Author Topic: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?  (Read 62551 times)

0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Benice

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #165 on: May 08, 2013, 08:50:57 PM »
Yes, as I said before the PT AG's opinion of the worth of the Reconstruction is that it might have settled the matter of the McCanns innocence once and for all (though I don't see how personally), not that it could have helped establish their guilt.

*** Fair enough. I dont see how any reconstruction could have proved guilt though. But thats another discussion. Leave it there.

I agree - it could neither prove guilt nor innocence and so I fail to see why it couldn't have been carried out by actors.
Martha, the objective of reconstruction (it's called "reconstitution" in Portuguese) isn't to stimulate people's memories but to try and fill the gap between stories and reality. According to the Portuguese CPP (same in France), reconstructions aren't made by actors but as much as possible by the protagonists of a crime.

In this country I don't think we make the victims of terrible and traumatic crimes re-live their experiences in a reconstruction, nor for that matter do we expect suspects to take part in reconstuctions in  the hope that they will incriminate themselves as far as I'm aware, though I may be wrong...

Actors are always used for reconstructions on Crimewatch.


The notion that innocence prevails over guilt – when there is no evidence to the contrary – is what separates civilization from barbarism.    Unfortunately, there are remains of barbarism among us.    Until very recently, it headed the PJ in Portimão. I hope he was the last one.
                                               Henrique Monteiro, chief editor, Expresso, Portugal

Offline Chinagirl

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #166 on: May 08, 2013, 09:56:24 PM »
This is a very confusing thread to come to as a new reader, or one who has been absent from the board for a while.  Part of it is discussing the value or otherwise of a reconstruction, and also the merits/meaning of words in the final report.

 8)><(
A

Offline John

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #167 on: May 08, 2013, 11:18:38 PM »
A reconstruction would be nothing more than a media circus.   In fact there are far too many unknowns for such a reconstruction to be enacted and what would it achieve in any event that hasn't already been done by former Detective Amaral or Channel 4?

If the PJ wanted a reconstruction they could do one any time, they have enough scripts for several versions.   
« Last Edit: May 08, 2013, 11:23:33 PM by John »
A malicious prosecution for a crime which never existed. An exposé of egregious malfeasance by public officials.
Indeed, the truth never changes with the passage of time.

icabodcrane

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #168 on: May 08, 2013, 11:47:19 PM »
A reconstruction would be nothing more than a media circus.   In fact there are far too many unknowns for such a reconstruction to be enacted and what would it achieve in any event that hasn't already been done by former Detective Amaral or Channel 4?

If the PJ wanted a reconstruction they could do one any time, they have enough scripts for several versions.   

I still think that if there is even the smallest chance that a reconstruction could help the investigation in some way, then it should happen

... and there is certainly no rational reason to object to it happening, is there  ?

Offline Benice

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #169 on: May 08, 2013, 11:48:28 PM »
A reconstruction would be nothing more than a media circus.   In fact there are far too many unknowns for such a reconstruction to be enacted and what would it achieve in any event that hasn't already been done by former Detective Amaral or Channel 4?

If the PJ wanted a reconstruction they could do one any time, they have enough scripts for several versions.   

Agreed.  And the only way a reconstruction would have been of any use to anyone was if the 10 people involved could each guarantee reproducing their exact movements that night with total and precise accuracy regarding the times - and that is simply not possible for ONE human being -  let alone 10 of them to do.

 

The notion that innocence prevails over guilt – when there is no evidence to the contrary – is what separates civilization from barbarism.    Unfortunately, there are remains of barbarism among us.    Until very recently, it headed the PJ in Portimão. I hope he was the last one.
                                               Henrique Monteiro, chief editor, Expresso, Portugal

Offline puglove

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #170 on: May 09, 2013, 12:00:14 AM »
A reconstruction would be nothing more than a media circus.   In fact there are far too many unknowns for such a reconstruction to be enacted and what would it achieve in any event that hasn't already been done by former Detective Amaral or Channel 4?

If the PJ wanted a reconstruction they could do one any time, they have enough scripts for several versions.   

I still think that if there is even the smallest chance that a reconstruction could help the investigation in some way, then it should happen

... and there is certainly no rational reason to object to it happening, is there  ?

Probably off-topic, and laying myself wide open to some sort of shouty attack, but to me checking on small children in bed means LOOKING AT THEM, making sure they haven't been sick, or the quilt isn't on their face, putting a hand on them to check if they're still breathing....not just cocking an ear whilst on my way to the loo.

Basically, not leaving them in a room, on their own, at all.
Jeremy Bamber kicked Mike Tesko in the fanny.

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #171 on: May 09, 2013, 12:01:07 AM »
they believed the police were out to get them and that the reconstruction was designed to help the police establish guilt, not to clear them or uncover new leads. 
I wish I could believe that, Martha. But belief is belief, it has virtues and defaults. I wish the MC could find peace, I really do. No one can blame them more than they do.

debunker

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #172 on: May 09, 2013, 12:04:54 AM »
A reconstruction would be nothing more than a media circus.   In fact there are far too many unknowns for such a reconstruction to be enacted and what would it achieve in any event that hasn't already been done by former Detective Amaral or Channel 4?

If the PJ wanted a reconstruction they could do one any time, they have enough scripts for several versions.   

I still think that if there is even the smallest chance that a reconstruction could help the investigation in some way, then it should happen

... and there is certainly no rational reason to object to it happening, is there  ?

Probably off-topic, and laying myself wide open to some sort of shouty attack, but to me checking on small children in bed means LOOKING AT THEM, making sure they haven't been sick, or the quilt isn't on their face, putting a hand on them to check if they're still breathing....not just cocking an ear whilst on my way to the loo.

Basically, not leaving them in a room, on their own, at all.

Depends on why you are checking them.

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #173 on: May 09, 2013, 12:05:37 AM »
A reconstruction would be nothing more than a media circus.   In fact there are far too many unknowns for such a reconstruction to be enacted and what would it achieve in any event that hasn't already been done by former Detective Amaral or Channel 4?

If the PJ wanted a reconstruction they could do one any time, they have enough scripts for several versions.   

Agreed.  And the only way a reconstruction would have been of any use to anyone was if the 10 people involved could each guarantee reproducing their exact movements that night with total and precise accuracy regarding the times - and that is simply not possible for ONE human being -  let alone 10 of them to do.

 
John and Benice, you're dreaming ! But it's all right and good once in a while !

Offline puglove

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #174 on: May 09, 2013, 12:16:28 AM »
A reconstruction would be nothing more than a media circus.   In fact there are far too many unknowns for such a reconstruction to be enacted and what would it achieve in any event that hasn't already been done by former Detective Amaral or Channel 4?

If the PJ wanted a reconstruction they could do one any time, they have enough scripts for several versions.   

I still think that if there is even the smallest chance that a reconstruction could help the investigation in some way, then it should happen

... and there is certainly no rational reason to object to it happening, is there  ?

Probably off-topic, and laying myself wide open to some sort of shouty attack, but to me checking on small children in bed means LOOKING AT THEM, making sure they haven't been sick, or the quilt isn't on their face, putting a hand on them to check if they're still breathing....not just cocking an ear whilst on my way to the loo.

Basically, not leaving them in a room, on their own, at all.

Depends on why you are checking them.

Hmm. I suppose it depends on the parent, and how neurotic they are. I've tried not to be a helicopter parent, all my children rode, and two of them evented which, along with ski-ing and rugby, is the sport that doctors warn against. But, until they were teenagers, I would still check on them and put my hand on them whilst they slept. They hated it, but I worried. And now I do it with my grandchildren. I want them to be happy and have the freedom that I had when I was little, but it can't happen. Look at April Jones.
Jeremy Bamber kicked Mike Tesko in the fanny.

debunker

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #175 on: May 09, 2013, 12:22:39 AM »
A reconstruction would be nothing more than a media circus.   In fact there are far too many unknowns for such a reconstruction to be enacted and what would it achieve in any event that hasn't already been done by former Detective Amaral or Channel 4?

If the PJ wanted a reconstruction they could do one any time, they have enough scripts for several versions.   

I still think that if there is even the smallest chance that a reconstruction could help the investigation in some way, then it should happen

... and there is certainly no rational reason to object to it happening, is there  ?

Probably off-topic, and laying myself wide open to some sort of shouty attack, but to me checking on small children in bed means LOOKING AT THEM, making sure they haven't been sick, or the quilt isn't on their face, putting a hand on them to check if they're still breathing....not just cocking an ear whilst on my way to the loo.

Basically, not leaving them in a room, on their own, at all.

