Author Topic: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.  (Read 2856270 times)

0 Members and 56 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline faithlilly

Re: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.
« Reply #20010 on: October 04, 2025, 10:50:04 PM »
Another interesting point of view on Reddit from the same Cadaver dig handler as before, answering a question in the Kayla Berg subreddit.  Apologies if it upsets anyone reading here.

https://www.reddit.com/user/hectorabaya/comments/

There's really no way to answer that question, unfortunately, because there's no official or universal standards for cadaver dog handlers. It's an entirely self-regulated field, and unfortunately since it is a rather complex one that people have a lot of misunderstandings about, some really shady handlers can become very successful despite having results that are questionable at best. Usually they'll eventually get weeded out when none of their finds are backed up by physical evidence, but not always. I do think that overall we do a pretty decent job of self-regulation as there are a lot of voluntary certifications and tests you can undergo, which most handlers I know do, which have very high standards, but it isn't required unless the individual law enforcement agency handling the investigation requires it (and in my experience they often don't even ask about certifications, but that can vary depending on the officer and the agency). I personally support licensing and other requirements, though, as this kind of stuff does have the potential to ruin lives, but the US has such a patchwork system I don't know how it would be feasible.

The majority of handlers I've met are aware of the tendency to false alert to please the handler and take great care with training it out both of the dog and of themselves using blind training exercises and the like, but you can never eliminate the possibility entirely. I've seen some very experienced handlers occasionally screw up and cue false alerts even in training exercises. It's really subtle and they're not aware they're doing it, but dogs are great at reading our body language and it only takes a moment.

As u/kagzig noted, too, a big problem is that people who don't have experience with detection dogs often wildly misinterpret K9 evidence. It's a very complex field and a large amount of factors go into interpreting the results. Even if the alert is correct from a training standpoint, it's entirely possible that whatever the dog is alerting on had nothing to do with the case. As a somewhat lighthearted example from a training exercise, my team was once holding a training in a city-owned warehouse with multiple rooms (they used it for storing landscaping tools, holiday decorations, that kind of thing). Since it was a training exercise, we knew exactly where we planted the samples, but the weird thing was that all of the dogs also alerted on a spot in a room that was far away from any of them. We couldn't really figure it out so asked the manager when he came to lock it up at the end of the day, and he told us that a worker had had a bad injury in that room a few days beforehand and bled enough that a substantial amount got on the floor. So that was a correct alert from the dogs as they were picking up trace amounts of blood, but if it had been a real case, it would have been a complete red herring. And I've seen things like that crop up many times in actual investigations as well.

This is already getting long so I'll stop there, except to say that I obviously do think K9 evidence is very valuable or I would not be a dog handler, but it should never be taken as Gospel. There are too many complicating factors, news reports are often inaccurate at best, and you really need a ton of background info about the dog, the handler and the search conditions and protocol to really draw anything approaching an accurate conclusion. And even then there's still a chance you're wrong if you're dealing with trace evidence that can't be analyzed. I wouldn't completely agree with the other poster that you can't use it as evidence unless you find a body, but at best it should be seen as a small piece of circumstantial evidence. In other words, IF there's all this other corroborating circumstantial evidence backing up the theory of events, and IF the K9 evidence fits easily into that, then that's one more puzzle piece falling into place. But if the K9 evidence doesn't fit any reasonable theory of the crime, it shouldn't be given any significant weight unless other corroborating evidence pops up. (and even that's an oversimplification, but it'll do for a Reddit post)

Thank you for the post. However it makes my case. Nothing in the post is new to either me or you. Grime himself said that the alerts were merely intelligence.

I think the point that you’re missing is there is absolutely no evidence that Grime unconsciously caused the alerts.
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Offline faithlilly

Re: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.
« Reply #20011 on: October 04, 2025, 11:00:45 PM »
Another interesting point of view on Reddit from the same Cadaver dig handler as before, answering a question in the Kayla Berg subreddit.  Apologies if it upsets anyone reading here.

https://www.reddit.com/user/hectorabaya/comments/

There's really no way to answer that question, unfortunately, because there's no official or universal standards for cadaver dog handlers. It's an entirely self-regulated field, and unfortunately since it is a rather complex one that people have a lot of misunderstandings about, some really shady handlers can become very successful despite having results that are questionable at best. Usually they'll eventually get weeded out when none of their finds are backed up by physical evidence, but not always. I do think that overall we do a pretty decent job of self-regulation as there are a lot of voluntary certifications and tests you can undergo, which most handlers I know do, which have very high standards, but it isn't required unless the individual law enforcement agency handling the investigation requires it (and in my experience they often don't even ask about certifications, but that can vary depending on the officer and the agency). I personally support licensing and other requirements, though, as this kind of stuff does have the potential to ruin lives, but the US has such a patchwork system I don't know how it would be feasible.

