Author Topic: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?  (Read 84685 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #315 on: September 23, 2015, 03:58:57 PM »
All the rest of the group ? Really ? While most said the helpfully ambiguous 'around 10' Tanner states that she first heard Kate and Fiona between 10-10.15'. So no consensus there. and certainly no  bar against the actual time of the alert being 'around 10.13'.
So you are choosing to disregard their combined efforts to construct a timeline (shortly after Madeleine went missing when events were freshest in their minds) as a work of fiction are you?  And the witness statement of Amy Tierney too? 
You are choosing to believe Gerry is giving the correct time in his May 10th statement for one reason only - and that is to make your cherished theory work.  Isn't that a bit silly Faithlilly?  What happened to "bowing to combined recollection"?  Please give a reason in your opinion for Gerry's insane decision to destroy his own alibi.

Offline faithlilly

Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #316 on: September 23, 2015, 04:07:08 PM »
So you are choosing to disregard their combined efforts to construct a timeline (shortly after Madeleine went missing when events were freshest in their minds) as a work of fiction are you?  And the witness statement of Amy Tierney too? 
You are choosing to believe Gerry is giving the correct time in his May 10th statement for one reason only - and that is to make your cherished theory work.  Isn't that a bit silly Faithlilly?  What happened to "bowing to combined recollection"?  Please give a reason in your opinion for Gerry's insane decision to destroy his own alibi.

The combined timeline says '22.00 ( approx ) which is of no help at all and I'm really not sure what you mean by Amy Tierney.
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #317 on: September 23, 2015, 04:10:20 PM »
The combined timeline says '22.00 ( approx ) which is of no help at all and I'm really not sure what you mean by Amy Tierney.
Perhaps you can point out where it says "approx." on the hand-written timelines?

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id261.html

ETA: this is what I meant about Amy Tierney - not her statement actually but others working with her (from Anna's earlier post):

22.05-22.20  Diane didn’t know how long she had been alone(5-10 mins) at the restaurant but decided to go to 5A since they hadn’t come back (poor lady seemed somewhat confused and who could blame her in the panic)

22.05  J williams
Snip
That on 3rd May at about 22.05 she was working at the Mini Club, at the "dinner time period" together with colleagues Charlotte and Amy, when a female individual arrived, whose name she does not know, just that she was the mother of a child there (belonging to Toddlers 2), being a guest who was staying at the resort and who left at the end of the week, who told her that a girl called "Maddie" has disappeared, and that the girl's parents needed help in looking for her.

22.08-22.17 Amy T went to 5A at(immediately she said) as she was working at the time.
Amy knew before emma(23) who was called by Lindsey at 10.17(who was informed by Amy) 
 so unsure what time Amy arrived at 5A but somewhere between 10. 08-10.17 she probably phoned Lindsay from 5A
In reply to the question asked, she said that the back door (porta das traseiras) that leads to the parking area was closed, but she doesn’t know whether the front door (porta da frente) was locked as when she arrived both the parents and a female friend of theirs whose name she does not know, were there and that is why the door was open.

I think it was very early and it was Diane ,Amy saw, before she went back to tapas for the camera and Amy left 5a around 10,15-20 to start the search after a short time at 5a.
She saw the shutters open and window partly open.
Gerry was seen by the pool 10.20ish and had also been to reception for police phonecall.

Fiona didn’t arrive at 5A until about 22.15/20


http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/EMMA-LOUISE.htm
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JACQUELINE_WILLIAMS.htm
http://themaddiecasefiles.com/post27240.html#p27240
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/LYNSAY-JAYNE.htm

Offline faithlilly

Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #318 on: September 23, 2015, 04:16:37 PM »
Perhaps you can point out where it says "approx." on the hand-written timelines?

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id261.html

ETA: this is what I meant about Amy Tierney - not her statement actually but others working with her (from Anna's earlier post):

22.05-22.20  Diane didn’t know how long she had been alone(5-10 mins) at the restaurant but decided to go to 5A since they hadn’t come back (poor lady seemed somewhat confused and who could blame her in the panic)

22.05  J williams
Snip
That on 3rd May at about 22.05 she was working at the Mini Club, at the "dinner time period" together with colleagues Charlotte and Amy, when a female individual arrived, whose name she does not know, just that she was the mother of a child there (belonging to Toddlers 2), being a guest who was staying at the resort and who left at the end of the week, who told her that a girl called "Maddie" has disappeared, and that the girl's parents needed help in looking for her.

