UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Mr Gray on January 03, 2016, 11:03:59 AM

Title: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 03, 2016, 11:03:59 AM
Most of the sceptic websites are claiming The Express apologised amaral whereas in truth they did not and merely made a correction. There is no mention of the word apology or regret. What does this say for the accuracy of material on these sites.

here is the full statement...

On the 29th April 2015 we published a headline on the front page which said “Maddy detective did lie about death cover-up claim”. We would like to make it clear that there was no determination by the Portuguese court that Mr Amaral lied. In fact the court ruled that Mr Amaral had breached the McCann’s right to reputation and ordered him to pay damages to them”.

Note that it does not concede that their initial claim that Amaral lied...it simply says the court did not rule on the matter.


Background


(http://i.imgur.com/aKnFBqP.jpg)


Resolution statements

Complaint
Complaint 03363-15 Bennett v Daily Express

Summary of complaint
1. Mr Anthony Bennett complained to the Independent Press Standards Organisation that the Daily Express had breached Clause 1 (Accuracy) of the Editors’ Code of Practice in a front-page headline “Maddy: Detective did lie about death cover-up”, published on 29 April 2015.
 
2. The front-page headline referred to an article on page 11 with the headline “McCanns win £428,000 over police chief’s slurs”. The article explained that the parents of Madeleine McCann had been awarded £428,000 in damages against Goncalo Amaral, a former Portuguese detective, who had libelled them in a book about the search for their daughter.
 
3. The complainant said that it was inaccurate to report that Mr Amaral had “lied”, as the court had not made any judgment on the truth of the detective's claims, and had merely focused on whether or not the detective's right to freedom of expression outweighed the McCanns’ right to reputation.
 
4. The newspaper accepted that the headline on the front page was inaccurate, and agreed that the truth of Mr Amaral’s claims were not examined during the trial. However, it did not accept that the front page headline represented a significant inaccuracy because the article itself did not report that the detective had lied, and was an accurate interpretation of the judgment. It said the headline had been written by a sub-editor who, in summarising the position of the Portuguese court, had made an assumption that the decision had been based on the truth of Mr Amaral’s claims, which is usually the case in English libel law.

Relevant Code Provisions
5. Clause 1 (Accuracy)

i) The Press must take care not to publish inaccurate, misleading or distorted information, including pictures.
 
ii) A significant inaccuracy, misleading statement or distortion once recognised must be corrected, promptly and with due prominence, and - where appropriate - an apology published. In cases involving the Regulator, prominence should be agreed with the Regulator in advance.

iii) The Press, whilst free to be partisan, must distinguish clearly between comment, conjecture and fact.

Mediated outcome
6. The complaint was not resolved through direct correspondence between the parties. IPSO therefore began an investigation into the matter. 
 
7. The newspaper published the following correction in its Amplifications and Clarifications column:

On the 29 April 2015 we published a headline on the front page which said “Maddy detective did lie about death cover up claim”. We would like to make it clear that there was no determination by the Portuguese court that Mr Amaral lied. In fact what the court decided was that Mr Amaral had breached the McCanns’ right to reputation and ordered him to pay damages to them.
 
8. The complainant said these actions resolved the matter to his satisfaction.
 
9. As the complaint was successfully mediated, the Complaints Committee did not make a determination as to whether there had been any breach of the Code.
 
Date complaint received: 05/05/2015
Date complaint concluded by IPSO: 27/11/2015

https://www.ipso.co.uk/IPSO/rulings/resolution-statements/detail.html?id=57

42
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on January 03, 2016, 11:44:50 AM
Did the express apologise to amaral?

Do we really care?
I for one don't give a rat's ass.
The Express dropped off then picked up what more is there to debate?
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Eleanor on January 03, 2016, 11:58:36 AM

https://www.ipso.co.uk/IPSO/rulings/resolution-statements/detail.html?id=57
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Jean-Pierre on January 03, 2016, 12:08:05 PM
Most of the sceptic websites are claiming The Express apologised amaral whereas in truth they did not and merely made a correction. There is no mention of the word apology or regret. What does this say for the accuracy of material on these sites.

here is the full statement...

On the 29th April 2015 we published a headline on the front page which said “Maddy detective did lie about death cover-up claim”. We would like to make it clear that there was no determination by the Portuguese court that Mr Amaral lied. In fact the court ruled that Mr Amaral had breached the McCann’s right to reputation and ordered him to pay damages to them”.

Note that it does not concede that their initial claim that Amaral lied...it simply says the court did not rule on the matter.

The issued a correction, but not an apology. 

It may save a lot of hot air to simply post the complaint resolution statement from IPSO

https://www.ipso.co.uk/IPSO/rulings/resolution-statements/detail.html?id=57

The complaint was resolved by the publishing of a correction by the Express. 

End of story.

Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 03, 2016, 12:08:51 PM
Did the express apologise to amaral?

Do we really care?
I for one don't give a rat's ass.
The Express dropped off then picked up what more is there to debate?

if you don't care...and don't want to debate ..that's fine

the point is that these posters are criticising the express for inaccuracy whilst being innacurate themselves
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: slartibartfast on January 03, 2016, 12:16:45 PM
Did the express apologise to amaral?

Do we really care?
I for one don't give a rat's ass.
The Express dropped off then picked up what more is there to debate?

Sounds about right.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 03, 2016, 12:17:36 PM
Sounds about right.

sounds about right because the sceptics have been proved to be wrong
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: stephen25000 on January 03, 2016, 12:31:14 PM
sounds about right because the sceptics have been proved to be wrong

Wrong Dave.

If the Express had done nothing wrong, then why print their apology ?
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 03, 2016, 12:37:49 PM
Wrong Dave.

If the Express had done nothing wrong, then why print their apology ?


they didn't print an apology as everyone apart from you seems to realise
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 03, 2016, 12:38:52 PM
Wrong Dave.

If the Express had done nothing wrong, then why print their apology ?

if sceptics can get something as simple as this wrong...how much more have they got wrong
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: ferryman on January 03, 2016, 01:23:42 PM
The issued a correction, but not an apology. 

It may save a lot of hot air to simply post the complaint resolution statement from IPSO

https://www.ipso.co.uk/IPSO/rulings/resolution-statements/detail.html?id=57

The complaint was resolved by the publishing of a correction by the Express. 

End of story.

Quote
4. The newspaper accepted that the headline on the front page was inaccurate, and agreed that the truth of Mr Amaral’s claims were not examined during the trial. However, it did not accept that the front page headline represented a significant inaccuracy because the article itself did not report that the detective had lied, and was an accurate interpretation of the judgment. It said the headline had been written by a sub-editor who, in summarising the position of the Portuguese court, had made an assumption that the decision had been based on the truth of Mr Amaral’s claims, which is usually the case in English libel law.

The court found that Amaral had abused his former position as coordinator of the shelved enquiry to traduce and malign the reputations of the McCanns  and found in favour of the McCanns on that basis.



Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: stephen25000 on January 03, 2016, 01:32:18 PM
The court found that Amaral had abused his former position as coordinator of the shelved enquiry to traduce and malign the reputations of the McCann and found in favour of the McCanns on that basis.


On how many counts did the court not find in favour of the mccanns ?

e.g. The book did not impede any 'search'.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 03, 2016, 01:39:50 PM
Nothing worries me about amaral's theories....they have been consigned to the bin
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: stephen25000 on January 03, 2016, 01:42:19 PM
Nothing worries me about amaral's theories....they have been consigned to the bin

Then why talk about him ?

As to his theory, the crime remains UNKNOWN.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 03, 2016, 01:42:29 PM
On how many counts did the court not find in favour of the mccanns ?

e.g. The book did not impede any 'search'.

the court did not say the book did not impede the search....

this what is so telling about you and others. You just do not read and understand things clearly enough. Your claim that the express apologised is a perfect example...they didn't...but you think they did
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 03, 2016, 01:43:44 PM
Then why talk about him ?

As to his theory, the crime remains UNKNOWN.

This thread is not about amaral its's about people who have misunderstood the express correction
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: stephen25000 on January 03, 2016, 01:44:23 PM
This thread is not about amaral its's about people who have misunderstood the express correction

It's all about Amaral.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on January 03, 2016, 02:02:07 PM
if you don't care...and don't want to debate ..that's fine

the point is that these posters are criticising the express for inaccuracy whilst being innacurate themselves

My point is: there is nothing to debate
The Express made an error picked up by Tony Bennett who complained about it then the Express corrected the error.
The End.

Amaral is yesterday's man as far as any investigation is concerned. In fact he has been yesterday's man since October 2007 so why keep banging on about him? There's a civil case involving him which remains "in progress" that is running into its seventh or eighth year which looks like being about as constructive as Jarndyce v Jarndyce but that is hardly relevant to the child's disappearance and determination of what befell her.
As for accuracy vis a vis sceptic websites and supporters websites I would not expect to find much accuracy in either.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: jassi on January 03, 2016, 02:20:59 PM
My point is: there is nothing to debate
The Express made an error picked up by Tony Bennett who complained about it then the Express corrected the error.
The End.

Amaral is yesterday's man as far as any investigation is concerned. In fact he has been yesterday's man since October 2007 so why keep banging on about him? There's a civil case involving him which remains "in progress" that is running into its seventh or eighth year which looks like being about as constructive as Jarndyce v Jarndyce but that is hardly relevant to the child's disappearance and determination of what befell her.
As for accuracy vis a vis sceptic websites and supporters websites I would not expect to find much accuracy in either.

