Author Topic: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?  (Read 62568 times)

0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.

registrar

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?p.03
« Reply #90 on: May 07, 2013, 09:37:27 PM »
the bottom line is,  icabodcrane wants proof that an abduction can occur within a three minute window.

Gerry alledges he checked his watch at 9.04 when he set off on his check, as he was also so veryvery precise about whenKate went to make her check, 10.03, how wierd is that? out having a lovely dinner and checking minutes on watches, you know the ones Clarence said none of them had on LOL but anyway

IF you take Gerrys times as accurate, then you have to factor in what he did from the time he left the bar and how long it took to leaving his apartment after seeing Madeleine in her roomand sitting outside chattinf to his mate

JaneTanner was not exact in her timings to the minute, she says she left 5 or 10 mins after Gerry, so between 9.09 and 9.14, so I dont think the three minute window is accurate here, youhave to figure out the difference between the time gerry saw Madeleine and the time Tanner saw a man and  figure out what could have happened inbetween

Its possible in this timeframe alledged abductor entered flat when Gerry was there chatting with Jez via front door somehow

Did you get so overexcited again inyour rush to  attack you forgot to sayanything? LOL

in English please
« Last Edit: May 07, 2013, 09:39:39 PM by registrar »

amaraltheofficeboy

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?p.03
« Reply #91 on: May 07, 2013, 09:38:17 PM »
the bottom line is,  icabodcrane wants proof that an abduction can occur within a three minute window.

Gerry alledges he checked his watch at 9.04 when he set off on his check, as he was also so veryvery precise about whenKate went to make her check, 10.03, how wierd is that? out having a lovely dinner and checking minutes on watches, you know the ones Clarence said none of them had on LOL but anyway

IF you take Gerrys times as accurate, then you have to factor in what he did from the time he left the bar and how long it took to leaving his apartment after seeing Madeleine in her roomand sitting outside chattinf to his mate

JaneTanner was not exact in her timings to the minute, she says she left 5 or 10 mins after Gerry, so between 9.09 and 9.14, so I dont think the three minute window is accurate here, youhave to figure out the difference between the time gerry saw Madeleine and the time Tanner saw a man and  figure out what could have happened inbetween

Its possible in this timeframe alledged abductor entered flat when Gerry was there chatting with Jez via front door somehow

Quote
icabodcrane
As I see it, if the Man Jane saw was the abductor, then he had, at most, a three  minute window of opportunity 

amaraltheofficeboy

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #92 on: May 07, 2013, 09:39:44 PM »
the bottom line is,  icabodcrane wants proof that an abduction can occur within a three minute window.

I think it is important to demonstrate whether or not it was possible for the  man who Jane saw to be the abductor, in the limited time frame allowed

If a re-enactment demonstrated that it was  not possible, for instance  (  that there simply wasn't enough time for the abductor to have carried out the crime in the time allowed )  then everyone  ( including the McCanns )   could eliminate that scenario, and concentrate on the next three quarters of an hour  ...  when an abduction really was possible

On the other hand, If it was demonstrated that it was entirely possible for the man Jane saw to have been the abductor,  (  because it had been established that there was, indeed, enough time to carry out the crime ) then the McCanns could be reassured that the man they have been highlighting as the abductor, almost certainly was

I really do believe that such a re-enactment would be helpful in that regard

Quote
icabodcrane
As I see it, if the Man Jane saw was the abductor, then he had, at most, a three  minute window of opportunity 

Offline Chinagirl

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #93 on: May 08, 2013, 12:13:26 AM »
The Scotland Yard review has already established that an abduction was possible in the time frame allowed, so Icabod's reasons for wanting a real life reconstruction would be a pointless and expensive exercise.

Neither an in situ reconstruction nor a computer generated model can establish who the abductor was, what happened to Madeline or where she is now. 
A

icabodcrane

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #94 on: May 08, 2013, 12:39:31 AM »
The Scotland Yard review has already established that an abduction was possible in the time frame allowed, so Icabod's reasons for wanting a real life reconstruction would be a pointless and expensive exercise.

Neither an in situ reconstruction nor a computer generated model can establish who the abductor was, what happened to Madeline or where she is now.

I don't think Scotland Yard have done that at all !

They have said  (  through Andy Redwood )  that there was an opportunity for abduction that night  ...  and we must all agree with that ...  but they most certainly have  not  said that Jane Tanner saw the abductor, and that an abduction may have occured between the time Gerry last saw Madeleine and Jane Tanner made her sighting of a  man carrying a child

That is misleading, and simply not true

Offline Chinagirl

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #95 on: May 08, 2013, 01:56:19 AM »
Have it your way, but my second point about not being able to identify the abductor or ascertain what happened to Madeleine stands.

I suspect that the only reason the [ censored word] have insisted on calling for a reconstruction for the last six years is because they hope for more ammunition to cast suspicion on the McCanns and their friends, especially Jane Tanner.  Let the reconstruction deviate by one millimetre or one minute from one of the statements and there would be cries of, "See - lies!!" from the [ censored word ] brigade.

Scotland Yard have said that an abduction by a stranger is the most likely scenario, and that there was time for such an occurrence, and that should be good enough for most people.  Establishing whether or not Tanner saw the abductor is pretty irrelevant at this stage, given the lack of identification, or what happened after she saw that particular figure.
A

icabodcrane

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #96 on: May 08, 2013, 03:00:57 AM »
Have it your way, but my second point about not being able to identify the abductor or ascertain what happened to Madeleine stands.

I suspect that the only reason the [ censored word] have insisted on calling for a reconstruction for the last six years is because they hope for more ammunition to cast suspicion on the McCanns and their friends, especially Jane Tanner.  Let the reconstruction deviate by one millimetre or one minute from one of the statements and there would be cries of, "See - lies!!" from the h..... brigade.

Scotland Yard have said that an abduction by a stranger is the most likely scenario, and that there was time for such an occurrence, and that should be good enough for most people.  Establishing whether or not Tanner saw the abductor is pretty irrelevant at this stage, given the lack of identification, or what happened after she saw that particular figure.

Who cares whether a reconstruction would be grist to the mill of  '[ censored word]'   ...  is there a chance ...  just a chance that it might  help find Madeleine ?

That is all that really matters, surely  ?

Offline Chinagirl

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #97 on: May 08, 2013, 04:54:09 AM »
It can't "help Madeleine" for the reasons I have outlined.
A

Offline Angelo222

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #98 on: May 08, 2013, 08:42:39 AM »
One does wonder which version of their timelines (one, two or three) and which versions of their statements (to many to count) did (smiler) Redwood load into that computer.

Let's not forget that the McCann's have already carried out a reconsruction (sort of) where they tried to explain the claimed checks of Tanner and Oldfield (why) the best that they could come up with in Tanner's case was that it didn't matter that Wilkins didn't see her walk by and if only Oldfield had just walked a few steps further into the room blah blah blah, they even linked Tanner's sighting to that of the Smiths to the extent of altering the carrying style as reported by the Smith family members to that of Tanner's claimed style.. now why would they do that?  Which part of this reconstruction was to help find Madeleine?

Bottom line is that the timelines and statements for that evening are lies pure and simple!

There will always be discrepancies and inconsistencies in any timeline and especially when nine people are involved.  The initial time-line was put together in haste and at a time of high anxiety in an attempt to assist the Portuguese authorities so attempting to use it by armchair sleuths some six years later is laughable.  Bottom line is Peter, you haven't got a baldy clue mate.    8(0(*
« Last Edit: May 08, 2013, 08:47:53 AM by Angelo222 »
De troothe has the annoying habit of coming to the surface just when you least expect it!!

Je ne regrette rien!!

