A Good, Bad or Average Theory What's The Difference?

[Anthro]

Are there any thoughts/views on the possibility that the ‘charity collector’ and ‘Smithman’ plotted Madeleine’s disappearance?

In addition to the post.



[attachment deleted by admin]

[Brietta]

In addition to the post.

I have not thought Smithman was of any relevance for quite some time, Anthro.  But I would like to know who the 'charity collectors' were and any others acting suspiciously who haven't yet been traced.

[Anthro]

I have not thought Smithman was of any relevance for quite some time, Anthro.  But I would like to know who the 'charity collectors' were and any others acting suspiciously who haven't yet been traced.

I’ll send you a pm, Brietta.

[Anthro]

These e-fits are presumably of the same person. Does anyone know which members of the Smith family contributed to each e-fit?

[sadie]

In addition to the post.
#

Soz, don't know how to make these images larger.


1.  If the missing L.H. part of Smithmans chin is pencilled in to match the RH side of his face, then there is quite a likeness between Smithman (bottom left) and the man 'X' in the photo (bottom right).  Smithmans eyes are a bit wider set than 'X's eyes, but everything else fits pretty well, Imo

From the look of the bright wide eyes, I have always thought that this was the image given by Aoife … and the brightness in the look was a young man encountering an attractive young woman, who was likewise attracted to him.  I believe that a sudden attraction causes the eyes to open wider     
A massive street lamp was positioned close behind Aoife and she would have got a very clear view of Smithmans face as he walked straight towards it.  The e-fit image is very clear.


2.  Looking closely at the photo of 'X' (bottom RH image), one can see a friends face partly showing.
I.M.O this part face is the face of the man in the top RH Image.   I should know who he is, Anthro., but I have forgotten    Is he the pig farmer? … or is he the animal cremation man ? … or is he the son of a certain Lady who worked at Ocean Club ?


This is remarkably interesting when one considers other extraordinary things that you have shown me, privately … most especially so, if he is the son of the lady that works at O.C.


Very well done Anthro, seems that you are a brilliant sleuth, but we still do not know anything for sure.  I think that SY should know everything pertinent that you have told me privately (which was amazing) and also these images, which seem to link.   They can judge. 

[Anthro]

Soz, don't know how to make these images larger.


1.  If the missing L.H. part of Smithmans chin is pencilled in to match the RH side of his face, then there is quite a likeness between Smithman (bottom left) and the man 'X' in the photo (bottom right).  Smithmans eyes are a bit wider set than 'X's eyes, but everything else fits pretty well, Imo

From the look of the bright wide eyes, I have always thought that this was the image given by Aoife … and the brightness in the look was a young man encountering an attractive young woman, who was likewise attracted to him.  I believe that a sudden attraction causes the eyes to open wider     
A massive street lamp was positioned close behind Aoife and she would have got a very clear view of Smithmans face as he walked straight towards it.  The e-fit image is very clear.


2.  Looking closely at the photo of 'X' (bottom RH image), one can see a friends face partly showing.
I.M.O this part face is the face of the man in the top RH Image.   I should know who he is, Anthro., but I have forgotten    Is he the pig farmer? … or is he the animal cremation man ? … or is he the son of a certain Lady who worked at Ocean Club ?


This is remarkably interesting when one considers other extraordinary things that you have shown me, privately … most especially so, if he is the son of the lady that works at O.C.


Very well done Anthro, seems that you are a brilliant sleuth, but we still do not know anything for sure.  I think that SY should know everything pertinent that you have told me privately (which was amazing) and also these images, which seem to link.   They can judge.

Hi Sadie

Thank you for your feedback. Attached is a picture of the same man and the other Smithman efit. I would like to know what you and other members’ thoughts are on this. The picture of the Cooperman efit’s mother was working at the Millennium and his stepfather at (presumably) the Tapas in 2007.

[Anthro]

Raymond Hewlett has been suspected of being involved. Please see attached pictures. Has he been mistakenly id’d?

[attachment deleted by admin]

[sadie]

Hi Sadie

Thank you for your feedback. Attached is a picture of the same man and the other Smithman efit. I would like to know what you and other members’ thoughts are on this. The picture of the Cooperman efit’s mother was working at the Millennium and his stepfather at (presumably) the Tapas in 2007.

Hi Anthro, the images could be clearer, but well done for finding them and pairing them

I can't say with either of the above pairings, that I see a convincing likeness.  In fact with the Raymond Hewett pairing, I think that they are not the same man.   

I judge these on different criteria to the images on that you showed on May 24th.  Of the four images that you posted on May 24th two were artists sketches/ electronically produced images that almost certainly would not have a photographic likeness, but a likeness was there never-the-less IMO. 
These latest images are actual photos, so they must match completely and as far as I can see they do not.

Sorry Anthro, but they are not very distinct, so maybe you should "put-them-on-the-back-burner to keep warm" in case other photos of the men compared come up, which prove me wrong.

[Lace]

Raymond Hewlett has been suspected of being involved. Please see attached pictures. Has he been mistakenly id’d?

I think the Police were comparing the picture of the man with the moustache in relation to Hewlett Anthro.

[Lace]

Hi Sadie

Thank you for your feedback. Attached is a picture of the same man and the other Smithman efit. I would like to know what you and other members’ thoughts are on this. The picture of the Cooperman efit’s mother was working at the Millennium and his stepfather at (presumably) the Tapas in 2007.

I think there is a strong resemblance Anthro.

[misty]

These e-fits are presumably of the same person. Does anyone know which members of the Smith family contributed to each e-fit?

You can find the answer to your question here. https://twitter.com/adriangatton/status/960169439986626560
(Gatton was a friend of the deceased Halligen whose firm reportedly commissioned the efits)

[faithlilly]

The problem with these photographs is context. When were they taken ? What do the individuals look like now ? The young man with the dreadlocks may look a bit like Melissa Little’s sketch, if you squint, but if the photos are recent then this man who appears to be in his late twenties, thirty at the most would only have been in his early teens at the time of Madeleine’s disappearance.

I’m also uncomfortable seeing photographs that were obviously not posted to be shared across the internet being used to suggest wrongdoing.

[Billy Whizz Fan Club]

In addition to the post.

Is it just me or does the third picture resemble GM?

[Brietta]

Is it just me or does the third picture resemble GM?

Is there any chance at all that we can have a day without innuendo about any members of a family which has just lost a dearly loved matriarch and has to cope with the German police broadcasting that they think their missing daughter is dead without further explanation.
I cannot imagine what they are going through but now that the sceptics on this forum have learned the meaning of the presumption of innocence and adopted it there should be less crap to the contrary posted here.  Thank you

[barrier]

Is there any chance at all that we can have a day without innuendo about any members of a family which has just lost a dearly loved matriarch and has to cope with the German police broadcasting that they think their missing daughter is dead without further explanation.
I cannot imagine what they are going through but now that the sceptics on this forum have learned the meaning of the presumption of innocence and adopted it there should be less crap to the contrary posted here. Thank you

Away with you, the thread about a supposed German suspect if full of nothing but.

(Got me space El)