Well said. My sentiments exactly
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 03, 2016, 02:32:05 PM
My point is: there is nothing to debate
The Express made an error picked up by Tony Bennett who complained about it then the Express corrected the error.
The End.

Amaral is yesterday's man as far as any investigation is concerned. In fact he has been yesterday's man since October 2007 so why keep banging on about him? There's a civil case involving him which remains "in progress" that is running into its seventh or eighth year which looks like being about as constructive as Jarndyce v Jarndyce but that is hardly relevant to the child's disappearance and determination of what befell her.
As for accuracy vis a vis sceptic websites and supporters websites I would not expect to find much accuracy in either.

the debate is  did the express apologise...if you don't wish to take part fair enough...but that is your second post on this thread
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: faithlilly on January 03, 2016, 02:36:19 PM
Well said. My sentiments exactly

Seconded.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 03, 2016, 02:48:03 PM
My point is: there is nothing to debate
The Express made an error picked up by Tony Bennett who complained about it then the Express corrected the error.
The End.

Amaral is yesterday's man as far as any investigation is concerned. In fact he has been yesterday's man since October 2007 so why keep banging on about him? There's a civil case involving him which remains "in progress" that is running into its seventh or eighth year which looks like being about as constructive as Jarndyce v Jarndyce but that is hardly relevant to the child's disappearance and determination of what befell her.
As for accuracy vis a vis sceptic websites and supporters websites I would not expect to find much accuracy in either.

I think you will find a lot..lot more accuracy on supporters sites
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: ferryman on January 03, 2016, 03:11:46 PM
My point is: there is nothing to debate
The Express made an error picked up by Tony Bennett who complained about it then the Express corrected the error.
The End.

Amaral is yesterday's man as far as any investigation is concerned. In fact he has been yesterday's man since October 2007 so why keep banging on about him? There's a civil case involving him which remains "in progress" that is running into its seventh or eighth year which looks like being about as constructive as Jarndyce v Jarndyce but that is hardly relevant to the child's disappearance and determination of what befell her.
As for accuracy vis a vis sceptic websites and supporters websites I would not expect to find much accuracy in either.

This thread centres on the trial, not the investigation.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: John on January 03, 2016, 03:39:09 PM
I considered whether to remove this thread but on balance it did ask a pertinent question, did the Daily Express apologise (see revised opening post).

To answer the question you have to look further into the background of the original complaint which by the way was made by Tony Bennett and not Gonçalo Amaral.  In order to do this unfortunately I must post a copy of the response made by Mr Bennett when asked about the correction later posted by the Daily Express.

Quote from: Tony Bennett on 10 December 2015
My dilemma was this. If I had carried on and asked IPSO to rule, and had not accepted a compromise, it was possible that IPSO might have decided the appeal against me. If you look at their argument, they said that their article was accurate, it was only the headline that was inaccurate. I did not want to risk an adverse ruling from IPSO - that would have been a setback.

I think I can reveal that the Daily Express initially offered a correction in which they did not formally admit that Amaral did not lie in court. 

I was allowed by IPSO to suggest an alternative wording for the correction, and did so.

The Daily Express refused to accept that.

And so it went on, until the moment that the Daily Express formally admitted these crucial words: 'Amaral did not lie'.   

Having secured that formal admission, and after nearly 7 months of correspondence, I decided to accept the wording which was published by the Express a few days ago.

http://jillhavern.forumotion.net/t12236-full-ipso-ruling-bennett-v-express-newspapers-published-10-december-2015

Clearly Mr Bennett was not happy that the Express had not gone far enough and made a fuller apology but had to settle for the lesser correction namely...

On the 29th April 2015 we published a headline on the front page which said “Maddy detective did lie about death cover-up claim”. We would like to make it clear that there was no determination by the Portuguese court that Mr Amaral lied. In fact the court ruled that Mr Amaral had breached the McCann’s right to reputation and ordered him to pay damages to them”.

This correction also answers another claim oft made on this forum and elsewhere to the effect that the recent court case held in Lisbon was a libel trial when in fact it related to reputation and not defamation.

Happy New Year everyone - Keep smiling!
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 03, 2016, 04:12:46 PM
I considered whether to remove this thread but on balance it did ask a pertinent question, did the Daily Express apologise (see revised opening post).

To answer the question you have to look further into the background of the original complaint which by the way was made by Tony Bennett and not Gonçalo Amaral.  In order to do this unfortunately I must post a copy of the response made by Mr Bennett when asked about the correction later posted by the Daily Express.

Clearly Mr Bennett was not happy that the Express had not gone far enough and made a fuller apology but had to settle for the lesser correction namely...

On the 29th April 2015 we published a headline on the front page which said “Maddy detective did lie about death cover-up claim”. We would like to make it clear that there was no determination by the Portuguese court that Mr Amaral lied. In fact the court ruled that Mr Amaral had breached the McCann’s right to reputation and ordered him to pay damages to them”.

This correction also answers another claim oft made on this forum and elsewhere to the effect that the recent court case held in Lisbon was a libel trial when in fact it related to reputation and not defamation.

Happy New Year everyone - Keep smiling!


defamation
ˌdɛfəˈmeɪʃ(ə)n/Submit
noun
the action of damaging the good reputation of someone; slander or libel.
"she sued him for defamation"


looks like defamation....I don't understand why posters are unwilling to accept this
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 03, 2016, 04:17:00 PM
the post by bennett...


My dilemma was this. If I had carried on and asked IPSO to rule, and had not accepted a compromise, it was possible that IPSO might have decided the appeal against me. If you look at their argument, they said that their article was accurate, it was only the headline that was inaccurate. I did not want to risk an adverse ruling from IPSO - that would have been a setback.

I think I can reveal that the Daily Express initially offered a correction in which they did not formally admit that Amaral did not lie in court. 

I was allowed by IPSO to suggest an alternative wording for the correction, and did so.

The Daily Express refused to accept that.

And so it went on, until the moment that the Daily Express formally admitted these crucial words: 'Amaral did not lie'.   

Having secured that formal admission, and after nearly 7 months of correspondence, I decided to accept the wording which was published by the Express a few days ago.



the Express correction did not say that.....bennett wrong again



Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: John on January 03, 2016, 04:24:38 PM

defamation
ˌdɛfəˈmeɪʃ(ə)n/Submit
noun
the action of damaging the good reputation of someone; slander or libel.
"she sued him for defamation"


looks like defamation....I don't understand why posters are unwilling to accept this

The Express chose to use the word reputation based on the Portuguese judgement. The problem is that the Portuguese have a different understanding of the term to that which people in the UK are familiar with.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: John on January 03, 2016, 04:27:39 PM
the post by bennett...


My dilemma was this. If I had carried on and asked IPSO to rule, and had not accepted a compromise, it was possible that IPSO might have decided the appeal against me. If you look at their argument, they said that their article was accurate, it was only the headline that was inaccurate. I did not want to risk an adverse ruling from IPSO - that would have been a setback.

I think I can reveal that the Daily Express initially offered a correction in which they did not formally admit that Amaral did not lie in court. 

I was allowed by IPSO to suggest an alternative wording for the correction, and did so.

The Daily Express refused to accept that.

And so it went on, until the moment that the Daily Express formally admitted these crucial words: 'Amaral did not lie'.   

Having secured that formal admission, and after nearly 7 months of correspondence, I decided to accept the wording which was published by the Express a few days ago.



the Express correction did not say that.....bennett wrong again

You certainly like to nitpick Dave.  The Express stated, "We would like to make it clear that there was no determination by the Portuguese court that Mr Amaral lied."
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 03, 2016, 04:30:51 PM
You certainly like to nitpick Dave.  The Express stated, "We would like to make it clear that there was no determination by the Portuguese court that Mr Amaral lied."

what that means is the court did not determine whether amaral lied or not...so to claim that the determination was "amaral did not lie" is a lie itself. You call it nitpicking....I call it accuracy...and if you are going to accuse popele of serious crimes...as bennett has...then you need to be accurate
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 03, 2016, 04:37:54 PM
if we were to accept that the court said amaral did not lie....then we can take that as the court said amaral told the truth.....if amaral told the truth then his book is true....that is why it is important to be accurate
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Jean-Pierre on January 03, 2016, 06:00:29 PM
I considered whether to remove this thread but on balance it did ask a pertinent question, did the Daily Express apologise (see revised opening post).

To answer the question you have to look further into the background of the original complaint which by the way was made by Tony Bennett and not Gonçalo Amaral.  In order to do this unfortunately I must post a copy of the response made by Mr Bennett when asked about the correction later posted by the Daily Express.

Clearly Mr Bennett was not happy that the Express had not gone far enough and made a fuller apology but had to settle for the lesser correction namely...

On the 29th April 2015 we published a headline on the front page which said “Maddy detective did lie about death cover-up claim”. We would like to make it clear that there was no determination by the Portuguese court that Mr Amaral lied. In fact the court ruled that Mr Amaral had breached the McCann’s right to reputation and ordered him to pay damages to them”.

This correction also answers another claim oft made on this forum and elsewhere to the effect that the recent court case held in Lisbon was a libel trial when in fact it related to reputation and not defamation
.

Happy New Year everyone - Keep smiling!

And happy new year to you  John.

The case was one of defamation.  Which can be defined as "Any intentional false communication, either written or spoken, that harms a person's reputation; decreases the respect, regard, or confidence in which a person is held; or induces disparaging, hostile, or disagreeable opinions or feelings against a person."

I cannot see any other way of describing the recent trial.