Offline Angelo222

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #99 on: May 08, 2013, 09:18:46 AM »
One way in which I believe a reconstruction would aid the investigation, is that it would confirm or exclude the possibility that the man  Jane Tanner saw was the abductor

As I see it, if the Man Jane saw was the abductor, then he had, at most, a three  minute window of opportunity 

In a reconstruction, a policeman would  play the part of  'the abductor' and whether or not it was possible for him to have entered the apartment, opened the window and shutters, picked up the sleeping child, made his way around the wall and through the car park, and be crossing the road just as Jane was reaching the top of the hill, would be demonstrated

If it was proven to be possible,  then the investigation could conclude that the man Jane saw very likely  was   the abductor

If it was proven to be impossible for the crime to have been committed in that time-frame, then the investigation could eliminate the man Jane saw as a possible abductor,  and concentrate on the other  'windows of opportunity'  that an abductor may have had   ( at some point later )

Wouldn't that be of benefit ?

There you have the problem with reconstructions Ica.  Which version are you going to use?  Is it the abductor lifted the unsecured outer shutter, slid the unlocked window along and climbed in or is it the one where the abductor walks in through the unlocked patio doors?   Maybe we should go with abductor being able to open the front door and walk in that way?

In the Gerry and Jez scene with Tanner, which side of the road are they to be on?

Can you see the problem Ica??

The police can't afford to reconstruct a fallacy.  There is no link between the guy Tanner saw and the man the Smith family saw.  There is also a time lapse of some 45 minutes between sightings.  So how was a man carrying a young child able to avoid being seen for 45 minutes in a holiday town with lots of people going about?

In my opinion a reconstruction is not possible unless you do ten or more  reconstructions showing every possible scenario and as we all know that will never happn,  A reconstruction is only possible where there is sufficient evidence of events to create one.
De troothe has the annoying habit of coming to the surface just when you least expect it!!

Je ne regrette rien!!

Offline Benice

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #100 on: May 08, 2013, 09:51:36 AM »
One way in which I believe a reconstruction would aid the investigation, is that it would confirm or exclude the possibility that the man  Jane Tanner saw was the abductor

As I see it, if the Man Jane saw was the abductor, then he had, at most, a three  minute window of opportunity 

In a reconstruction, a policeman would  play the part of  'the abductor' and whether or not it was possible for him to have entered the apartment, opened the window and shutters, picked up the sleeping child, made his way around the wall and through the car park, and be crossing the road just as Jane was reaching the top of the hill, would be demonstrated

If it was proven to be possible,  then the investigation could conclude that the man Jane saw very likely  was   the abductor

If it was proven to be impossible for the crime to have been committed in that time-frame, then the investigation could eliminate the man Jane saw as a possible abductor,  and concentrate on the other  'windows of opportunity'  that an abductor may have had   ( at some point later )

Wouldn't that be of benefit ?

There you have the problem with reconstructions Ica.  Which version are you going to use?  Is it the abductor lifted the unsecured outer shutter, slid the unlocked window along and climbed in or is it the one where the abductor walks in through the unlocked patio doors?   Maybe we should go with abductor being able to open the front door and walk in that way?

In the Gerry and Jez scene with Tanner, which side of the road are they to be on?

Can you see the problem Ica??

The police can't afford to reconstruct a fallacy.  There is no link between the guy Tanner saw and the man the Smith family saw.  There is also a time lapse of some 45 minutes between sightings.  So how was a man carrying a young child able to avoid being seen for 45 minutes in a holiday town with lots of people going about?

In my opinion a reconstruction is not possible unless you do ten or more  reconstructions showing every possible scenario and as we all know that will never happn,  A reconstruction is only possible where there is sufficient evidence of events to create one.
Jane Tanner didn't see anyone, her sighting is purely to give Gerry an alibi for the Smith sighting.. that's the link.  8(0(*

For what reason would she take such a massive risk for someone she hardly knew and had only met half a dozen  times or so previously -  over a period of 3/4years.   The Paynes were her friends - not the McCanns.    IMO She would have to be mentally deranged to put her family at such risk - and not the normal intelligent person she clearly is.    Your claim makes no sense to me whatsoever.  Would you care to elaborate?




