Has support for Amaral and the Mccanns reached devotion by their supporters ?

[Lyall]

Try  to remember your thread is about amaral

Every thread is for you guys.

[stephen25000]

Try  to remember your thread is about amaral

Please read the thread title carefully.

[Aiofe]

So pray tell, what caused Madeleine's disappearance.

I presume you have proof of how she disappeared ?

Whatever the answer, leaving them alone was not a prime cause.

If abducted, then the abductor is the prime cause.

If she died earlier in the day and her corpse was disposed of, then that is the prime cause.

If she woke and wandered, she must have been disposed of by someone, and that is the prime cause.

Leaving them alone can only be a secondary cause as being left alone cannot be a direct cause of death.

[Aiofe]

sadie, this case is not about amaral, it is about what the mccanns failed to do.

Try to remember that.

Please read the title of the thread!

[stephen25000]

Whatever the answer, leaving them alone was not a prime cause.

If abducted, then the abductor is the prime cause.

If she died earlier in the day and her corpse was disposed of, then that is the prime cause.

If she woke and wandered, she must have been disposed of by someone, and that is the prime cause.

Leaving them alone can only be a secondary cause as being left alone cannot be a direct cause of death.

'If she died earlier in the day and her corpse was disposed of, then that is the prime cause.'

Do you give credence to that theory ?

P.S. As they were left alone, assuming nothing happened before that evening, then the prime cause of her disappearance is the fact the parents weren't there. What happened afterwards is probably something we will never know.

[Aiofe]

'If she died earlier in the day and her corpse was disposed of, then that is the prime cause.'

Do you give credence to that theory ?

I have insufficient evidence to make any decision together with the maturity and intelligence to keep my mouth shut about things beyond my ken. If only others had those abilities!

[jassi]

'If she died earlier in the day and her corpse was disposed of, then that is the prime cause.'

Do you give credence to that theory ?

P.S. As they were left alone, assuming nothing happened before that evening, then the prime cause of her disappearance is the fact the parents weren't there. What happened afterwards is probably something we will never know.

We might - police are sometime much cleverer than we give them credit for. It is possible that they believe they  know exactly what happened but are, as yet, unable to prove it.
I shall continue to have faith in them until washed away by whitewash.

[stephen25000]

We might - police are sometime much cleverer than we give them credit for. It is possible that they believe they  know exactly what happened but are, as yet, unable to prove it.
I shall continue to have faith in them until washed away by whitewash.

Fair points Jassi.

[Aiofe]

We might - police are sometime much cleverer than we give them credit for. It is possible that they believe they  know exactly what happened but are, as yet, unable to prove it.
I shall continue to have faith in them until washed away by whitewash.

This is what in the world of Criminology known as "The Policeman's Fallacy".

[jassi]

This is what in the world of Criminology known as "The Policeman's Fallacy".

I'm not familiar with that. Would you care to explain ?

[sadie]

Well sadie, can you say the mccanns are decent honourable people for placing their children in danger ?


Ultimately, this is where the case starts and finishes.

You haven't answered the question yet, Stephen

Do you think that Amaral is a decent , honest good policeman?

[Wonderfulspam]

You haven't answered the question yet, Stephen

Do you think that Amaral is a decent , honest good policeman?

He had a 26 year career in the police in which he became a Criminal Investigation Coordinator.

If he wasn't a good policeman, I don't think he would have reached such a high rank or had such a long career.

[stephen25000]

You haven't answered the question yet, Stephen

Do you think that Amaral is a decent , honest good policeman?

What is the title of the thread sadie ?


Your support of the mccanns can easily be catergorized as obsessive.

 >@@(*&)

[Aiofe]

I'm not familiar with that. Would you care to explain ?

The assumption that they have special powers of divination that allows them to know things with insufficient evidence.

[LagosBen]

He had a 26 year career in the police in which he became a Criminal Investigation Coordinator.

If he wasn't a good policeman, I don't think he would have reached such a high rank or had such a long career.

So I have read but - what confuses me is -  If as is stated,  he was so good in the Drug Traffficking section -Why was he moved?   >@@(*&)