Netflix launches new 8-part documentary about the disappearance of Madeleine McCann.

[ShiningInLuz]

Along with several  amusing  anecdotes.

From memory, it was with a stiff brandy or two.

Leah Chase has just died.  I need to go and look up her recipe for gumbo.   

[Mr Gray]

There is another video of Gerry laughing in doors a couple of days after Madeleine went missing.  I find that difficult to explain.

my reply has been removed....I certainly understand it...nothing abnormal atall imo..but perhaps I have more experience of life and death

[Robittybob1]

that was the expression used...you and others are making an assumption it was  a joke

A stand up comedian will sometimes make a joke but the audience doesn't laugh.  Was that still a joke?

Saying "will they put the dogs on the stand" etc is a joke in my way of thinking.  Whether Kate found it funny or laconic is up to her.

[Mr Gray]

A stand up comedian will sometimes make a joke but the audience doesn't laugh.  Was that still a joke?

Saying "will they put the dogs on the stand" etc is a joke in my way of thinking.  Whether Kate found it funny or laconic is up to her.

you can think it was joke but you have no right to assume kate saw it as  a joke...or CF intended it as a joke

[G-Unit]

What’s important is not the way Freud spoke but the words he said.

Was Kate McCann accused of nymphomania? Where did Freud get that from?

[Robittybob1]

Either the parents are psychopaths who did away with their child’s body and were having a laugh and a joke with Clement about the dogs or they weren’t and they did n’t and would therefore know that the dog alerts were rubbish.  Which is it in your view?

IMO it is not a clear cut choice as you make out.  In my theory I introduce the cadaver dog alerts to another body.  So the choice had another option
1. Either the parents are psychopaths who did away with their child’s body and were having a laugh and a joke with Clement about the dogs

2.  or they weren’t and they did n’t and would therefore know that the dog alerts were rubbish.
3. the cadaver dog alerted to another body.

They are the choices as I see it. Not just two choices but three.

[Mr Gray]

Was Kate McCann accused of nymphomania? Where did Freud get that from?

where did you get it from

[Mr Gray]

IMO it is not a clear cut choice as you make out.  In my theory I introduce the cadaver dog alerts to another body.  So the choice had another option
1. Either the parents are psychopaths who did away with their child’s body and were having a laugh and a joke with Clement about the dogs

2.  or they weren’t and they did n’t and would therefore know that the dog alerts were rubbish.
3. the cadaver dog alerted to another body.

They are the choices as I see it. Not just two choices but three.

theres more

the alert was false
the alert was due to accidental contamination by the pj
or deliberate contamination by the pj

[Robittybob1]

you can think it was joke but you have no right to assume kate saw it as  a joke...or CF intended it as a joke

Do I need permission to make assumptions?  No I don't think so I just do.

[Mr Gray]

Do I need permission to make assumptions?  No I don't think so I just do.

you can make as amny assumptions as you like ....but conclusions based on assunptions have no value

[Robittybob1]

where did you get it from

It is from Kate's book. 

[Mr Gray]

It is from Kate's book.

kate doesnt talk about joking...you need to stick to the facts

[Robittybob1]

you can make as amny assumptions as you like ....but conclusions based on assunptions have no value

Yet you agreed with John didn't you.  He made an assumption and someone agreed with him. Did that agreement have no value?

[Robittybob1]

kate doesnt talk about joking...you need to stick to the facts

We are now discussing her being described as a "nymphomaniac". 

[Mr Gray]

Yet you agreed with John didn't you.  He made an assumption and someone agreed with him. Did that agreement have no value?

I agreed with johns cite which showed evidence....john made no assumption...he provided a cite