Author Topic: The tracker dogs  (Read 140190 times)

0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.

icabodcrane

  • Guest
Re: The tracker dogs
« Reply #150 on: April 29, 2013, 05:30:43 PM »
Mark Harrison did a reconnaissance, debated with colleagues from the University of the Algarve, meditated.

But Mark Harrison just worked to the brief Encanrcadio (sp) gave him.
Have you read his 3 reports, his rog, and the document on the EVRD dog ?

Yes, very carefully.
Then I don't understand your point. MH's help was requested according to his speciality.

Perhaps I've read the report a little more closely than you?

He says that his report considers, solely the possibility that Madeleine has been murdered (contradicting a claim of Amaral's that no one talked about murder) and offers to consider other possibilities or scenarios on request. 

He also disowns UK participation in 3 searches and, after the inspections at the villa and the gym, issued PJ personnel with translated instructions on how to conduct a search.

If he'd seen that as his duty, he'd have done so before the first search.

There is also strong reason to believe the PJ cribbed off this literature Harrison gave them for their report of the inspection at the gym.

And no one has provided a convincing explanation of why there were searches at places Madeleine never went near.

Lee Rainbow mentioned murder when he advised  that a possible homicide involving the parents should be investigated with the same vigour as a possible abduction

I believe Harrison was acting on that advice 

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: The tracker dogs
« Reply #151 on: April 29, 2013, 05:35:28 PM »
Mark Harrison did a reconnaissance, debated with colleagues from the University of the Algarve, meditated.

But Mark Harrison just worked to the brief Encanrcadio (sp) gave him.
Have you read his 3 reports, his rog, and the document on the EVRD dog ?

Yes, very carefully.
Then I don't understand your point. MH's help was requested according to his speciality.

Perhaps I've read the report a little more closely than you?

He says that his report considers, solely the possibility that Madeleine has been murdered (contradicting a claim of Amaral's that no one talked about murder) and offers to consider other possibilities or scenarios on request. 

He also disowns UK participation in 3 searches and, after the inspections at the villa and the gym, issued PJ personnel with translated instructions on how to conduct a search.

If he'd seen that as his duty, he'd have done so before the first search.

There is also strong reason to believe the PJ cribbed off this literature Harrison gave them for their report of the inspection at the gym.

And no one has provided a convincing explanation of why there were searches at places Madeleine never went near.

Lee Rainbow mentioned murder when he advised  that a possible homicide involving the parents should be investigated with the same vigour as a possible abduction

I believe Harrison was acting on that advice

Rainbow simply said that the possibility of parental involvement should not be discounted, but added that there was no evidence to suggest such.

He offered standard, generic, advice, routinely issued in circumstances such as those of that investigation ...

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: The tracker dogs
« Reply #152 on: April 29, 2013, 05:52:49 PM »
Bren has produced an excellent blog on the Lee Rainbow report I'm sure she won't mind me bringing here:

http://regretsandramblings.com/2011/09/24/the-rainbow-report/

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: The tracker dogs
« Reply #153 on: April 29, 2013, 05:54:40 PM »
Mark Harrison did a reconnaissance, debated with colleagues from the University of the Algarve, meditated.

But Mark Harrison just worked to the brief Encanrcadio (sp) gave him.
Have you read his 3 reports, his rog, and the document on the EVRD dog ?

Yes, very carefully.
Then I don't understand your point. MH's help was requested according to his speciality.

Perhaps I've read the report a little more closely than you?

He says that his report considers, solely the possibility that Madeleine has been murdered (contradicting a claim of Amaral's that no one talked about murder) and offers to consider other possibilities or scenarios on request. 

He also disowns UK participation in 3 searches and, after the inspections at the villa and the gym, issued PJ personnel with translated instructions on how to conduct a search.

If he'd seen that as his duty, he'd have done so before the first search.

There is also strong reason to believe the PJ cribbed off this literature Harrison gave them for their report of the inspection at the gym.

And no one has provided a convincing explanation of why there were searches at places Madeleine never went near.

