Author Topic: The tapas group and the 'reconstitution' that was never to take place.  (Read 361400 times)

0 Members and 7 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Albertini

Re: The tapas group and the 'reconstitution' that was never to take place.
« Reply #390 on: June 11, 2014, 03:26:46 PM »
So why didn't Amaral arrange a Reconstitution.  He was in charge, after all.  And at the beginning was the time to do it.  A year later was far too late.

Because, the need for the reconstitution came about as a result of the discrepancies in statements and Rogatories over that year period.

Here's how Rebelo puts it:

Quote
1 - Why do the PJ want them to take part in the re-enactment?

The PJ wants them to take part in the re-enactment because they were the ones who experienced the situation. Therefore they are in the best conditions to reproduce it.

2 - What is the aim, what are the PJ trying to achieve with the re-enactment?

The PJ is trying to find out, with accuracy, the circumstances of the events occurred, using for that purpose the exact place of events and the same persons who took part in it.

It's hard for the police to find the window of opportunity when the stories keep changing and don't match up.

It's taken the best part of what, 2 to 3 years for SY to find it, and you're criticising the PJ for taking a year??

Really?


Offline Eleanor

Re: The tapas group and the 'reconstitution' that was never to take place.
« Reply #391 on: June 11, 2014, 03:44:05 PM »
Because, the need for the reconstitution came about as a result of the discrepancies in statements and Rogatories over that year period.

Here's how Rebelo puts it:

It's hard for the police to find the window of opportunity when the stories keep changing and don't match up.

It's taken the best part of what, 2 to 3 years for SY to find it, and you're criticising the PJ for taking a year??

Really?

You can call it what you like but it still could have been done in the beginning.

And where in that statement does Rebelo mention discrepancies?

Offline Mr Gray

Re: The tapas group and the 'reconstitution' that was never to take place.
« Reply #392 on: June 11, 2014, 03:50:45 PM »
Because, the need for the reconstitution came about as a result of the discrepancies in statements and Rogatories over that year period.

Here's how Rebelo puts it:

It's hard for the police to find the window of opportunity when the stories keep changing and don't match up.

It's taken the best part of what, 2 to 3 years for SY to find it, and you're criticising the PJ for taking a year??

Really?

 your claim that the PJ are experts shows how little you understand the real facts in this case. Had they really been experts carried out a proper investigation we would not be here now. They have been described as incompetent and their investigation "bungled" for good raeson

Offline Mr Gray

Re: The tapas group and the 'reconstitution' that was never to take place.
« Reply #393 on: June 11, 2014, 04:07:30 PM »
When rebelo took over there were articles in the Portuguese press from which the Mail ran ana rticle which included....

This was then reported in the Daily Mail on the 22nd October 2007, where the article said:


Meanwhile, a police source quoted in a Portuguese newspaper said: “There was important material lying all over the place that hadn’t been considered by investigators.

“A lot of key information was discarded. The whole process is being reviewed. Putting all the papers in order has been a massive task.”

Officers have been working round-the-clock to log on to a computer all information relating to the disappearance of four-year-old Madeleine from the holiday complex in May.



So these are your experts...

Offline Albertini

Re: The tapas group and the 'reconstitution' that was never to take place.
« Reply #394 on: June 11, 2014, 04:13:19 PM »
You can call it what you like but it still could have been done in the beginning.

And where in that statement does Rebelo mention discrepancies?

It's a good job they didn't do it at the start, it would have been a huge waste of time, given the way the statements changed or "evolved" over time.

Which door would Gerry MCann have walked in? What time would the guys have left the tennis after the Paraiso?

So many changes they'd have been running round like extras from a Benny Hill set.

What do you think Rebelo means when he states it would be to determine what happened and when, when he already has numerous statements and Rogatories from the group?

Fortunately a real Judge, looking at the self same evidence used in a real court the word "incongruous and contradictory" to describe the statements. 

Offline Benice

Re: The tapas group and the 'reconstitution' that was never to take place.
« Reply #395 on: June 11, 2014, 04:18:14 PM »
Benice

Just because you don't know how or can't see the merits of why is neither here nor there in the scheme of things.

This is a diligence which is in the Penal Code because clearly the Portuguese feel there is some benefit in these types of practices actually helping an investigation move forward.

They are professional investigators and will have done this kind of thing before.

