A Good, Bad or Average Theory What's The Difference?

[G-Unit]

Do you believe there is a possibility that Amaral is lying or that his chums in the PJ are lying to him?

Lying about Operation Grange looking at a German paedophile? I've no idea, but the UK newspapers seem to have run with it and have speculated that it was Ney. Upon which he clarified that it wasn't Ney. Perhaps he got his information from a UK policeman, have you thought of that? Didn't some of them donate to his friend's GoFundMe appeal which enabled him to defend himself against the McCann's attack?

[Vertigo Swirl]

Lying about Operation Grange looking at a German paedophile? I've no idea, but the UK newspapers seem to have run with it and have speculated that it was Ney. Upon which he clarified that it wasn't Ney. Perhaps he got his information from a UK policeman, have you thought of that? Didn't some of them donate to his friend's GoFundMe appeal which enabled him to defend himself against the McCann's attack?

Hang on a minute.   You think some UK cops supportive of Amaral would feed him misinformation (an ex-cop in Portugal notorious for his campaign against the McCsnns) that the investigation was focused on a specific German paedophile and that Amaral would be gullible enough to lap it up and spill the beans to the media?  This seems a tortuous conspiracy theory too far as far as I’m concerned!

[G-Unit]

Hang on a minute.   You think some UK cops supportive of Amaral would feed him misinformation (an ex-cop in Portugal notorious for his campaign against the McCsnns) that the investigation was focused on a specific German paedophile and that Amaral would be gullible enough to lap it up and spill the beans to the media?  This seems a tortuous conspiracy theory too far as far as I’m concerned!

So you think the story that Operation Grange is looking at a German paedophile is a lie?

[Mr Gray]

So you think the story that Operation Grange is looking at a German paedophile is a lie?

Afaiac... I don't know and I don't particularly care

[Vertigo Swirl]

So you think the story that Operation Grange is looking at a German paedophile is a lie?

No I don’t.  Do you?
Why would police involved in Operation Grange tell Amaral what they were investigating though?
Also, fyi, I don’t believe there is any real evidence that any cops from the Met supported or continue to support Amaral.

[Mr Gray]

No I don’t.  Do you?
Why would police involved in Operation Grange tell Amaral what they were investigating though?
Also, fyi, I don’t believe there is any real evidence that any cops from the Met supported or continue to support Amaral.

I agree with the comment in UK police supporting amaral.. Total fantasy imo

[Eleanor]

No I don’t.  Do you?
Why would police involved in Operation Grange tell Amaral what they were investigating though?
Also, fyi, I don’t believe there is any real evidence that any cops from the Met supported or continue to support Amaral.

The donation by British Police was very iffy.  It was a lump sum attributed to several unnamed Police Officers, but largely thought to have come from PeterMac himself.
Although there was no direct proof.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Let’s pretend for a minute thst it’s true.  There’s a bunch of UK police officers who support Amaral.  Not only that but they are receiving information direct from Op Grange concerning sensitive info re: the investigation.  They phone up Amaral and give him the juicy morsels concerning a German paedo.  Why?  Just so he can get a few quid by selling the story to the media?
Alternatively, these are Gonc supporting cops feeding him duff info - why?

[Vertigo Swirl]

I’m going for the Occam’s Razor principle here.  Bent ex-cop is receiving insider info from his ex-colleagues who are renowned for leaking info about this case over the years, and the information is correct.  The investigation is focused on stranger abduction and not the McCanns.  Bent ex-cop is making a few quid peddling said leaked info to the press. 

All IMO.

[G-Unit]

No I don’t.  Do you?
Why would police involved in Operation Grange tell Amaral what they were investigating though?
Also, fyi, I don’t believe there is any real evidence that any cops from the Met supported or continue to support Amaral.

So you think Operation Grange is interested in a German paedophile? If so, then Amaral wasn't lying when he said that.

[Vertigo Swirl]

So you think Operation Grange is interested in a German paedophile? If so, then Amaral wasn't lying when he said that.

I never said he was.  In fact I would say it’s almost certain that Op Grange are pursuing stranger abduction and not the McCanns, which is what I’ve been saying for years, but doubters continue to doubt,

[G-Unit]

I never said he was.  In fact I would say it’s almost certain that Op Grange are pursuing stranger abduction and not the McCanns, which is what I’ve been saying for years, but doubters continue to doubt,

So if Amaral wasn't lying his information came from somewhere, and the UK police and the Portuguese police are possible sources as both would have access to it.

[Mr Gray]

So if Amaral wasn't lying his information came from somewhere, and the UK police and the Portuguese police are possible sources as both would have access to it.

correct...you can speculate either...for what its worth

[G-Unit]

I never said he was.  In fact I would say it’s almost certain that Op Grange are pursuing stranger abduction and not the McCanns, which is what I’ve been saying for years, but doubters continue to doubt,

Oh, sorry. I thought that's where you were going when you said he had repeated disinformation. So it was true?

[Vertigo Swirl]

Oh, sorry. I thought that's where you were going when you said he had repeated disinformation. So it was true?

You having a bad comprehension day or something?  I suggest you read back.