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: The tracker dogs
« Reply #154 on: April 29, 2013, 05:57:05 PM »
You've not got your quotes quite right.

I can't spot your own comment?

icabodcrane

  • Guest
Re: The tracker dogs
« Reply #155 on: April 29, 2013, 05:59:14 PM »
Mark Harrison did a reconnaissance, debated with colleagues from the University of the Algarve, meditated.

But Mark Harrison just worked to the brief Encanrcadio (sp) gave him.
Have you read his 3 reports, his rog, and the document on the EVRD dog ?

Yes, very carefully.
Then I don't understand your point. MH's help was requested according to his speciality.

Perhaps I've read the report a little more closely than you?

He says that his report considers, solely the possibility that Madeleine has been murdered (contradicting a claim of Amaral's that no one talked about murder) and offers to consider other possibilities or scenarios on request. 

He also disowns UK participation in 3 searches and, after the inspections at the villa and the gym, issued PJ personnel with translated instructions on how to conduct a search.

If he'd seen that as his duty, he'd have done so before the first search.

There is also strong reason to believe the PJ cribbed off this literature Harrison gave them for their report of the inspection at the gym.

And no one has provided a convincing explanation of why there were searches at places Madeleine never went near.

Lee Rainbow mentioned murder when he advised  that a possible homicide involving the parents should be investigated with the same vigour as a possible abduction

I believe Harrison was acting on that advice

Rainbow simply said that the possibility of parental involvement should not be discounted, but added that there was no evidence to suggest such.

He offered standard, generic, advice, routinely issued in circumstances such as those of that investigation ...

Rainbow used the word 'homicide' in relation to the McCanns

I was pointing out that murder, had, therefore been mentioned, and it was the British police who mentioned it 

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: The tracker dogs
« Reply #156 on: April 29, 2013, 06:06:06 PM »
Rainbow used the word 'homicide' in relation to the McCanns

Did he?  Where?

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: The tracker dogs
« Reply #157 on: April 29, 2013, 06:08:00 PM »
Mark Harrison did a reconnaissance, debated with colleagues from the University of the Algarve, meditated.

But Mark Harrison just worked to the brief Encanrcadio (sp) gave him.
Have you read his 3 reports, his rog, and the document on the EVRD dog ?

Yes, very carefully.
Then I don't understand your point. MH's help was requested according to his speciality.

Perhaps I've read the report a little more closely than you?

He says that his report considers, solely the possibility that Madeleine has been murdered (contradicting a claim of Amaral's that no one talked about murder) and offers to consider other possibilities or scenarios on request. 

He also disowns UK participation in 3 searches and, after the inspections at the villa and the gym, issued PJ personnel with translated instructions on how to conduct a search.

If he'd seen that as his duty, he'd have done so before the first search.

There is also strong reason to believe the PJ cribbed off this literature Harrison gave them for their report of the inspection at the gym.

And no one has provided a convincing explanation of why there were searches at places Madeleine never went near.
Ferryman, I'd appreciate really hearing your hymn ;), but please try to argue with quotations and references in order to help people follow you.
Interesting, among other points, would be to know which types of scenarios MH was likely thinking of. Victim of manslaughter ? Of accident ? Of a Collector ?
Why do you seem to find abusive the idea of searching the victim of a murder ? Is it because you know that predators kill their victims right away, which means that if no body had been found the victim hadn't been killed ? What about a predator who knew DNA could betray him  and made sure none of his would be found ?
« Last Edit: April 29, 2013, 06:10:07 PM by AnneGuedes »

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: The tracker dogs
« Reply #158 on: April 29, 2013, 06:17:52 PM »
Ok.

To keep it less cluttered, I'll make a separate post rather than quote.

Here is what Harrison recommended:

In considering the two scenarios that Madeleine McCann has been murdered and her body disposed of by a person on foot or in a vehicle, I have reflected on the areas within zone 1 that have been previously searched or subject to forensic examination.

Mark Warner Creche at Praia Da Luz.

