Author Topic: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?  (Read 84609 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline pegasus

Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #330 on: September 23, 2015, 06:23:19 PM »
It's also worth essaying the sequence of events by the Gospel according to Amaral.

Kate returns to the villa to find Madeleine (dead!)

Gerry is oblivious and unaware in the restaurant.

Kate (somehow) pulls it together, returns to the restaurant and communicates devastating news to Gerry (without anyone noticing).

Gerry leaves the restaurant (without anyone noticing), returns to the apartment, scoops up the remains of his daughter, whisks them past the noses of the Smiths and "hides" (Amaral's exact word!) them on the beach.

He returns back to the restaurant.

Kates leaves the restaurant, then returns a second time to simulate an 'abduction'.

Does that ring true and realistic?
Obviously that theory is impossible.
But I am impressed that you have taken the time to actually read and understand his theory. Some people who say they are Amaral supporters do not seem to do that, and so we see put forward theories which contradict Amaral's theory in many ways, abandoning his hypothesis that the child walked from the bedroom to the lounge, and proposing a discovery time far earlier and even more ridiculous than the time proposed by Amaral IMO.
« Last Edit: September 23, 2015, 06:26:12 PM by pegasus »

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #331 on: September 24, 2015, 05:35:46 PM »
Are we able to put to bed once and for all the myth that Gerry was Smithman?

Let us not forget - members of the Tapas group put together a timeline of events that were fresh in their minds on the night - this showed consensus agreement between them that the alarm was raised by Kate at 10pm.  There is no mention of Gerry being absent at the time the alarm was raised, and as the alarm seems to coincide within the Smithman sighting then it would be impossible for Gerry to have been in two places at once. 

The only way Gerry could have been Smithman is if the whole Tapas group are covering for him.  Is this likely?  I don't think so. 


Offline Brietta

Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #332 on: September 24, 2015, 05:43:55 PM »
Are we able to put to bed once and for all the myth that Gerry was Smithman?

Let us not forget - members of the Tapas group put together a timeline of events that were fresh in their minds on the night - this showed consensus agreement between them that the alarm was raised by Kate at 10pm.  There is no mention of Gerry being absent at the time the alarm was raised, and as the alarm seems to coincide within the Smithman sighting then it would be impossible for Gerry to have been in two places at once. 

The only way Gerry could have been Smithman is if the whole Tapas group are covering for him.  Is this likely?  I don't think so.

In addition, one only has to compare the obviously mistaken Smith and McCuskey statements to add another very compelling reason why that particular identification was entirely wrong ... why the notion has persisted is just one of the mysteries associated with Madeleine's case.
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

Offline G-Unit

Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #333 on: September 24, 2015, 05:46:25 PM »
In addition, one only has to compare the obviously mistaken Smith and McCuskey statements to add another very compelling reason why that particular identification was entirely wrong ... why the notion has persisted is just one of the mysteries associated with Madeleine's case.

Mr McClusky identified Kate too! Silly man.
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #334 on: September 24, 2015, 05:48:28 PM »
Are we able to put to bed once and for all the myth that Gerry was Smithman?

Let us not forget - members of the Tapas group put together a timeline of events that were fresh in their minds on the night - this showed consensus agreement between them that the alarm was raised by Kate at 10pm.  There is no mention of Gerry being absent at the time the alarm was raised, and as the alarm seems to coincide within the Smithman sighting then it would be impossible for Gerry to have been in two places at once. 

The only way Gerry could have been Smithman is if the whole Tapas group are covering for him.  Is this likely?  I don't think so.

As a generic statement, I fear not (in response to what I underline).

But all sensible people who follow these events closely long ago have, for precisely the reasons you so clearly set out above ....

Offline faithlilly

Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #335 on: September 24, 2015, 05:59:12 PM »
Are we able to put to bed once and for all the myth that Gerry was Smithman?

Let us not forget - members of the Tapas group put together a timeline of events that were fresh in their minds on the night - this showed consensus agreement between them that the alarm was raised by Kate at 10pm.  There is no mention of Gerry being absent at the time the alarm was raised, and as the alarm seems to coincide within the Smithman sighting then it would be impossible for Gerry to have been in two places at once. 

The only way Gerry could have been Smithman is if the whole Tapas group are covering for him.  Is this likely?  I don't think so.

Not everyone contributed to the timeline written on the night. In the timeline handed in to the PJ on the 10th of May everyone did and it is ambiguous as to the time of the alert, using 'approx' to suggest there was no true consensus.
« Last Edit: September 24, 2015, 06:01:46 PM by Faithlilly »
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Offline pegasus

Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #336 on: September 24, 2015, 06:08:00 PM »
Are we able to put to bed once and for all the myth that Gerry was Smithman? ... (snip)
IMO yes, because of clothing - the irish group saw a man in white or light beige trousers and a child with long sleeves - but the missing child was wearing short sleeves and her father was wearing blue jeans.

