Author Topic: Robert Murat calls for them all to be brought back to Portugal for re-enactment  (Read 42796 times)

0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline sika

My own view is that a reconstruction is a complete waste of time.  Both Amaral and Channel 4 have attempted partial re-enactments which are helpful but anything further at this stage would probably end up in the realms of fantasy world.

I wonder how much the Express paid Murat this time?
You would think that Mr Murat would want to disappear into obscurity.

Offline Chinagirl

Why?  He's done nothing wrong.
A

Offline gilet

"Last week Prime Minister David Cameron had a private meeting with the McCanns in London, promising them the review would not fall foul of budget cuts and giving them enough confidence to say on their website that they hope for a significant breakthrough in the months ahead."

Had not seen that covered.

Nor have we seen any evidence backing up the claim. I am not prepared simply to accept the word of a journalist who isn't even able to offer a quote as a minimum regarding a story.

If a paper says that without backing, they run the risk of another paper asking Cameron "Did you or did you not meet with the McCanns?" My general rule is that actions and quotes attributed to public figures are to be regarded as probably factual if that person could reasonably deny it.

It is the kind of risk that the Express and a few other papers seem perfectly willing to take. Its not the kind of libel that will ever cost them money so what is the issue?

I don't treat the content of papers by rules. I simply mistrust the content if they don't provide evidence for the claims they make. I have the same attitude to posts on forums and blogs too.

Offline sika

Why?  He's done nothing wrong.
I formed that opinion having read the news paper article. It sounds like Murat has been to hell and back. Therefore, I would have thought that he would want to disappear into obscurity.
Unfortunately, whether its true or not, his participation in this article, looks like a money making enterprise.
Perhaps he was not paid or simply donated his fee to charity. Would be nice to know.

debunker

  • Guest
"Last week Prime Minister David Cameron had a private meeting with the McCanns in London, promising them the review would not fall foul of budget cuts and giving them enough confidence to say on their website that they hope for a significant breakthrough in the months ahead."

Had not seen that covered.

Nor have we seen any evidence backing up the claim. I am not prepared simply to accept the word of a journalist who isn't even able to offer a quote as a minimum regarding a story.

If a paper says that without backing, they run the risk of another paper asking Cameron "Did you or did you not meet with the McCanns?" My general rule is that actions and quotes attributed to public figures are to be regarded as probably factual if that person could reasonably deny it.

It is the kind of risk that the Express and a few other papers seem perfectly willing to take. Its not the kind of libel that will ever cost them money so what is the issue?

I don't treat the content of papers by rules. I simply mistrust the content if they don't provide evidence for the claims they make. I have the same attitude to posts on forums and blogs too.

Scepticism is one thing, distrust is another. If we are to interpret the political world, inferences need to be drawn from incomplete information.

Potentially deniable but undenied statements are at least worthy of initial belief. Not convincing but certainly directive.

Offline gilet

"Last week Prime Minister David Cameron had a private meeting with the McCanns in London, promising them the review would not fall foul of budget cuts and giving them enough confidence to say on their website that they hope for a significant breakthrough in the months ahead."

Had not seen that covered.

Nor have we seen any evidence backing up the claim. I am not prepared simply to accept the word of a journalist who isn't even able to offer a quote as a minimum regarding a story.

If a paper says that without backing, they run the risk of another paper asking Cameron "Did you or did you not meet with the McCanns?" My general rule is that actions and quotes attributed to public figures are to be regarded as probably factual if that person could reasonably deny it.

It is the kind of risk that the Express and a few other papers seem perfectly willing to take. Its not the kind of libel that will ever cost them money so what is the issue?

I don't treat the content of papers by rules. I simply mistrust the content if they don't provide evidence for the claims they make. I have the same attitude to posts on forums and blogs too.

Scepticism is one thing, distrust is another. If we are to interpret the political world, inferences need to be drawn from incomplete information.

Potentially deniable but undenied statements are at least worthy of initial belief. Not convincing but certainly directive.

Clearly we disagree on this issue. My scepticism/distrust (however you prefer to look upon it) stems from a very long interaction with the UK media. Articles about my own father's career, for example, which range over a number of decades back as far as the 1950s and in which there was no real desire on the part of the journalists even of some of the more reputable papers to be accurate in their stories.  Though the stories were almost always favourable towards him, there were invariably exaggerations and inaccuracies which could easily have been corrected but were not because they made for a better story.

I am open-minded as to the possibility of such a meeting between the McCanns and Cameron but without evidence I won't be accepting it as fact.

Offline Angelo222

My own view is that a reconstruction is a complete waste of time.  Both Amaral and Channel 4 have attempted partial re-enactments which are helpful but anything further at this stage would probably end up in the realms of fantasy world.

I wonder how much the Express paid Murat this time?
You would think that Mr Murat would want to disappear into obscurity.

Clearly the Express have taken a throw away comment by Murat about a possible reconstruction and spun it into a front page sensation in order to flog their tainted product. 
De troothe has the annoying habit of coming to the surface just when you least expect it!!

Je ne regrette rien!!

Offline gilet

My own view is that a reconstruction is a complete waste of time.  Both Amaral and Channel 4 have attempted partial re-enactments which are helpful but anything further at this stage would probably end up in the realms of fantasy world.

I wonder how much the Express paid Murat this time?
You would think that Mr Murat would want to disappear into obscurity.

Clearly the Express have taken a throw away comment by Murat about a possible reconstruction and spun it into a front page sensation in order to flog their tainted product.

I think that is an excellent summary of the article.

I am still wondering though whether the motive for Murat talking to the journalist about his desire for UK police involvement in the investigation in Portugal is related to what he said last April.  I know under the circumstances I would prefer a UK cop to be around during interviews.