This is the location of the last confirmed sighting by a person independent of family members of Madeleine McCann. Although this location was within the original search area it may well benefit from a further search using enhanced detecting methods for human remains. This will depend on the size of any outside grounds and concealed areas inside the building.

McCann's Apartment.

The apartment in which the McCann's had stayed may present further
opportunities to search. The use of a specialist EVRD (Enhanced Victim
Recovery Dog) and CSI dog (human blood detecting dog) could potentially indicate on whether Madeline's blood is in the property or the scent of a dead body is present. In relation to the dead body scent if such a scent is indicated by the EVRD and no body is located it may suggest that a body has been in the property but removed. This search process could be repeated in all the apartments that were occupied by the friends holidaying with the McCann's.
Murat's House and Garden.

The property has been forensically examined to recover any surface trace evidence however the house and gardens may benefit from a fully invasive specialist search to preclude the presence of Madeleine McCann.
A method previously employed on similar cases has been to use the below assets.
Deploy the EVRD to search the house and garden to ensure Madeleine McCann's remains are not present. The dog may also indicate if a body has been stored in the recent past and then moved off the property, though this is not evidential merely intelligence.
Deploy the CSI dog to search the house to locate any human blood.
This will act in support of the forensic examination already completed.
An inhibiting factor will be on areas where Luminol has been used.


Page 2228 :

Deploy geophysical instruments in the house and garden to detect any burial of a body or concealment in voids.

These specialists should be supported by physical search teams exploring and accessing all areas where concealment of a child's body could be made typically 0.5m.

Murat's Vehicles.

All vehicles Murat has had access to have been forensically examined to recover any surface trace evidence however they may all benefit from a full search by the EVRD and CSI dogs. They may be able to detect whether a dead body has been transported in one of the vehicles for intelligence purposes or detect human blood deposits that can be recovered and
examined in a laboratory for Madeleine McCann's blood.

Open Area to East of Praia Da Luz.

This open area between the village urban limits and the Boavista golf club to the east and includes a plateau on which sits a trig point and mobile phone mast.
This area has been previously searched by officers and dogs walking through the area to check for Madeleine McCann's visible remains. However considering the new scenario of Homicide and concealed deposition this area affords many opportunities to dispose of a body. Within this area there are old empty properties, wells, thick vegetation, pockets of soft sand and natural fissures in the cliffs. Whilst there is no intelligence she is buried or concealed in this land it would be a natural place an offender may choose dose to the Village using the least effort principle. A proportionate response may therefore be considered to conduct a search of this area using a team of Victim Recovery Dogs (VRD) that are specifically trained to located concealed human remains.
Prior to undertaking this task it would be beneficial to consult with a Forensic Anthropologist with knowledge of this region of Portugal to give opinion as to the likely state of any remains to be found. Further research could also be conducted with regards to the natural scavenging predators in the area.

An inhibiting factor is that since the disappearance of the child an old empty house adjacent to the Trig Point on the Rocha Negra has been demolished and all rubble removed, If she was concealed within this property the search would be unlikely to detect her now.

Praia Da Luz Beach and Shoreline.

The beach and shoreline are bounded by high cliffs and shallow waters. The beach has fine granular sand and provides easy digging. However the beach is extensively used by tourists and locals and af?rds minimal areas of cover from view for concealment. It may be considered appropriate to use the VRD dog team supported by geophysical GPR to sweep the beach. This would be


Page 2229 :

a considerable time and cost undertaking and should be weighed in the absence of specific intelligence.

Search Duration.

If all the described assets were deployed it would be likely all assets would complete their searches within one week.

Costs.

Currently only costs for the EVRD and CSI are available.
The daily rate for this dog team is 1000 Euros. Flight travel costs for handler and dogs could be 2750 Euros. Veterinary costs: U.K. and Portugal to comply with Pet Passports scheme 450 Euros. Accommodation, subsistence and vehicle transportation would incur extra charge.
Costs for a VRD dog team to conduct the open area search are not available at the time of writing. Such a team could be sourced from several countries within Europe or USA that have this capability including the UK. However the UK is limited to those teams whose dogs have "pet passports" due to UK quarantine restrictions.