The majority of handlers I've met are aware of the tendency to false alert to please the handler and take great care with training it out both of the dog and of themselves using blind training exercises and the like, but you can never eliminate the possibility entirely. I've seen some very experienced handlers occasionally screw up and cue false alerts even in training exercises. It's really subtle and they're not aware they're doing it, but dogs are great at reading our body language and it only takes a moment.

As u/kagzig noted, too, a big problem is that people who don't have experience with detection dogs often wildly misinterpret K9 evidence. It's a very complex field and a large amount of factors go into interpreting the results. Even if the alert is correct from a training standpoint, it's entirely possible that whatever the dog is alerting on had nothing to do with the case. As a somewhat lighthearted example from a training exercise, my team was once holding a training in a city-owned warehouse with multiple rooms (they used it for storing landscaping tools, holiday decorations, that kind of thing). Since it was a training exercise, we knew exactly where we planted the samples, but the weird thing was that all of the dogs also alerted on a spot in a room that was far away from any of them. We couldn't really figure it out so asked the manager when he came to lock it up at the end of the day, and he told us that a worker had had a bad injury in that room a few days beforehand and bled enough that a substantial amount got on the floor. So that was a correct alert from the dogs as they were picking up trace amounts of blood, but if it had been a real case, it would have been a complete red herring. And I've seen things like that crop up many times in actual investigations as well.

This is already getting long so I'll stop there, except to say that I obviously do think K9 evidence is very valuable or I would not be a dog handler, but it should never be taken as Gospel. There are too many complicating factors, news reports are often inaccurate at best, and you really need a ton of background info about the dog, the handler and the search conditions and protocol to really draw anything approaching an accurate conclusion. And even then there's still a chance you're wrong if you're dealing with trace evidence that can't be analyzed. I wouldn't completely agree with the other poster that you can't use it as evidence unless you find a body, but at best it should be seen as a small piece of circumstantial evidence. In other words, IF there's all this other corroborating circumstantial evidence backing up the theory of events, and IF the K9 evidence fits easily into that, then that's one more puzzle piece falling into place. But if the K9 evidence doesn't fit any reasonable theory of the crime, it shouldn't be given any significant weight unless other corroborating evidence pops up. (and even that's an oversimplification, but it'll do for a Reddit post)

This is the same individual, isn’t it?

‘ And just for the record, I'm am and always have been a volunteer (as are almost all SAR personnel in the United States), so I've got no profit motive here. The most money I make is reimbursement of my travel costs. Sometimes the officer in charge arranges for sandwiches and soft drinks/hot coffee at incident base, which is a nice perk but not something I'm willing to cover up the deaths of innocent hikers for.’

He appears to be a search and rescue volunteer. Is he also a cadaver dog expert? He is also in the US where cadaver dogs are less regulated.
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Offline Vertigo Swirl

Re: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.
« Reply #20012 on: October 04, 2025, 11:12:04 PM »
Thank you for the post. However it makes my case. Nothing in the post is new to either me or you. Grime himself said that the alerts were merely intelligence.

I think the point that you’re missing is there is absolutely no evidence that Grime unconsciously caused the alerts.
I think the point you’re missing is that there is absolutely no evidence that the dogs were alerting to the dead body of Madeleine McCann, that is surely the most important point at all.  The posts I have copied over are interesting because clearly they are written from someone not invested in the petty point scoring this case engenders but who has clear and unbiased views regarding the strengths and weaknesses of utilising cadaver dogs in trying to solve crimes generally , which is supported by insightful anecdotal evidence.  Her conclusions are that the dog alerts in this case are most likely explained by unconscious handler bias, and in another post she makes reference to the way Grime repeatedly called the dog back to the car covered in Madeleine posters to support her view.  Another point she made which I had never considered in 18 years of thinking about this case is the pressure on someone like Grime to achieve results particularly in a high profile case like this one, ie to furnish LE with alerts and therefore earn their fee so to speak, which again can lead to unconscious handler bias. She mentions the disappointment felt when dogs don’t alert on cases as if they have somehow failed, when in actual fact not alerting is potentially as valuable as an alert in helping to work out what happened in a case.  As a dog handler herself obviously she has a positive view of the dogs abilities to find cadavers and evidence in cases but at the same time she also understands their and their handlers’ limits too.  Very even handed and fair analysis I thought, and whilst you may profess to have known it all before I felt it lent a fresh perspective to the subject.
"You can't reason with the unreasonable".

