
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: slartibartfast on July 13, 2014, 05:21:51 PM
Everything "Faithlilly" describes as having been suffered by herself and fellow sceptics applies also to many McCann supporters so that kind of cancels that argument out, leaving the daily victimisation and abuse of  the McCanns and their family as the subject of discussion here.  Her argument is typical "sceptic" deflection from the point of the thread - i.e:  is there anything intrinsically wrong or suspicious about the McCanns having people monitoring the net for them?

It doesn't cancel anything out, 2 wrongs do not make a right. No one should be abusing anyone about the case. Expressing belief or doubt about the McCann's story should not make one a target of abuse.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: stephen25000 on July 13, 2014, 05:22:42 PM
Everything "Faithlilly" describes as having been suffered by herself and fellow sceptics applies also to many McCann supporters so that kind of cancels that argument out, leaving the daily victimisation and abuse of  the McCanns and their family as the subject of discussion here.  Her argument is typical "sceptic" deflection from the point of the thread - i.e:  is there anything intrinsically wrong or suspicious about the McCanns having people monitoring the net for them?

Faithlilly  is hardly the only mccann skeptic to receive abuse.


Why is it mccann supporters won't accept it has happened in both directions ?


Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: stephen25000 on July 13, 2014, 05:24:00 PM
It doesn't cancel anything out, 2 wrongs do not make a right. No one should be abusing anyone about the case. Expressing belief or doubt about the McCann's story should not make one a target of abuse.

Precisely, and it happens on here as well.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: DCI on July 13, 2014, 05:29:42 PM
It doesn't cancel anything out, 2 wrongs do not make a right. No one should be abusing anyone about the case. Expressing belief or doubt about the McCann's story should not make one a target of abuse.

Expressing belief or doubt about the Amaral's story should not make one a target of abuse, either.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: slartibartfast on July 13, 2014, 05:31:39 PM
Expressing belief or doubt about the Amaral's story should not make one a target of abuse, either.

That is irrelevant, his story was his opinion about the McCann Story so not a separate issue.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: stephen25000 on July 13, 2014, 05:33:59 PM
Expressing belief or doubt about the Amaral's story should not make one a target of abuse, either.

True enough, but as you know when tempers get frayed, as we have seen on here, it happens.

Though fairly 'mildly' compared to other sites.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on July 13, 2014, 05:41:21 PM
It doesn't cancel anything out, 2 wrongs do not make a right. No one should be abusing anyone about the case. Expressing belief or doubt about the McCann's story should not make one a target of abuse.

Where did I say 2 wrongs make a right?  The abuse of sceptics is at least equal to the abuse of McCann supporters and is not the subject of discussion here. 
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Brietta on July 13, 2014, 05:44:33 PM
There certainly should be people monitoring the internet; there should be arrests and prosecutions as well as an official inquiry into why incitement to hatred has been allowed for well over six years. 

I consider this is part of the real McCann Circus which should have been STOPped with the full force of law; a real break down in policing and law and order.

I think it is time to step back and take stock of exactly where this statement emanates from - "We have people that monitor the internet". 
Dr Kate McCann did not say it;
Dr Gerry McCann did not say it;
Anne Guedes did not write it in her court report; ... but … Joana Morais did.

So like a great deal of the 'couthy' sayings that have entered into legend in Madeleine’s case … the originator is none other than Joana Morais.

 - CLIP - Written by Joana Morais - Judge Maria Emília de Melo e Castro allows a question put by Dr. Isabel Duarte - What were the reactions to the book and to the documentary in England?

Kate Healy - The reactions were less negative than in Portugal, due to the newspapers in England who were sued for defamatory articles, those articles weren't based on evidence. We have people that monitor the internet and there are groups of people, like the 'Madeleine Foundation' who have caused us great distress by publishing Mr. Amaral's theories on the internet, which has compounded to our vilification.

