Author Topic: The McCanns were lucky that all three children weren't taken.  (Read 8932 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

debunker

  • Guest
Re: The McCanns were lucky that all three children weren't taken.
« Reply #15 on: May 09, 2013, 04:36:31 PM »
This might be a better example of how statistics provide knowledge Heri

You have to make journey and there are two cars in which you can  make it

One of the cars has been alerted by a specialist dog indicating that an explosive is in the boot

Statistics tell you that there is an 80% chance that he is correct

The second car was not alerted by the same dog

Statistics tell you there is a 20% chance that he is wrong

You are aware that there may, therefore,  be explosives in both cars,  or in neither

The statistics give you an element of knowledge with which to make your choice

Correct, but as in the McCann case it does not give you any information about the actuality! only the probability.

icabodcrane

  • Guest
Re: The McCanns were lucky that all three children weren't taken.
« Reply #16 on: May 09, 2013, 04:39:28 PM »
This might be a better example of how statistics provide knowledge Heri

You have to make journey and there are two cars in which you can  make it

One of the cars has been alerted by a specialist dog indicating that an explosive is in the boot

Statistics tell you that there is an 80% chance that he is correct

The second car was not alerted by the same dog

Statistics tell you there is a 20% chance that he is wrong

You are aware that there may, therefore,  be explosives in both cars,  or in neither

The statistics give you an element of knowledge with which to make your choice

Correct, but as in the McCann case it does not give you any information about the actuality! only the probability.

I agree,  statistics suggest that the dogs were  probably   correct

debunker

  • Guest
Re: The McCanns were lucky that all three children weren't taken.
« Reply #17 on: May 09, 2013, 04:52:47 PM »
This might be a better example of how statistics provide knowledge Heri

You have to make journey and there are two cars in which you can  make it

One of the cars has been alerted by a specialist dog indicating that an explosive is in the boot

Statistics tell you that there is an 80% chance that he is correct

The second car was not alerted by the same dog

Statistics tell you there is a 20% chance that he is wrong

You are aware that there may, therefore,  be explosives in both cars,  or in neither

The statistics give you an element of knowledge with which to make your choice

Correct, but as in the McCann case it does not give you any information about the actuality! only the probability.

I agree,  statistics suggest that the dogs were  probably   correct

To a degree well short of any sort of probative evidence. Because it is quite possible that every alet was false, we know nothing more definite about the actual situation than we did before the dogs were asked to sniff!

Offline Heriberto Janosch

Re: The McCanns were lucky that all three children weren't taken.
« Reply #18 on: May 09, 2013, 05:09:32 PM »

Obviously why statistics is never used in the real world. I think you are very mistaken in considering statistcs this way. But do feel free to go on believing something that is not true- unless you can cite the academic source of what you are saying.

I agree that statistics cannot speak to the individual case, but it can inform choice in an individual case.

"I agree that statistics cannot speak to the individual case, but it can inform choice in an individual case"

This statement is a good example of "criminal profiler's" wishful thinking ... If statistics cannot speak to the individual case, they can not inform choice ... This type of statistics inform nothing about a new single case by themselves.

You can base your choice in statistics, but that is not scientific.

Sources:

Wikström, P-O, and Sampson, R.J., (editors) The Explanation of Crime. Context, Mechanisms and Development Cambridge University Press.  Chapter 1: A systematic perspective on crime by Mario Bunge.

Any work of Mario Bunge on statistics, probabilities, Bayesian misuse, etc.

Heri.
« Last Edit: May 09, 2013, 09:20:07 PM by Admin »

debunker

  • Guest
Re: The McCanns were lucky that all three children weren't taken.
« Reply #19 on: May 09, 2013, 05:15:31 PM »
"I agree that statistics cannot speak to the individual case, but it can inform choice in an individual case"

This statement is a good example of "criminal profiler's" wishful thinking ... If statistics cannot speak to the individual case, they can not inform choice ... This type of statistics inform nothing about a new single case by themselves.

You can base your choice in statistics, but that is not scientific.

Sources:

Wikström, P-O, and Sampson, R.J., (editors) The Explanation of Crime. Context, Mechanisms and Development Cambridge University Press.  Chapter 1: A systematic perspective on crime by Mario Bunge.

Any work of Mario Bunge on statistics, probabilities, Bayesian misuse, etc.

Heri.




 

Edited by

PER-OLOF H. WIKSTRÖM

University of Cambridge

 

ROBERT J. SAMPSON

Harvard University

That is the blunderbus approach to cites. Please give the specific passages where that enormous tome supports your rather odd interpretation.
« Last Edit: May 09, 2013, 09:19:13 PM by Admin »

Offline Heriberto Janosch

Re: The McCanns were lucky that all three children weren't taken.
« Reply #20 on: May 09, 2013, 05:16:12 PM »
This might be a better example of how statistics provide knowledge Heri

You have to make journey and there are two cars in which you can  make it

One of the cars has been alerted by a specialist dog indicating that an explosive is in the boot

Statistics tell you that there is an 80% chance that he is correct

The second car was not alerted by the same dog

Statistics tell you there is a 20% chance that he is wrong

You are aware that there may, therefore,  be explosives in both cars,  or in neither

The statistics give you an element of knowledge with which to make your choice

Another wrong thought experiment: in this second experiment you are applying statistics based on a lot of past performances of one single dog, to the next action of the same dog.

Heri.   


