Madeleine McCann alive?

[barrier]

The Supreme Court of Portugal is nothing to write home about.

Pointless the ECHR route is then.

[barrier]

How about the Archiving Report which can be found in the PJ files ???

What of it? nothing much to write home about.

[G-Unit]

The Supreme Court of Portugal is nothing to write home about.

They could see that the archiving dispatch was filed under the wrong part of Article 277.

[Eleanor]

Pointless the ECHR route is then.

The ECHR is precisely the place to go.

[pathfinder73]

Difficult for some to accept..

Adrian Prout wasn't a suspect before he was arrested. People will believe anything 

[Brietta]

What of it? nothing much to write home about.

Don't know about that ... perhaps it is all in the understanding of exactly what it was that the Prosecutors concluded when dropping all legal restrictions against the chosen arguidos.

Madeleine McCann files: Portuguese prosecutors criticise police
Portuguese prosecutors have fiercely criticised the country's police for failing to uncover any clues over Madeleine McCann's disappearance.
By Caroline Gammell in Portimao 12:09PM BST 05 Aug 2008
Detectives' inability even to establish whether the toddler is alive or dead epitomised the inquiry's shortcomings, said public prosecutors Jose de Magalhaes and Joao Melchior Gomes.

The case against Kate and Gerry McCann, both 40, was dropped last month after it was decided that there was insufficient evidence against the couple.
...
The prosecutors said despite the huge manhunt and inquiry, little had been achieved.

"No element of proof whatsoever was found which allows us to form any lucid, sensible, serious and honest conclusion about the circumstances (of Madeleine's disappearance).

"Including, and most dramatically, establishing whether she is alive or dead, which seems more probable."
...
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/2504246/Madeleine-McCann-files-Portuguese-prosecutors-criticise-police.html


Which brings us right back round to where we should be bearing in mind that the discussion on this thread asks the question of whether or not Madeleine McCann is still alive ... raising the on topic question of who it was who declared her dead without a shred of evidence to support that hypothesis as stated by the Portuguese Prosecutors?

[Miss Taken Identity]

Don't know about that ... perhaps it is all in the understanding of exactly what it was that the Prosecutors concluded when dropping all legal restrictions against the chosen arguidos.

Madeleine McCann files: Portuguese prosecutors criticise police
Portuguese prosecutors have fiercely criticised the country's police for failing to uncover any clues over Madeleine McCann's disappearance.
By Caroline Gammell in Portimao 12:09PM BST 05 Aug 2008
Detectives' inability even to establish whether the toddler is alive or dead epitomised the inquiry's shortcomings, said public prosecutors Jose de Magalhaes and Joao Melchior Gomes.





The case against Kate and Gerry McCann, both 40, was dropped last month after it was decided that there was insufficient evidence against the couple.
...
The prosecutors said despite the huge manhunt and inquiry, little had been achieved.

"No element of proof whatsoever was found which allows us to form any lucid, sensible, serious and honest conclusion about the circumstances (of Madeleine's disappearance).

"Including, and most dramatically, establishing whether she is alive or dead, which seems more probable."
...
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/2504246/Madeleine-McCann-files-Portuguese-prosecutors-criticise-police.html


Which brings us right back round to where we should be bearing in mind that the discussion on this thread asks the question of whether or not Madeleine McCann is still alive ... raising the on topic question of who it was who declared her dead without a shred of evidence to support that hypothesis as stated by the Portuguese Prosecutors?

The case against Kate and Gerry McCann, both 40, was dropped last month after it was decided that there was insufficient evidence against the couple.


Yes  this does not equate to INNOCENT/ or CLEARED.

I do not believe MBM was declared dead or alive. the evidence would be 50/50 surely? i.e she is either dead or not dead.

The theory was mentioned. an accident perhaps... this was part of an analysis of probabilities- what could have happened- them police do these things ALL the time.. tsk.

[Miss Taken Identity]

They know what crime wasn't committed

 

Yeah they know there was no abduction from  bed by via a window!  everythig else is still on the table!

[Eleanor]

Yeah they know there was no abduction from  bed by via a window!  everythig else is still on the table!

Are you spoiling for a fight?  If so, take care.

[Miss Taken Identity]

Are you spoiling for a fight?  If so, take care.

No I don't need to 'fight'.  All this is evidenced! No one is looking for 'tannerman' and SY are looking at 'woke and wandered'. says it all really.

[Eleanor]

No I don't need to 'fight'.  All this is evidenced! No one is looking for 'tannerman' and SY are looking at 'woke and wandered'. says it all really.

No it doesn't.  You are cherry picking and stating Opinion as Fact.

[Vertigo Swirl]

No I don't need to 'fight'.  All this is evidenced! No one is looking for 'tannerman' and SY are looking at 'woke and wandered'. says it all really.

Can you provide a cite for SY know Madeleine wasn’t abducted please .

[Angelo222]

The mccanns were suspects... Now they are not...there is no real chance of them being involved... They have been cleared

Nonsense.  Nobody has yet been arrested for the crime whatever that is let alone prosecuted so the case is wide open. The Portuguese Supreme Court have gone to the trouble to make it be known that the McCanns have not been cleared and that is good enough for me regardless of all the bleating to the contrary.

The McCanns had every opportunity back in 2007 to cooperate fully with the police but for some reason they chose not to do so.  They brought all of this down upon their own heads from the moment they went out socialising leaving three young vulnerable children alone.  Their stupidity is unmatched imo.

They have never been cleared of involvement in any criminal conduct whether that be pre disappearance or post disappearance and that is down to them and their friends.

[Miss Taken Identity]

Can you provide a cite for SY know Madeleine wasn’t abducted please .

from the window.. hmm it is well documented in another thread go look.

Parents claim MBM was abducted via window you all argued how it was possible - rest my case.

[barrier]

Which brings us right back round to where we should be bearing in mind that the discussion on this thread asks the question of whether or not Madeleine McCann is still alive ... raising the on topic question of who it was who declared her dead without a shred of evidence to support that hypothesis as stated by the Portuguese Prosecutors?

No one but no one from any investigation as said they have evidence she left 5a alive,the last person to offer a opinion was Rowley,(and I'd surmise it will be the last we hear),is that they have no evidence pointing to Madeleine being dead or alive.£11+ million buys that gem.