A Good, Bad or Average Theory What's The Difference?

[Vertigo Swirl]

Kids in China have been stolen to order to live with other families, some of them forget their past identities.  It’s fairly well known.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Right'O.

Let's have some examples of such a thing happening.

Google Steven Sayner.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Or how about this case?
https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/health-and-families/features/an-abducted-child-reveals-the-true-story-of-her-stolen-life-three-decades-later-a6711121.html

Let me know when you’ve had enough Spam.

[Wonderfulspam]

Or how about this case?
https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/health-and-families/features/an-abducted-child-reveals-the-true-story-of-her-stolen-life-three-decades-later-a6711121.html

Let me know when you’ve had enough Spam.

Abducted by her own father.

Next.

[Anthro]

Hi Vertigo Swirl, are you thinking of Natascha Kampusch?

[Vertigo Swirl]

Hi Vertigo Swirl, are you thinking of Natascha Kampusch?

Yes, her.  Also there are some of the half million kids who were forcibily removed from this country and sent to live in Australia in the last century, many of whom lost touch with who they really were, their family name, siblings etc. 

[Wonderfulspam]

Maybe Maddie was abducted by an Amish community, can't google her own name.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Abducted by her own father.

Next.

So what?  This is what you found so hard to believe -

"The idea that Maddie is alive & well, living with some foreign family is cobblers.

How has she forgotten her parents, siblings & her own bleedin name ffs?"

And this case demonstrates perfectly well that it is possible, unless you can explain why it does not?

[Vertigo Swirl]

Maybe Maddie was abducted by an Amish community, can't google her own name.

If she doesn't know her own name maybe nothing's coming up when she googles her new name. 

[Vertigo Swirl]

Spam seems to believe it is impossible for a child to forget details such as the name they were called for the first 4 years of their life and details of their early childhood.  Has this been scientifically proven to be the case?

[Wonderfulspam]

Google Steven Sayner.

Stayner claims he knew who he was but was unaware of how to summon help.

Next.

[Wonderfulspam]

So what?  This is what you found so hard to believe -

"The idea that Maddie is alive & well, living with some foreign family is cobblers.

How has she forgotten her parents, siblings & her own bleedin name ffs?"

And this case demonstrates perfectly well that it is possible, unless you want explain why it does not?

Because Maddie died May 3rd 2007. Imo

[G-Unit]

If Madeleine was abducted and taken to live in another family she was definitely harmed psychologically by that experience in my opinion.

[Wonderfulspam]

That girl in Germany who was abducted by some bloke and kept for years.  Can’t remember her name.

Natasha what's her face.
Knew who she was but was held locked in the paedo's basement & couldn't summon help.

Next.

[Eleanor]

I doubt that I would have remembered my name from four years old, especially if I had been given a new name.

Her new life would have been full of new things.  New places and possibly a new language.

There might be some vestiges in there somewhere.  But where could she start from when her new life would have been so very different?

I was called Mitch from a very young age, by all and sundry outside of the family, so I have some difficulty in remembering who Maureen was.  I have to adjust my thinking when addressed by my family.