 - CLIP - Written by Anne Guedes - Isabel Duarte (for the plaintiffs) – Was there a reaction to the book and the documentary in the UK?
Judge reformulates but keeps the question

KMC says that there were a bit less reactions than in Portugal and that it was because of the media who accepted what the book said and published reports upon it. People on the Web and through e-mails were stimulated to insult them, like the Madeleine Foundation, and created a lot of damages. As Gonçalo Amaral was the coordinator of the investigation, it provided him credibility and it intensified the vilification of them.
http://www.justpamalam.co.uk/Kate_McCann_08_07_2014.htm

Spot the difference?  But why falsify a court report ... people will notice when the official version is published? 

IMO the audience to which it is directed, won't care, just another myth for addition to all the other discredited myths about Madeleine's family.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: slartibartfast on July 13, 2014, 05:48:25 PM
Where did I say 2 wrongs make a right?  The abuse of sceptics is at least equal to the abuse of McCann supporters and is not the subject of discussion here.

If you can accept that questioning or having doubts about the McCann's story does not equal abuse of the McCanns then I can accept that.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: faithlilly on July 13, 2014, 05:48:25 PM
I note that you fall far short of condemning the insanity and volume of the abuse directed at the Drs McCann, who I may remind you are the parents of a missing child.

I also note that what you are describing is the situation being suffered day and daily but multiplied thousands fold by the McCann family. 

It says a lot about you that while you condemn isolated incidents you fail to condemn organised campaigns against people you do not know but have decided views about. Why is that?
You ignore the danger implicit in goading seriously disturbed individuals into action against the targets of this organised vitriol.  Why is that? 

What kind of mind is it that would even think of putting on a ‘madeleine’ face mask … a child who is missing ... and surrounding her mother while she is running to raise money for the charity set up to assist in publicising missing people and assisting their families?   
IMO a very disturbed mind indeed.

Yet in a certain section of society ... it met with universal approval ... and I note you do not distance yourself from it.

And I ask you what kind of obsessed individual would attempt to get a person sacked with all the financial implications it may have for the person and their family simply because  you do not agree on the criminal culpability of a couple neither of you know ?
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Brietta on July 13, 2014, 06:16:11 PM
I condemn all such behaviour no matter what side it comes from. I notice though no supporter has condemned such behaviour when it's targeted at sceptics

But you still do not condemn the long running, organised campaigns to vilify the family of a missing child, which extends to the child herself when attempts are made to interfere with and impede the investigation into exactly what happened to her.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: faithlilly on July 13, 2014, 06:23:37 PM
But you still do not condemn the long running, organised campaigns to vilify the family of a missing child, which extends to the child herself when attempts are made to interfere with and impede the investigation into exactly what happened to her.

I do not condemn the perfectly legal discussion of this case.

Now do you condemn the targeting of sceptics by supporters simply because they have a different opinion ?
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Mr Gray on July 13, 2014, 06:29:14 PM
I do not condemn the perfectly legal discussion of this case.

Now do you condemn the targeting of sceptics by supporters simply because they have a different opinion ?

so you don't condemn the long running campaign to vilify the parents...as its quite legal...but extremely nasty....any harassment you incur by doing this I think you fully deserve..as long as its legal of course
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on July 13, 2014, 06:30:46 PM
If you can accept that questioning or having doubts about the McCann's story does not equal abuse of the McCanns then I can accept that.
No I'm sorry I can't accept that, because you and I know that this "questioning" and "having doubts" (which sounds all innocent and wide-eyed when described in those terms) amounts to a lot more than just "questioning" and "having doubts".  It's almost invariably accompanied by a combination of at least one of the following: snide, insulting written observations, "satirical" pictures, abusive forum names and avatars, out-right libellous accusation, myths and lies, snooping and prying into the family's personal affairs, campaigning against them by writing letters, spamming newspaper articles, actively seeking out new people to "convert" to the sceptic cause etc.  By all means have your doubts and your questions, but when it crosses the line is when it is accompanied by any of the above behaviour.  Then it becomes abuse of the parents of a missing child, which is not acceptable in any decent civilised society, in my opinion. 
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: slartibartfast on July 13, 2014, 06:38:48 PM
No I'm sorry I can't accept that, because you and I know that this "questioning" and "having doubts" (which sounds all innocent and wide-eyed when described in those terms) amounts to a lot more than just "questioning" and "having doubts".  It's almost invariably accompanied by a combination of at least one of the following: snide, insulting written observations, "satirical" pictures, abusive forum names and avatars, out-right libellous accusation, myths and lies, snooping and prying into the family's personal affairs, campaigning against them by writing letters, spamming newspaper articles, actively seeking out new people to "convert" to the sceptic cause etc.  By all means have your doubts and your questions, but when it crosses the line is when it is accompanied by any of the above behaviour.  Then it becomes abuse of the parents of a missing child, which is not acceptable in any decent civilised society, in my opinion.

