Eddie's alert in the garden

[ferryman]

thank you for bringing amaral's lies to the forum...no wonder he has found himself in so much trouble

One thing the above quote does confirm (absolutely true!) is that the shelved enquiry was a murder enquiry.

[ferryman]

Oooops.

I fear we are way off-topic.

Lady-moderator will be along to box our ears in due course ....

[Eleanor]

Oh Dear.  Fraid so.  But even I get carried away sometimes.

However, Back On Topic would be good.

I will have to delete further Off Topic Posts.  So don't waste your time and mine.

[pathfinder73]

thank you for bringing amaral's lies to the forum...no wonder he has found himself in so much trouble

That was written to Amaral. He didn't write it.

"To the coordinator of the criminal investigation."

[ferryman]

That was written to Amaral. He didn't write it.

"To the coordinator of the criminal investigation."

Already noted.

[Brietta]

Here is the whole extract from what Pathfinder quotes.

My justification for quoting the whole is extract is to expose something scandalous and wicked; inclusion (in, supposedly, the 'official' files) of something unofficial and not part of the body of released files.

Note the give-away absence, no official file reference number:

We know that Joao Carlos (who wrote the above) redeemed himself later and proved himself (over the whole investigation) a worthy and commendable PJ officer.

But the above was not his finest moment.

Very definitely a genuine misunderstanding of Eddie's behaviour in the garden.

A mistake was made which has entered into the lexicon and which we have all accepted. 

The video makes it clear that Martin Grime did not claim Eddie had alerted in the garden.  Subsequently when enumerating alleged alerts he did not claim that there had had been an alert in the garden.

On that basis I think it is clear that Eddie did not alert in the garden and that any such claim is mistaken.

[ferryman]

Very definitely a genuine misunderstanding of Eddie's behaviour in the garden.

A mistake was made which has entered into the lexicon and which we have all accepted. 

The video makes it clear that Martin Grime did not claim Eddie had alerted in the garden.  Subsequently when enumerating alleged alerts he did not claim that there had had been an alert in the garden.

On that basis I think it is clear that Eddie did not alert in the garden and that any such claim is mistaken.

Certainly I can't find a reference to the garden in anything Grime has written

[Eleanor]

Didn't we all see Martin Grime saying that he should bring the dogs back again in daylight because he wasn't sure?  Or was it just Eddie?

This never happened.  So, A Dog's Breakfast.

[pathfinder73]

"What we should understand with this dog is that he only barks when he finds something, he won't bark at any other times." MG

Eddie clearly barks in the flower bed.

At 39 seconds for proof.

[ferryman]

That certainly sounded like a bark (to me).

[Alice Purjorick]

Very definitely a genuine misunderstanding of Eddie's behaviour in the garden.

A mistake was made which has entered into the lexicon and which we have all accepted. 

The video makes it clear that Martin Grime did not claim Eddie had alerted in the garden.  Subsequently when enumerating alleged alerts he did not claim that there had had been an alert in the garden.

On that basis I think it is clear that Eddie did not alert in the garden and that any such claim is mistaken.

Not according to the Archiving Report & Summary.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/LEGAL_SUMMARY.htm

[ferryman]

Not according to the Archiving Report & Summary.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/LEGAL_SUMMARY.htm

It's a long document.

Care to give us the relevant cite?

[ferryman]

Not according to the Archiving Report & Summary.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/LEGAL_SUMMARY.htm

So if Eddie, indeed, alerted in the garden, we are back to looking to some defence (for the dog) of why he did so.

Pig-based fertiliser is one (plausible) explanation.

Any others?

[Alice Purjorick]

So if Eddie, indeed, alerted in the garden, we are back to looking to some defence (for the dog) of why he did so.

Pig-based fertiliser is one (plausible) explanation.

Any others?

The proposition was that Eddie did not alert in the garden.
The Archiving Report says he did.
I merely pointed the proposition was incorrect and provided a link to the cite as per forum rules.
Whether you can find it in the archiving report and how you want to dress it up is no concern of mine.

[ferryman]

The proposition was that Eddie did not alert in the garden.
The Archiving Report says he did.
I merely pointed the proposition was incorrect and provided a link to the cite as per forum rules.
Whether you can find it in the archiving report and how you want to dress it up is no concern of mine.

So Martin Grime made no reference to Eddie's alert in the garden.

Why not?