Could it? Let's think. Can we answer any of these questions?
Firstly a planned abduction by a group. Why look in this resort? Why did they want a three year old girl? For themselves or for someone else? Why this child and not one of the ten pretty little three year old girls described by Bridget O'Donald?
Secondly a planned abduction by one person. Again, why here and why this child?
An opportunist? Unlikely because there was no opportunity, the opportunity had to be created.
A burglary gone wrong. Did someone walking past just decide to try the shutters, then the window? Did they see someone exit the patio doors and just pop in on a whim? Most burglars run if a child cries.
If it was a premeditated planned abduction, then the Ocean club in PdL is an ideal location IMO.
Holiday resorts are constantly full of strange faces as holidaymakers come and go.
It is on the coastline, so escape could be made by boat or by road.
There was no CCTV at the complex.
It was advertised as a child-friendly place.
IIRC The general public were allowed to go in and out.
5A was ideally situated and described as a burglars dream IIRC by the UK police.
There is no police station in PdL - the nearest is in Lagos
IMO the fact that Madeleine was abducted on the night before the last night of the holiday is very pertinent - as the perpetrator would be aware that routines can change on the last night - as people prepare to depart the following day.
The PT laws may have been a factor. In Portugal if a child disappears it appears there is no immediate media public campaign to draw attention to that fact - as there would be in other countries. IMO that lack of publicity would be seen as a massive advantage to would-be abductor(s).
According to Mrs Murat - locals may be scared to approach the police for fear of being wrongly implicated themselves. IMO. This reluctance is another plus for would be abductors.
All in all therefore it seems to me that anyone planning to abduct a child would have concluded that PdL, the child friendly Ocean club and apartment 5A fitted the bill perfectly - especially if more than one abductor was involved.