Netflix launches new 8-part documentary about the disappearance of Madeleine McCann.

[Mr Gray]

We are now discussing her being described as a "nymphomaniac".

by whom

[slartibartfast]

by whom

CF

[Robittybob1]

by whom

Wasn't that the question.  Who raised the issue of Kate being described as a nymphomaniac first?  CF had never met Kate before so it can't be from personal experience.

[Mr Gray]

CF

Im not aware ...cite please

[Mr Gray]

Wasn't that the question.  Who raised the issue of Kate being described as a nymphomaniac first?  CF had never met Kate before so it can't be from personal experience.

lets see the cite first

[Robittybob1]

lets see the cite first

The paragraph from her book has been cited several times already.

[Mr Gray]

The paragraph from her book has been cited several times already.

ive read it now...he asks a question...that is not a statement

[Robittybob1]

when and where

Here is John citation of the part of the book under discussion http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10613.msg532703#msg532703

[Mr Gray]

Here is John citation of the part of the book under discussion http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10613.msg532703#msg532703

he asks a question...why is that so important to posters

[Robittybob1]

ive read it now...he asks a question...that is not a statement

The question asked was one from him trying to determine the facts:  "‘So,  Kate,  which  of  the  devout  Catholic, alcoholic,  depressed,  nymphomaniac  parts  is correct?’"

Which of those is a fact or what was just rumour.  But who started those rumours?  Did he formulate those concepts from reading the Portuguese papers?  I surely hope he wasn't also a confidant of Amaral.

[Mr Gray]

The question asked was one from him trying to determine the facts:  "‘So,  Kate,  which  of  the  devout  Catholic, alcoholic,  depressed,  nymphomaniac  parts  is correct?’"

Which of those is a fact or what was just rumour.  But who started those rumours?  Did he formulate those concepts from reading the Portuguese papers?  I surely hope he wasn't also a confidant of Amaral.

why is taht important

[Robittybob1]

why is taht important

Are you being serious or just being facetious?  Being a depressed mother could easily be important to the case.

[Mr Gray]

Are you being serious or just being facetious?  Being a depressed mother could easily be important to the case.

I'm  serious....if you are serious send your concerns to the PJ.. I'm sure they will laugh at them

[Robittybob1]

I'm  serious....if you are serious send your concerns to the PJ.. I'm sure they will laugh at them

What!  My concerns about you would be a joke to the PJ.  Well that tells us something doesn't it?

[G-Unit]

The question asked was one from him trying to determine the facts:  "‘So,  Kate,  which  of  the  devout  Catholic, alcoholic,  depressed,  nymphomaniac  parts  is correct?’"

Which of those is a fact or what was just rumour.  But who started those rumours?  Did he formulate those concepts from reading the Portuguese papers?  I surely hope he wasn't also a confidant of Amaral.

I don't recall any speculation or rumours about nymphomania, so I wondered why it entered Freud's mind, that's all.