Author Topic: At what time were the police called after Madeleine's disappearance?  (Read 89189 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

icabodcrane

  • Guest
Re: At what time were the police called after Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #240 on: June 02, 2013, 10:07:08 PM »

So she didn't mention it  - so what is so sinister about that?

I didn't say it was  'sinister'  I said it was significant  ...  and it is in relation to this thread, which asks when the police were first contacted, and by whom

We are told, by Gerry, through his police statement, that he went to the 24 hour reception to ask about the police

So what time was that ?  ... what did they tell him ? ...   did they tell him that the police had already been called, or that that the police had  not been called yet ...   what was Gerry's response,  did he insist that the police be called there and then in his presence,  or did he not ? 

This is very relevent detail  (  especially with a view to the McCanns subsequent berating of the police response )   so why hasn't Gerry given those details ?  ...  and why did Kate not take the opportunity to give them in her book ?

In my view it it utterly insignificant and is merely a form of nitpicking.

One account refers to the fact that Gerry checked the kids club. This may have been at the same time as he went to the Reception. We do not know for sure.

Another account written with a completely different focus some years previously relates the fact that Gerry went to the reception. Perhaps he insisted then, perhaps not.  We really do not know and probably never will.

There is no inconsistency or discrepancy at all, no significance whatsoever.

You still have failed to explain what you think any of this proves.

It proves that six years later we still havn't had answers from the McCanns to even the most basic  questions

Did  Gerry ask the receptionist to call the police that night,   for instance  ?

It's a pretty fundemental question isn't it ?   ...  and it's never been answered has it ?

Offline Benice

Re: At what time were the police called after Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #241 on: June 02, 2013, 10:12:26 PM »

So she didn't mention it  - so what is so sinister about that?

I didn't say it was  'sinister'  I said it was significant  ...  and it is in relation to this thread, which asks when the police were first contacted, and by whom

We are told, by Gerry, through his police statement, that he went to the 24 hour reception to ask about the police

So what time was that ?  ... what did they tell him ? ...   did they tell him that the police had already been called, or that that the police had  not been called yet ...   what was Gerry's response,  did he insist that the police be called there and then in his presence,  or did he not ? 

This is very relevent detail  (  especially with a view to the McCanns subsequent berating of the police response )   so why hasn't Gerry given those details ?  ...  and why did Kate not take the opportunity to give them in her book ?

In my view it it utterly insignificant and is merely a form of nitpicking.

One account refers to the fact that Gerry checked the kids club. This may have been at the same time as he went to the Reception. We do not know for sure.

Another account written with a completely different focus some years previously relates the fact that Gerry went to the reception. Perhaps he insisted then, perhaps not.  We really do not know and probably never will.

There is no inconsistency or discrepancy at all, no significance whatsoever.

You still have failed to explain what you think any of this proves.

It proves that six years later we still havn't had answers from the McCanns to even the most basic  questions

Did  Gerry ask the receptionist to call the police that night,   for instance  ?

It's a pretty fundemental question isn't it ?   ...  and it's never been answered has it ?

Apols if I'm wrong,  but I thought you said he gave the answer to that in his statement to the police.

The notion that innocence prevails over guilt – when there is no evidence to the contrary – is what separates civilization from barbarism.    Unfortunately, there are remains of barbarism among us.    Until very recently, it headed the PJ in Portimão. I hope he was the last one.
                                               Henrique Monteiro, chief editor, Expresso, Portugal

icabodcrane

  • Guest
Re: At what time were the police called after Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #242 on: June 02, 2013, 10:17:31 PM »

So she didn't mention it  - so what is so sinister about that?

I didn't say it was  'sinister'  I said it was significant  ...  and it is in relation to this thread, which asks when the police were first contacted, and by whom

We are told, by Gerry, through his police statement, that he went to the 24 hour reception to ask about the police

So what time was that ?  ... what did they tell him ? ...   did they tell him that the police had already been called, or that that the police had  not been called yet ...   what was Gerry's response,  did he insist that the police be called there and then in his presence,  or did he not ? 