Costs for a geophysical search team to conduct the search of Murat's house and garden are not available at the time of writing. These could be sourced from a commercial surveying company, a university or military within Portugal. Alternatively enquires could be made within the UK.

Offshore.

The sea in general circumstances would be immediately attractive to an offender as an easy way of body disposal and so must be considered.
The searches of the coastline was conducted by the Maritime Police and Coastguard. They searched the sea for any body buoyant on the surface and checked the coves and caves.
It could be considered appropriate to conduct research into the tidal flows and movement of the sea in this region and hypothesise where a body may travel if entered at certain points. It has been observed the depth of the sea appears shallow at the relevant area of coastline and this may become an inhibiting factor for any offender wishing to dispose of a body in it.
Overall Summary.

This report has highlighted the extensive and professional efforts made by the Portuguese authorities regarding the search to locate Madeleine McCann alive. It has now begun to consider further opportunities to re search locations in order to address the possibility that she has been murdered and concealed nearby. This would be a proportionate and appropriate response given the elapsed time since her disappearance and previous experience in such similar cases. Should the investigators wish to discuss and develop the issues raised


Page 2230 :

in this initial assessment I would be happy to do so. Should further advisory ?in country? support be required of the National Search Advisor following this initial assessment phase formal approval must be sought from the NPIA.



(Mark Harrison)

Note that he recommended only vehicles owned or driven by Murat should be inspected.

It was following briefings undertaken with Encarnadio that all the other searches emerged.

In an edit, I will add Harrison's summary of searches.

The timeline of these searches was as follows:
 
On 31-07-07 the PJ conducted canine searches with a search warrant at apartments in Praia da Luz that had been previously occupied by the McCanns and their friends.
 
On 01-08-07 the PJ and GNR assisted by a canine, conducted searches on the eastern beach and wasteland in Praia da Luz.
 
On 02-08-07 the PJ conducted a search warrant at a villa in Praia da Luz currently occupied by the McCann family.
 
Later the same day PJ officers conducted a screening procedure involving items removed from the McCann’s villa.
 
On 03-08-07 PJ and GNR officers were given instruction based on translated extracts from NPIA doctrine on search management and procedures. This focused on search procedures relating to buildings and vehicles.
 
On 04-08-07 and 05-08-07 a search warrant was executed at the villa and gardens belonging to the PJ suspect Robert Murat. This search involved both PJ and GNR personnel supported by civil defence, geophysical equipment operators and a canine handler.
 
On 06-08-07 ten vehicles were searched associated to the enquiry.
 
On 07-08-07 the western beach and remaining wasteland areas were searched using canine and GNR personnel.
 
On 08-08-07 the drains around the apartment block where Madeleine McCann disappeared from were subject to a visual inspection by PJ officers.


See how selective Harrison is in owning UK participation?

He describes both inspections at villa and gym as PJ exercises.

He disowns ownership of inspection of the vehicles altogether.

He only acknowledges UK participation in those inspections he recommended: the holiday apartments, areas around PdL and the Murats' place.

That's it ...

« Last Edit: April 29, 2013, 06:33:56 PM by ferryman »

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: The tracker dogs
« Reply #159 on: April 29, 2013, 06:50:58 PM »
And here is where I believe the PJ cribbed off the literature Harrison gave them:

Date: August 2nd 2007 - 11.20pm

On that date, following the home visit made to the McCann's' current residence, on the Rue des Fleurs, various items of clothing were laid out in an appropriate place for this purpose, to carry out an inspection by the dog handling unit.

The collected items of clothing were set out individually with the agreement and under the directions provided by the British technicians, the dogs having previously covered the space where the clothing was laid out.

1 - 11.20pm: Prior reconnaissance of the place by the two canine units to guarantee that the space was clear of all odours being sought. The reconnaissance was completed at 11.30pm without anything being signalled by the dogs.

2 - 11.30pm: An initial inspection by the human blood detecting dog, began with the clothing packed in the box bearing the notation: "Living room." At 11.40pm, the inspection was completed without the dog showing anything abnormal.