It's a bit disingenuous of you to be questioning and second guessing why  it was asked for, how it would have worked and what the benefit was given you are not Portuguese nor a detective.

Leave it to the experts, just go along with it, and everything else asked,  to help keep the search for your missing child alive.

As Ferryman has kindly pointed out the friends refusal to take part coupled with Mitchell's statement that the McCann's lawyers would block their return to Portugal PREVENTED the Portuguese from discovering the same window of opportunity in the timelines that SY say they have found 7 years later.

That's the real killer blow which has come out of this thread.

I am still gobsmacked by the significance of it and surprised that it hasn't come up before.

On the contrary I can see the merits of any recon- if the participants know what time they did things.  In this case they don't know - so the chances of their achieving an accurate reproduction of events which took place - covering a period of  several hours - 12 months previous -  are practically zero IMO.   There are too many people and too many possible permutations of times involved for that to happen. 

As 'accuracy' of timing is absolutely vital in order to replicate this particular recon. and that is the one thing the 10 people involved cannot provide  - then it is clearly asking for the impossible IMO.

It's all very easy to keep going on and on about the recon. but not so easy when people are asked to describe how this recon would actually be carried out in practical terms. 

If it was easy - you would be able to answer my questions regarding the problems posed by the lack of accurate times  - the impact of which would be to reduce to virtually nil  - any chance of an accurate recon being achievable -  and in the light of that - what measures the group/PJ could take to deal with that massive problem.

Remember- the group were only to be given one go at this recon.
The notion that innocence prevails over guilt – when there is no evidence to the contrary – is what separates civilization from barbarism.    Unfortunately, there are remains of barbarism among us.    Until very recently, it headed the PJ in Portimão. I hope he was the last one.
                                               Henrique Monteiro, chief editor, Expresso, Portugal

Offline Albertini

Re: The tapas group and the 'reconstitution' that was never to take place.
« Reply #396 on: June 11, 2014, 04:18:49 PM »
When rebelo took over there were articles in the Portuguese press from which the Mail ran ana rticle which included....

This was then reported in the Daily Mail on the 22nd October 2007, where the article said:


Meanwhile, a police source quoted in a Portuguese newspaper said: “There was important material lying all over the place that hadn’t been considered by investigators.

“A lot of key information was discarded. The whole process is being reviewed. Putting all the papers in order has been a massive task.”

Officers have been working round-the-clock to log on to a computer all information relating to the disappearance of four-year-old Madeleine from the holiday complex in May.



So these are your experts...

You do know that unnamed sources are usually the work of the journalist themselves to back up the thrust of their article don't you, or more likely in this case the work of a certain pink hued spokesman who fed a story to support his clients and spun it accordingly?

Now if you could provide a direct attributable link,  to maybe SY saying this, now we'd be talking.

Instead you're drivelling on and relying on "unnamed sources" in newspapers.

Credibility red flag raised!

Offline Eleanor

Re: The tapas group and the 'reconstitution' that was never to take place.
« Reply #397 on: June 11, 2014, 04:19:58 PM »
It's a good job they didn't do it at the start, it would have been a huge waste of time, given the way the statements changed or "evolved" over time.

Which door would Gerry MCann have walked in? What time would the guys have left the tennis after the Paraiso?

So many changes they'd have been running round like extras from a Benny Hill set.

What do you think Rebelo means when he states it would be to determine what happened and when, when he already has numerous statements and Rogatories from the group?

Fortunately a real Judge, looking at the self same evidence used in a real court the word "incongruous and contradictory" to describe the statements.

According to what I have read, Rebelo was so busy cleaning up the mess left by Amaral, and trying to make sense of what Amaral thought was important or not, that he didn't have time for anything else.  Tis no wonder to me that Rebelo was confused.

Offline Carana

Re: The tapas group and the 'reconstitution' that was never to take place.
« Reply #398 on: June 11, 2014, 04:39:52 PM »
Desperation! Look at the date of the article. 6th April. Mitchell quoted directly by the paper not as a "source close to the family" or a "pal" but by name. 

The first emails started being exchanged on the 20th April some two weeks later to arrange the reconstitution and whilst there is no paper trail its probably safe to assume discussions took place before the 20th.

