Journalist Sonia Poulton promises "The untold story of Madeleine McCann".

[Anna]

Yet you promote it at every opportunity.

Without one iota of evidence.

Keep it up.

I don’t think that this argument is going anywhere.
Some people, firmly believe that Madeleine was abducted and others firmly believe that she was not……without evidence in either case.
Then there are others with theories of what may have happened.
Opinions is all that can be given, since there is no evidence on which to draw a conclusion. None of us know what happened to the child.

[ferryman]

I don’t think that this argument is going anywhere.
Some people, firmly believe that Madeleine was abducted and others firmly believe that she was not……without evidence in either case.
Then there are others with theories of what may have happened.
Opinions is all that can be given, since there is no evidence on which to draw a conclusion. None of us know what happened to the child.

There is evidence in support of abduction.

The implausibility of Madeleine carefully closing the gate and the doors behind her if she left voluntarily.

Madeleine's out-door shoes found in the villa

The evidence of the Smiths and the evidence of Jane Tanner (carrying a child at the right time).

[Anna]

There is evidence in support of abduction.

The implausibility of Madeleine carefully closing the gate and the doors behind her if she left voluntarily.

Madeleine's out-door shoes found in the villa

The evidence of the Smiths and the evidence of Jane Tanner (carrying a child at the right time).

Thank you FM,
I see where you are coming from, but is there any hard evidence that a stranger removed her from 5A?. The child seen being carried could have been any child, since no abductor has yet been identified.

IMO abduction seems the most likely explanation for the child's disappearance, but that is only my opinion and I have no hard evidence with which to back it up.

[stephen25000]

I don’t think that this argument is going anywhere.
Some people, firmly believe that Madeleine was abducted and others firmly believe that she was not……without evidence in either case.
Then there are others with theories of what may have happened.
Opinions is all that can be given, since there is no evidence on which to draw a conclusion. None of us know what happened to the child.

We can agree on that.

[ferryman]

Thank you FM,
I see where you are coming from, but is there any hard evidence that a stranger removed her from 5A?. The child seen being carried could have been any child, since no abductor has yet been identified.

IMO abduction seems the most likely explanation for the child's disappearance, but that is only my opinion and I have no hard evidence with which to back it up.

For me the circumstantial evidence is sufficiently plausible to be compelling ...

[jassi]

For me the circumstantial evidence is sufficiently plausible to be compelling ...

Didn't Tony Blair say something along those lines about Iraq? 

[stephen25000]

Didn't Tony Blair say something along those lines about Iraq? 

Indeed he did, as he was in the pocket of Bush.

Metaphorically of course. *&*%£

[ferryman]

Didn't Tony Blair say something along those lines about Iraq? 

Tony Blaire never made any comment about the McCanns (so far as I'm aware) ...

[stephen25000]

Tony Blaire never made any comment about the McCanns (so far as I'm aware) ...

Don't you get irony ?

[ferryman]

Don't you get irony ?

Yes.

But you clearly don't

[stephen25000]

Yes.

But you clearly don't

What an inane response.

[jassi]

What an inane response.

Are you sure you haven't missed an 's'out of that? These damned typos are so easy.

[ferryman]

What an inane response.

                                 

[stephen25000]

Are you sure you haven't missed an 's'out of that? These damned typos are so easy.

Maybe yes, maybe no.

[Anna]

Can we please try and get back on topic. Thank you