  • Robert Murat was in his thirties and living with his mother. Half English and Half Portuguese, when Madeleine went missing he offered his skills to the Portuguese Police as a translator. But eleven days in with no quick resolution to the investigation in sight the spotlight turned on him. Now Robert Murat believes that with the Portuguese Police under pressure he was an easy scapegoat.

    ROBERT MURAT: At one stage I was taken to an area where they wanted to fingerprint me and take photographs and all that kind of stuff. And I think they were trying to disorient,er, me because they moved me around from room to room, hallway to hallway, corridor to corridor and it seemed very choreographed calling out, “Well, take photographs of him” and you know, he’s, er, “We want to send a team to Poland.” It was kind of a choreographed situation.

    RB: What, to intimidate you?

    ROBERT MURAT: Yeah, I think so. And it did intimidate me at the time. Its now that I realise what was going on. I had five people rushing into a room and, erm, and standing behind me and it felt very very ‘Life on Mars’. It felt very, er you know, erm, just very pressured.

    RB: He was questioned for nineteen hours before he was released. The next day he returned to collect his belongings and Robert Murat says he met Goncalo Amaral, the lead detective.

    ROBERT MURAT: He basically told me it was a game of two halves and as the night before I hadn’t confessed, erm, then, he would get me on the second half and he just kind of turned his back on me. He didn’t… He just… It seemed he didn’t care about the truth. That was the, thats how I felt.


Approx 10.50 - 12.50
« Last Edit: May 05, 2013, 10:12:35 AM by gilet »

Offline DCI

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 2585
  • Total likes: 6
  • Why are some folks so sick in the head!!!
Is this a new story ?
It is in tomorrows Sunday express.   8)-)))


It looks like Mr Murat is still trying to get closure.

He must be really pissed at being named as a suspect by members of the tapas 9.  It must have damaged his business interests no end and after he went out of his way to assist them?  There's gratitude for you?

He wasn't named as a suspect, by the Tapas 9, though John. They didn't know his name, for one, and the 3 that said he was there that night, did not include Jane.
IMO, Amaral pushed and pushed, for Jane Tanner to be framed as pointing him out, when she did not.
He lied about her pointing him out, in his book.

Don't forget he's good at getting to the (cough) truth as Murat says. He was gonna get him one way or another.

Quote
ROBERT MURAT: He basically told me it was a game of two halves and as the night before I hadn’t confessed, erm, then, he would get me on the second half and he just kind of turned his back on me. He didn’t… He just… It seemed he didn’t care about the truth. That was the, thats how I felt.

As for his business interests

Quote
His property business went, partly because his computers were held by the PJ for so long, but now he has built up Newteq, an Apple-authorised service provider on the Algarve.
Kate's 500 Mile Cycle Challenge

https://www.justgiving.com/KateMcCann/

ferryman

  • Guest
IMO, Amaral pushed and pushed, for Jane Tanner to be framed as pointing him out, when she did not.
He lied about her pointing him out, in his book.


Agreed!

I think a concerted effort was made to push Murat off the agenda and (as Amaral hoped!) leave all paths clear that led to the McCanns' door.

I believe that included corrupting Martin Smith's statement so that it did not contradict Murat's alibi of spending the night with his mother.

icabodcrane

  • Guest
What is remarkable here, I think,  is that the Express have given the front page  ( and a striking headline ) to a story which cannot be called  'helpful' to the McCanns and their campaign

What does it matter what Robert Murat thinks Scotland Yard  should  be doing, afterall  ... why make a front page headline expressing his opinion on the matter ?

"Bring them all back to Portugal"  implies that the McCanns and their mates should be  'brought' back whether they like it or not

I'm wondering if this could be a shot across the bows to Gerry, post Leveson ...  a message that they  ( the press )  can be  'unhelpful'  in ways that are not directly addressed by the proposed Royal Charter

Offline Eleanor


Since there is absolutely no chance of anyone being forced back to Portugal, this is all a bit of a waste of time.

Redblossom

  • Guest
My own view is that a reconstruction is a complete waste of time.  Both Amaral and Channel 4 have attempted partial re-enactments which are helpful but anything further at this stage would probably end up in the realms of fantasy world.

I wonder how much the Express paid Murat this time?

It is a long time ago now, and IIRC SY have made appeals last year on Crimewatch to anyone who was around at the time to come forward. We are not privy to that information and what has transpired. Robert Murat has a point, attempting a reconstruction with as many people as possible as were there on the night, or as Murat says the previous two days might be fruitful.

In the Stephen Lawrence case, they are still making appeals 20 years later. There are other cases where reconstructions were done years after as well and yielded new information.

If SY, who are on an unlimited budget of millions, and timescale, recommend this, it will not look good if the Tapas group refuse to go back IMO, that is if a reconstruction is part of SY's remit.
« Last Edit: May 05, 2013, 02:03:14 PM by Redblossom »

ferryman

  • Guest

Since there is absolutely no chance of anyone being forced back to Portugal, this is all a bit of a waste of time.

I recall having a biit of a dust-up with Sans on that point. 

I thought there was (at least a theoretical) chance they could be; he insisted there wasn't.

Sans is seldom wrong ...

icabodcrane

  • Guest

Since there is absolutely no chance of anyone being forced back to Portugal, this is all a bit of a waste of time.

Why would they need to be   'forced'   

The McCanns have expressed their full confidence in Scotland Yard and the progress they are making with the review.  If a reconstruction were to be advised and requested by the Yard,  then the McCanns, and their friends,  would surely have no grounds on which to object and refuse

Why did Clarence Mitchell not confirm that when the story was run past him ?  ...  why did did he say No comment ?