11.41: The canine human remains recovery dog started its inspection and "marked" various clothes. The inspection was completed at 11.52pm. The clothes were returned to their box for later use.

From 12.02am until 1.30am, (03/08/07) all the other boxes, containing clothing from the twins' bedroom, from the friends' bedroom, from the bedroom of the couple labelled 1 & 2, as well as the empty luggage, was inspected by the two dogs without conclusive results.


Given that there was wholesale disregard for principles of cross-contamination, in the inspection itself, coming months after the crime that prompted it, and in the way clothes were taken to the villa, the reconnoitre was pointless anyway, as was the inspection.

But the give-away is that there was no gap between reconnoitre and search, suggesting the clothes were laid out before the search.

So any apparent scent should have been detected during reconnoitre.

The PJ just took bits from Harrison's report.

And there is evidence from the GNR dog searches that the Portuguese are pretty clued up on good practice in dog searches, much better clued up than Grime (at least on the evidence of his performance in PdL)

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: The tracker dogs
« Reply #160 on: April 29, 2013, 08:22:30 PM »

Perhaps I've read the report a little more closely than you?

He says that his report considers, solely the possibility that Madeleine has been murdered (contradicting a claim of Amaral's that no one talked about murder) and offers to consider other possibilities or scenarios on request. 

He also disowns UK participation in 3 searches and, after the inspections at the villa and the gym, issued PJ personnel with translated instructions on how to conduct a search.

If he'd seen that as his duty, he'd have done so before the first search.

There is also strong reason to believe the PJ cribbed off this literature Harrison gave them for their report of the inspection at the gym.

And no one has provided a convincing explanation of why there were searches at places Madeleine never went near.
Ferryman, I'm re-reading all MH's literature (I like that chap, I think he's a gentleman). Here above I underlined your points that need (imo) some clarification. Nearly all... I'm sorry.
1) I admit you read MH more closely than me.
2) Where does GA contradicts MH on the topic of murder ?
3) I might be dumb, but where does MH say that he disowns 3 searches ?
4) Are those 3 disowned searches a) the villa, b) the clothes and c) the cars (the "disowned" reason here being that the Scenic wasn't supposed to be checked) ?
5) Do you infer from MH'd (late) instructions that for some reason he wasn't aware the PJ inspectors had no preparation to this kind of task whatsoever ? Do you think that he would have called Eddie and Keela if he'd been told there was a cadaver dog here in Portugal (btw there's one now).
6) you speak of "duty", I'm not sure this is right. MH doesn't seem to do things out of duty but when he thinks something is required and he can do it.
7) "strong reason to believe the PJ cribbed off this literature Harrison gave them". What is this "strong reason" ? And in what way was MH's literature "cribbed off" ?
On the relevance to search in places where Madeleine never went I agree with you. I'm not impressed neither by the clothes (possibly smelling UK corpses as someone suggested) nor by the car findings. The flat is another story.
« Last Edit: April 29, 2013, 08:25:20 PM by AnneGuedes »

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: The tracker dogs
« Reply #161 on: April 29, 2013, 08:53:36 PM »

Perhaps I've read the report a little more closely than you?

He says that his report considers, solely the possibility that Madeleine has been murdered (contradicting a claim of Amaral's that no one talked about murder) and offers to consider other possibilities or scenarios on request. 

He also disowns UK participation in 3 searches and, after the inspections at the villa and the gym, issued PJ personnel with translated instructions on how to conduct a search.

If he'd seen that as his duty, he'd have done so before the first search.

There is also strong reason to believe the PJ cribbed off this literature Harrison gave them for their report of the inspection at the gym.