This is very relevent detail  (  especially with a view to the McCanns subsequent berating of the police response )   so why hasn't Gerry given those details ?  ...  and why did Kate not take the opportunity to give them in her book ?

In my view it it utterly insignificant and is merely a form of nitpicking.

One account refers to the fact that Gerry checked the kids club. This may have been at the same time as he went to the Reception. We do not know for sure.

Another account written with a completely different focus some years previously relates the fact that Gerry went to the reception. Perhaps he insisted then, perhaps not.  We really do not know and probably never will.

There is no inconsistency or discrepancy at all, no significance whatsoever.

You still have failed to explain what you think any of this proves.

It proves that six years later we still havn't had answers from the McCanns to even the most basic  questions

Did  Gerry ask the receptionist to call the police that night,   for instance  ?

It's a pretty fundemental question isn't it ?   ...  and it's never been answered has it ?

Apols if I'm wrong,  but I thought you said he gave the answer to that in his statement to the police.

He said he went to the 24 hour reception to  'ask about the police'

What does that mean ?   ...  and what did reception tell him  'about the police' ?

And why did Kate make no mention of this visit made to reception by Gerry in her book ...  whilst bothering to tell us about the two times Gerry asked Matthew to go there ?

Offline Mo Stache

Re: At what time were the police called after Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #243 on: June 02, 2013, 10:17:46 PM »
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/HELDER_LUIS.htm

"03- Processos Vol III Pages 796 to 797
TRANSLATIONS BY INES
 
03_VOLUME_IIIa_Page_796
 
03_VOLUME_IIIa_Page_797
 
Date: 2007/05/09
Witness Statement
Helder Jorge Samaio Luis


Occupation: Receptionist Ocean Club

Has worked at the Ocean Club for almost a year and a half and works as a Receptionist at the main Ocean Club Reception. He doesn't work fixed hours but he always works on the 16.00 to 34.00 shift.

All his work takes place at the main reception.

He knows about the situation that happened at the Ocean Club concerning the disappearance of a little given that on the day in question (03/05/2007) he was on duty and was contacted by a member of staff from the Tapas Restaurant between 09.30 and 22.00 who informed him that the daughter of some guests who were dining there had disappeared.

That he immediately contacted the GNR in Lagos, shortly after this the child’s father and John Hill arrived at the reception and he phoned the GNR again.

He then contacted the head of reception Vítor Santos and informed him of the situation.

He remained at the OC reception until 24.00 when he was replaced by a colleague Mr Eliseu.

He then left the OC and went home.

He did not see or hear anything suspicious on 3rd May nor on the previous days.

Reads, signs, ratifies."
« Last Edit: August 22, 2016, 06:45:19 PM by John »

icabodcrane

  • Guest
Re: At what time were the police called after Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #244 on: June 02, 2013, 10:47:14 PM »

I understand that there are some who think the McCanns should not be questioned about  anything regarding their daughter's disappearance,  but there are those of us who think they should, at least,  be clear about the most fundemental details

They have been fully aware of the questions that have been asked ...  indeed, whilst the Portuguese investigation was ongoing they frequently alluded to the fact that they  wanted  to address the questions being asked, but were compelled not to,  given Portuguese judicial secrecy

Yet five years after the  'secrecy'  impediment was lifted,  we   still  don't even know something as basic as how soon  Gerry went to reception and what was said there

I have never come across anyone who thinks the McCanns should not be questioned about absolutely everything relating to the case.

The difference is that you appear to think that they should be questioned by and have to answer amateur detectives on forums, blogs and even on Twitter.   The reality is that they have no responsibilty to do any such thing.

And you have claimed that you think it is a fundamental matter that Gerry's statement and Kate's book written years later don't match word for word. I find that idea ridiculous personally.  It is not fundamental, it isn't even significant to the crux of the matter the disappearance of Madeleine.

I think you are nit-picking and I think many readers here will feel the same.

