Another long but informative post from the Reddit handler about her work, experience and area of expertise. Faith need not bother to read it as she already knows it all, but others msy find it interesting, if only that it proves this woman knows what she is talking about (it’s about a case of a missing Japanese child):
hectorabaya
•
7y ago
•
Edited 7y ago
It goes both ways, and some dogs that are cross-trained for both will alert on either. It just depends on the dog and training. However if these dogs are all tracking dogs, they would be looking for a living person (also, I can't really speak to Japanese search protocol, but it would be exceedingly unusual in most places to bring out cadaver dogs within a day of a child going missing in the woods unless there was a specific reason to believe they were deceased. You always start out assuming that a missing person like this is alive to minimize the chances of missing someone in need of rescue, then switch to recovery mode if too much time passes for them to realistically survive the conditions). Tracking dogs work by following residual scent left behind, while cadaver dogs work by pinpointing the actual source of the scent (this can be residual traces, but the way they work to pinpoint it is a bit different). Of course if Yuki died at a place she had walked to the tracking dogs should still get the handlers close enough to find her, assuming a good scent trail.
24 hours is not enough time to significantly weaken the scent trail in ideal conditions. In fact that's a pretty standard timeframe for starting a K9 search. I'm not a tracking dog handler so take this with a grain of salt, but the way my team approaches it is we have a high degree of confidence for about 72 hours after the person disappears in most conditions for the tracking dogs. After that it starts dropping significantly, though we'll still be willing to give it a try for awhile depending on the specific circumstances and how many resources we have available (sometimes we get stretched thin and then we may need to prioritize searches where we have more likelihood of being useful). The reason I'm not willing to state that more confidently is that different handlers have different opinions and I don't want to wade into that debate since I've never trained or handled a tracking dog (air scent dogs, my specialty, can work indefinitely as long as the victim is in the area).
The backpack would present a problem and honestly I'm just completely speculating as this is such an unusual situation and like I said, I am not a tracking dog handler so I don't spend as much time thinking about weird situations for them as I do for area search and cadaver dogs. The latter two wouldn't have problems finding a child in a backpack if the child was in the search area, because they work by finding scent coming from the victim and that will permeate most things. However, depending on the materials of the pack it could contain the scent enough that there wouldn't be much of a trail left. I'd say it's possible, but I couldn't really give any odds on probability.
The problem I have with putting much stock in the K9 evidence in this case is twofold. First, there are a lot of ways a scent trail can be destroyed. It's actually pretty hard to do yourself, like if you're trying to mask your own trail, but weather conditions, surface conditions (eg. vegetation vs. bare dirt vs. asphalt), and the amount of traffic through the area can all play a role. If the area the dogs lost her scent was one where ground searchers had rendezvoused or repeatedly canvassed, for example, they could have just trampled over it enough to destroy the trail. That is a lot of dogs to have all lose the scent at the exact same place if that's true, but it's entirely possible. You really need to have a lot more information about the field conditions and the general operation to really give K9 evidence like this any meaningful context.
The second part is the bigger issue, and that's that I have seen a heck of a lot of inaccurate reporting of K9 searches even in English-language reporting of US searches. It's often like a game of telephone, and very few people really understand the nuances of K9 searches (if I had a dime for every time I've seen air scent dogs called tracking dogs, which isn't even really that much of a nuance...). So then with this particular case you also have the issue of potential translation errors on top of all of the normal confusion. Also, western media does have a tendency to play up the "weird" aspects of Japanese news stories, even reputable outlets.
So unless there are primary sources available, I do think there's a pretty solid chance that the information about the K9 teams is simply inaccurate as well. I'm not saying it's impossible that they ran that many dogs over the same area and all of them stopped at the exact same spot, but I think it's also quite possible that some of those "tracking dogs" were really area search dogs who are expected to often not find a scent (as the name implies, they clear certain areas, so if the victim isn't in that area, they won't find a scent) or the dogs actually were following a kind of weak trail and lost it at different places or things like that.
Sorry, that got long. I hope it all made sense, I don't have a lot of time this weekend. I also just quickly skimmed the info so I might be missing some information.
eta: just for clarity, I tend to use the terms "air scent" and "area search" interchangeably. Area search is a form of air scent work.