Offline Vertigo Swirl

Re: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.
« Reply #20013 on: October 04, 2025, 11:14:14 PM »
This is the same individual, isn’t it?

‘ And just for the record, I'm am and always have been a volunteer (as are almost all SAR personnel in the United States), so I've got no profit motive here. The most money I make is reimbursement of my travel costs. Sometimes the officer in charge arranges for sandwiches and soft drinks/hot coffee at incident base, which is a nice perk but not something I'm willing to cover up the deaths of innocent hikers for.’

He appears to be a search and rescue volunteer. Is he also a cadaver dog expert? He is also in the US where cadaver dogs are less regulated.
So which of her views do you disagree with then?  What has she written that is just plain false?  Earleir you said you knew it all and could have written it yourself but now you seem to be intent on rubbishing what she has written, so let’s hear your rebuttal of it.
"You can't reason with the unreasonable".

Offline faithlilly

Re: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.
« Reply #20014 on: October 04, 2025, 11:17:21 PM »
I think the point you’re missing is that there is absolutely no evidence that the dogs were alerting to the dead body of Madeleine McCann, that is surely the most important point at all.  The posts I have copied over are interesting because clearly they are written from someone not invested in the petty point scoring this case engenders but who has clear and unbiased views regarding the strengths and weaknesses of utilising cadaver dogs in trying to solve crimes generally , which is supported by insightful anecdotal evidence.  Her conclusions are that the dog alerts in this case are most likely explained by unconscious handler bias, and in another post she makes reference to the way Grime repeatedly called the dog back to the car covered in Madeleine posters to support her view.  Another point she made which I had never considered in 18 years of thinking about this case is the pressure on someone like Grime to achieve results particularly in a high profile case like this one, ie to furnish LE with alerts and therefore earn their fee so to speak, which again can lead to unconscious handler bias. She mentions the disappointment felt when dogs don’t alert on cases as if they have somehow failed, when in actual fact not alerting is potentially as valuable as an alert in helping to work out what happened in a case.  As a dog handler herself obviously she has a positive view of the dogs abilities to find cadavers and evidence in cases but at the same time she also understands their and their handlers’ limits too.  Very even handed and fair analysis I thought, and whilst you may profess to have known it all before I felt it lent a fresh perspective to the subject.

You claimed that the poster was a cadaver dog handler when it appears that she is merely a search and rescue volunteer so yes, I do probably know as much as her about cadaver dogs.
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Offline faithlilly

Re: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.
« Reply #20015 on: October 04, 2025, 11:20:37 PM »
So which of her views do you disagree with then?  What has she written that is just plain false?  Earleir you said you knew it all and could have written it yourself but now you seem to be intent on rubbishing what she has written, so let’s hear your rebuttal of it.

Is the poster a cadaver dog handler as you claimed?

Does she live in the US where anyone with a dog and the will can claim to be a cadaver dog handler?
« Last Edit: October 04, 2025, 11:33:08 PM by faithlilly »
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Online Eleanor

Re: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.
« Reply #20016 on: October 05, 2025, 06:56:45 AM »

I seem to remember that Eddie began his career as a Search and rescue Dog.  I had forgotten about that.

Offline Vertigo Swirl

Re: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.
« Reply #20017 on: October 05, 2025, 08:51:24 AM »
You claimed that the poster was a cadaver dog handler when it appears that she is merely a search and rescue volunteer so yes, I do probably know as much as her about cadaver dogs.
No, she claimed she was a cadaver dog handler, in the first post I made referencing her.  It is possible to be both you know!  The fact that you claim to know as much about dog handling as someone who has worked with cadaver and SAR dogs, taken part in real life cases and done countless training courses is of course as laughable as it is arrogant.  But even in the highly unlikely event that you know as much as she, you will then have to concede she is right about everything she says, or if not dispute it with your reasoning why. 
« Last Edit: October 05, 2025, 08:55:00 AM by Vertigo Swirl »
"You can't reason with the unreasonable".

Offline Vertigo Swirl

Re: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.
« Reply #20018 on: October 05, 2025, 09:09:38 AM »
Another long but informative post from the Reddit handler about her work, experience and area of expertise.  Faith need not bother to read it as she already knows it all, but others msy find it interesting, if only that it proves this woman knows what she is talking about (it’s about a case of a missing Japanese child):

hectorabaya
•
7y ago
•
Edited 7y ago
It goes both ways, and some dogs that are cross-trained for both will alert on either. It just depends on the dog and training. However if these dogs are all tracking dogs, they would be looking for a living person (also, I can't really speak to Japanese search protocol, but it would be exceedingly unusual in most places to bring out cadaver dogs within a day of a child going missing in the woods unless there was a specific reason to believe they were deceased. You always start out assuming that a missing person like this is alive to minimize the chances of missing someone in need of rescue, then switch to recovery mode if too much time passes for them to realistically survive the conditions). Tracking dogs work by following residual scent left behind, while cadaver dogs work by pinpointing the actual source of the scent (this can be residual traces, but the way they work to pinpoint it is a bit different). Of course if Yuki died at a place she had walked to the tracking dogs should still get the handlers close enough to find her, assuming a good scent trail.

24 hours is not enough time to significantly weaken the scent trail in ideal conditions. In fact that's a pretty standard timeframe for starting a K9 search. I'm not a tracking dog handler so take this with a grain of salt, but the way my team approaches it is we have a high degree of confidence for about 72 hours after the person disappears in most conditions for the tracking dogs. After that it starts dropping significantly, though we'll still be willing to give it a try for awhile depending on the specific circumstances and how many resources we have available (sometimes we get stretched thin and then we may need to prioritize searches where we have more likelihood of being useful). The reason I'm not willing to state that more confidently is that different handlers have different opinions and I don't want to wade into that debate since I've never trained or handled a tracking dog (air scent dogs, my specialty, can work indefinitely as long as the victim is in the area).

The backpack would present a problem and honestly I'm just completely speculating as this is such an unusual situation and like I said, I am not a tracking dog handler so I don't spend as much time thinking about weird situations for them as I do for area search and cadaver dogs. The latter two wouldn't have problems finding a child in a backpack if the child was in the search area, because they work by finding scent coming from the victim and that will permeate most things. However, depending on the materials of the pack it could contain the scent enough that there wouldn't be much of a trail left. I'd say it's possible, but I couldn't really give any odds on probability.

The problem I have with putting much stock in the K9 evidence in this case is twofold. First, there are a lot of ways a scent trail can be destroyed. It's actually pretty hard to do yourself, like if you're trying to mask your own trail, but weather conditions, surface conditions (eg. vegetation vs. bare dirt vs. asphalt), and the amount of traffic through the area can all play a role. If the area the dogs lost her scent was one where ground searchers had rendezvoused or repeatedly canvassed, for example, they could have just trampled over it enough to destroy the trail. That is a lot of dogs to have all lose the scent at the exact same place if that's true, but it's entirely possible. You really need to have a lot more information about the field conditions and the general operation to really give K9 evidence like this any meaningful context.

The second part is the bigger issue, and that's that I have seen a heck of a lot of inaccurate reporting of K9 searches even in English-language reporting of US searches. It's often like a game of telephone, and very few people really understand the nuances of K9 searches (if I had a dime for every time I've seen air scent dogs called tracking dogs, which isn't even really that much of a nuance...). So then with this particular case you also have the issue of potential translation errors on top of all of the normal confusion. Also, western media does have a tendency to play up the "weird" aspects of Japanese news stories, even reputable outlets.

So unless there are primary sources available, I do think there's a pretty solid chance that the information about the K9 teams is simply inaccurate as well. I'm not saying it's impossible that they ran that many dogs over the same area and all of them stopped at the exact same spot, but I think it's also quite possible that some of those "tracking dogs" were really area search dogs who are expected to often not find a scent (as the name implies, they clear certain areas, so if the victim isn't in that area, they won't find a scent) or the dogs actually were following a kind of weak trail and lost it at different places or things like that.

Sorry, that got long. I hope it all made sense, I don't have a lot of time this weekend. I also just quickly skimmed the info so I might be missing some information.

eta: just for clarity, I tend to use the terms "air scent" and "area search" interchangeably. Area search is a form of air scent work.
« Last Edit: October 05, 2025, 09:18:41 AM by Vertigo Swirl »
"You can't reason with the unreasonable".

Offline Vertigo Swirl

Re: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.
« Reply #20019 on: October 05, 2025, 09:17:17 AM »
It’s interesting to me that Faith would seek to rubbish the experience and views of someone who doesn’t get paid for their valuable work, when she also rubbishes the views and opinions of those she believes receive money for them by the press.  A strange double standard in my view.
What I also find very interesting is that this handler was of the opinion that the McCanns were likely guilty of involvement in their daughter’s disappearance UNTIL she watched videos of the dog alerts.  Remember she is a dog handler with 20+ years of using dogs to sniff out thr bodies of people who have gone missing, and I think her view is worth hearing even if you disagree with it.  Of course I’m sure Reddit is simply bursting with fully paid and accredited enhanced cadaver dog handlers who think otherwise, but I have yet to come acoss them.
"You can't reason with the unreasonable".

Offline faithlilly

Re: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.
« Reply #20020 on: October 05, 2025, 10:12:19 AM »
No, she claimed she was a cadaver dog handler, in the first post I made referencing her.  It is possible to be both you know!  The fact that you claim to know as much about dog handling as someone who has worked with cadaver and SAR dogs, taken part in real life cases and done countless training courses is of course as laughable as it is arrogant.  But even in the highly unlikely event that you know as much as she, you will then have to concede she is right about everything she says, or if not dispute it with your reasoning why.

I said I could have written what the poster had written…and yes ‘claimed’ is the operative word. Perhaps she forgot herself?
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Offline faithlilly

Re: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.
« Reply #20021 on: October 05, 2025, 10:14:33 AM »
It’s interesting to me that Faith would seek to rubbish the experience and views of someone who doesn’t get paid for their valuable work, when she also rubbishes the views and opinions of those she believes receive money for them by the press.  A strange double standard in my view.
What I also find very interesting is that this handler was of the opinion that the McCanns were likely guilty of involvement in their daughter’s disappearance UNTIL she watched videos of the dog alerts.  Remember she is a dog handler with 20+ years of using dogs to sniff out thr bodies of people who have gone missing, and I think her view is worth hearing even if you disagree with it.  Of course I’m sure Reddit is simply bursting with fully paid and accredited enhanced cadaver dog handlers who think otherwise, but I have yet to come acoss them.

Let’s agree to disagree and move one.
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Offline Vertigo Swirl

Re: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.
« Reply #20022 on: October 05, 2025, 10:42:32 AM »
Let’s agree to disagree and move one.
Move one what?
 But sure, let’s move on just as the investigation into Madeleine’s disappearance has, and the dog alerts long since consigned to a footnote in history.

eta: just leaving this here for future reference https://www.reddit.com/r/UnresolvedMysteries/comments/6qq47l/comment/dl0bc5t/
« Last Edit: October 05, 2025, 11:08:43 AM by Vertigo Swirl »
"You can't reason with the unreasonable".

Offline faithlilly

Re: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.
« Reply #20023 on: October 05, 2025, 11:27:50 AM »
Move one what?
 But sure, let’s move on just as the investigation into Madeleine’s disappearance has, and the dog alerts long since consigned to a footnote in history.

eta: just leaving this here for future reference https://www.reddit.com/r/UnresolvedMysteries/comments/6qq47l/comment/dl0bc5t/

Wouldn’t your time be better spent catching the last of the beautiful autumnal sunshine before winter sets in rather than rehashing old arguments?

I’m just waiting for my golden tart tatin to come out of the oven and I’ll be doing the same.

Have a wonderful afternoon VS.
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Offline Vertigo Swirl

Re: New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.
« Reply #20024 on: October 05, 2025, 12:27:09 PM »
Wouldn’t your time be better spent catching the last of the beautiful autumnal sunshine before winter sets in rather than rehashing old arguments?

I’m just waiting for my golden tart tatin to come out of the oven and I’ll be doing the same.

Have a wonderful afternoon VS.
Thanks,  have just been out to Lidl to do the weekly shop.  I can’t say the experience was a joy but at least I have something for lunch and will enjoy the autumnal views of my garden while I have it.  Sadly, no golden tart tatin for me, just a ryvita or two with some cream cheese and pickles, and a corn on the cob afterwards.  I will then make up my bed with clean sheets, clean the bathroom and then reward myself with a few chapters of my new book afterwards whilst sat in my sunny conservatory.  Bliss!
"You can't reason with the unreasonable".