Offline Heriberto Janosch

Re: The McCanns were lucky that all three children weren't taken.
« Reply #21 on: May 09, 2013, 05:19:18 PM »


That is the blunderbus approach to cites. Please give the specific passages where that enormous tome supports your rather odd interpretation.


The book may have 300 pages, and I cited chapter 1, I do not have the book here. But when at home I will give the info. Some books are in Spanish :(

Heri.
« Last Edit: May 09, 2013, 09:19:37 PM by Admin »

Offline Heriberto Janosch

Re: The McCanns were lucky that all three children weren't taken.
« Reply #22 on: May 09, 2013, 05:22:17 PM »
This might be a better example of how statistics provide knowledge Heri

You have to make journey and there are two cars in which you can  make it

One of the cars has been alerted by a specialist dog indicating that an explosive is in the boot

Statistics tell you that there is an 80% chance that he is correct

The second car was not alerted by the same dog

Statistics tell you there is a 20% chance that he is wrong

You are aware that there may, therefore,  be explosives in both cars,  or in neither

The statistics give you an element of knowledge with which to make your choice

Correct, but as in the McCann case it does not give you any information about the actuality! only the probability.

I agree,  statistics suggest that the dogs were  probably   correct

You can not talk about probabilities!

You can not infer from a sample of a lot of past cases even one characteristic of the next single case. You can guess ... but that is not scientific.

Heri.

Offline Iggy68

Re: The McCanns were lucky that all three children weren't taken.
« Reply #23 on: May 09, 2013, 05:34:36 PM »
I would say they were damned unlucky to lose one.

There is abundant evidence in the files that they ran very regular checks and while theft (of property) is common enough, child abduction is incredibly rare. 

I would say, statistically, far the most probable (deleterious) outcome was all three children safe but possessions from the apartment taken.

Statistics can not be used to explain a SINGLE case. That is not scientific. You can not apply "probailities" here.

I believe the abductor may be a burglar but versatile offender, who took Madeleine because she went to the window, and did not see the twins.

Heri.

 
 
i think a young child would be quite a hard thing to 'fence' even for the most enterpriseing and opportunistic thief

Offline Heriberto Janosch

Re: The McCanns were lucky that all three children weren't taken.
« Reply #24 on: May 09, 2013, 05:41:13 PM »
I would say they were damned unlucky to lose one.

There is abundant evidence in the files that they ran very regular checks and while theft (of property) is common enough, child abduction is incredibly rare. 

I would say, statistically, far the most probable (deleterious) outcome was all three children safe but possessions from the apartment taken.

Statistics can not be used to explain a SINGLE case. That is not scientific. You can not apply "probailities" here.

I believe the abductor may be a burglar but versatile offender, who took Madeleine because she went to the window, and did not see the twins.

Heri.

 
 
i think a young child would be quite a hard thing to 'fence' even for the most enterpriseing and opportunistic thief

Yours is a valid opinion, Iggy68.

Heri.

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: The McCanns were lucky that all three children weren't taken.
« Reply #25 on: May 09, 2013, 06:16:03 PM »
If it could be established that there are far more people in the world likely to steal property than to steal a child (I think it could!) why would it be wrong to assert that an intruder was statistically more likely to steal property than to steal a child?

Offline Eleanor

Re: The McCanns were lucky that all three children weren't taken.
« Reply #26 on: May 09, 2013, 06:18:03 PM »
If it could be established that there are far more people in the world likely to steal property than to steal a child (I think it could!) why would it be wrong to assert that an intruder was statistically more likely to steal property than to steal a child?

Not really, because this one didn't.

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: The McCanns were lucky that all three children weren't taken.
« Reply #27 on: May 09, 2013, 06:22:25 PM »
If it could be established that there are far more people in the world likely to steal property than to steal a child (I think it could!) why would it be wrong to assert that an intruder was statistically more likely to steal property than to steal a child?

Not really, because this one didn't.

I'm not disputing the fact (of abduction!)

Put it like this.  If you were to win multi-millions on the lottery, would you be of the view that you had defied statistical odds to be so lucky?

Surely you would?

debunker

  • Guest
Re: The McCanns were lucky that all three children weren't taken.
« Reply #28 on: May 09, 2013, 06:24:02 PM »
If it could be established that there are far more people in the world likely to steal property than to steal a child (I think it could!) why would it be wrong to assert that an intruder was statistically more likely to steal property than to steal a child?

Not really, because this one didn't.

I'm not disputing the fact (of abduction!)

Put it like this.  If you were to win multi-millions on the lottery, would you be of the view that you had defied statistical odds to be so lucky?

Surely you would?

No. No one had defied statistical odds. Someone somewhere wins almost every week.

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: The McCanns were lucky that all three children weren't taken.
« Reply #29 on: May 09, 2013, 06:27:46 PM »
If it could be established that there are far more people in the world likely to steal property than to steal a child (I think it could!) why would it be wrong to assert that an intruder was statistically more likely to steal property than to steal a child?

Not really, because this one didn't.

I'm not disputing the fact (of abduction!)

Put it like this.  If you were to win multi-millions on the lottery, would you be of the view that you had defied statistical odds to be so lucky?

Surely you would?

No. No one had defied statistical odds. Someone somewhere wins almost every week.

Yes.  There's a statistic that says someone will win.

And there's another statistic that says that someone is highly unlikely to be you.

The title of this thread:

 Topic: The McCanns were lucky that all three children weren't taken.

I would argue they were extremely unlucky one was taken.