Given that they would have to go back to Portugal to perform the reconstruction Mitchell saying their lawyers would block any move to return to Portugal "now" is by definition a rejection of taking part in the reconstruction, because if your lawyers block you going back to Portugal they are blocking you from taking part in the reconstruction that is being held in that country aren't they?

Deary me.

So you find the Mirror quoting the Sunday People with a quote that may or may not have been relevant to whatever the hack decided to file as copy that night to be a reliable source?

Offline Albertini

Re: The tapas group and the 'reconstitution' that was never to take place.
« Reply #399 on: June 11, 2014, 04:41:28 PM »
According to what I have read, Rebelo was so busy cleaning up the mess left by Amaral, and trying to make sense of what Amaral thought was important or not, that he didn't have time for anything else.  Tis no wonder to me that Rebelo was confused.

I'm sure you have "read" it somewhere but just because you read it somewhere doesn't mean it is true, does it?

I'm sure, and the Judge in the libel case agrees with me that the confusion was caused by the "incongruous" and "contradictory" statements provided.

Offline Albertini

Re: The tapas group and the 'reconstitution' that was never to take place.
« Reply #400 on: June 11, 2014, 04:43:04 PM »
So you find the Mirror quoting the Sunday People with a quote that may or may not have been relevant to whatever the hack decided to file as copy that night to be a reliable source?

Given there is a quoted and verifiable name attached to the quote, yes.

Has Clarence ever come out and asked for it to be retracted or stated he didn't say it?

The answer you're looking for is "no".

Offline Carana

Re: The tapas group and the 'reconstitution' that was never to take place.
« Reply #401 on: June 11, 2014, 04:54:41 PM »
Given there is a quoted and verifiable name attached to the quote, yes.

Has Clarence ever come out and asked for it to be retracted or stated he didn't say it?

The answer you're looking for is "no".

I thought quoting the Mirror was bad enough, but quoting the Mirror quoting the Sunday People as a reliable source of all things...

There is nothing in that quote that mentions the reconstruction, unless you can find a different direct quote from elsewhere in which CM specifically says that the lawyers would block the McCanns from going back to Portugal to take part in a reconstruction.






Offline Carana

Re: The tapas group and the 'reconstitution' that was never to take place.
« Reply #402 on: June 11, 2014, 05:02:03 PM »
You are confusing a Portuguese penal code reconstitution with a Crime watch style TV reconstruction. 

They are not the same thing, despite what a certain spokesman tried to claim during the period that the PJ were trying to arrange their reconstitution.

What was to stop Amaral & co organising a "Portuguese penal code reconstitution" in early-mid May 2007 when more participants would have been there, including OC staff? It could have been over and done with over 7 years ago.

Offline Albertini

Re: The tapas group and the 'reconstitution' that was never to take place.
« Reply #403 on: June 11, 2014, 05:06:34 PM »
I thought quoting the Mirror was bad enough, but quoting the Mirror quoting the Sunday People as a reliable source of all things...

There is nothing in that quote that mentions the reconstruction, unless you can find a different direct quote from elsewhere in which CM specifically says that the lawyers would block the McCanns from going back to Portugal to take part in a reconstruction.

Are you being pedantic? Already clearly explained the dates and timings in several pages.

Are you saying that Clarence Mitchell didn't say it even though he is quoted by two newspapers as saying it in an article written by Tom Carlin?

Also you do know the People and the Mirror are the same newspapers owned by the same people?

Are you intent on becoming a flat earther simply to try and desperately cling on to your point, despite it being shown as incorrect?

I expected more from you.

Offline Carana

Re: The tapas group and the 'reconstitution' that was never to take place.
« Reply #404 on: June 11, 2014, 05:41:20 PM »
Are you being pedantic? Already clearly explained the dates and timings in several pages.

Are you saying that Clarence Mitchell didn't say it even though he is quoted by two newspapers as saying it in an article written by Tom Carlin?

Also you do know the People and the Mirror are the same newspapers owned by the same people?

Are you intent on becoming a flat earther simply to try and desperately cling on to your point, despite it being shown as incorrect?

I expected more from you.

Not at all. If CM had clearly stated that lawyers would have blocked the McCanns from going back to PT for a reconstitution/reconstruction, I would have wondered if that was even possible as they were supposedly under a legal obligation to do so.

As it is, I'm still waiting for clarification beyond quotes of quotes of tabloids in which the actual quote made no such direct reference.