A Good, Bad or Average Theory What's The Difference?

[Anthro]

Jez saw the woman in purple aka Jane Tanner. She had long black hair according to Jenny Murat aka Jane Tanner.

Jenny Murat’s description of the woman included ‘slight’ and ‘thin’. To me, this doesn’t fit a description of Jane Tanner.

[misty]

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/video/exterior-shots-of-gerry-and-kate-mccann-departing-the-news-footage/487715646?adppopup=true

From 38sec, Jenny Murat walking along the pavement (red top) past the "woman in purple" on morning of 4th May 2007. That's the same Jane Tanner who later was reported to have identified JM's son as Tannerman based on his gait.
Media reports quoted Jenny saying she didn't recognise the woman in purple so it's highly unlikely to have been Jane Tanner - or Luisa Todorov.
https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/3469215/madeleine-mccann-disappearance-latest-theory-woman-in-car/

[pathfinder73]

Luisa has denied it and did she have long black hair? Her hair is curly from recent pics.

[pathfinder73]

Jenny Murat’s description of the woman included ‘slight’ and ‘thin’. To me, this doesn’t fit a description of Jane Tanner.

Do you think she looks fat? Nonsense!  The woman in purple was Jane Tanner.

Jane Tanner in PDL

[Anthro]

Do you think she looks fat? Nonsense!  The woman in purple was Jane Tanner.

Jane Tanner in PDL

The fact that she doesn’t look ‘thin’ (to me at least), doesn’t mean she is fat. Those are your words. She surely is not ‘slight’. Is it known that Jane Tanner has been hanging around block 5 before Madeleine disappeared?

[pathfinder73]

Yes Jez Wilkins is the witness. Her mobile records also reveal that she was using it at that time.

"I left the apartment and turned right. I walked via the lower street, looked to the building block where the McCann apartment was situated and saw a woman dressed in purple clothing. I referred to this woman in relation to the questions asked by Jane Tanner."

https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JEREMY-WILKINS-ROGATORY.htm

The raw telecom data provided to OP TASK shows that the mobile phone attributed to Jane TANNER (0780854191) was in contact with mobile number 07949731844 at 20:30:21 hrs on 3rd May 2007

https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JANE_TANNER_MOBILE.htm

[Anthro]

Yes Jez Wilkins is the witness. Her mobile records also reveal that she was using it at that time.

"I left the apartment and turned right. I walked via the lower street, looked to the building block where the McCann apartment was situated and saw a woman dressed in purple clothing. I referred to this woman in relation to the questions asked by Jane Tanner."

https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JEREMY-WILKINS-ROGATORY.htm

The raw telecom data provided to OP TASK shows that the mobile phone attributed to Jane TANNER (0780854191) was in contact with mobile number 07949731844 at 20:30:21 hrs on 3rd May 2007

https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JANE_TANNER_MOBILE.htm

That call was made to Charlotte Gorrod?

[Anthro]

Yes Jez Wilkins is the witness. Her mobile records also reveal that she was using it at that time.

"I left the apartment and turned right. I walked via the lower street, looked to the building block where the McCann apartment was situated and saw a woman dressed in purple clothing. I referred to this woman in relation to the questions asked by Jane Tanner."

https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JEREMY-WILKINS-ROGATORY.htm

The raw telecom data provided to OP TASK shows that the mobile phone attributed to Jane TANNER (0780854191) was in contact with mobile number 07949731844 at 20:30:21 hrs on 3rd May 2007

https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JANE_TANNER_MOBILE.htm

What about Jenny Murat’s memory of whom she saw? A woman, wearing a skirt, trying to hide herself around a lamppost. [my summary]. Jane Tanner does not come across as someone wearing a skirt on holiday?

[Brietta]

What about Jenny Murat’s memory of whom she saw? A woman, wearing a skirt, trying to hide herself around a lamppost. [my summary]. Jane Tanner does not come across as someone wearing a skirt on holiday?

And what possible reason would Jane have had to try to hide herself?  She was perfectly entitled to be seen either outside her holiday accommodation or in the vicinity thereof.

The problem appears to be that whatever innocuous, legitimate or normal action taken by any of the McCann party, it is portrayed as at the least "suspicious" but the behaviour of strangers reportedly 'hanging around' in the immediate vicinity of a property soon to become a crime scene are totally ignored or excused.  Quite bizarre!

[pathfinder73]

She was most likely reading and replying to her friends text message (Charlotte in

That call was made to Charlotte Gorrod?

Yes see Jane's rog. She was most likely reading and replying to her text message outside the apartments when Jez noticed her there dressed in purple. Do you think there were two woman in purple at that time at the same location? Time to leave fantasy land!

[misty]

She was most likely reading and replying to her friends text message (Charlotte in

Yes see Jane's rog. She was most likely reading and replying to her text message outside the apartments when Jez noticed her there dressed in purple. Do you think there were two woman in purple at that time in the same location? Time to leave fantasy land!

So which car was Jenny driving when she saw the woman in purple & how do you correlate the time of the sighting with both the 8pm closing time of Baptista & Jenny arriving home at around the same time as Robert? (see statement 15/5/07 https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JENNIFER-MURAT.htm). Robert said he arrived home between 7.15 & 7.30pm in his first statement

[pathfinder73]

So which car was Jenny driving when she saw the woman in purple & how do you correlate the time of the sighting with both the 8pm closing time of Baptista & Jenny arriving home at around the same time as Robert? (see statement 15/5/07 https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JENNIFER-MURAT.htm). Robert said he arrived home between 7.15 & 7.30pm in his first statement

About 19h50 she went to the "Batista" supermarket to buy bread

https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JENNIFER-MURAT.htm

She said in reports that she was on her way back from the supermarket when she spotted the woman in purple.

[misty]

About 19h50 she went to the "Batista" supermarket to buy bread

https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JENNIFER-MURAT.htm

She said in reports that she was on her way back from the supermarket when she spotted the woman in purple.

Baptista closed at 8pm. How long would it have taken JM to make that short drive up Rua FdG Martins & what car was she driving?

[barrier]

And what possible reason would Jane have had to try to hide herself?  She was perfectly entitled to be seen either outside her holiday accommodation or in the vicinity thereof.

The problem appears to be that whatever innocuous, legitimate or normal action taken by any of the McCann party, it is portrayed as at the least "suspicious" but the behaviour of strangers reportedly 'hanging around' in the immediate vicinity of a property soon to become a crime scene are totally ignored or excused.  Quite bizarre!

The Very same can be said of any one that was going about their daily business and trying to retro fit them into something suspicious like an alleged abduction by amateur sleuths. St Mary Mead is where it belongs.

[Mr Gray]

The Very same can be said of any one that was going about their daily business and trying to retro fit them into something suspicious like an alleged abduction by amateur sleuths. St Mary Mead is where it belongs.

But the likelihood of an abduction has been confirmed by the professional sleuths