And no one has provided a convincing explanation of why there were searches at places Madeleine never went near.
Ferryman, I'm re-reading all MH's literature (I like that chap, I think he's a gentleman). Here above I underlined your points that need (imo) some clarification. Nearly all... I'm sorry.
1) I admit you read MH more closely than me.
2) Where does GA contradicts MH on the topic of murder ?
3) I might be dumb, but where does MH say that he disowns 3 searches ?
4) Are those 3 disowned searches a) the villa, b) the clothes and c) the cars (the "disowned" reason here being that the Scenic wasn't supposed to be checked) ?
5) Do you infer from MH'd (late) instructions that for some reason he wasn't aware the PJ inspectors had no preparation to this kind of task whatsoever ? Do you think that he would have called Eddie and Keela if he'd been told there was a cadaver dog here in Portugal (btw there's one now).
6) you speak of "duty", I'm not sure this is right. MH doesn't seem to do things out of duty but when he thinks something is required and he can do it.
7) "strong reason to believe the PJ cribbed off this literature Harrison gave them". What is this "strong reason" ? And in what way was MH's literature "cribbed off" ?
On the relevance to search in places where Madeleine never went I agree with you. I'm not impressed neither by the clothes (possibly smelling UK corpses as someone suggested) nor by the car findings. The flat is another story.

Here is the extract from Amaral's book I take particular exception to:

After a week of intense work, Harrison presents the results of his study to my coordinating group. Even if we were expecting it, his conclusions confirm our worst fears. The most plausible scenario is the following: there is no doubt that Madeleine is dead, and her body is hidden somewhere in the area around Praia da Luz. He praises the quality of the work carried out by the Portuguese authorities in trying to find the little girl alive. According to him, the time has come to redirect the searches in order to find, this time, a body hidden in the surrounding area.

AMAZING STATISTICS

Great Britain has at its disposal the world's biggest data bank on homicide of children under five years old. Since 1960, the count is 1528. Harrison is well acquainted with its contents. He often draws information from there which helps him to resolve similar cases. Valuable information can be found there on on various criminal modus operandi, places where bodies are hidden, techniques used to get rid of a body. He relates that on one occasion, thanks to the data, he was able to deduce the maximum distance a body might be found in relation to where the crime had been committed.

The figures quoted in the report he hands over give us the shivers. The crimes, including those of a sexual nature, are committed by the parents in 84% of cases; 96% are perpetrated by friends and relatives. In only 4% of them is the murderer or abductor a total stranger to the victim. In this roundabout way, Mark Harrison points out that the guilty party may be a person close to Madeleine, and even her own parents. From now on, we have to explore this track, especially as the others have proved fruitless.


First point to note is that Harrison's speciality is advising in murder investigations.  So if you think of cause and effect, the PJ would not have drafted him in other than to advise on 'murder'.

The PJ had determined that Madeleine had been murdered and Harrison's role was to advise on how best to progress that line of enquiry.

3) ... where does MH say that he disowns 3 searches ?

Disowns in the sense that he does not own UK participation: for instance, describing searches at villa and gym as PJ exercises! 

4) Are those 3 disowned searches a) the villa, b) the clothes and c) the cars (the "disowned" reason here being that the Scenic wasn't supposed to be checked) ?

Can't think of a single logical reason why the scenic should have been checked, even if that check did provide the one action of Grime's for which I give him credit: to have the ignition card tested independently.  Otherwise, there would be stronger reason to suspect 'death scent in the car'

5) Do you infer from MH'd (late) instructions that for some reason he wasn't aware the PJ inspectors had no preparation to this kind of task whatsoever ? Do you think that he would have called Eddie and Keela if he'd been told there was a cadaver dog here in Portugal (btw there's one now).

No.  I infer from the instructions that he had observed unacceptable practice in what he had observed.

7) "strong reason to believe the PJ cribbed off this literature Harrison gave them". What is this "strong reason" ? And in what way was MH's literature "cribbed off" ?

While the Portuguese clearly have experience (and expertise) in use of sniffer dogs, they don't, in use of cadaver dogs, and the principle of cross-contamination of a death scent is very specific to cadaver dogs.  That has to have come from somewhere, and it clearly didn't come from Grime.  So my money is on the instructions Harrison gave them.