Regarding the topic under discussion it is not merely a matter of Gerry's statement and Kate's book not  'matching word for word'  it is a case of Gerry saying he did something  (  went to reception to ask about the police )  and Kate implying  ( by ommission )  that he had done any such thing

And it certainly is significant to the crux of this thread,  which seeks to determine who first contacted the police and when 


AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: At what time were the police called after Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #245 on: June 02, 2013, 11:39:58 PM »

I do not in any way whatsoever think as you do that the omission suggests what you claim about Gerry going to the Reception or not. She says he was at the miniclub. She says nothing about reception.
That's true, Gilet, but is also true the fact that nobody of the miniclub saw Mr McCann.

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: At what time were the police called after Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #246 on: June 02, 2013, 11:58:45 PM »
Rachael :
her husband headed to the main reception to see if he could find MADELEINE there, since her "nursery" was there, that also being the place he contacted the local police authorities.
Matt sort of went  off to sort of look a bit more and search and he, he went down to call the
Police at the main reception of the Ocean Club,  and I went to tell Jane what had happened
Fiona :
I remember saying to Matt at that point ‘You go down to main reception and phone the Police.
Matthew :
Fiona, I think, asked me to go and phone the Police
I volunteered to go up to the Millennium Restaurant because it was just one of the routes that I thought she might have taken

It seems the idea to go and phone the police was Fiona's.
Going to the Millennium Restaurant was a smart idea, because Madeleine could have thought her parents were there since she had had dinner with them in that restaurant.

Offline gilet

Re: At what time were the police called after Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #247 on: June 03, 2013, 12:00:55 AM »

I do not in any way whatsoever think as you do that the omission suggests what you claim about Gerry going to the Reception or not. She says he was at the miniclub. She says nothing about reception.
That's true, Gilet, but is also true the fact that nobody of the miniclub saw Mr McCann.

Do you actually have any evidence to support that claim or is  that just your assumption based on omissions? Have each of the staff present at the time actually stated that?

I simply do not accept that omission of this kind is evidence of anything because we do not know what those staff were asked.


Offline gilet

Re: At what time were the police called after Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #248 on: June 03, 2013, 12:02:02 AM »
Rachael :
her husband headed to the main reception to see if he could find MADELEINE there, since her "nursery" was there, that also being the place he contacted the local police authorities.
Matt sort of went  off to sort of look a bit more and search and he, he went down to call the
Police at the main reception of the Ocean Club,  and I went to tell Jane what had happened
Fiona :
I remember saying to Matt at that point ‘You go down to main reception and phone the Police.
Matthew :
Fiona, I think, asked me to go and phone the Police
I volunteered to go up to the Millennium Restaurant because it was just one of the routes that I thought she might have taken

It seems the idea to go and phone the police was Fiona's.
Going to the Millennium Restaurant was a smart idea, because Madeleine could have thought her parents were there since she had had dinner with them in that restaurant.

Seriously are you trying to suggest that in the panic of the moment, in the desperation of such a situation there could not have been two people who made similar suggestions?

Or what is the point you are making by the use of this snippet?

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: At what time were the police called after Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #249 on: June 03, 2013, 01:42:10 AM »
I have no reason to doubt what the TP7 told, except for a few un-truths said to protect themselves from neglect accusation. So when Matthew says Fiona asked him and when Fiona says she asked Matthew to go to the main reception in order to have the police called, I'm prone to think it is true.

Offline gilet

Re: At what time were the police called after Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #250 on: June 03, 2013, 02:13:47 AM »
I have no reason to doubt what the TP7 told, except for a few un-truths said to protect themselves from neglect accusation. So when Matthew says Fiona asked him and when Fiona says she asked Matthew to go to the main reception in order to have the police called, I'm prone to think it is true.

I also think this is true. Just as I think it is true that Gerry made the same suggestion.

You still don't seem to be aware that more than one person can make the same suggestion. Just because Fiona suggested it does NOT mean Gerry didn't.

