TVI ordered to pay €20,000 to Robert Murat for calling him a "paedophile".

[barrier]

Didn't the PJ dig up parts of Casa Liliana back in May 2007 and used probes and ground penetrating radar in an attempt to find any trace of the missing child.

Didn't their attentions then turn elsewhere after finding zilch concerning R Murat.

[Robittybob1]

Didn't their attentions then turn elsewhere after finding zilch concerning R Murat.

But would you bury a child in your own mother's backyard?  IMO it is an odd place to look.  OK at least they eliminated that section.  But just one of thousands of potential sections I'd imagine.

[Sunny]

But would you bury a child in your own mother's backyard?  IMO it is an odd place to look.  OK at least they eliminated that section.  But just one of thousands of potential sections I'd imagine.

I think that barrier wasn't just referring to the digs at Casa Liliana Robittybob1 but other investigations regarding Robert Murat that turned up nothing against him.

[Robittybob1]

I think that barrier wasn't just referring to the digs at Casa Liliana Robittybob1 but other investigations regarding Robert Murat that turned up nothing against him.

I'm a bit confused now sorry.  I don't study RM.

[Robittybob1]

have you not seen supporters abused on other forums......we were referred to as arse lickers here today

Really did I miss that one?

[Sunny]

I'm a bit confused now sorry.  I don't study RM.

Neither have I Robittybob1 but I have read enough to see that there was nothing against him (I think).

[Robittybob1]

Neither have I Robittybob1 but I have read enough to see that there was nothing against him (I think).

But what do you think about this statement from Stephen Carpenter?  http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=9966.msg481335#msg481335

[Sunny]

But what do you think about this statement from Stephen Carpenter?  http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=9966.msg481335#msg481335

I have seen it before but it is most interesting though.  As they searched Murat's house and indeed dug up his garden I remember reading then I can't see anything pointing to him.

However who is the 50 year old Englishman?

From Stephen Carpenter's statement


And when we entered the garage I asked who lived there, he replied that his son lived there and then there were distractions and because I was concentrated on the fifty year old English man, this man is Portuguese

I will have a look see if I can find the laundryworker too.

[Robittybob1]

I have seen it before but it is most interesting though.  As they searched Murat's house and indeed dug up his garden I remember reading then I can't see anything pointing to him.

However who is the 50 year old Englishman?

From Stephen Carpenter's statement


And when we entered the garage I asked who lived there, he replied that his son lived there and then there were distractions and because I was concentrated on the fifty year old English man, this man is Portuguese

I will have a look see if I can find the laundryworker too.

If you find anything could you post it here please?
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10045.0

[Sunny]

If you find anything could you post it here please?
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10045.0

Will do 

[barrier]

I think that barrier wasn't just referring to the digs at Casa Liliana Robittybob1 but other investigations regarding Robert Murat that turned up nothing against him.

Got it in one.

[Miss Taken Identity]

Got it in one.

He answered ALL the questions, was released with all his pc and hardware, which was confiscated, which is very telling. So we need to ask- who put him in the frame and why? was this to take the heat away from the parents? and was this why the PJ may have began to think- hang on...abduction? let's look at this story again see if it fits lol

[Miss Taken Identity]

Possibly because he is as yet the only P J officer who was involved in the investigation who has turned his thoughts on the case into a source of income.

You think?

what about the parents a lot more wealthy than before Their daughters disappearance. They even set up a company and began 'selling' their wares.  The newspapers, Kates pubisher, the lawyers the PR team...hmm but lets not talk about that... eh? 

[Robittybob1]

It was marketing.

[Sunny]

His book was imo written as a money earning exercise . His book is based on his flawed thinking and reasoning.
He accused Madeleine's parents of being involved in her disappearance.
There's absolutely nothing about the man which I admire.
I would say more but this is all off topic.

Erngath, what are your views on Danny Collins and his book Vanished, The Truth About The Disappearance of Madeleine McCann. You could say exactly the same about his book, and IMO that was certainly flawed and he certainly wrote it to make money for himself.

I have read the first one but not his latest book so I can't say if it was any better.