Author Topic: How likely is it that Jane Tanner and the Smiths saw the 'same' man ?  (Read 143638 times)

0 Members and 4 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline pegasus

Re: How likely is it that Jane Tanner and the Smiths saw the 'same' man ?
« Reply #435 on: November 08, 2013, 10:02:57 PM »
Hi pathfinder yes I agree 21:39 (13.75 euros) - that is the very first Kellys till record that can belong to the witnesses.
The previous till record at 20:52 (1.50 euros) is far too early (and too cheap).
« Last Edit: November 08, 2013, 10:09:55 PM by pegasus »

Offline pathfinder73

Re: How likely is it that Jane Tanner and the Smiths saw the 'same' man ?
« Reply #436 on: November 08, 2013, 10:23:41 PM »
Thanks pegasus. Yes I agree there were 9 in total so it would be quite costly for a round of drinks (4 adults). If they bought the drinks at 9.39pm (13.75 euros) then I think it would take at least 15 minutes for them all to finish their drinks. That seems to fit with the 9.55-10pm leaving Kelly's bar estimate time.
« Last Edit: November 08, 2013, 10:37:17 PM by pathfinder73 »
Smithman carrying a child in his arms checked his watch after passing the Smith family and the time was 10:03. Both are still unidentified 10 years later.

Offline pegasus

Re: How likely is it that Jane Tanner and the Smiths saw the 'same' man ?
« Reply #437 on: November 09, 2013, 04:01:09 AM »
I think people remember how long they were at a place, much better than they remember the exact times they arrived and left.

Witness A recalls being at Kellys for about 30 minutes. P and M don't say directly however they imply it was longer.

Going conservativly by A's 30 minutes, assume it takes 5 minutes for the bargirl to pour the drinks (its easy to prove there was no queue). So that would give arrival at Kellys at 2134, drinks served at 2139 (till reciept), and if A's 30 minutes is correct that would give departare from Kellys at 1004. (The durations implied indirectly by M and P would place it later).

« Last Edit: November 09, 2013, 04:10:18 AM by pegasus »

Offline colombosstogey

Re: How likely is it that Jane Tanner and the Smiths saw the 'same' man ?
« Reply #438 on: November 09, 2013, 06:38:57 AM »
"We were home two weeks when my son rang up and asked was he dreaming or did we meet a man carrying a child the night Madeleine was taken. We all remembered that we had the same recollection. I felt we should report it to the police.

"I rang the Portuguese police and they took a statement from me on the phone. Then they asked me to make a statement to gardai, which I did in Drogheda two weeks after the disappearance.

"Two days later, Leicestershire police got on to us and said they wanted to speak to all nine of us. But we felt there was no point dragging grand children and the whole lot out to Portugal so just my eldest son, Peter, and youngest daughter, Aoife, and I flew to Luz to make a statement.

The couple (Martin & Mary) were with their daughter Aoife, their son Peter and his wife Sile, as well as four grandchildren Tadhg, Cole, Aisling and Eimear. 9 in total.

Thanks for that Pathfinder I did read this ages ago but forgot about it....

So if they thought they were dreaming just how much did they see?

Obviously the sighting didnt upset or bother them much that not really.

I like the JT sighting dont think this sighting has anything to do with the case, I certainly never thought it was GM, why on earth would he do that?

No I just think it was a seconds sighting when they were walking in a lit dark street, they saw someone possibly carrying a child thought nothing of it..and walked on.

Personally I dont think any abductor is going to be walking that far from the apartment where the child was taken. It makes no sense. There was a dark area and a car park at the front of the apartment and a car could have easily been parked away towards the Lagos road, and the abductor had no need whatsoever to go into PDL.

Thats my opinion only. It isnt logical. I never thought this sighting was viable way back in 2008, and never thought Tanners was either ever.

No logically for me, some how the front door was used, was it an inside job perhaps, as the key was usual.

