OK - where in the post below is Brietta saying the judge made a fundamental error, as you claim she said?
I claimed no such thing.
I neither posted she stated nor was saying. I posted:
"I don't believe she has but ferryman and Brietta think she has".Ferryman and Brietta have posted between them that the case was reopened because of the emergence of new evidence.
The judge ruled that the reopening of the case due to the emergence of new evidence was not proved.
Not proved = not shown beyond doubt.
Ferryman stated the only reason a case can be reopened is if there is new evidence.
It would then follow that if the case has been reopened then it is self-evident and proved beyond doubt there is new evidence as there is no other mechanism by which the case may be reopened.
If the case has been reopened and the judge says it has not been proved the case was reopened because of the emergence of new evidence then if follows that there is a mechanism by which the case may be reopened other than new evidence.
So if ferryman and Brietta are right the judge is wrong.
If the judge is right Ferryman and Brietta are wrong.
Faites vos jeux.
The whole fol de rol starts on about page 37 of this thread.