Author Topic: The McCanns were lucky that all three children weren't taken.  (Read 8909 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Eleanor

Re: The McCanns were lucky that all three children weren't taken.
« Reply #30 on: May 09, 2013, 06:31:06 PM »
If it could be established that there are far more people in the world likely to steal property than to steal a child (I think it could!) why would it be wrong to assert that an intruder was statistically more likely to steal property than to steal a child?

Not really, because this one didn't.

I'm not disputing the fact (of abduction!)

Put it like this.  If you were to win multi-millions on the lottery, would you be of the view that you had defied statistical odds to be so lucky?

Surely you would?

But you don't know what the next one will do.  Sorry, I shall only sound like a gibbering idiot if I try to explain.  It is just in my head.

Offline Heriberto Janosch

Re: The McCanns were lucky that all three children weren't taken.
« Reply #31 on: May 09, 2013, 07:03:03 PM »
A better cite:

“The statistical approach to crime detection and control is methodologically wrong, because statistics is about groups, not individuals. Individual behaviour can only be forecast on the basis of a study of individual characteristics”.

Pages 21-22, Wikström, P-O, and Sampson, R.J., (editors) The Explanation of Crime. Context, Mechanisms and Development Cambridge University Press.

This a book edited by Cambridge and Harvard criminologists. You can not find this in "criminal profilers" books, or "win the lottery" books, of course.

Sorry, but maybe my English is not good enough to express this idea ...

I will submit my last example:

It is well known in criminology that 90% of crimes are commited by men (past cases statistics).

What can you say about the next single case based only in this statistics? Nothing.

The next case can be commited 100% by a man or 100% by a woman (nobody would say "by a person 90% man and 10% woman"). And it is not scientific to assign “probabilities” here. You can only guess, like psychics.

There are two levels of analysis, the great sample, and the single case. You can not merge them.

You can say, "well, the next 10 prisons to build will be 9 for men, and 1 for woman" ... That is right! But you can not say nothing about the next single case. The only thing you can do is guess like psychics or criminal profilers  ?{)(**

So, the better thing you can do is investigate the single case  in itself!

And see how interesting, even in the imagined scenario that past statistics said that 100% of crimes are commited by men, it is not scientific to assign “probabilities” to the next case. It could be the first crime by a woman in the history!

It is well known in statistical thermodynamics: in one (single) level in a gas every particle are moving in a different manner, but in the superior level as a whole (the group of particles) mantains constant the pressure, the temperature and the volume of the gas ... You can not predict anything about a single particle knowing the pressure, the temperature and the volume of the gas ...

Very interesting all of your comments. Have a good night!

Heri.
« Last Edit: May 09, 2013, 07:47:30 PM by Heriberto Janosch »

amaraltheofficeboy

  • Guest
Re: The McCanns were lucky that all three children weren't taken.
« Reply #32 on: May 09, 2013, 07:06:04 PM »
Quote
If you were to win multi-millions on the lottery, would you be of the view that you had defied statistical odds to be so lucky?

every ticket has an equal chance.

registrar

  • Guest
Re: The McCanns were lucky that all three children weren't taken.
« Reply #33 on: May 09, 2013, 07:10:48 PM »
Quote
If you were to win multi-millions on the lottery, would you be of the view that you had defied statistical odds to be so lucky?

every ticket has an equal chance.

and everytime a coconut

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: The McCanns were lucky that all three children weren't taken.
« Reply #34 on: May 09, 2013, 07:14:52 PM »
Heri, I think, maybe we're slightly at cross-purposes here.

I don't dispute that nothing can be inferred about the likely guilt or innocence of someone accused of a crime from statistics.

Nothing can.

That was the error of Roy Meadow.'

But I was taking the title heading of this thread, were the McCanns lucky all three children weren't taken to argue that they were extremely unlucky one was.

I think that event is statistically improbable (although I don't dispute it happened)

Offline Heriberto Janosch

Re: The McCanns were lucky that all three children weren't taken.
« Reply #35 on: May 09, 2013, 07:28:24 PM »
Heri, I think, maybe we're slightly at cross-purposes here.

I don't dispute that nothing can be inferred about the likely guilt or innocence of someone accused of a crime from statistics.

Nothing can.

That was the error of Roy Meadow.'

But I was taking the title heading of this thread, were the McCanns lucky all three children weren't taken to argue that they were extremely unlucky one was.

I think that event is statistically improbable (although I don't dispute it happened)

If you are writing "I think that event is statistically improbable" I failed to let you understand what I was saying when I wrote, for example, this ... http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=1526.msg44442#msg44442

 ?{)(**

amaraltheofficeboy

  • Guest
Re: The McCanns were lucky that all three children weren't taken.
« Reply #36 on: May 09, 2013, 07:31:31 PM »
Quote
She retorted that they were damn lucky that all three weren't taken.  Phew!!!

I suppose if one of your children were knocked over by a car (God forbid) but the other 2 weren't - you would say you were lucky.

Very strange expression.

Offline Angelo222

Re: The McCanns were lucky that all three children weren't taken.
« Reply #37 on: May 09, 2013, 07:35:26 PM »
In reality both apply.  They were unlucky to have had a child abducted but lucky that they didn't lose two more to the same fiend.  You can also say they were unlucky to have chosen Praia da luz in Portugal in the first place.

And yes ATOB, lucky the other two weren't knocked down.

It's known in English as a "figure of speech". 
« Last Edit: May 09, 2013, 07:38:06 PM by Angelo222 »
De troothe has the annoying habit of coming to the surface just when you least expect it!!

Je ne regrette rien!!