Author Topic: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?  (Read 62555 times)

0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #150 on: May 08, 2013, 06:15:30 PM »

What was stopping the Portuguese authorities doing their own reconstruction using actors, if the reconstruction was of such vital import at providing evidence that could nail the McCanns? 

The AG's opinion on the recon is that it *might* have settled the matter of the McCanns innocence once and for all, not that it could have helped establish their guilt!

7 - The re-enactment will only turn out to be efficient if performed by the participants in the events, once the information provided by the same participants needs to be tested and efficiently compared on-site, and that can only be achieved by means of their own performances. Thus, the possibility of using actors has to be put aside;
Paulo Rebelo

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RE_ENACTMENT.htm

If the PJ believed the McCanns and their friends were all lying why would they give any credence to a reconstruction based on their version of events anyway?
The PJ didn't believe they were all lying but found it better to have the discrepancies cleared, at least partly. Do you find this abusive ?

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #151 on: May 08, 2013, 06:24:56 PM »
If the PJ believed the McCanns and their friends were all lying why would they give any credence to a reconstruction based on their version of events anyway?

****

I dont know that the PJ thought they were all lyng, do you?

And even if they did, the PP states they missed this opportunity to remove any remnant suspiciions about their version of events.

Yes, as I said before the PT AG's opinion of the worth of the Reconstruction is that it might have settled the matter of the McCanns innocence once and for all (though I don't see how personally), not that it could have helped establish their guilt.
Martha, the PGR's objective was to understand what had happened to Madeleine. The question of guilt was secondary (imo), a fortiori because murder was discarded by the investigation. As no trace of Madeleine had been found, the PGR wished 1) to make sure the possible parents' involvement wasn't a lead and 2) by chance to find a clue towards a new lead.

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #152 on: May 08, 2013, 06:32:26 PM »
Anne, do you know if the PP shelved the case and removed arguido status because they shelved the case as no crime could be identified in the case, and arguido status of the three had to be removed,  or was the arguido status removed because there was no evidence against the arguidos. IE can a case be shelved but still keep people as arguidos?
They had to either charge or not, because the Robert M's arguido status had exhausted all possible extensions. As he had no evidence, or not enough to charge, the PGR couldn't but shelf the case. This is very clear in his dispatch where he indicates how the case can be open before the prescription.
When a case is shelved the arguido status are also "shelved" !

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #153 on: May 08, 2013, 06:34:15 PM »

What was stopping the Portuguese authorities doing their own reconstruction using actors, if the reconstruction was of such vital import at providing evidence that could nail the McCanns? 

The AG's opinion on the recon is that it *might* have settled the matter of the McCanns innocence once and for all, not that it could have helped establish their guilt!

7 - The re-enactment will only turn out to be efficient if performed by the participants in the events, once the information provided by the same participants needs to be tested and efficiently compared on-site, and that can only be achieved by means of their own performances. Thus, the possibility of using actors has to be put aside;
Paulo Rebelo

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RE_ENACTMENT.htm

If the PJ believed the McCanns and their friends were all lying why would they give any credence to a reconstruction based on their version of events anyway?
The PJ didn't believe they were all lying but found it better to have the discrepancies cleared, at least partly. Do you find this abusive ?

Why would I find it abusive?

Who did the PJ believe were lying and who did they believe weren't lying, can you tell me?
No idea, Martha ! I don't have friends there who could tell me !

debunker

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #154 on: May 08, 2013, 06:36:23 PM »
Anne, do you know if the PP shelved the case and removed arguido status because they shelved the case as no crime could be identified in the case, and arguido status of the three had to be removed,  or was the arguido status removed because there was no evidence against the arguidos. IE can a case be shelved but still keep people as arguidos?
They had to either charge or not, because the Robert M's arguido status had exhausted all possible extensions. As he had no evidence, or not enough to charge, the PGR couldn't but shelf the case. This is very clear in his dispatch where he indicates how the case can be open before the prescription.
When a case is shelved the arguido status are also "shelved" !

What word did he use for the arguido status- was it 'shelved' or something else?

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #155 on: May 08, 2013, 06:39:18 PM »
Yes, as I said before the PT AG's opinion of the worth of the Reconstruction is that it might have settled the matter of the McCanns innocence once and for all (though I don't see how personally), not that it could have helped establish their guilt.

*** Fair enough. I dont see how any reconstruction could have proved guilt though. But thats another discussion. Leave it there.

I agree - it could neither prove guilt nor innocence and so I fail to see why it couldn't have been carried out by actors.
Martha, the objective of reconstruction (it's called "reconstitution" in Portuguese) isn't to stimulate people's memories but to try and fill the gap between stories and reality. According to the Portuguese CPP (same in France), reconstructions aren't made by actors but as much as possible by the protagonists of a crime.

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #156 on: May 08, 2013, 06:44:07 PM »
... the objective of reconstruction (it's called "reconstitution" in Portuguese) isn't to stimulate people's memories but to try and fill the gap between stories and reality.

I think we all understand that's the purpose, Anne.

But I think the premise (that it is possible to do that) is flawed, precisely because, however honest the endeavour and the intent, you can never faithfully reproduce second time around what actually happened, live and in real time on first instance.

It is just a flawed concept ...

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #157 on: May 08, 2013, 06:48:25 PM »

What word did he use for the arguido status- was it 'shelved' or something else?
Archiving of the files concerning the arguidos
Extinction of the coercion measures

debunker

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #158 on: May 08, 2013, 06:50:00 PM »

What word did he use for the arguido status- was it 'shelved' or something else?
Archiving of the files concerning the arguidos
Extinction of the coercion measures

So arguido status was not archived but made extinct- that sounds a bit more permanent than shelved!

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #159 on: May 08, 2013, 06:51:14 PM »
... the objective of reconstruction (it's called "reconstitution" in Portuguese) isn't to stimulate people's memories but to try and fill the gap between stories and reality.

I think we all understand that's the purpose, Anne.

But I think the premise (that it is possible to do that) is flawed, precisely because, however honest the endeavour and the intent, you can never faithfully reproduce second time around what actually happened, live and in real time on first instance.

It is just a flawed concept ...
That's what you think ! I have no opinion, these reconstructions are not public.

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #160 on: May 08, 2013, 06:55:41 PM »

What word did he use for the arguido status- was it 'shelved' or something else?
Archiving of the files concerning the arguidos
Extinction of the coercion measures

So arguido status was not archived but made extinct- that sounds a bit more permanent than shelved!
I did'nt write that but "extinction of the coercion measures" : declaram-se extinctas as medidas de coacção impostas aos arguidos.
The files concerning the arguidos are shelved, archived.

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #161 on: May 08, 2013, 07:00:04 PM »
Yes, as I said before the PT AG's opinion of the worth of the Reconstruction is that it might have settled the matter of the McCanns innocence once and for all (though I don't see how personally), not that it could have helped establish their guilt.

*** Fair enough. I dont see how any reconstruction could have proved guilt though. But thats another discussion. Leave it there.

I agree - it could neither prove guilt nor innocence and so I fail to see why it couldn't have been carried out by actors.
Martha, the objective of reconstruction (it's called "reconstitution" in Portuguese) isn't to stimulate people's memories but to try and fill the gap between stories and reality. According to the Portuguese CPP (same in France), reconstructions aren't made by actors but as much as possible by the protagonists of a crime.

In this country I don't think we make the victims of terrible and traumatic crimes re-live their experiences in a reconstruction, nor for that matter do we expect suspects to take part in reconstuctions in  the hope that they will incriminate themselves as far as I'm aware, though I may be wrong...
I don't think that reconstructions are made very often. Sometimes people denounce themselves and tell implausible stories. In this case a reconstruction might be useful.

debunker

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #162 on: May 08, 2013, 07:06:16 PM »

What word did he use for the arguido status- was it 'shelved' or something else?
Archiving of the files concerning the arguidos
Extinction of the coercion measures

So arguido status was not archived but made extinct- that sounds a bit more permanent than shelved!
I did'nt write that but "extinction of the coercion measures" : declaram-se extinctas as medidas de coacção impostas aos arguidos.
The files concerning the arguidos are shelved, archived.

I repeat:

What word did he use for the arguido status- was it 'shelved' or something else?

debunker

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #163 on: May 08, 2013, 07:54:32 PM »
Would you expect a rape victim to do a reconstruction of the events leading up to their assault?  I wouldn't, and frankly I don't think this is any different.  It was a deeply traumatic and devastating event and I can fully understand the McCanns not exactly jumping for joy at the prospect of re-enacting that night's events, so it's to their credit that they actually agreed to take part in my view.

They had no choice as they were arguidos, only the tapas 7 had a choice.

I dont think your likening this reconstruction to victims of a crime is helpful or relevant here as at the time they were still suspects, not the  same is it?

Arguido status means little in English law. It would have taken a year to enforce  EAW on the McCanns to do a reconstruction.

debunker

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #164 on: May 08, 2013, 08:05:46 PM »
They could be forced back to Portugal, but not forced to do a reconstruction which would transgress their right to silence.