And finally, there is a (moderately) thought-provoking blog advancing the theory that in his assertion that Gerry hid (distinct from buried) Madeleine on the beach, he actually plaguarised the proper detective work of Harrison.

Would you like to read it?

Redblossom

  • Guest
Re: The tracker dogs
« Reply #162 on: April 29, 2013, 09:47:16 PM »
In reading the reports on the Portuguese sniffer dogs, I missed the report of the handler whose dog was given a towel to sniff (sic):

He comes to the process in the role of Chief of the GNR Search and Rescue Team.

I think that confirms it.  Search and rescue dogs don't track the individual and unique human scent.
The dogs used to find Madeleine's scent trail were not sniffer/detection dogs, such as drugs or explosives dogs, they were SAR dogs, search and rescue, with scent discrimination. If they were not, no clothing or items with her scent on would have been requested.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Detection_dog

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Search_dog
« Last Edit: April 29, 2013, 09:49:27 PM by Redblossom »

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: The tracker dogs
« Reply #163 on: April 29, 2013, 09:50:36 PM »

First point to note is that Harrison's speciality is advising in murder investigations.  So if you think of cause and effect, the PJ would not have drafted him in other than to advise on 'murder'.

The PJ had determined that Madeleine had been murdered and Harrison's role was to advise on how best to progress that line of enquiry.

3) ... where does MH say that he disowns 3 searches ?

Disowns in the sense that he does not own UK participation: for instance, describing searches at villa and gym as PJ exercises! 

4) Are those 3 disowned searches a) the villa, b) the clothes and c) the cars (the "disowned" reason here being that the Scenic wasn't supposed to be checked) ?

Can't think of a single logical reason why the scenic should have been checked, even if that check did provide the one action of Grime's for which I give him credit: to have the ignition card tested independently.  Otherwise, there would be stronger reason to suspect 'death scent in the car'

5) Do you infer from MH'd (late) instructions that for some reason he wasn't aware the PJ inspectors had no preparation to this kind of task whatsoever ? Do you think that he would have called Eddie and Keela if he'd been told there was a cadaver dog here in Portugal (btw there's one now).

No.  I infer from the instructions that he had observed unacceptable practice in what he had observed.

7) "strong reason to believe the PJ cribbed off this literature Harrison gave them". What is this "strong reason" ? And in what way was MH's literature "cribbed off" ?

While the Portuguese clearly have experience (and expertise) in use of sniffer dogs, they don't, in use of cadaver dogs, and the principle of cross-contamination of a death scent is very specific to cadaver dogs.  That has to have come from somewhere, and it clearly didn't come from Grime.  So my money is on the instructions Harrison gave them.

And finally, there is a (moderately) thought-provoking blog advancing the theory that in his assertion that Gerry hid (distinct from buried) Madeleine on the beach, he actually plaguarised the proper detective work of Harrison.

Would you like to read it?
2) I always had a feeling there was some fanfaronnade in GA's sayings, some kind of boasting that has to be related with Portuguese marialvism to be understood (I nevertheless think GA is deeply a honest guy). Let's say that the idea of murder came from the PJ, MH gently recognizing the PJ leadership in the investigation. Don't you think the PJ head inspector and the LC debated with the NPIA before deciding to send MH to PDL ?
3) 4) Could be your interpretation. After all had they searched the villa if the search of the flat had produced no alert ?
5) "Unacceptable practices" up to what point ? And observed where ? You cast a critical eye on the Portuguese police methods, but it seems you scrutinize MG as well. Why ?
7) I don't understand, Ferryman, please be more specific.
Read a theory that GA plagiarised MH ? Why not ?

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: The tracker dogs
« Reply #164 on: April 29, 2013, 09:53:21 PM »
The dogs used to find Madeleine's scent trail were not sniffer/detection dogs, such as drugs or explosives dogs, they were SAR dogs, search and rescue, with scent discrimination. If they were not, no clothing or items with her scent on would have been requested.

A search and rescue dog trained to find an individual and unique scent would be able to find, only, the individual and unique scent of the person it was primed to find, not much use to all the other poor souls trapped and in need of rescue ...