I had a thought way back about a women taking her. I dont know why it just keeps popping up. I have had all kinds of things pop up like maintenance men etc, but from the beginning i wondered about a women. Someone she knew. Go in the front door pick her up even she woke she wouldnt be frightened if it was a face she knew, then back out the front door, even perhaps allowing her to walk to a waiting car or back to a house to be taken on.....perhaps this was the scent the GNR dogs found.

Anyway just thoughts but it would work for me if someone had access to that front door.....thats the key to this I think...

I just dont see anyone taking her and walking through PDL it was supposed to be a holiday complex with people walking and milling about, it was one of the quietest i have ever heard of lol...no one about...just a few.....

Poor maddy will we ever know what happened to her.

After all these years NOTHING NEW has come up really just a lot of Who Shot John theorys and sightings....and possible suspects who are dead......


Offline pathfinder73

Re: How likely is it that Jane Tanner and the Smiths saw the 'same' man ?
« Reply #439 on: November 09, 2013, 03:14:03 PM »
Hi, I wouldn't read too much into the dreaming comment. Just a figure of speech and I doubt all 9 were dreaming  8)-)))

Aiofe seemed to know more about the correct time - maybe because she was not drinking alcohol. She said they arrived at Kelly's bar at around 9.30pm and left 30 mins later at 10pm so from that the Smithman sighting was maybe 10.03pm estimate time (possibly a little bit later see Pegasus post above).

They probably didn't consider that a possible abductor was walking with the child through the streets. First thing you'd think if you heard about an abduction, would be, "Did anyone see the getaway vehicle?" It was probably later when they all discussed it they found that some of them noticed the girl was in a deep sleep and in hindsight thought that was strange. Barefeet, no blanket or coat to keep her warm etc.

I definitely have come to the opinion that Madeleine was outside the apartment at 8.30pm. Jane Tanner never saw the abductor because the window was closed at the time of her sighting. The bag witness statement I was hoping to find seems to be missing from the files. The bag IMO was used to store the clothes that were on the wardrobe shelf where Eddie barked.
« Last Edit: November 09, 2013, 03:42:22 PM by pathfinder73 »
Smithman carrying a child in his arms checked his watch after passing the Smith family and the time was 10:03. Both are still unidentified 10 years later.

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: How likely is it that Jane Tanner and the Smiths saw the 'same' man ?
« Reply #440 on: November 09, 2013, 03:44:52 PM »

Aoife seemed to know more about the correct time - maybe because she was not drinking alcohol. She said they arrived at Kelly's bar at around 9.30pm and left 30 mins later at 10pm so from that the Smithman sighting was maybe 10.03pm estimate time (possibly a little bit later see Pegasus post above).
I'd agree with that, since Aoife was aware of the time they left the Golfino and of the time spent at Kelly's

They probably didn't consider that a possible abductor was walking with the child through the streets. First thing you'd think if you heard about an abduction, would be, "Did anyone see the getaway vehicle?"
Of course, they saw a father and a daughter and not Erlkönig !

I definitely have come to the opinion that Madeleine was outside the apartment at 8.30pm.
What do you mean ? In the flowerbed ?

Jane Tanner never saw the abductor because the window was closed at the time of her sighting. The bag witness statement I was hoping to find seems to be missing from the files. The bag IMO was used to store the clothes that were on the wardrobe shelf where Eddie barked.
Which clothes ? And why ?

Offline pathfinder73

Re: How likely is it that Jane Tanner and the Smiths saw the 'same' man ?
« Reply #441 on: November 09, 2013, 03:54:13 PM »
Hypothesis: Bag was placed down in/next to the flower bed at the bottom of outside apartment steps to check that the coast was clear. When coast was clear, bag taken from/next to flower bed and concealed outside before 8.30pm. Smithman goes to back to hidden outside bag in the first searches at 10pm, retrieves what's inside the bag and is seen passing the Smith family. A bag was needed for concealment which was the one that was previously used to store the clothes on wardrobe shelf and where Eddie later barked.


