Why would you automatically believe someone had to be lying? There are major discrepances between loads of witness statements - particularly when it comes to remembering times. It doesn't mean anyone is lying.
The cleaner - who was mentioned earlier, said that on the day of the McCanns arrival 2 cots were delivered to 5A. According to Kate 3 cots were delivered - one of which was later lent to the Paynes. This doesn't mean anyone lied - the cleaner simply related what she remembered - but that doesn't guarantee that her recall was completely accurate. However it seems to me that in your opinion one of them must have been lying?
Why anyone would expect so many different people to all have identical memories of every situation is a mystery to me.
The still bigger mystery would be why anyone would
not regard, apparently, identical memory recall as suspicious (ie, evidence of collusion and cover-up).
Who the hell, on holiday, remembers whether they entered or exited a building through the front door or the back door on a given occasion, particularly if it isn't clear, in context, what
is the 'front' or 'back' door)?