22.08-22.17 Amy T went to 5A at(immediately she said) as she was working at the time.
Amy knew before emma(23) who was called by Lindsey at 10.17(who was informed by Amy) 
 so unsure what time Amy arrived at 5A but somewhere between 10. 08-10.17 she probably phoned Lindsay from 5A
In reply to the question asked, she said that the back door (porta das traseiras) that leads to the parking area was closed, but she doesn’t know whether the front door (porta da frente) was locked as when she arrived both the parents and a female friend of theirs whose name she does not know, were there and that is why the door was open.

I think it was very early and it was Diane ,Amy saw, before she went back to tapas for the camera and Amy left 5a around 10,15-20 to start the search after a short time at 5a.
She saw the shutters open and window partly open.
Gerry was seen by the pool 10.20ish and had also been to reception for police phonecall.

Fiona didn’t arrive at 5A until about 22.15/20


http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/EMMA-LOUISE.htm
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JACQUELINE_WILLIAMS.htm
http://themaddiecasefiles.com/post27240.html#p27240
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/LYNSAY-JAYNE.htm

This is the combined timeline created by all the main protagonists and says Kate left the table at  '22.00 (approx )'.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/TIME_LINE_3_MAY_07.htm
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #319 on: September 23, 2015, 04:32:32 PM »
This is the combined timeline created by all the main protagonists and says Kate left the table at  '22.00 (approx )'.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/TIME_LINE_3_MAY_07.htm
Why are you disregarding the actual hand-written timeline, compiled by the group that actual night?

Here we have a tangible piece of evidence  in police custody of the time the group say the alarm was raised - 10pm.

10pm is also the time you believe Gerry is up to no good.

However, Gerry's alibi is that at 10pm he is with the group when the alarm is raised, as agreed by the group in their hand-written timeline, now with the police.

When then, does Gerry tell the police 7 days later that the alarm occurred 13 minutes later, thus destroying his crucial alibi? 

My take on this is that Gerry simply made a mistake in his second statement, or even that it was an error of communication / translation which easily explains the discrepancy. 

You however have the harder task of coming up with a plausible reason why Gerry would destroy his own alibi.

Over to you.

Offline jassi

Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #320 on: September 23, 2015, 04:40:40 PM »
Why are you disregarding the actual hand-written timeline, compiled by the group that actual night?

Here we have a tangible piece of evidence  in police custody of the time the group say the alarm was raised - 10pm.

10pm is also the time you believe Gerry is up to no good.

However, Gerry's alibi is that at 10pm he is with the group when the alarm is raised, as agreed by the group in their hand-written timeline, now with the police.

When then, does Gerry tell the police 7 days later that the alarm occurred 13 minutes later, thus destroying his crucial alibi? 

My take on this is that Gerry simply made a mistake in his second statement, or even that it was an error of communication / translation which easily explains the discrepancy. 

You however have the harder task of coming up with a plausible reason why Gerry would destroy his own alibi.

Over to you.


Not necessarily. By later mentioning 10.13 could be an attempt to imply that he was there from just after 9.30, thereby extending his alibi.
It would seem that none of them really had much idea about the actual time and were merely gestimating times to fit  their narrative. All in my own opinion, of course.
« Last Edit: September 23, 2015, 05:18:44 PM by jassi »
I believe everything. And l believe nothing.
I suspect everyone. And l suspect no one.
I gather the facts, examine the clues... and before   you know it, the case is solved!"

Or maybe not -

OG have been pushed out by the Germans who have reserved all the deck chairs for the foreseeable future

Offline faithlilly

Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #321 on: September 23, 2015, 04:56:42 PM »
Why are you disregarding the actual hand-written timeline, compiled by the group that actual night?

Here we have a tangible piece of evidence  in police custody of the time the group say the alarm was raised - 10pm.

10pm is also the time you believe Gerry is up to no good.

However, Gerry's alibi is that at 10pm he is with the group when the alarm is raised, as agreed by the group in their hand-written timeline, now with the police.