As an aside, Amaral was fortunate that the McCanns decided pragmatically to bring an action under the civil code.  In my opinion they could have more easily (and with less hassle) have brought an action under 183 of the Criminal Code, which carries a possible sentence of 2 years.   
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: ferryman on January 03, 2016, 06:48:43 PM
And happy new year to you  John.

The case was one of defamation.  Which can be defined as "Any intentional false communication, either written or spoken, that harms a person's reputation; decreases the respect, regard, or confidence in which a person is held; or induces disparaging, hostile, or disagreeable opinions or feelings against a person."

I cannot see any other way of describing the recent trial.

As an aside, Amaral was fortunate that the McCanns decided pragmatically to bring an action under the civil code.  In my opinion they could have more easily (and with less hassle) have brought an action under 183 of the Criminal Code, which carries a possible sentence of 2 years.

Can I tease out a nuance of definition, there, JP?

I have long understood that any statement lowering reputation and proven untrue (whether believed or not) would be libel.

But is it the case that even a statement proven untrue (that lowers reputation!) nevertheless sincerely believed by the person who said it would steer clear the person who made the statement clear (of being guilty of libel)?
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Jean-Pierre on January 03, 2016, 07:11:09 PM
Can I tease out a nuance of definition, there, JP?

I have long understood that any statement lowering reputation and proven untrue (whether believed or not) would be libel.

But is it the case that even a statement proven untrue (that lowers reputation!) nevertheless sincerely believed by the person who said it would steer clear the person who made the statement clear (of being guilty of libel)?

Its complex and inevitably depends on the circumstances.  It is not good enough to say "well, I believed x to be a zzzz".  The sincerely held belief defense will require proof and evidence to support that belief. 

This text may help:

http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/jt201012/jtselect/jtdefam/203/20306.htm

Paragraph 42 and 43 may help.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Carana on January 03, 2016, 07:43:07 PM
Can I tease out a nuance of definition, there, JP?

I have long understood that any statement lowering reputation and proven untrue (whether believed or not) would be libel.

But is it the case that even a statement proven untrue (that lowers reputation!) nevertheless sincerely believed by the person who said it would steer clear the person who made the statement clear (of being guilty of libel)?

In which country, FM?
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: ferryman on January 03, 2016, 08:27:31 PM
In which country, FM?

I hadn't realised JP was citing English law.

I had in mind Portugal.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: mercury on January 03, 2016, 08:41:57 PM
I hadn't realised JP was citing English law.

I had in mind Portugal.

GA lost his libel suit to psychic lawyer Marcos on thatvery basis...that he sincerely believed Lenor Cipriano when she said GA was one of the torturers or looked in or egged the others on whatever exactly it was she said
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: ferryman on January 03, 2016, 09:00:32 PM
GA lost his libel suit to psychic lawyer Marcos on thatvery basis...that he sincerely believed Lenor Cipriano when she said GA was one of the torturers or looked in or egged the others on whatever exactly it was she said

Or whatever she said

What did she say?
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: mercury on January 03, 2016, 09:04:20 PM
Or whatever she said

What did she say?

Obviously somethng that libelled GA hence the libel suit...try the mccann supporting purply forum...thats where I read it

Ps doesnt mtter what the convicted murderess and liar said exactly, the point was that psychic lawyers defence was he believed her....
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 03, 2016, 09:15:59 PM
Obviously somethng that libelled GA hence the libel suit...try the mccann supporting purply forum...thats where I read it

Ps doesnt mtter what the convicted murderess and liar said exactly, the point was that psychic lawyers defence was he believed her....

I think you will find you are wrong and repeating a myth...the public Ministry asked for an acquittal on the basis that the accusations were basically true....the fact that Correia believed them was a further modifying factor but not the reason for the acquittal
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 03, 2016, 09:26:37 PM
Obviously somethng that libelled GA hence the libel suit...try the mccann supporting purply forum...thats where I read it

Ps doesnt mtter what the convicted murderess and liar said exactly, the point was that psychic lawyers defence was he believed her....

In the summing up, the judge stated that the necessary conditions had not been met in order to even consider the legal possibility of sentencing António Pedro Dores, president of ACED, who published the "Report On the Torture of Leonor Cipriano Perpetrated by the Policía Judiciaria", the subject of the law suit brought by Gonçalo Amaral.



what that means in english is the judge felt amaral hadn't even got the basis of  a case
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: mercury on January 03, 2016, 10:29:31 PM
I think you will find you are wrong and repeating a myth...the public Ministry asked for an acquittal on the basis that the accusations were basically true....the fact that Correia believed them was a further modifying factor but not the reason for the acquittal

just do not take it upon yourself out of some obscure license to accuse me of repeating a myth when I am just posting my understandng of a situation.

[ moderated ]
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: John on January 03, 2016, 10:42:33 PM
And happy new year to you  John.

The case was one of defamation.  Which can be defined as "Any intentional false communication, either written or spoken, that harms a person's reputation; decreases the respect, regard, or confidence in which a person is held; or induces disparaging, hostile, or disagreeable opinions or feelings against a person."

I cannot see any other way of describing the recent trial.

As an aside, Amaral was fortunate that the McCanns decided pragmatically to bring an action under the civil code.  In my opinion they could have more easily (and with less hassle) have brought an action under 183 of the Criminal Code, which carries a possible sentence of 2 years.

Yes, had the case been held in England under English Law but the trial was held in Portugal which has its own laws pertaining to what constitutes libel as against what impugns integrity and reputation.  We are all very well versed in the fact now that the Portuguese State and by extension its people and its laws hold freedom of speech very dear to them.  That is why the Portuguese word difamação (defamation) never featured once in the trial judgement.

Bottom line is you can call it whatever you want but the Portuguese judge refused to accept it was a case of defamation as understood in terms of Portuguese Law.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: John on January 03, 2016, 10:54:50 PM
what that means is the court did not determine whether amaral lied or not...so to claim that the determination was "amaral did not lie" is a lie itself. You call it nitpicking....I call it accuracy...and if you are going to accuse popele of serious crimes...as bennett has...then you need to be accurate

It's very simple, the Daily Express printed a claim that Gonçalo Amaral lied to the Court but following one or more complaints to IPSO had to print a retraction.

That retraction being...

On the 29th April 2015 we published a headline on the front page which said “Maddy detective did lie about death cover-up claim”. We would like to make it clear that there was no determination by the Portuguese court that Mr Amaral lied. In fact the court ruled that Mr Amaral had breached the McCann’s right to reputation and ordered him to pay damages to them”.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: faithlilly on January 03, 2016, 11:23:03 PM
And happy new year to you  John.

The case was one of defamation.  Which can be defined as "Any intentional false communication, either written or spoken, that harms a person's reputation; decreases the respect, regard, or confidence in which a person is held; or induces disparaging, hostile, or disagreeable opinions or feelings against a person."

I cannot see any other way of describing the recent trial.

As an aside, Amaral was fortunate that the McCanns decided pragmatically to bring an action under the civil code.  In my opinion they could have more easily (and with less hassle) have brought an action under 183 of the Criminal Code, which carries a possible sentence of 2 years.

But no money.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: mercury on January 03, 2016, 11:29:17 PM
But no money.
Oops
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 04, 2016, 08:12:37 AM
It's very simple, the Daily Express printed a claim that Gonçalo Amaral lied to the Court but following one or more complaints to IPSO had to print a retraction.

That retraction being...

On the 29th April 2015 we published a headline on the front page which said “Maddy detective did lie about death cover-up claim”. We would like to make it clear that there was no determination by the Portuguese court that Mr Amaral lied. In fact the court ruled that Mr Amaral had breached the McCann’s right to reputation and ordered him to pay damages to them”.

  so the correction did not contain the words "amaral did not lie" as bennett and the Portugal resident  has claimed  and
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: slartibartfast on January 04, 2016, 08:13:32 AM
But no money.

That was my first thought.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Jean-Pierre on January 04, 2016, 09:00:17 AM
That was my first thought.

As I said in my post - the mccanns are pragmatic.  Mind you it would have been much easier to bring a criminal action against amaral.  So It's fortunate  for your friend Amaral that they are pragmatic.  I can't imagine that a couple of years locked up with his former clients would be a walk in the park. 
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: stephen25000 on January 04, 2016, 09:07:00 AM
As I said in my post - the mccanns are pragmatic.  Mind you it would have been much easier to bring a criminal action against amaral.  So It's fortunate  for your friend Amaral that they are pragmatic.  I can't imagine that a couple of years locked up with his former clients would be a walk in the park.

The only two noticeable aims of the mccanns were revenge and obtaining money in a case, for which they re responsible in the first place, with their lack of child care.

IMO of course.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Jean-Pierre on January 04, 2016, 10:50:12 AM
The only two noticeable aims of the mccanns were revenge and obtaining money in a case, for which they re responsible in the first place, with their lack of child care.

IMO of course.

Revenge?  Or stopping Amaral defaming them. 

Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: G-Unit on January 04, 2016, 10:51:58 AM
The Express didn't seem to apologise to Goncalo Amaral. Nevertheless it retracted it's statement that he lied as it was not proved in court that he had. The Express may still think he did, as may others, but they're not allowed to say so in the Media.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: stephen25000 on January 04, 2016, 10:55:00 AM
Revenge?  Or stopping Amaral defaming them.

You seem to forget that Amaral's theory was not unique to him.

Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: faithlilly on January 04, 2016, 12:10:18 PM
As I said in my post - the mccanns are pragmatic.  Mind you it would have been much easier to bring a criminal action against amaral.  So It's fortunate  for your friend Amaral that they are pragmatic.  I can't imagine that a couple of years locked up with his former clients would be a walk in the park.

Pragmatic ? In what way ?
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Jean-Pierre on January 04, 2016, 12:29:37 PM
You seem to forget that Amaral's theory was not unique to him.

That is true, of course.

But what has that got to do with it?
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: faithlilly on January 04, 2016, 12:35:05 PM
That is true, of course.

But what has that got to do with it?

Again JP can suing Amaral knowing that the case may cost hundreds of thousands of pounds in lawyer's bills and take years be considered in any shape or form 'pragmatic' ?
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: faithlilly on January 04, 2016, 12:45:42 PM
And happy new year to you  John.

The case was one of defamation.  Which can be defined as "Any intentional false communication, either written or spoken, that harms a person's reputation; decreases the respect, regard, or confidence in which a person is held; or induces disparaging, hostile, or disagreeable opinions or feelings against a person."

I cannot see any other way of describing the recent trial.

As an aside, Amaral was fortunate that the McCanns decided pragmatically to bring an action under the civil code.  In my opinion they could have more easily (and with less hassle) have brought an action under 183 of the Criminal Code, which carries a possible sentence of 2 years.

Apologies JP I meant to ask this earlier but could you please provide some information on the piece of legislation cited above ?
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Jean-Pierre on January 04, 2016, 12:54:02 PM
Apologies JP I meant to ask this earlier but could you please provide some information on the piece of legislation cited above ?

There is a narrative about criminal defamation in Portugal, and in particular in the context of press freedom which may be more useful than looking up the criminal code.

http://www.freemedia.at/fileadmin/user_upload/PortugalCriminalDef_IPI_ENG.pdf
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: slartibartfast on January 04, 2016, 01:05:18 PM
There is a narrative about criminal defamation in Portugal, and in particular in the context of press freedom which may be more useful than looking up the criminal code.

http://www.freemedia.at/fileadmin/user_upload/PortugalCriminalDef_IPI_ENG.pdf

Definition of narrative?
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Jean-Pierre on January 04, 2016, 01:23:18 PM
Definition of narrative?

Maybe article or report would have been better choice of words.   8(0(*
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: slartibartfast on January 04, 2016, 01:43:33 PM
Maybe article or report would have been better choice of words.   8(0(*

 8(0(*
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Jean-Pierre on January 04, 2016, 02:22:01 PM
Again JP can suing Amaral knowing that the case may cost hundreds of thousands of pounds in lawyer's bills and take years be considered in any shape or form 'pragmatic' ?

They have a strong case, and were reasonably confident of obtaining damages from Amaral. 

The alternative - criminal code, would mean much lower financial damages but would be easier to bring. 
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: G-Unit on January 04, 2016, 03:15:46 PM
They have a strong case, and were reasonably confident of obtaining damages from Amaral. 

The alternative - criminal code, would mean much lower financial damages but would be easier to bring.

Wasn't it attempted by Duarte?
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Jean-Pierre on January 04, 2016, 03:20:38 PM
Wasn't it attempted by Duarte?

As far as I am aware no. 
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on January 04, 2016, 03:32:53 PM
They have a strong case, and were reasonably confident of obtaining damages from Amaral. 

The alternative - criminal code, would mean much lower financial damages but would be easier to bring.

Maybe the pragmatic view would have been the old Roman SPQR. Small Profits and Quick Returns then draw a line under it and move on  8(0(*
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Jean-Pierre on January 04, 2016, 03:40:15 PM
Maybe the pragmatic view would have been the old Roman SPQR. Small Profits and Quick Returns then draw a line under it and move on  8(0(*

We are talking Portuguese Justice system here, Alice.

Which grinds exceeding slow.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on January 04, 2016, 03:49:50 PM
We are talking Portuguese Justice system here, Alice.

Which grinds exceeding slow.
Do you believe that the criminal route would have taken longer than seven years with no conclusive result?
It's rather droll that the UKs longest case lasted 10 years (not counting the bit with ECHR which added another ten)
and is known as The McLibel Case.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Carana on January 04, 2016, 04:13:43 PM
But no money.

What do you base that on? An alternative to a prison sentence for crimes with a low maximum sentence is a fine. I haven't found anything that defines how the fine is calculated, however (to double-check), the concept of not profiting from illegal gains (should that be proven) is enshrined in the penal code.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Carana on January 04, 2016, 04:25:29 PM
They have a strong case, and were reasonably confident of obtaining damages from Amaral. 

The alternative - criminal code, would mean much lower financial damages but would be easier to bring.

I wondered about that as well and I'm still mulling over it, although I'd need to go back and check again.

From memory, the civil code seems to be broader than the penal one.

Which articles in the penal code would cover the primary reason for complaint (the damage to the search for Madeleine)?

Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Jean-Pierre on January 04, 2016, 05:09:45 PM
I wondered about that as well and I'm still mulling over it, although I'd need to go back and check again.

From memory, the civil code seems to be broader than the penal one.

Which articles in the penal code would cover the primary reason for complaint (the damage to the search for Madeleine)?

The penal code covers defamation - articles 180 to 183.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: faithlilly on January 04, 2016, 05:11:02 PM
They have a strong case, and were reasonably confident of obtaining damages from Amaral. 

The alternative - criminal code, would mean much lower financial damages but would be easier to bring.

So you admit that from the get-go it was always about money and never about the damage being done to the search ?
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Jean-Pierre on January 04, 2016, 05:14:22 PM
So you admit from the get-go it was always about money and never about the damage being done to the search ?

My opinion is as worthless as yours faith. 
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: faithlilly on January 04, 2016, 05:20:05 PM
My opinion is as worthless as yours faith.

But interesting nonetheless.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Jean-Pierre on January 04, 2016, 05:31:00 PM
But interesting nonetheless.

hmmmm.  Yours or mine?

The verdict covered financial settlements for the McCanns, excluded financial settlements for Madeleine and the twins, and also stopped further publication or distribution of the book and video documentary. 

So the result was not only financial. 
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: faithlilly on January 04, 2016, 05:45:40 PM
hmmmm.  Yours or mine?

The verdict covered financial settlements for the McCanns, excluded financial settlements for Madeleine and the twins, and also stopped further publication or distribution of the book and video documentary. 

So the result was not only financial.

But none of that would have been apparent at the outset. A criminal complaint would have had a swifter outcome if, as the McCanns professed, damage to the search was their main motivation in taking Amaral to court.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: G-Unit on January 04, 2016, 05:52:48 PM
As far as I am aware no.

Either it was a rumour, it was refused or they decided it would be more lucrative to sue?

The McCann couple will file a criminal action against Gonçalo Amaral for allegedly violating the judicial secrecy when he published facts concerning the investigation, in his book “Maddie – The Truth of the Lie”.

According to Lusa Agency, the British couple’s lawyer, Isabel Duarte, stated that the action will be filed after a certificate from the trial of the book’s prohibition is extracted, which is expected to happen as soon as next week.
http://joana-morais.blogspot.com/2010/01/mccanns-accuse-amaral-of-violating.html
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Jean-Pierre on January 04, 2016, 06:43:30 PM
Either it was a rumour, it was refused or they decided it would be more lucrative to sue?

The McCann couple will file a criminal action against Gonçalo Amaral for allegedly violating the judicial secrecy when he published facts concerning the investigation, in his book “Maddie – The Truth of the Lie”.

According to Lusa Agency, the British couple’s lawyer, Isabel Duarte, stated that the action will be filed after a certificate from the trial of the book’s prohibition is extracted, which is expected to happen as soon as next week.
http://joana-morais.blogspot.com/2010/01/mccanns-accuse-amaral-of-violating.html

Well he's lucky the mccanns and Duarte decided to go for the civil option, and so are the directors of the publishing house.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Carana on January 04, 2016, 07:18:55 PM
The penal code covers defamation - articles 180 to 183.

Yes, I know... but how would the penal code have covered the the alleged damage to the search for Madeleine?

Bearing in mind when this was launched (i.e., before an official launch / relaunch of the investigation). the civil course, if indeed broader, may have made more sense.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: ferryman on January 04, 2016, 07:27:59 PM
But none of that would have been apparent at the outset. A criminal complaint would have had a swifter outcome if, as the McCanns professed, damage to the search was their main motivation in taking Amaral to court.

Distinct from damage to Amaral (such as landing him in jail) as a criminal libel action might have resulted in.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: G-Unit on January 04, 2016, 08:21:28 PM
Well he's lucky the mccanns and Duarte decided to go for the civil option, and so are the directors of the publishing house.

They were speaking about lodging a criminal complaint during the injunction period (when they were winning). They later lost that action, which may be why they didn't file a complaint at that time. Perhaps they'll reconsider if they win the present appeal.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: faithlilly on January 04, 2016, 10:51:24 PM
Distinct from damage to Amaral (such as landing him in jail) as a criminal libel action might have resulted in.

Not sure what point you're making Ferryman.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Carana on January 04, 2016, 11:53:53 PM
The penal code covers defamation - articles 180 to 183.

Yes, I know... but I don't see how those would cover the alleged direct damage to Madeleine.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: faithlilly on January 05, 2016, 12:11:31 AM
Yes, I know... but I don't see how those would cover the alleged direct damage to Madeleine.

I'm not sure how you'd quantify that anyway.mthe McCanns certainly didn't try.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Carana on January 05, 2016, 12:14:06 PM
I'm not sure how you'd quantify that anyway.mthe McCanns certainly didn't try.

I'm not sure how that could be quantified, either.

If you were in their position, what evidence would you have presented?

- Paiva was wheeled in to state that the book didn''t influence him as desk officer. Well, erm, probably not in view of his stance on the case.

- It was impossible to quantify any impact directly attributable to his book /"documentary". Half-baked leaks to the media while he was in charge are a fact (but that is not part of the trial), compounded by the spoutings of an "experienced professional" in charge of the case for the first five months on any media outlet that would have him.

But how would anyone quantify that?

Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: G-Unit on January 05, 2016, 03:15:18 PM
I'm not sure how that could be quantified, either.

If you were in their position, what evidence would you have presented?

- Paiva was wheeled in to state that the book didn''t influence him as desk officer. Well, erm, probably not in view of his stance on the case.

- It was impossible to quantify any impact directly attributable to his book /"documentary". Half-baked leaks to the media while he was in charge are a fact (but that is not part of the trial), compounded by the spoutings of an "experienced professional" in charge of the case for the first five months on any media outlet that would have him.

But how would anyone quantify that?

Making an allegation is all well and good. Making no attempt whatsoever to bring evidence to support the allegation is wierd.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Carana on January 05, 2016, 04:44:55 PM
Making an allegation is all well and good. Making no attempt whatsoever to bring evidence to support the allegation is wierd.

Which party are you talking about?
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: G-Unit on January 06, 2016, 09:23:17 AM
Which party are you talking about?

The party that alleged a search had been damaged but brought no evidence of the damage to the courtroom. The same party one of whom claimed that they suffered from a deep and serious depression but brought no medical evidence to support their claim.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: faithlilly on January 06, 2016, 09:29:45 AM
The party that alleged a search had been damaged but brought no evidence of the damage to the courtroom. The same party one of whom claimed that they suffered from a deep and serious depression but brought no medical evidence to support their claim.

In fact the party who was at pains to point out in their book that they did not take any kind of anti-depressant.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Carana on January 06, 2016, 11:36:59 AM
The party that alleged a search had been damaged but brought no evidence of the damage to the courtroom. The same party one of whom claimed that they suffered from a deep and serious depression but brought no medical evidence to support their claim.

Some could say the same of Amaral, hence my question for clarification....

The evidence of an experienced trauma counsellor doesn't count then?
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Carana on January 06, 2016, 11:41:13 AM
In fact the party who was at pains to point out in their book that they did not take any kind of anti-depressant.

So? Some people choose anti-depressants, and but they seem to have chosen exercise and the support of a professional counsellor and friends and family. Different people have different ways of coping.

Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: G-Unit on January 06, 2016, 12:21:17 PM
Some could say the same of Amaral, hence my question for clarification....

The evidence of an experienced trauma counsellor doesn't count then?

A trauma counsellor is not qualified to diagnose serious depression, that is a medical condition.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 06, 2016, 12:25:35 PM
A trauma counsellor is not qualified to diagnose serious depression, that is a medical condition.

I would say they would have a very valid opinion
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Carana on January 06, 2016, 01:03:33 PM
A trauma counsellor is not qualified to diagnose serious depression, that is a medical condition.

What makes you think that only clinical depression can be accepted as sole evidence of psychological / social / emotional damage in a PT court?
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: G-Unit on January 06, 2016, 01:15:13 PM
I would say they would have a very valid opinion

Would you? I would say he could give his opinion, but when it comes to depression he isn't qualified to judge.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 06, 2016, 01:25:42 PM
Would you? I would say he could give his opinion, but when it comes to depression he isn't qualified to judge.

Are you qualified to judge if he's qualified to judge

Is Shona whoever of the Mail qualified to tell us lots of us sedate our children
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Jean-Pierre on January 06, 2016, 01:32:38 PM
However, the case was judged on the merits of the arguments and evidence presented by both sides, and the court made its judgement. 
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Carana on January 06, 2016, 01:34:07 PM
A trauma counsellor is not qualified to diagnose serious depression, that is a medical condition.

The court case is about damage caused.

Where does it state in PT law that clinically diagnosed depression is the sole evidence admissible?
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Eleanor on January 06, 2016, 01:49:23 PM
I think we have gone a bit Off Topic.  Could we get back, please.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Carana on January 06, 2016, 02:19:14 PM
Back to OP



On the 29th April 2015 we published a headline on the front page which said “Maddy detective did lie about death cover-up claim”. We would like to make it clear that there was no determination by the Portuguese court that Mr Amaral lied. In fact the court ruled that Mr Amaral had breached the McCann’s right to reputation and ordered him to pay damages to them”.


I'd agree with that correction regarding the headline. There was indeed nothing in the trial ruling that proved that he'd actually lied...
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: G-Unit on January 06, 2016, 05:25:02 PM
What makes you think that only clinical depression can be accepted as sole evidence of psychological / social / emotional damage in a PT court?

If someone claims to be suffering from 'deep depression' it's not unreasonable to expect a qualified person to be asked to confirm it. Depression is a word used lightly by all and sundry and ranges from being a bit fed up to being clinically depressed. Was Kate McCann a bit fed up or actually suffering from clinical depression? We don't know as no expert testimony was offered, only the opinions of unqualified people.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Carana on January 06, 2016, 05:37:38 PM
If someone claims to be suffering from 'deep depression' it's not unreasonable to expect a qualified person to be asked to confirm it. Depression is a word used lightly by all and sundry and ranges from being a bit fed up to being clinically depressed. Was Kate McCann a bit fed up or actually suffering from clinical depression? We don't know as no expert testimony was offered, only the opinions of unqualified people.

Are you suggesting that Alan Pike wasn't qualified to give evidence in court?
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 06, 2016, 06:03:38 PM
If someone claims to be suffering from 'deep depression' it's not unreasonable to expect a qualified person to be asked to confirm it. Depression is a word used lightly by all and sundry and ranges from being a bit fed up to being clinically depressed. Was Kate McCann a bit fed up or actually suffering from clinical depression? We don't know as no expert testimony was offered, only the opinions of unqualified people.

looks like the court wasn't that fussy
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Eleanor on January 06, 2016, 06:11:41 PM
If someone claims to be suffering from 'deep depression' it's not unreasonable to expect a qualified person to be asked to confirm it. Depression is a word used lightly by all and sundry and ranges from being a bit fed up to being clinically depressed. Was Kate McCann a bit fed up or actually suffering from clinical depression? We don't know as no expert testimony was offered, only the opinions of unqualified people.

How do you define Depression?  It doesn't actually have obvious symptoms.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: slartibartfast on January 06, 2016, 06:44:00 PM
How do you define Depression?  It doesn't actually have obvious symptoms.

That's why you need a qualified doctor to diagnose.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 06, 2016, 06:47:03 PM
That's why you need a qualified doctor to diagnose.

so Kate or Gerry
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Eleanor on January 06, 2016, 06:52:03 PM
That's why you need a qualified doctor to diagnose.

How do you qualify a Doctor of Depression?  There aren't any obvious signs.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Brietta on January 06, 2016, 06:55:54 PM
That's why you need a qualified doctor to diagnose.

In my opinion they handled their mental health awareness and coping mechanisms in similar and different ways as suited their personalities.

Both used physical exercise.  One being more outgoing took an active organisational route.  The other was more introspective. 

However I believe depression is more complex than "snapping oneself out of it" and I think these parents should be congratulated in coming through such a dark time rather than excoriated.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 06, 2016, 07:07:59 PM
If someone claims to be suffering from 'deep depression' it's not unreasonable to expect a qualified person to be asked to confirm it. Depression is a word used lightly by all and sundry and ranges from being a bit fed up to being clinically depressed. Was Kate McCann a bit fed up or actually suffering from clinical depression? We don't know as no expert testimony was offered, only the opinions of unqualified people.

Do you think Kate would find it difficult to get a diagnosis from a doctor..
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on January 06, 2016, 07:13:18 PM
Do you think Kate would find it difficult to get a diagnosis from a doctor..

No.Checkout ambulance chasing solicitors. It's always possible to have a medical opinion on each side of the divide on any topic.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: stephen25000 on January 06, 2016, 07:15:01 PM
Do you think Kate would find it difficult to get a diagnosis from a doctor..


Some people don't like hearing the truth.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: slartibartfast on January 06, 2016, 07:20:09 PM
How do you qualify a Doctor of Depression?  There aren't any obvious signs.

You must have been fortunate to have never had to support someone with depression.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 06, 2016, 07:24:31 PM
No.Checkout ambulance chasing solicitors. It's always possible to have a medical opinion on each side of the divide on any topic.


of course and that's why the court would not take that much notice of one...
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: slartibartfast on January 06, 2016, 07:28:03 PM

of course and that's why the court would not take that much notice of one...

So you are saying doctors are not above selling their integrity?
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 06, 2016, 07:32:56 PM
So you are saying doctors are not above selling their integrity?

no
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: slartibartfast on January 06, 2016, 07:43:13 PM
no

So why would courts not take that much notice of one?
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on January 06, 2016, 07:46:15 PM

of course and that's why the court would not take that much notice of one...
That's why courts do law and not science.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 06, 2016, 07:55:52 PM
So why would courts not take that much notice of one?

gunit is making a massive point about a medical diagnosis...any one could walk into their doctors having looked at the symptoms on the net and be diagnosed with depression.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: slartibartfast on January 06, 2016, 07:57:46 PM
gunit is making a massive point about a medical diagnosis...any one could walk into their doctors having looked at the symptoms on the net and be diagnosed with depression.

It would depend on the doctor.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: G-Unit on January 06, 2016, 08:51:47 PM
You must have been fortunate to have never had to support someone with depression.

Grim, isn't it? Very difficult for all concerned.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: G-Unit on January 06, 2016, 08:54:51 PM
gunit is making a massive point about a medical diagnosis...any one could walk into their doctors having looked at the symptoms on the net and be diagnosed with depression.

Are doctors really so easy to fool? Goodness!
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Brietta on January 06, 2016, 08:59:42 PM
It would depend on the doctor.

Have the forum rules been changed?  I am not quite sure why every thread is allowed to degenerate into all that can be thought of in any which way possible as pejorative to the Drs McCann to the exclusion of the topic which in this case is ... the Express and Mr Amaral.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: stephen25000 on January 06, 2016, 09:03:11 PM
Have the forum rules been changed?  I am not quite sure why every thread is allowed to degenerate into all that can be thought of in any which way possible as pejorative to the Drs McCann to the exclusion of the topic which in this case is ... the Express and Mr Amaral.

Why this need Brietta to keep using 'drs' ?

We do know their professions already.

Do you think it gives their actions some kudos by constant repetition of that term ?
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: carlymichelle on January 06, 2016, 09:04:41 PM
Why this need Brietta to keep using 'drs' ?

We do know their professions already.

Do you think it gives their actions some kudos by constant repetition of that term ?

i have wondered that myself   kate isnt even a  dr now is she?
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: stephen25000 on January 06, 2016, 09:06:01 PM
i have wondered that myself   kate isnt even a  dr now is she?

She is inactive, and does not have a licence to practice, but is still counted as a Doctor Carly.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: jassi on January 06, 2016, 09:06:41 PM
i have wondered that myself   kate isnt even a  dr now is she?

Once a doctor, always a doctor - unless struck off
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Brietta on January 06, 2016, 09:07:59 PM
i have wondered that myself   kate isnt even a  dr now is she?

Oh ?? ... when did Dr McCann or if you prefer Dr Healey have her epaulettes ripped off and her sword broken?
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: stephen25000 on January 06, 2016, 09:08:57 PM
Oh ?? ... when did Dr McCann or if you prefer Dr Healey have her epaulettes ripped off and her sword broken?

You are taking that very personally. 8**8:/:
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: carlymichelle on January 06, 2016, 09:10:45 PM
You are taking that very personally. 8**8:/:

what i meant  was kate has not been a dr for  at least 10 years now has she?
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: stephen25000 on January 06, 2016, 09:12:22 PM
what i meant  was kate has not been a dr for  at least 10 years now has she?

I believe she was doing locum work prior to events, but did not have a full time job.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: slartibartfast on January 06, 2016, 09:14:48 PM
Have the forum rules been changed?  I am not quite sure why every thread is allowed to degenerate into all that can be thought of in any which way possible as pejorative to the Drs McCann to the exclusion of the topic which in this case is ... the Express and Mr Amaral.

Totally off topic, we weren't even talking about the McCanns.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Brietta on January 06, 2016, 09:20:51 PM
By the third post on this thread it had been conclusively concluded that the Daily Express had not issued an apology to Gonçalo Amaral.  Wishful thinking may have confused the printing of a correction with a much desired apology.

What is it about that which appears to have produced a little harmless goading aimed at myself ... just boredom? or no-one else rising to the bait?

Please do try to post in an adult manner giving fellow members even the barest modicum of respect which I feel you are going out of your way to deny me, you will be amazed at how good it may make you feel about yourself.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 06, 2016, 09:21:57 PM
Are doctors really so easy to fool? Goodness!

What makes you think they are fooled
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Brietta on January 06, 2016, 09:24:52 PM
Totally off topic, we weren't even talking about the McCanns.

Whoever or whatever you were involved in discussing it was indeed "totally off topic" ... unless the latter discussion about depression has some locus in "Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?".
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Brietta on January 06, 2016, 09:30:17 PM
what i meant  was kate has not been a dr for  at least 10 years now has she?

As far as I am aware, Dr Kate McCann has not practised either as McCann or Healey for some time.  How long I do not know and care even less because I am not as wrapped up in her personal life as some are.
What her qualification is or when she last used it remains an irrelevance in a thread about Mr Amaral and the Express, or that is what is said at the top of the page.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: stephen25000 on January 06, 2016, 09:31:27 PM
By the third post on this thread it had been conclusively concluded that the Daily Express had not issued an apology to Gonçalo Amaral.  Wishful thinking may have confused the printing of a correction with a much desired apology.

What is it about that which appears to have produced a little harmless goading aimed at myself ... just boredom? or no-one else rising to the bait?

Please do try to post in an adult manner giving fellow members even the barest modicum of respect which I feel you are going out of your way to deny me, you will be amazed at how good it may make you feel about yourself.

No it wasn't.

If the Express had nothing to apologize for, why the statement ?
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: slartibartfast on January 06, 2016, 09:31:36 PM
Whoever or whatever you were involved in discussing it was indeed "totally off topic" ... unless the latter discussion about depression has some locus in "Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?".

It was about lack of expert testimony in the damages trial and drifted with input from both sides.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: carlymichelle on January 06, 2016, 09:34:02 PM
depression is a  real  thing which i happen to suffer  with  and   i take anti depressents  i dont think  depression is anything to be ashamed of and    nor should  anyone with it  be ashaed of it i dont think it is right to say  someone   does or  does not have depression  im just saying 
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: stephen25000 on January 06, 2016, 09:35:58 PM
depression is a  real  thing which i happen to suffer  with  and   i take anti depressents  i dont think  depression is anything to be ashamed of and    nor should  anyone with it  be ashaed of it i dont think it is right to say  someone   does or  does not have depression  im just saying

Yes Carlymichelle.

Many people do get this at some point or points in their life and it is not to be laughed at or ridiculed.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: slartibartfast on January 06, 2016, 09:37:25 PM
Yes Carlymichelle.

Many people do get this at some point or points in their life and it is not to be laughed at or ridiculed.

Agreed.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Brietta on January 06, 2016, 10:00:06 PM
No it wasn't.

If the Express had nothing to apologize for, why the statement ?

The Daily Express and Daily Star carried unprecedented front page apologies to Gerry and Kate McCann

~~~~~~~


The Daily Star said it was making a "wholehearted apology" to the couple

~~~~~~~
 

It (the Daily Star) recognised "that such a suggestion is absolutely untrue and that Kate and Gerry are completely innocent of any involvement in their daughter's disappearance".

~~~~~~~


Under the headline Kate and Gerry McCann: Sorry, the Express said it had apologised because "we accept that a number of articles in the newspaper have suggested that the couple caused the death of their missing daughter Madeleine and then covered it up", before acknowledging "there is no evidence whatsoever to support this theory".

~~~~~~~


The "substantial sum" that Express Newspapers will pay in damages would go to the Find Madeleine fund.
http://www.theguardian.com/media/2008/mar/19/dailyexpress.dailystar

(http://i.telegraph.co.uk/multimedia/archive/02064/sorryy_2064043c.jpg)

That represents an apology.

The following represents a correction.  Something which is entirely different and could never be mistaken for an apology.

Quote:

7. The newspaper published the following correction in its Amplifications and Clarifications column:

On the 29 April 2015 we published a headline on the front page which said “Maddy detective did lie about death cover up claim”. We would like to make it clear that there was no determination by the Portuguese court that Mr Amaral lied. In fact what the court decided was that Mr Amaral had breached the McCanns’ right to reputation and ordered him to pay damages to them.
https://www.ipso.co.uk/IPSO/rulings/resolution-statements/detail.html?id=57
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: stephen25000 on January 06, 2016, 10:02:13 PM
The Daily Express and Daily Star carried unprecedented front page apologies to Gerry and Kate McCann

~~~~~~~


The Daily Star said it was making a "wholehearted apology" to the couple

~~~~~~~
 

It (the Daily Star) recognised "that such a suggestion is absolutely untrue and that Kate and Gerry are completely innocent of any involvement in their daughter's disappearance".

~~~~~~~


Under the headline Kate and Gerry McCann: Sorry, the Express said it had apologised because "we accept that a number of articles in the newspaper have suggested that the couple caused the death of their missing daughter Madeleine and then covered it up", before acknowledging "there is no evidence whatsoever to support this theory".

~~~~~~~


The "substantial sum" that Express Newspapers will pay in damages would go to the Find Madeleine fund.
http://www.theguardian.com/media/2008/mar/19/dailyexpress.dailystar

(http://i.telegraph.co.uk/multimedia/archive/02064/sorryy_2064043c.jpg)

That represents an apology.

The following represents a correction.  Something which is entirely different and could never be mistaken for an apology.

Quote:

7. The newspaper published the following correction in its Amplifications and Clarifications column:

On the 29 April 2015 we published a headline on the front page which said “Maddy detective did lie about death cover up claim”. We would like to make it clear that there was no determination by the Portuguese court that Mr Amaral lied. In fact what the court decided was that Mr Amaral had breached the McCanns’ right to reputation and ordered him to pay damages to them.
https://www.ipso.co.uk/IPSO/rulings/resolution-statements/detail.html?id=57

You're off tiopic.

This is about the Express and Amaral.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 06, 2016, 10:18:38 PM
You're off tiopic.

This is about the Express and Amaral.

its about an apology and Brietta is showing you what an apology looks like because you don't seem to understand....
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: stephen25000 on January 06, 2016, 10:30:07 PM
its about an apology and Brietta is showing you what an apology looks like because you don't seem to understand....
aa

Give it a break.

I know full well her intention?
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Brietta on January 06, 2016, 10:36:29 PM
You're off tiopic.

This is about the Express and Amaral.

I beg your pardon!  I am not off topic, which you might have realised had you bothered to read my post.  As Davel has pointed out, it is an illustration of the difference between an apology which is unprecedented for its front page prominence and a correction which appeared in the depths of the newspaper as a footnote at the bottom of the correspondence page, I think.

My post concludes with the Express correction which was negotiated with the complainant ... which is so insignificant I suppose you could be forgiven for failing to notice or interpret it. Particularly as you appear to think it may be an apology, which it certainly is not.


"7. The newspaper published the following correction in its Amplifications and Clarifications column:

On the 29 April 2015 we published a headline on the front page which said “Maddy detective did lie about death cover up claim”. We would like to make it clear that there was no determination by the Portuguese court that Mr Amaral lied. In fact what the court decided was that Mr Amaral had breached the McCanns’ right to reputation and ordered him to pay damages to them.
https://www.ipso.co.uk/IPSO/rulings/resolution-statements/detail.html?id=57"
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: stephen25000 on January 06, 2016, 10:40:18 PM
I beg your pardon!  I am not off topic, which you might have realised had you bothered to read my post.  As Davel has pointed out, it is an illustration of the difference between an apology which is unprecedented for its front page prominence and a correction which appeared in the depths of the newspaper as a footnote at the bottom of the correspondence page, I think.

My post concludes with the Express correction which was negotiated with the complainant ... which is so insignificant I suppose you could be forgiven for failing to notice or interpret it. Particularly as you appear to think it may be an apology, which it certainly is not.


"7. The newspaper published the following correction in its Amplifications and Clarifications column:

On the 29 April 2015 we published a headline on the front page which said “Maddy detective did lie about death cover up claim”. We would like to make it clear that there was no determination by the Portuguese court that Mr Amaral lied. In fact what the court decided was that Mr Amaral had breached the McCanns’ right to reputation and ordered him to pay damages to them.
https://www.ipso.co.uk/IPSO/rulings/resolution-statements/detail.html?id=57"

I know what you were doing brietta.

Make no mistake,.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: ferryman on January 07, 2016, 09:31:22 AM
The Express made a trivial error in stating that Amaral's (proven and demonstrable!) lies might be the basis of the McCanns' victory in the libel trial.

The judge chose the ground of Amaral's (equally demonstrable) abuse of privileged position as (first) coordinator of the shelved enquiry to traduce and malign an innocent and distraught couple to hand victory to the McCanns in the libel trial.

Big deal.

How is Amaral's appeal coming along?
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: stephen25000 on January 07, 2016, 09:37:11 AM
The Express made a trivial error in stating that Amaral's (proven and demonstrable!) lies might be the basis of the McCanns' victory in the libel trial.

The judge chose the ground of Amaral's (equally demonstrable) abuse of privileged position as (first) coordinator of the shelved enquiry to traduce and malign an innocent and distraught couple to hand victory to the McCanns in the libel trial.

Big deal.

How is Amaral's appeal coming along?

'trivial error' ?

i.e. LIE.

As to the appeal, well nothing to do with anyone on here, is it ?
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 07, 2016, 11:26:33 AM
'trivial error' ?

i.e. LIE.

As to the appeal, well nothing to do with anyone on here, is it ?
Wrong again....
The Express has not been shown to have lied...that's why they have not apologised...it really is simple but you cannot seem to understand it
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: stephen25000 on January 07, 2016, 11:29:59 AM
Wrong again....
The Express has not been shown to have lied...that's why they have not apologised...it really is simple but you cannot seem to understand it

WRONG.           

and by the way, the Express has been licking the proverbial since their libel case with the mccanns, and supporting abduction, with no evidence whatsoever to back it.                                         
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 07, 2016, 11:34:19 AM
WRONG.           

and by the way, the Express has been licking the proverbial since their libel case with the mccanns, and supporting abduction, with no evidence whatsoever to back it.                                       

show me where I am wrong...the express has not been shown or admitted to lying..
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: slartibartfast on January 07, 2016, 11:39:11 AM
show me where I am wrong...the express has not been shown or admitted to lying..

So same as the Sunday Times?
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 07, 2016, 11:47:34 AM
So same as the Sunday Times?

stephen made a specific claim that the express lied...that isn't true and that's the point I am addressing...so you would agree the Express has not been shown to have lied
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: stephen25000 on January 07, 2016, 11:51:56 AM
UK Daily Express publishes written apology over headline calling Maddie cop a liar - See more at:



http://portugalresident.com/uk-daily-express-publishes-written-apology-over-headline-calling-maddie-cop-a-liar#sthash.tYejGotO.dpuf
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Brietta on January 07, 2016, 11:59:02 AM
WRONG.           

and by the way, the Express has been licking the proverbial since their libel case with the mccanns, and supporting abduction, with no evidence whatsoever to back it.                                       

I don't think you have quite grasped the concept.

All British newspapers printed the same lies that the Express did about Madeleine's case for the simple reason that all relied on the same erroneous leaks from the Portuguese investigation that were being printed in the Portuguese press.
Had the Drs McCann been minded to ... they could have sued almost every publication in Britain for libel ... and they would have won for the simple reason that lies had been printed.


**Snip
The Daily Star said it was making a "wholehearted apology" to the couple for "stories suggesting the couple were responsible for, or may be responsible for, the death of their daughter Madeleine and covering it up".

It recognised "that such a suggestion is absolutely untrue and that Kate and Gerry are completely innocent of any involvement in their daughter's disappearance".

**Snip
Under the headline Kate and Gerry McCann: Sorry, the Express said it had apologised because "we accept that a number of articles in the newspaper have suggested that the couple caused the death of their missing daughter Madeleine and then covered it up", before acknowledging "there is no evidence whatsoever to support this theory".

**Snip
"There is nothing that has been said about the McCanns that could not have been published in a balanced way. It's when you move into over the top headlines and unbalanced reporting that you go beyond the protection that the libel laws give."
http://www.theguardian.com/media/2008/mar/19/dailyexpress.dailystar


Neither the Express nor any other British newspaper have been "licking the proverbial".  They have merely been complying with the law.
Which may perhaps explain why the Times recently paid out a substantial sum for printing a totally erroneous report without due diligence (there is a thread on this fiasco already on the forum).

The Express did not require to make any payment to Mr Amaral, nor did it require to make an apology to him ... why someone should have taken it upon himself to raise the issue which obviously had no substance on his behalf remains a puzzlement to me.
However ... it must by now be apparent that the Express did not apologise to Mr Amaral ... most contributors understood and got that by the third post on page one of the thread.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 07, 2016, 11:59:09 AM
UK Daily Express publishes written apology over headline calling Maddie cop a liar - See more at:



http://portugalresident.com/uk-daily-express-publishes-written-apology-over-headline-calling-maddie-cop-a-liar#sthash.tYejGotO.dpuf

the portugal resident lied....fact
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Brietta on January 07, 2016, 12:02:28 PM
the portugal resident lied....fact

                            Golly gosh!!!  So unlike them to get things the wrong way round.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: stephen25000 on January 07, 2016, 12:04:34 PM
                            Golly gosh!!!  So unlike them to get things the wrong way round.

You mean like the Express and other tabloids telling the truth ? @)(++(* @)(++(* @)(++(*
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Brietta on January 07, 2016, 12:16:26 PM
You mean like the Express and other tabloids telling the truth ? @)(++(* @)(++(* @)(++(*

I have decided that the overuse of smileys is indicative of ...  ...  ... je ne sais quoi LOL ...  ...  ... but something.

As you put it so eruditely??  "licking the proverbial " doesn't really come into it when there are libel laws in place.

My interpretation of that is that newspapers can't print downright lies without risk of being sued.  There again is the Portugal Resident actually a newspaper worth suing?
Isn't it more a free sheet type thing for ex pats?
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: stephen25000 on January 07, 2016, 12:20:44 PM
I have decided that the overuse of smileys is indicative of ...  ...  ... je ne sais quoi LOL ...  ...  ... but something.

As you put it so eruditely??  "licking the proverbial " doesn't really come into it when there are libel laws in place.

My interpretation of that is that newspapers can't print downright lies without risk of being sued.  There again is the Portugal Resident actually a newspaper worth suing?
Isn't it more a free sheet type thing for ex pats?

You'll pleased to hear, decisions on your posts have been made as well.

As to the Portugal Resident, merely because it doesn't follow the mccann mantra, does not make it wrong.

I'm sure the Express proprietors can take the opportunity to sue those of the Resident. 8(0(*
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Mr Gray on January 07, 2016, 01:00:24 PM
You'll pleased to hear, decisions on your posts have been made as well.

As to the Portugal Resident, merely because it doesn't follow the mccann mantra, does not make it wrong.

I'm sure the Express proprietors can take the opportunity to sue those of the Resident. 8(0(*

Looks like they have already been in touch with bennett
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Carana on January 07, 2016, 03:05:04 PM
I have decided that the overuse of smileys is indicative of ...  ...  ... je ne sais quoi LOL ...  ...  ... but something.

As you put it so eruditely??  "licking the proverbial " doesn't really come into it when there are libel laws in place.

My interpretation of that is that newspapers can't print downright lies without risk of being sued.  There again is the Portugal Resident actually a newspaper worth suing?
Isn't it more a free sheet type thing for ex pats?

There is the Portugal Resident (which used to be the Algarve Resident). This was run at the time by a couple, but appears to have been taken over and IMO appears far less objective than it used to be. Numerous articles related to the Cipriano or the Madeleine case no longer appear to be online.

Portugal News is a different entity. Paul Luckman was the publisher and comes across (IMO) as a staunch Amaral supporter for whatever reason.

Brendan de Beer is / was the editor, but comes across to me as an objective journalist, who has frequently contributed to the Guardian, sometimes in association with others.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Brietta on January 07, 2016, 03:55:08 PM
There is the Portugal Resident (which used to be the Algarve Resident). This was run at the time by a couple, but appears to have been taken over and IMO appears far less objective than it used to be. Numerous articles related to the Cipriano or the Madeleine case no longer appear to be online.

Portugal News is a different entity. Paul Luckman was the publisher and comes across (IMO) as a staunch Amaral supporter for whatever reason.

Brendan de Beer is / was the editor, but comes across to me as an objective journalist, who has frequently contributed to the Guardian, sometimes in association with others.

Thanks Carana.

I have seen positive comment about Brendan de Beer's journalism as well as some criticism.  Which probably indicates that he is objective in his reporting as you can't suit everyone on every occasion.

The thing that sticks in my mind about Paul Luckman is his interview with Eamonn Holmes about burglaries which I found hilarious (the interview ... not the burglaries, which can be dangerous as well as traumatic).
Luckman was in denial and Holmes had just suffered a burglary.
I agree with your assessment of Luckman.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on January 07, 2016, 04:41:45 PM
Thanks Carana.

I have seen positive comment about Brendan de Beer's journalism as well as some criticism.  Which probably indicates that he is objective in his reporting as you can't suit everyone on every occasion.

The thing that sticks in my mind about Paul Luckman is his interview with Eamonn Holmes about burglaries which I found hilarious (the interview ... not the burglaries, which can be dangerous as well as traumatic).
Luckman was in denial and Holmes had just suffered a burglary.
I agree with your assessment of Luckman.
I'd suggest you take more into account when assessing Luckman, whatever then results.

I was looking at that video for something else a little while back, and the reality of what happened is somewhat different.

The news had come out that burglaries had been reported to UK police, I think by way of Crimewatch call lines.

So what source did Holmes think could magically explain 'more burglaries'?  Should Luckman have a source inside OG when clearly Holmes did not?  Should Luckman have had a source inside the PJ, when clearly Holmes did not?  Were all these crimes reported to the Portuguese police?  I don't know the answer.  Holmes did not know the answer.  Why is Luckman supposed to know?

If Holmes (or team) had done just a little bit of thinking they would have realised judicial secrecy laws should have prevented Luckman from getting this information.  Even if he had some info, asking him to say on camera that he was probably breaking the law in doing so is hardly an intelligent approach.

My personal assessment is that framing the question in such a way live on-line is about as dumb as it gets.  If Holmes actually thinks Luckman has more information, he should have got it off-line, then simply trotted out "a source close to the investigation informed us ...".

I don't think this interview shows Luckman in a bad light.  I do think the approach used by Holmes was ill-thought out.  As to the capability of Luckman or Holmes in general, I have no evidence or opinion.

Speaking personally, I would take the article as an apology, irrespective of whether certain specific words were used.  If a newspaper prints that someone lied, and then is forced to retract that in a subsequent statement, the apology might be half-hearted, but taking the meaning of the whole text into account, it is there.

Since we are supposedly united in justice for Madeleine, getting rid of such mistruths is a small step of progress.

For the record, I am neither an Amaral supporter or detractor.  I don't have enough evidence to form a valid opinion, and I have no interest in wading through hours of case material etc. to come to a conclusion on this.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: Brietta on January 07, 2016, 05:14:27 PM
I'd suggest you take more into account when assessing Luckman, whatever then results.

I was looking at that video for something else a little while back, and the reality of what happened is somewhat different.

The news had come out that burglaries had been reported to UK police, I think by way of Crimewatch call lines.

So what source did Holmes think could magically explain 'more burglaries'?  Should Luckman have a source inside OG when clearly Holmes did not?  Should Luckman have had a source inside the PJ, when clearly Holmes did not?  Were all these crimes reported to the Portuguese police?  I don't know the answer.  Holmes did not know the answer.  Why is Luckman supposed to know?

If Holmes (or team) had done just a little bit of thinking they would have realised judicial secrecy laws should have prevented Luckman from getting this information.  Even if he had some info, asking him to say on camera that he was probably breaking the law in doing so is hardly an intelligent approach.

My personal assessment is that framing the question in such a way live on-line is about as dumb as it gets.  If Holmes actually thinks Luckman has more information, he should have got it off-line, then simply trotted out "a source close to the investigation informed us ...".

I don't think this interview shows Luckman in a bad light.  I do think the approach used by Holmes was ill-thought out.  As to the capability of Luckman or Holmes in general, I have no evidence or opinion.

Speaking personally, I would take the article as an apology, irrespective of whether certain specific words were used.  If a newspaper prints that someone lied, and then is forced to retract that in a subsequent statement, the apology might be half-hearted, but taking the meaning of the whole text into account, it is there.

Since we are supposedly united in justice for Madeleine, getting rid of such mistruths is a small step of progress.

For the record, I am neither an Amaral supporter or detractor.  I don't have enough evidence to form a valid opinion, and I have no interest in wading through hours of case material etc. to come to a conclusion on this.

With respect, I really do not see where judicial secrecy comes into the equation ... if it did ... Luckman was surely at liberty to say as much to Holmes and answer those questions he could.

He gave an interview on the same subject to BBC radio the transcript can be read and the audio can be listened to here ... http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/press/84april14/5Live_24_04_2014.htm ... in which he mentioned no constraints of secrecy but with his negative signature as regards any progress in Madeleine's case well to the fore.

One thing I found interesting was his confirmation of the sharing of information not only with the Met but with Madeleine's parents.


**Snip
Em we had a situation where er the Met stated that the police, the Portuguese police had not told them about a Cape Verdian who apparently was accused of three rapes of children and yet we had it directly from the police that in fact they had briefed the Met and the McCanns 6 months earlier in Lisbon even with a power point presentation on this case so these things don't do an awful lot to help relations and uh lets see what happens.
Title: Re: Did the Daily Express apologise to Gonçalo Amaral?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on January 07, 2016, 08:28:26 PM
With respect, I really do not see where judicial secrecy comes into the equation ... if it did ... Luckman was surely at liberty to say as much to Holmes and answer those questions he could.

He gave an interview on the same subject to BBC radio the transcript can be read and the audio can be listened to here ... http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/press/84april14/5Live_24_04_2014.htm ... in which he mentioned no constraints of secrecy but with his negative signature as regards any progress in Madeleine's case well to the fore.

One thing I found interesting was his confirmation of the sharing of information not only with the Met but with Madeleine's parents.


**Snip
Em we had a situation where er the Met stated that the police, the Portuguese police had not told them about a Cape Verdian who apparently was accused of three rapes of children and yet we had it directly from the police that in fact they had briefed the Met and the McCanns 6 months earlier in Lisbon even with a power point presentation on this case so these things don't do an awful lot to help relations and uh lets see what happens.
On the Holmes front Luckman should have pointed out 1) judicial secrecy 2) simply state that he had, at that time, no information.  Holmes was treating Luckman as the 'knowledgeable' source on the Algarve.  Your link makes it clear that Luckman thought the Portuguese media was one of his sources, better informed than he was.  He should have pointed that out to Holmes.  Further, if there was anything in the Portuguese media about it at the time, he should have said "according to Portuguese media sources ..."

I don't know whether there was much or anything about it in the Portuguese media at the time.  I don't read Portuguese newspapers on a regular basis.  I seldom watch Portuguese news on TV.  So I am not stating an idea I don't know about as fact.

I do know that the airing of Crimewatch 2013 and the Smithman e-fits were told about on Portuguese TV.  However, I cannot find anything other than minor stories that do not put these e-fits into real context.

Let me move on to the link you posted, Brietta.  Many thanks for that.

I have copied the bit that immediately precedes your quote.

"PL – Yes, totally em this, this suggestion that they're not. I read headlines in the UK this morning arrests imminent … complete nonsense em the, the Met cannot make and I am sure they're not even claiming, they can't come into Portugal to make arrests mm you'll remember we had a situation like this 2, 3 months ago where there was mass coverage and they were arriving to make arrests and it just petered into nothing, there was nothing it was just a regular visit."

What do we have in the mix now?

UK press gets checked by Luckman, and supposedly reporting imminent arrests.  Luckman points out this is nonsense.

He then goes on in your section to discuss what Cape Verde man has or has not been up to.  Luckman claims that SY are ignorant of CVman being involved in multiple child rape cases.  He also asserts that this supposed ignorance is untrue, claiming that the Met and the McCanns were given a Powerpoint briefing months earlier. According to Portuguese sources who are better placed than him.

Assuming Portuguese media is correct, one CVman was investigated by the PJ team from Oporto, but was subsequently cleared.

Why the Porto team would brief the McCanns is beyond me.  I can see them briefing OG, but I cannot see them briefing the McCanns.

The final bit is simple.  Was CVman ever investigated for raping 3 children?  I haven't seen that allegation anywhere, not in Portuguese media, and not in the UK media who would have had it as front page news.

in Holmes v Luckman, Luckman should simply have quoted judicial secrecy, and stated that he could not confirm OG claims re break-ins.  Holmes did not cover himself in glory with his approach.

Trying to pick useful information out of this lot is like sifting through a train wreck.