A Good, Bad or Average Theory What's The Difference?

[Mr Gray]

In the dark how could it be 100% for anybody? Body language was the main factor in Martin Smith naming GM -  he witnessed an action replay of that night.

He states he was watching the 10 pm news on BBC and saw the McCANNS getting off the plane and coming down the steps. He states it was like watching an action replay of the night he saw the male carrying the child back in Portugal. He states the way Gerry was carrying his twin triggered something in his head. It was exactly the same way and look of the other male seen the night Maddy went missing.

https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_SMITH.htm

if you give credence to the smith sighting then you should give more credence to the 99% sighting of maddie in the petrol station. Fhen we have all the other sightings.

i think its clear smith thought it might be Gerry...but he was wrong

[G-Unit]

The answer is obvious and I'm surprised you need it explained
Amaral was the only one to write a book... The only one to appear on tv... The only one giving multiple interviews promoting the theory.
The others kept it where it belonged... Inside the investigation

The McCanns appeared on TV, gave multiple interviews and wrote a book. Why should they be the only ones allowed to promote their theory?

[Mr Gray]

The McCanns appeared on TV, gave multiple interviews and wrote a book. Why should they be the only ones allowed to promote their theory?

Again a simple answer...because their daughter was missing...wht amaral did and has done is a total disgrace imo...hopefully the ECHR will agree and censure amaral and portugal

the mccanns aim is to promote  the search for their daughter...what is amarals

[barrier]

It might seem like that to you... Perhaps I just do it to wind up amaral supporters... And he is a lying convicted criminal

Again a simple answer...because their daughter was missing...wht amaral did and has done is a total disgrace imo...hopefully the ECHR will agree and censure amaral and portugal

Clearly it winds you up,not to wind the Amaral "supporters" up.

[Mr Gray]

Clearly it winds you up,not to wind the Amaral "supporters" up.

is that supposed to make some sense

[Wonderfulspam]

if you give credence to the smith sighting then you should give more credence to the 99% sighting of maddie in the petrol station. Fhen we have all the other sightings.

i think its clear smith thought it might be Gerry...but he was wrong

The Smith sighting took place in PDL within a short walking distance of the apartment at roughly 10:04 on the night Maddie disappeared.

The alarm was raised somewhere between 9:50 (MO) & 10:15 (GM).


The petrol station sighting took place some six days later, in a completely different country.....where the abductor had now supposedly given up hiding the worlds most high profile missing child, preferring instead to allow her to wander round a petrol station asking for her mum.

[Wonderfulspam]

 "She had this pretty face and long blonde hair to the shoulders, green eyes."

https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/8737819/madeleine-mccann-morocco-petrol-station-sighting/


She was close enough to be able to see her eye colour.

Give over. 

[G-Unit]

Again a simple answer...because their daughter was missing...wht amaral did and has done is a total disgrace imo...hopefully the ECHR will agree and censure amaral and portugal

the mccanns aim is to promote  the search for their daughter...what is amarals

Amaral thinks the child is dead, the McCanns say she's alive. No-one knows who's right, but why should one be censored and not the other?

[Vertigo Swirl]

I agree with you to some extent but there were extenuating factors which led police to the conclusions they came to. One such factor was an independent eye witness who was categoric that he had met GM that night carrying an unresponsive female child.

He was far from categoric, by as much as 40% in fact.

[Vertigo Swirl]

The answer is obvious and I'm surprised you need it explained
Amaral was the only one to write a book... The only one to appear on tv... The only one giving multiple interviews promoting the theory.
The others kept it where it belonged... Inside the investigation

Exactemundo 

[Vertigo Swirl]

Amaral thinks the child is dead, the McCanns say she's alive. No-one knows who's right, but why should one be censored and not the other?

Because one is making wholly unsubstantiated claims about the others, surely even you can understand this?

[Vertigo Swirl]

Amaral thinks the child is dead, the McCanns say she's alive. No-one knows who's right, but why should one be censored and not the other?

Says the woman who demands that “Remoaners” must now shut up.  When must sceptics do likewise?

[Mr Gray]

Amaral thinks the child is dead, the McCanns say she's alive. No-one knows who's right, but why should one be censored and not the other?

areyou serious or just in denial....amaral is saying a lot more than Maddie is dead...he is saying the mccanns have lied and they know what happened to her...and he is claiming the evidence supports this when it doesnt

[pathfinder73]

if you give credence to the smith sighting then you should give more credence to the 99% sighting of maddie in the petrol station. Fhen we have all the other sightings.

i think its clear smith thought it might be Gerry...but he was wrong

They didn't release his efits in their no stone unturned? book. No they wanted to nail it on Tannerman who has been eliminated by SY. SY had to release the efits 5 years later. Everything comes back to that sighting and a dodgy watch!

[barrier]

They didn't release his efits in their no stone unturned? book. No they wanted to nail it on Tannerman who has been eliminated by SY. SY had to release the efits 5 years later. Everything comes back to that sighting and a dodgy watch!

Funny that when they weren't wearing watches according to Mitchell who wasn't there.

You had nine people in a bar without watches on, without mobile phones, and absolute panic set in when they realised what had happened.