It is very easy now for SY to confirm the blue jeans by simply asking the T7.
To make GM into the man seen by the irish group requires THREE clothing changes
1. A change just before sighting from blue jeans to white trousers.
2. A change just before sighting from short sleeve pyjama top to long sleeved top.
3. A change immediately after sighting from white trousers back to blue jeans.
Sherlock Holmes wouldbe appalled by such flagrant changing of facts to fit an incorrect theory.
« Last Edit: September 24, 2015, 06:26:50 PM by pegasus »

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #337 on: September 24, 2015, 06:13:03 PM »
Not everyone contributed to the timeline written on the night. In the timeline handed in to the PJ on the 10th of May everyone did and it is ambiguous as to the time of the alert, using 'approx' to suggest there was no true consensus.

David Payne and Rusell O'Brien put together the handwritten timelines, both putting the time of alarm being raised at 10pm, the subsequent later timeline in which all contributed also has the time of the alarm being raised at 10pm, with the caveat "Times shown are approximate, but accurate to the best of our knowledge".  I don't know what you mean by "no true consensus" as it is crystal clear that the consensus view of the time the alarm was raised was 10pm.  If there was no true consensus on the timing of events that night then no collaboration on a timeline would be possible - it would be 9 different timelines. 

I know you're rooting for a later alarm time Faithlilly,  but apart from Gerry himself (unaccountably destroying his own alibi) not one other member of the Tapas group claims that they were still seated at the table as late as 10.13pm.


Offline pegasus

Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #338 on: September 24, 2015, 06:39:19 PM »
The timeline handed to PJ on 10th May was typed by ROB, with all 7 of the T7 present, on a laptop bborrowed from tennis coach GJ, and then checked by the 2 parents, this was all done on approx May 7th/8th. No other people were involved in writing it - no translators, no "hugh" secret agents. It was then handed on a memory stick (via an LP liaison officer) to the PJ on May 10th at Portimao. The text we see is the original english. There are no translation errors. Therefore it is a very accurate record of the timeline according to the T9.

Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #339 on: September 24, 2015, 06:41:20 PM »
Are we able to put to bed once and for all the myth that Gerry was Smithman?

Let us not forget - members of the Tapas group put together a timeline of events that were fresh in their minds on the night - this showed consensus agreement between them that the alarm was raised by Kate at 10pm.  There is no mention of Gerry being absent at the time the alarm was raised, and as the alarm seems to coincide within the Smithman sighting then it would be impossible for Gerry to have been in two places at once. 

The only way Gerry could have been Smithman is if the whole Tapas group are covering for him.  Is this likely?  I don't think so.

I don't know. It sounds though that you wish to be the arbiter and your will must prevail.
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #340 on: September 24, 2015, 06:56:00 PM »
IMO yes, because of clothing - the irish group saw a man in white or light beige trousers and a child with long sleeves - but the missing child was wearing short sleeves and her father was wearing blue jeans.

It is very easy now for SY to confirm the blue jeans by simply asking the T7.
To make GM into the man seen by the irish group requires THREE clothing changes
1. A change just before sighting from blue jeans to white trousers.
2. A change just before sighting from short sleeve pyjama top to long sleeved top.
3. A change immediately after sighting from white trousers back to blue jeans.
Sherlock Holmes wouldbe appalled by such flagrant changing of facts to fit an incorrect theory.
Wouldn't he just!

Offline faithlilly

Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #341 on: September 24, 2015, 07:18:03 PM »
David Payne and Rusell O'Brien put together the handwritten timelines, both putting the time of alarm being raised at 10pm, the subsequent later timeline in which all contributed also has the time of the alarm being raised at 10pm, with the caveat "Times shown are approximate, but accurate to the best of our knowledge".  I don't know what you mean by "no true consensus" as it is crystal clear that the consensus view of the time the alarm was raised was 10pm.  If there was no true consensus on the timing of events that night then no collaboration on a timeline would be possible - it would be 9 different timelines. 

I know you're rooting for a later alarm time Faithlilly,  but apart from Gerry himself (unaccountably destroying his own alibi) not one other member of the Tapas group claims that they were still seated at the table as late as 10.13pm.

The clue is '22.00 APPROX'. If you look hard enough you will find it.
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #342 on: September 24, 2015, 08:30:34 PM »
Obviously that theory is impossible.
But I am impressed that you have taken the time to actually read and understand his theory. Some people who say they are Amaral supporters do not seem to do that, and so we see put forward theories which contradict Amaral's theory in many ways, abandoning his hypothesis that the child walked from the bedroom to the lounge, and proposing a discovery time far earlier and even more ridiculous than the time proposed by Amaral IMO.

Thank you for that, Pegasus.

Appreciated.

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #343 on: September 24, 2015, 10:01:46 PM »
The clue is '22.00 APPROX'. If you look hard enough you will find it.
The bigger clue is 22.00, not 22.10, and definitely not 22.15 APPROX. 

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Could Smithman be the key to Madeleine's disappearance?
« Reply #344 on: September 26, 2015, 06:37:47 PM »
If the alarm was raised at 10.13 Faithlilly, could you please explain why it took Russell at least 20 minutes to take two bites of his dinner, which was re-served to him shortly after his return to table at appox 9.45pm?