« Last Edit: November 09, 2013, 04:08:18 PM by pathfinder73 »
Smithman carrying a child in his arms checked his watch after passing the Smith family and the time was 10:03. Both are still unidentified 10 years later.

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: How likely is it that Jane Tanner and the Smiths saw the 'same' man ?
« Reply #442 on: November 09, 2013, 04:17:52 PM »
Why would Smithman conceal outside ?

Offline Eleanor

Re: How likely is it that Jane Tanner and the Smiths saw the 'same' man ?
« Reply #443 on: November 09, 2013, 04:26:44 PM »

So are we saying that we don't know at what time The Smiths saw this man carrying a child?  I thought The PJ had sorted that long ago.
But then I thought they had sorted a lot of things.

Offline pegasus

Re: How likely is it that Jane Tanner and the Smiths saw the 'same' man ?
« Reply #444 on: November 09, 2013, 04:44:49 PM »
If the witnesses were served their drinks at 21:39, then SY's estimate of the sighting being at 22:00 allows very little time to relax in Kellys, especially with lots of young kids and toilet trips. Also we do not know whether a following till record (for example at 21:46 and 21:49) might also be relevant.

Offline Eleanor

Re: How likely is it that Jane Tanner and the Smiths saw the 'same' man ?
« Reply #445 on: November 09, 2013, 04:59:23 PM »
If the witnesses were served their drinks at 21:39, then SY's estimate of the sighting being at 22:00 allows very little time to relax in Kellys, especially with lots of young kids and toilet trips. Also we do not know whether a following till record (for example at 21:46 and 21:49) might also be relevant.

So the Smiths could have left earlier or later?  Hmm.  I shall have to have a think about that.

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: How likely is it that Jane Tanner and the Smiths saw the 'same' man ?
« Reply #446 on: November 09, 2013, 05:03:22 PM »
If the witnesses were served their drinks at 21:39, then SY's estimate of the sighting being at 22:00 allows very little time to relax in Kellys, especially with lots of young kids and toilet trips. Also we do not know whether a following till record (for example at 21:46 and 21:49) might also be relevant.
They might only have had coffees (they had none at the Dolphin where they ordered 2 bottles of Matteus Rose and 5 coca-colas).

Offline pegasus

Re: How likely is it that Jane Tanner and the Smiths saw the 'same' man ?
« Reply #447 on: November 09, 2013, 05:32:47 PM »
AnnaGuedes your research is good.
I am currently thinking the sighting was at some time between 22:00 and 22:25.


Offline jassi

Re: How likely is it that Jane Tanner and the Smiths saw the 'same' man ?
« Reply #448 on: November 09, 2013, 05:35:40 PM »
AnnaGuedes your research is good.
I am currently thinking the sighting was at some time between 22:00 and 22:25.

Am I right in thinking that the later it was, the less likely it would be to be an abductor?
I believe everything. And l believe nothing.
I suspect everyone. And l suspect no one.
I gather the facts, examine the clues... and before   you know it, the case is solved!"

Or maybe not -

OG have been pushed out by the Germans who have reserved all the deck chairs for the foreseeable future

Offline pathfinder73

Re: How likely is it that Jane Tanner and the Smiths saw the 'same' man ?
« Reply #449 on: November 09, 2013, 05:36:51 PM »
Why would Smithman conceal outside ?

If you are planning on setting up an abduction then the abductee can't be in the apartment - "she's gone, an abductor must have taken her". Some place else is a possibility but I believe outside due to the first searches going on outside at 10pm and Smithman taking the risk i.e. having to move her through streets (he did use quiet back streets (route was quickly planned prior) but didn't count on a big family group of 9 coming past)  a second time further away from the apartment to a better hiding place.
I think the Smith family would have passed Smithman 10 to10:05pm estimate time.
« Last Edit: November 09, 2013, 06:09:40 PM by pathfinder73 »
Smithman carrying a child in his arms checked his watch after passing the Smith family and the time was 10:03. Both are still unidentified 10 years later.