     


The notion that innocence prevails over guilt – when there is no evidence to the contrary – is what separates civilization from barbarism.    Unfortunately, there are remains of barbarism among us.    Until very recently, it headed the PJ in Portimão. I hope he was the last one.
                                               Henrique Monteiro, chief editor, Expresso, Portugal

Offline Angelo222

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #101 on: May 08, 2013, 10:04:06 AM »
And mores to the point why would she argue with Gerry on camera for Ch4 about where he and Jez were standing if she were wanting to make him look good?   The bigger picture folks....always look for the bigger picture.  8(0(*
De troothe has the annoying habit of coming to the surface just when you least expect it!!

Je ne regrette rien!!

Offline peter claridge

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #102 on: May 08, 2013, 10:10:05 AM »
And mores to the point why would she argue with Gerry on camera for Ch4 about where he and Jez were standing if she were wanting to make him look good?   The bigger picture folks....always look for the bigger picture.  8(0(*
That would be the scripted acting scene you're refering to there.  The bigger picture folks.. always look for the bigger picture.  8(0(*

Offline Angelo222

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #103 on: May 08, 2013, 10:17:56 AM »
I do concede that a reconstruction which attempts to portray Gerry McCann as the man carrying a child through the streets of PdL (having changed his clothes in order to do so and then back again) in the time frame would be a valuable exercise in order to silence once and for all the "sceptics" who think Gerry has superhuman powers.

Gerrys presence in and around the tapas bar from 9pm onwards is established from the evidence of at least a dozen people.  There only ever was one person missing from the table for any length of time and that was Russell.  Gerry never left the Ocean Club grounds except for the short walk up the street to the apartment gate and even then his presence is evidenced by Jez Wilkins and Jane Tanner.

De troothe has the annoying habit of coming to the surface just when you least expect it!!

Je ne regrette rien!!

Offline faithlilly

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #104 on: May 08, 2013, 10:25:19 AM »
The reasons for the reconstruction are laid out in the AG's shelving despatch and the questions they raise are as fundamental to solving the case as they were 5 years ago :


E – About the interest of the reconstruction
 
Taking into account that there were certain points in the arguidos' and witnesses' statements that revealed, apparently at least, contradiction or that lacked physical confirmation, it was decided to carry out the "reconstruction of the fact", a diligence that is consecrated in article 150 of the Penal Process Code in the sense of duly clarifying, on the very location of the facts, the following very important details, among others:
 
1 – The physical, real and effective proximity between Jane Tanner, Gerald McCann and Jeremy Wilkins, at the moment when the first person walked by them, and which coincided with the sighting of the supposed suspect, carrying a child. It results, in our perspective, strange that neither Gerald McCann nor Jeremy Wilkins saw her, or the alleged abductor, despite the exiguity of the space and the peacefulness of the area;
 
2 – The situation concerning the window to the bedroom where Madeleine slept, together with the twins, which was open, according to Kate. It seemed then necessary to clarify if there was a draught, since movement of the curtains and pressure under the bedroom door are mentioned, which, eventually, could be verified through the reconstitution;
 
3 – The establishment of a timeline and of a line of effective checking on the minors that were left alone in the apartments, given that, if it is believed that such checking was as tight as the witnesses and the arguidos describe it, it would be, at least, very difficult to reunite conditions for the introduction of an abductor in the residence and the posterior exit of said abductor, with the child, namely through a window with scarce space. It is added that the supposed abductor could only pass, through that window, holding the minor in a different position (vertical) from the one that witness JANE TANNER saw (horizontal);
 
4 – What happened during the time lapse between approximately 6.45/7 p.m. – the time at which MADELEINE was seen for the last time, in her apartment, by a different person (David Payne) from her parents or siblings – and the time at which the disappearance is reported by Kate Healy – at around 10 p.m.;
 
5 – The obvious and well-known advantages of immediate appreciation of evidence, or in other words, the fulfilment of the principle of contiguity of evidence in order to form a conviction, as firm as possible, about what was seen by Jane Tanner and the other interposers, and, eventually, to dismiss once and for all any doubts that may subsist concerning the innocence of the missing [child's] parents.

Thank you to Astro for the translation.
« Last Edit: May 08, 2013, 11:15:54 AM by Faithlilly »
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?