Depends on why you are checking them.

Hmm. I suppose it depends on the parent, and how neurotic they are. I've tried not to be a helicopter parent, all my children rode, and two of them evented which, along with ski-ing and rugby, is the sport that doctors warn against. But, until they were teenagers, I would still check on them and put my hand on them whilst they slept. They hated it, but I worried. And now I do it with my grandchildren. I want them to be happy and have the freedom that I had when I was little, but it can't happen. Look at April Jones.

Sounds like helicopter parenting to me. I stopped worrying about the children being dead in bed when it became statistically unlikely- once they were past four.

There is no indication at all that child abduction or child sexual abuse has increased since the middle of last century. Most experts suspect the real level has declined somewaht with it being easier to report and more likely to be believed.

The main danger to children now compared to them is fast traffic nearby. When I was young, few people could afford a car.

Offline puglove

Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #176 on: May 09, 2013, 12:29:08 AM »
A reconstruction would be nothing more than a media circus.   In fact there are far too many unknowns for such a reconstruction to be enacted and what would it achieve in any event that hasn't already been done by former Detective Amaral or Channel 4?

If the PJ wanted a reconstruction they could do one any time, they have enough scripts for several versions.   

I still think that if there is even the smallest chance that a reconstruction could help the investigation in some way, then it should happen

... and there is certainly no rational reason to object to it happening, is there  ?

Probably off-topic, and laying myself wide open to some sort of shouty attack, but to me checking on small children in bed means LOOKING AT THEM, making sure they haven't been sick, or the quilt isn't on their face, putting a hand on them to check if they're still breathing....not just cocking an ear whilst on my way to the loo.

Basically, not leaving them in a room, on their own, at all.

Depends on why you are checking them.

Hmm. I suppose it depends on the parent, and how neurotic they are. I've tried not to be a helicopter parent, all my children rode, and two of them evented which, along with ski-ing and rugby, is the sport that doctors warn against. But, until they were teenagers, I would still check on them and put my hand on them whilst they slept. They hated it, but I worried. And now I do it with my grandchildren. I want them to be happy and have the freedom that I had when I was little, but it can't happen. Look at April Jones.

Sounds like helicopter parenting to me. I stopped worrying about the children being dead in bed when it became statistically unlikely- once they were past four.

There is no indication at all that child abduction or child sexual abuse has increased since the middle of last century. Most experts suspect the real level has declined somewaht with it being easier to report and more likely to be believed.

The main danger to children now compared to them is fast traffic nearby. When I was young, few people could afford a car.

You're probably right. But...cliché alert.... you can't turn the clocks back. I'd rather have a cross, resentful sprog who wants to go tadpoling down the river just as it's getting dark, and I've said "no", than wondering where they are and calling the police when it's too late. I like my chicks to be in the nest.
Jeremy Bamber kicked Mike Tesko in the fanny.

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #177 on: May 09, 2013, 12:30:42 AM »
A reconstruction would be nothing more than a media circus.   In fact there are far too many unknowns for such a reconstruction to be enacted and what would it achieve in any event that hasn't already been done by former Detective Amaral or Channel 4?

If the PJ wanted a reconstruction they could do one any time, they have enough scripts for several versions.   

I still think that if there is even the smallest chance that a reconstruction could help the investigation in some way, then it should happen

... and there is certainly no rational reason to object to it happening, is there  ?

Probably off-topic, and laying myself wide open to some sort of shouty attack, but to me checking on small children in bed means LOOKING AT THEM, making sure they haven't been sick, or the quilt isn't on their face, putting a hand on them to check if they're still breathing....not just cocking an ear whilst on my way to the loo.

Basically, not leaving them in a room, on their own, at all.

Depends on why you are checking them.

Hmm. I suppose it depends on the parent, and how neurotic they are. I've tried not to be a helicopter parent, all my children rode, and two of them evented which, along with ski-ing and rugby, is the sport that doctors warn against. But, until they were teenagers, I would still check on them and put my hand on them whilst they slept. They hated it, but I worried. And now I do it with my grandchildren. I want them to be happy and have the freedom that I had when I was little, but it can't happen. Look at April Jones.

Sounds like helicopter parenting to me. I stopped worrying about the children being dead in bed when it became statistically unlikely- once they were past four.

There is no indication at all that child abduction or child sexual abuse has increased since the middle of last century. Most experts suspect the real level has declined somewaht with it being easier to report and more likely to be believed.

The main danger to children now compared to them is fast traffic nearby. When I was young, few people could afford a car.
My father-to-be bought a car just before WW2, with earned money from the State.

debunker

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #178 on: May 09, 2013, 12:35:37 AM »
A reconstruction would be nothing more than a media circus.   In fact there are far too many unknowns for such a reconstruction to be enacted and what would it achieve in any event that hasn't already been done by former Detective Amaral or Channel 4?

If the PJ wanted a reconstruction they could do one any time, they have enough scripts for several versions.   

I still think that if there is even the smallest chance that a reconstruction could help the investigation in some way, then it should happen

... and there is certainly no rational reason to object to it happening, is there  ?

Probably off-topic, and laying myself wide open to some sort of shouty attack, but to me checking on small children in bed means LOOKING AT THEM, making sure they haven't been sick, or the quilt isn't on their face, putting a hand on them to check if they're still breathing....not just cocking an ear whilst on my way to the loo.

Basically, not leaving them in a room, on their own, at all.

Depends on why you are checking them.

Hmm. I suppose it depends on the parent, and how neurotic they are. I've tried not to be a helicopter parent, all my children rode, and two of them evented which, along with ski-ing and rugby, is the sport that doctors warn against. But, until they were teenagers, I would still check on them and put my hand on them whilst they slept. They hated it, but I worried. And now I do it with my grandchildren. I want them to be happy and have the freedom that I had when I was little, but it can't happen. Look at April Jones.

Sounds like helicopter parenting to me. I stopped worrying about the children being dead in bed when it became statistically unlikely- once they were past four.

There is no indication at all that child abduction or child sexual abuse has increased since the middle of last century. Most experts suspect the real level has declined somewaht with it being easier to report and more likely to be believed.

The main danger to children now compared to them is fast traffic nearby. When I was young, few people could afford a car.
My father-to-be bought a car just before WW2, with earned money from the State.

Yawn. Very few people compared with now had cars in say 1950. You could play in the street with no cares as they were mostly empty. Don't make me dig out statistics to prove it. Remember that anecdote is not the singular of data. Take your stories, meaningless as they are, away with you.

icabodcrane

  • Guest
Re: What would a reconstruction demonstrate or clarify ?
« Reply #179 on: May 09, 2013, 12:52:59 AM »
A reconstruction would be nothing more than a media circus.   In fact there are far too many unknowns for such a reconstruction to be enacted and what would it achieve in any event that hasn't already been done by former Detective Amaral or Channel 4?

If the PJ wanted a reconstruction they could do one any time, they have enough scripts for several versions.   

I still think that if there is even the smallest chance that a reconstruction could help the investigation in some way, then it should happen

... and there is certainly no rational reason to object to it happening, is there  ?

Probably off-topic, and laying myself wide open to some sort of shouty attack, but to me checking on small children in bed means LOOKING AT THEM, making sure they haven't been sick, or the quilt isn't on their face, putting a hand on them to check if they're still breathing....not just cocking an ear whilst on my way to the loo.

Basically, not leaving them in a room, on their own, at all.

Depends on why you are checking them.

Hmm. I suppose it depends on the parent, and how neurotic they are. I've tried not to be a helicopter parent, all my children rode, and two of them evented which, along with ski-ing and rugby, is the sport that doctors warn against. But, until they were teenagers, I would still check on them and put my hand on them whilst they slept. They hated it, but I worried. And now I do it with my grandchildren. I want them to be happy and have the freedom that I had when I was little, but it can't happen. Look at April Jones.

Sounds like helicopter parenting to me. I stopped worrying about the children being dead in bed when it became statistically unlikely- once they were past four.

There is no indication at all that child abduction or child sexual abuse has increased since the middle of last century. Most experts suspect the real level has declined somewaht with it being easier to report and more likely to be believed.

The main danger to children now compared to them is fast traffic nearby. When I was young, few people could afford a car.

You're probably right. But...cliché alert.... you can't turn the clocks back. I'd rather have a cross, resentful sprog who wants to go tadpoling down the river just as it's getting dark, and I've said "no", than wondering where they are and calling the police when it's too late. I like my chicks to be in the nest.

I love the way you express yourself shona  ...  no agenda honesty is so refreshing