So from your second to last sentence, you do accept the questioning or having doubts about the McCann's story is not abuse.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on July 13, 2014, 06:46:30 PM
So from your second to last sentence, you do accept the questioning or having doubts about the McCann's story is not abuse.
Did you not read my post, or do I have to repeat myself?  The vast majority of "questioning" and "doubting" is accompanied by McCann abuse in one form or another.  To its credit this forum is just about the only place on the internet where there is some attempt to limit the abuse but it is not always very successful.  If all posters who questioned  and doubted were like Pegasus (who I assume is a sceptic) then I would not class that as abusive per se, but he or she is a rare fish indeed. 
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: faithlilly on July 13, 2014, 06:59:59 PM
I'm sure the behaviour that you describe is illegal so no I do not condone it.

Now please answer my question. 
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Brietta on July 13, 2014, 07:00:29 PM
I do not condemn the perfectly legal discussion of this case.

Now do you condemn the targeting of sceptics by supporters simply because they have a different opinion ?

I strongly support the targetting by the requisite authorities of those who take part in abusive internet activities which everyone taking part in this discussion is familiar with.
Many of these persons should have been hauled in years ago and questioned with a view to prosecution; I deplore that the police have done this only to the more extreme.


Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: jassi on July 13, 2014, 07:04:12 PM
I strongly support the targetting by the requisite authorities of those who take part in abusive internet activities which everyone taking part in this discussion is familiar with.
Many of these persons should have been hauled in years ago and questioned with a view to prosecution; I deplore that the police have done this only to the more extreme.

Obviously theses people have not omitted any actual crime, other than offending your concept of what is right.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: faithlilly on July 13, 2014, 07:05:56 PM
I strongly support the targetting by the requisite authorities of those who take part in abusive internet activities which everyone taking part in this discussion is familiar with.
Many of these persons should have been hauled in years ago and questioned with a view to prosecution; I deplore that the police have done this only to the more extreme.

Why are you so loath to condemn your fellow supporters Brietta ?

Do you believe jeopardising someone's livelihood because you do not agree with them is ever justifiable ?
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Brietta on July 13, 2014, 07:06:31 PM
I'm sure the behaviour that you describe is illegal so no I do not condone it.

Now please answer my question.

I do not tolerate abuse or bullying of any kind ... as should be plain from what I post.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: faithlilly on July 13, 2014, 07:09:00 PM
I do not tolerate abuse or bullying of any kind ... as should be plain from what I post.

So I take it from your reply you condemn your fellow supporters for doing so ?

Thank you Brietta.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Brietta on July 13, 2014, 07:11:01 PM
Why are you so loath to condemn your fellow supporters Brietta ?

Do you believe jeopardising someone's livelihood because you do not agree with them is ever justifiable ?

Gonna give me two minutes to type ... I am not Speedy Gonzales ... I do the two finger stuff with the occasional thumb ... so do stop badgering please.
I don't really go in for rhetorical questions ... but you will note your question has been answered in my ... last post.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: faithlilly on July 13, 2014, 07:11:52 PM
Gonna give me two minutes to type ... I am not Speedy Gonzales ... I do the two finger stuff with the occasional thumb ... so do stop badgering please.
I don't really go in for rhetorical questions ... but you will note your question has been answered in my ... last post.

It has indeed and a thank you offered.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Brietta on July 13, 2014, 07:15:18 PM
It has indeed and a thank you offered.

 ... and thank you for your condemnation of the organised campaigns against the McCann family, a very few of which I have detailed ...
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on July 13, 2014, 07:26:23 PM
This is all very interesting but has anyone yet discussed if having people who monitor the internet for abuse and threats is worthy of suspicion and / or criticism?
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: slartibartfast on July 13, 2014, 07:31:43 PM
This is all very interesting but has anyone yet discussed if having people who monitor the internet for abuse and threats is worthy of suspicion and / or criticism?

If it just for spotting abuse and threats, no. If it is to spot negative publicity and counter it, we are getting into government territory.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on July 13, 2014, 07:34:45 PM
If it just for spotting abuse and threats, no. If it is to spot negative publicity and counter it, we are getting into government territory.
Government territory?  What does that mean? 
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: slartibartfast on July 13, 2014, 07:39:21 PM
Government territory?  What does that mean?

The sort of thing governments and large corporations do to protect their ratings.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on July 13, 2014, 07:42:06 PM
The sort of thing governments and large corporations do to protect their ratings.
Any evidence that this is what the McCanns are doing?
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Mr Gray on July 13, 2014, 07:42:43 PM
The sort of thing governments and large corporations do to protect their ratings.

so now its not government territory but commercial
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: slartibartfast on July 13, 2014, 07:44:38 PM
Any evidence that this is what the McCanns are doing?

It's called internet monitoring.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Benice on July 13, 2014, 08:03:52 PM
Obviously theses people have not omitted any actual crime, other than offending your concept of what is right.

IIRC they are in breach of the Malicious Communications Act and could possibly be prosecuted under that?

I can fully understand why monitoring sites where groups of people openly discuss and encourage various threats of violence/actions  against the McCann family is necessary.     The obvious potential  danger being that one or more of these hate-filled people will decide to take their vile threats off the web and into the 'real' world.  Therefore to be forewarned is to be fore-armed.

IMO there are sceptics who genuinely have questions/doubts about this case.  And no way are they to be confused with  those people whose only interest in this case is to gleefully and joyfully hound,  harrass and abuse the family of a missing child.   IMO this is because some of them still believe every single myth that has been invented over the last 7 years and some of them because they are the type of people who get sadistic pleasure out of the misfortune of others.    (Shadenfreude? sp)

I do not personally know of any sites where comparable threats of violence/actions  against Amaral and his family are even made, let alone are regarded as the norm.   

This thread is not about what one set of posters do to another - it's about a set of posters who IMO  because of their malicous, threatening  on-line behaviour against the McCann family actually do require to be monitored - and if they are not - then they should be imo.
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on July 13, 2014, 08:08:40 PM
It's called internet monitoring.
what is?
Title: Re: We have people that monitor the internet.
Post by: slartibartfast on July 13, 2014, 08:10:37 PM
IIRC they are in breach of the Malicious Communications Act and could possibly be prosecuted under that?

I can fully understand why monitoring sites where groups of people openly discuss and encourage various threats of violence/actions  against the McCann family is necessary.     The obvious potential  danger being that one or more of these hate-filled people will decide to take their vile threats off the web and into the 'real' world.  Therefore to be forewarned is to be fore-armed.

IMO there are sceptics who genuinely have questions/doubts about this case.  And no way are they to be confused with  those people whose only interest in this case is to gleefully and joyfully hound,  harrass and abuse the family of a missing child.   IMO this is because some of them still believe every single myth that has been invented over the last 7 years and some of them because they are the type of people who get sadistic pleasure out of the misfortune of others.    (Shadenfreude? sp)

I do not personally know of any sites where comparable threats of violence/actions  against Amaral and his family are even made, let alone are regarded as the norm.   

This thread is not about what one set of posters do to another - it's about a set of posters who IMO  because of their malicous, threatening  on-line behaviour against the McCann family actually do require to be monitored - and if they are not - then they should be imo.

I would agree with you with the proviso that all those threatening violence or other real world action, except through the proper channels, against anyone as a result of this case should be monitored.