On the other matter, could you please specify what "untruths" you are referring to regarding people covering up neglect or is that just a nasty dig without real evidence?

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: At what time were the police called after Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #251 on: July 03, 2015, 12:57:59 PM »
Gerry McCann asked for the police to be called a lot earlier than that.


Really.

What time was that then, and can it be corroborated ?
« Last Edit: July 19, 2015, 01:24:05 PM by John »

Offline G-Unit

Re: At what time were the police called after Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #252 on: July 03, 2015, 02:29:46 PM »
Gerry McCann asked for the police to be called a lot earlier than that.

Whether or not the parents were neglectful or not shouldn't have been an issue,   a child was missing and that child deserved to have been given 100 %.   Not putting out her photo straight away,  not alerting the ferry and airports etc.   in my opinion is not giving 100%.   It was Amaral's fault not the police who were just following orders.

Who did Gerry ask to call the police? Fiona asked Matt to do it, but he was too wimpish to get the job done;

I said, you've got to phone the Police, you know, a child's been taken, and they went, oh no, she's probably just sort of woken up and he thought she's probably sort of wandered off or something like that and you thought, yeah, maybe you're right, maybe you're right, erm, can you please, it was sort of, it was kind of, it was sort a weird kind of lack of urgency, you know, he'd ring, but you had to sort and stand there and say, ring now, ring now, so I don't know if they rang at that point, but certainly, erm, you know, I certainly asked them to, about perhaps sort of maybe about ten past ten maybe.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MATTHEW-OLDFIELD-ROGATORY.htm

Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline pathfinder73

Re: At what time were the police called after Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #253 on: July 03, 2015, 02:48:02 PM »
Who did Gerry ask to call the police? Fiona asked Matt to do it, but he was too wimpish to get the job done;

I said, you've got to phone the Police, you know, a child's been taken, and they went, oh no, she's probably just sort of woken up and he thought she's probably sort of wandered off or something like that and you thought, yeah, maybe you're right, maybe you're right, erm, can you please, it was sort of, it was kind of, it was sort a weird kind of lack of urgency, you know, he'd ring, but you had to sort and stand there and say, ring now, ring now, so I don't know if they rang at that point, but certainly, erm, you know, I certainly asked them to, about perhaps sort of maybe about ten past ten maybe.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MATTHEW-OLDFIELD-ROGATORY.htm

Gerry wasn't with them when Fiona asked Matt to go. Matt didn't see Gerry next after the alarm until he arrived with John Hill at reception at around 10:40.
 
Dave and Russell were just running off sort of shouting, so Fiona, I think, asked me to go and phone the Police, so I actually went down the route to where she would have gone for Nursery drop off, which his back to the, to the main reception essentially, so I went down that route looking for her at that time and I asked the reception to phone the Police, and that must have been about five past, it's difficult to know what time it was at that time, but maybe about ten past ten, five past ten, ten past ten'.

I think it's Stuart HILL or, well the Manager, the sort of Manager got involved, that might have been when it occurred. Erm, so there was plenty of running around through the back streets and back to the apartment and then, you know, where's the, where are the Police, where are the Police, erm, and so went back down to the reception, this would have been about thirty minutes or so later, erm, back to reception, erm, and at that point, Gerry had come down as well. (MO)

10:10 to 10:40 = 30 minutes

Smithman carrying a child in his arms checked his watch after passing the Smith family and the time was 10:03. Both are still unidentified 10 years later.

Offline lordpookles

Re: At what time were the police called after Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #254 on: July 15, 2015, 04:29:34 PM »
I have heard from various sources - those being newspaper reports largely that the police were first called at 10.14 on the 3rd of May after Madeleine disappeared. I've also heard contradictory reports that the Portuguese police say the first call they received was at 10.40.

So what time were the police in fact called that night? Any actual evidence would be appreciated although I suspect this is another area of huge uncertainty.
« Last Edit: July 15, 2015, 04:32:10 PM by lordpookles »