When then, does Gerry tell the police 7 days later that the alarm occurred 13 minutes later, thus destroying his crucial alibi? 

My take on this is that Gerry simply made a mistake in his second statement, or even that it was an error of communication / translation which easily explains the discrepancy. 

You however have the harder task of coming up with a plausible reason why Gerry would destroy his own alibi.

Over to you.

Gerry had no idea what the waiting staff would say so best to stick to the truth, approx would just have to make things suitably obscure.
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #322 on: September 23, 2015, 05:18:50 PM »
Gerry had no idea what the waiting staff would say so best to stick to the truth, approx would just have to make things suitably obscure.
That's a bit lame for you Faithlilly.  Why is it that you have chosen on this one particular matter to disregard combined recollection (within hours of the event) in favour of the recollection of one man seven days after the event, when earlier you said you would bow to combined recollection? 

No need to answer - it's actually not hard to work out why.  It's because you need Gerry to be accurate on this one particular matter in order for your theory to work, never mind what any other witness says.  Can't you see how warped that logic is?  Of course you can't.

ETA: which member of staff verified that the alarm was raised at nearly 10.15pm?
« Last Edit: September 23, 2015, 05:20:55 PM by Alfred R Jones »

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #323 on: September 23, 2015, 05:19:42 PM »

Not necessarily. By later mentioning 10.13 could be an attempt to imply that he was there from just after 9.30, thereby extending his alibi.
It would seem that none of them really had much idea about the actual time and were merely gestimating times to fit  their narrative. All in my own opinion, of course.
Sorry, not following your train of thought there at all.

Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #324 on: September 23, 2015, 05:23:37 PM »

Not necessarily. By later mentioning 10.13 could be an attempt to imply that he was there from just after 9.30, thereby extending his alibi.
It would seem that none of them really had much idea about the actual time and were merely gestimating times to fit  their narrative. All in my own opinion, of course.

True! one of the only independent testimonies to time was that of Jez Wilkins who said he met Gerry between 20:45 and 21:45 and chatted for about 3 minutes or so. He would never be drawn into narrowing down the time span.
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #325 on: September 23, 2015, 05:34:05 PM »
True! one of the only independent testimonies to time was that of Jez Wilkins who said he met Gerry between 20:45 and 21:45 and chatted for about 3 minutes or so. He would never be drawn into narrowing down the time span.
When did he say that?

Furthermore, when was he asked to narrow the time span, and then refused to be drawn into doing so?
« Last Edit: September 23, 2015, 05:44:47 PM by Alfred R Jones »

Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #326 on: September 23, 2015, 05:52:14 PM »
When did he say that?

Furthermore, when was he asked to narrow the time span, and then refused to be drawn into doing so?

Look in here.
You will find it if you persevere.
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #327 on: September 23, 2015, 05:54:03 PM »
Look in here.
You will find it if you persevere.
I've just re-read his statements and his rogatory and he doesn't put an hour long time window on the meeting as far as I can see. Nor can I see any refusal to be more specific.  Perhaps I missed it so a link would be good, or a quote from a statement...?

Offline pegasus

Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #328 on: September 23, 2015, 05:55:55 PM »
When did he say that?

Furthermore, when was he asked to narrow the time span, and then refused to be drawn into doing so?
Here Alfred is the answer to both your questions

"... I met Gerry on the road between 20h45 and 21h15. I am aware of the importance of this hour and am also aware that the media announced our meeting time as 21h05. Even if this were correct, I have no idea from where such information originated. It is not possible to give you a more exact time ..."

Source: rogatory 8th Apr 2008 http://www.mccannfiles.com/id327.html

Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #329 on: September 23, 2015, 05:58:06 PM »
I've just re-read his statements and his rogatory and he doesn't put an hour long time window on the meeting as far as I can see. Nor can I see any refusal to be more specific.  Perhaps I missed it so a link would be good, or a quote from a statement...?
You are right just testing (  8(0(* ) it should have read 20:45 to 21:15. (ie quarter to nine to quarterpast nine in the evening civilian time)

Edited due to crap keyboard skills  ?{)(**
« Last Edit: September 23, 2015, 06:15:32 PM by Alice Purjorick »
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey