Author Topic: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...  (Read 135101 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline ShiningInLuz

Re: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...
« Reply #420 on: October 20, 2015, 11:27:11 PM »
Me neither but it has been suggested that there are such people stealing children 'to order' as it were.

I'm asking the questions because I was wondering who the abductor that every talks about could be. People are convinced there was one but who was he and why did he go to this resort and why did he take this child?

If the abduction was planned, why Madeleine? There was a slightly younger but just as cute child in 5H and no-one checked on that child, watchers would have noticed. None of the checkers went upstairs, so no chance of being disturbed. Unless they were Ocean Club employees or holiday makers they wouldn't know about the baby alarm, so 5H would have been an easier target if the group were watched.

I would like to hear a supporter explain just why this particular child was targeted.
1.  Why assume this particular child was targeted?  There were 8 children in the group, 7 of them girls, all under age 4.  Perhaps a child under (insert age here) was the target?

2. The receptionist booking the holiday stated that there was a request to be on the ground floor, due to young children.  Holiday organiser David Payne is the parent who ends up with children not on the ground floor.

3. After discussion about 30 min hearing checks not being done at Luz, David Payne decides on a baby monitor.  3 other sets of parents do not.

4. None of the checkers decides to do something painfully obvious.  Like leave one parent behind per night, doing all the patrols.  Or splitting the duties, with each parent checking all 3 ground floor apartments every 10 minutes.

I am far from convinced that Madeleine was THE target, as opposed to someone who wound up with the short straw.
What's up, old man?

Offline mercury

Re: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...
« Reply #421 on: October 20, 2015, 11:28:08 PM »
Me neither but it has been suggested that there are such people stealing children 'to order' as it were.

I'm asking the questions because I was wondering who the abductor that every talks about could be. People are convinced there was one but who was he and why did he go to this resort and why did he take this child?

If the abduction was planned, why Madeleine? There was a slightly younger but just as cute child in 5H and no-one checked on that child, watchers would have noticed. None of the checkers went upstairs, so no chance of being disturbed. Unless they were Ocean Club employees or holiday makers they wouldn't know about the baby alarm, so 5H would have been an easier target if the group were watched.

I would like to hear a supporter explain just why this particular child was targeted.

They're all just "theories" in explanation  to an alleged  abduction NOTHNG more

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...
« Reply #422 on: October 20, 2015, 11:30:33 PM »
Me neither but it has been suggested that there are such people stealing children 'to order' as it were.

I'm asking the questions because I was wondering who the abductor that every talks about could be. People are convinced there was one but who was he and why did he go to this resort and why did he take this child?

If the abduction was planned, why Madeleine? There was a slightly younger but just as cute child in 5H and no-one checked on that child, watchers would have noticed. None of the checkers went upstairs, so no chance of being disturbed. Unless they were Ocean Club employees or holiday makers they wouldn't know about the baby alarm, so 5H would have been an easier target if the group were watched.

I would like to hear a supporter explain just why this particular child was targeted.
Unless a supporter here also happens to be the abductor (unlikely!) then how in God's name should any of us know why Madeleine was targeted?  Why was that child in Wales snatched from her bath?  I expect there were "cuter" ones, more snatchable ones all over town!  It's an idiotic question to put to us, nobody except the abductor can answer it. 

Offline G-Unit

Re: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...
« Reply #423 on: October 21, 2015, 08:44:54 AM »
Unless a supporter here also happens to be the abductor (unlikely!) then how in God's name should any of us know why Madeleine was targeted?  Why was that child in Wales snatched from her bath?  I expect there were "cuter" ones, more snatchable ones all over town!  It's an idiotic question to put to us, nobody except the abductor can answer it.

People are sure there was an abduction, and have discussed endlessly whether the abductor watched, where from, why he opened the shutters. I haven't seen any discussion about why, and whether he was local, a holiday maker or someone who came into PdL specially.

Abductors of little girls Madeleine's age are rare. She's younger than the children a sexual predator usually chooses and too old to be taken to be someone's child. Given the frequency of the checks and the fact that three children were in the room someone was prepared to take a huge risk to get this child. There were two others in the group not much different in age and cuteness. One of those wasn't being checked. Neither was their apartment on the route of the checkers, it was out of the way upstairs, giving someone more time and less chance of being spotted. Either the abductor wanted Madeleine to the exclusion of all others or he was quite dim imo.
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline Benice

Re: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...
« Reply #424 on: October 21, 2015, 09:06:06 AM »
Could it? Let's think.  Can we answer any of these questions? 

Firstly a planned abduction by a group. Why look in this resort? Why did they want a three year old girl? For themselves or for someone else? Why this child and not one of the ten pretty little three year old girls described by Bridget O'Donald?

Secondly a planned abduction by one person. Again, why here and why this child?

An opportunist? Unlikely because there was no opportunity, the opportunity had to be created.

A burglary gone wrong. Did someone walking past just decide to try the shutters, then the window? Did they see someone exit the patio doors and just pop in on a whim? Most burglars run if a child cries.


If it was a premeditated planned abduction, then the Ocean club in PdL is an ideal location IMO.   

Holiday resorts are constantly full of strange faces as holidaymakers come and go.   

It is on the coastline, so escape could be made by boat or by road. 

There was no CCTV at the complex. 

It was advertised as a child-friendly place. 

IIRC The general public were allowed to go in and out.

5A was ideally situated and described as a burglars dream IIRC by the UK police. 

There is no police station in PdL - the nearest is in Lagos

IMO the fact that Madeleine was abducted on the night before the last night of the holiday is very pertinent - as the perpetrator would be aware that routines can change on the last night - as people prepare to depart  the following day.

The  PT laws may have been a factor.   In Portugal if a child disappears it appears there is no immediate media public campaign to draw attention to that fact - as there would be in other countries.  IMO that lack of publicity would be seen as a massive advantage to would-be abductor(s).     

According to Mrs Murat - locals may be scared to approach the police for fear of being wrongly implicated themselves. IMO.      This reluctance is another plus for would be abductors.

All in all therefore it seems to me that anyone planning to abduct a child would have concluded that PdL, the child friendly Ocean club and apartment 5A fitted the bill perfectly - especially if more than one abductor was involved.



The notion that innocence prevails over guilt – when there is no evidence to the contrary – is what separates civilization from barbarism.    Unfortunately, there are remains of barbarism among us.    Until very recently, it headed the PJ in Portimão. I hope he was the last one.
                                               Henrique Monteiro, chief editor, Expresso, Portugal

Offline Eleanor

Re: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...
« Reply #425 on: October 21, 2015, 09:10:51 AM »

If it was a premeditated planned abduction, then the Ocean club in PdL is an ideal location IMO.   

Holiday resorts are constantly full of strange faces as holidaymakers come and go.   

It is on the coastline, so escape could be made by boat or by road. 

There was no CCTV at the complex. 

It was advertised as a child-friendly place. 

IIRC The general public were allowed to go in and out.

5A was ideally situated and described as a burglars dream IIRC by the UK police. 

There is no police station in PdL - the nearest is in Lagos

IMO the fact that Madeleine was abducted on the night before the last night of the holiday is very pertinent - as the perpetrator would be aware that routines can change on the last night - as people prepare to depart  the following day.

The  PT laws may have been a factor.   In Portugal if a child disappears it appears there is no immediate media public campaign to draw attention to that fact - as there would be in other countries.  IMO that lack of publicity would be seen as a massive advantage to would-be abductor(s).     

According to Mrs Murat - locals may be scared to approach the police for fear of being wrongly implicated themselves. IMO.      This reluctance is another plus for would be abductors.

All in all therefore it seems to me that anyone planning to abduct a child would have concluded that PdL, the child friendly Ocean club and apartment 5A fitted the bill perfectly - especially if more than one abductor was involved.

Good Post.

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...
« Reply #426 on: October 21, 2015, 09:32:56 AM »
People are sure there was an abduction, and have discussed endlessly whether the abductor watched, where from, why he opened the shutters. I haven't seen any discussion about why, and whether he was local, a holiday maker or someone who came into PdL specially.

Abductors of little girls Madeleine's age are rare. She's younger than the children a sexual predator usually chooses and too old to be taken to be someone's child. Given the frequency of the checks and the fact that three children were in the room someone was prepared to take a huge risk to get this child. There were two others in the group not much different in age and cuteness. One of those wasn't being checked. Neither was their apartment on the route of the checkers, it was out of the way upstairs, giving someone more time and less chance of being spotted. Either the abductor wanted Madeleine to the exclusion of all others or he was quite dim imo.
Why would an upstairs location be better for gaining access to and for carrying away a child from? &%+((£

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...
« Reply #427 on: October 21, 2015, 09:35:00 AM »
People are sure there was an abduction, and have discussed endlessly whether the abductor watched, where from, why he opened the shutters. I haven't seen any discussion about why, and whether he was local, a holiday maker or someone who came into PdL specially.

Abductors of little girls Madeleine's age are rare. She's younger than the children a sexual predator usually chooses and too old to be taken to be someone's child. Given the frequency of the checks and the fact that three children were in the room someone was prepared to take a huge risk to get this child. There were two others in the group not much different in age and cuteness. One of those wasn't being checked. Neither was their apartment on the route of the checkers, it was out of the way upstairs, giving someone more time and less chance of being spotted. Either the abductor wanted Madeleine to the exclusion of all others or he was quite dim imo.
Can we have some research to back up the statement above please?  I wasn't aware that 4 year olds were not such attractive targets for  paedos, nor that there was any hard and fast rule about the age suitability of snatched children for other purposes. 

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...
« Reply #428 on: October 21, 2015, 09:49:33 AM »
Can we have some research to back up the statement above please?  I wasn't aware that 4 year olds were not such attractive targets for  paedos, nor that there was any hard and fast rule about the age suitability of snatched children for other purposes.

So alfred, in terms of simplicity, why wouldn't an abductor take one of Madeleine's younger siblings ?

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...
« Reply #429 on: October 21, 2015, 09:54:16 AM »
So alfred, in terms of simplicity, why wouldn't an abductor take one of Madeleine's younger siblings ?
How should I know?  Is there some sort of rule of child abduction that says the younger the better? 

Offline Eleanor

Re: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...
« Reply #430 on: October 21, 2015, 09:55:26 AM »
So alfred, in terms of simplicity, why wouldn't an abductor take one of Madeleine's younger siblings ?

Separating Twins would not have been a good idea.  And then there would have been the problem of nappies while on the move.

Offline G-Unit

Re: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...
« Reply #431 on: October 21, 2015, 10:02:19 AM »

If it was a premeditated planned abduction, then the Ocean club in PdL is an ideal location IMO.   

Holiday resorts are constantly full of strange faces as holidaymakers come and go.   

It is on the coastline, so escape could be made by boat or by road. 

There was no CCTV at the complex. 

It was advertised as a child-friendly place. 

IIRC The general public were allowed to go in and out.

5A was ideally situated and described as a burglars dream IIRC by the UK police. 

There is no police station in PdL - the nearest is in Lagos

IMO the fact that Madeleine was abducted on the night before the last night of the holiday is very pertinent - as the perpetrator would be aware that routines can change on the last night - as people prepare to depart  the following day.

The  PT laws may have been a factor.   In Portugal if a child disappears it appears there is no immediate media public campaign to draw attention to that fact - as there would be in other countries.  IMO that lack of publicity would be seen as a massive advantage to would-be abductor(s).     

According to Mrs Murat - locals may be scared to approach the police for fear of being wrongly implicated themselves. IMO.      This reluctance is another plus for would be abductors.

All in all therefore it seems to me that anyone planning to abduct a child would have concluded that PdL, the child friendly Ocean club and apartment 5A fitted the bill perfectly - especially if more than one abductor was involved.

They did go to a lot of trouble. didn't they? I wonder if they investigated all of Europe or just Portugal or just the Algarve before deciding that the Ocean Club was exactly the place to find three year old children. They must then have gone to investigate on the ground, as it were.

Checks revealed little or no CCTV, no police station, and a reluctance by locals to interact with the police. Of course they also revealed that three year old girls didn't wander around on their own like older children. They were either with their parents or in childcare during the day. In the evenings they were either with their parents when dining, in their apartments with a babysitter or at the night creche with childcare workers.

Did these checks take place during the week beginning 28th April or earlier, I wonder? The previous occupant of G5A had a visitor, a charity collector. Was he 'casing the joint'? He only got as far as the roadside gate, so he didn't see much. Would he have gone up the steps to the patio if the occupant wan't in the garden/patio area? Perhaps, but why? All he would have found was a balcony and two locked patio doors.

If the abductor (s) were there all week when the McCanns were there why did they choose G5A? It may have been a burglar's dream, but not during the evening. From 8.30pm to midnight there was a constant stream of people passing back and forth checking on children in Block 5. On Sunday, Tuesday and Wednesday some people stayed in the apartments. On Thursday someone was in the apartments from 9.30pm onwards. In the first floor apartment was a permanent resident who could have heard something and called the authorities at any moment.

Anyone still proceeding in the face of such problems must have been determined to abduct one child in particular in my opinion. There must have been easier targets.

Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...
« Reply #432 on: October 21, 2015, 10:11:38 AM »
They did go to a lot of trouble. didn't they? I wonder if they investigated all of Europe or just Portugal or just the Algarve before deciding that the Ocean Club was exactly the place to find three year old children. They must then have gone to investigate on the ground, as it were.

Checks revealed little or no CCTV, no police station, and a reluctance by locals to interact with the police. Of course they also revealed that three year old girls didn't wander around on their own like older children. They were either with their parents or in childcare during the day. In the evenings they were either with their parents when dining, in their apartments with a babysitter or at the night creche with childcare workers.

Did these checks take place during the week beginning 28th April or earlier, I wonder? The previous occupant of G5A had a visitor, a charity collector. Was he 'casing the joint'? He only got as far as the roadside gate, so he didn't see much. Would he have gone up the steps to the patio if the occupant wan't in the garden/patio area? Perhaps, but why? All he would have found was a balcony and two locked patio doors.

If the abductor (s) were there all week when the McCanns were there why did they choose G5A? It may have been a burglar's dream, but not during the evening. From 8.30pm to midnight there was a constant stream of people passing back and forth checking on children in Block 5. On Sunday, Tuesday and Wednesday some people stayed in the apartments. On Thursday someone was in the apartments from 9.30pm onwards. In the first floor apartment was a permanent resident who could have heard something and called the authorities at any moment.

Anyone still proceeding in the face of such problems must have been determined to abduct one child in particular in my opinion. There must have been easier targets.
Nice facetious post there.  Ask yourself - have other children been abducted from or molested and / or murdered in their own homes (or places considered home) by strangers before, in unprepossessing random locations and at extremely high risk of discovery by the perpetrator?  If the answer is yes (which it surely must be), then is it not also possible in this case?  If not, please state why not.

Offline Benice

Re: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...
« Reply #433 on: October 21, 2015, 10:41:00 AM »
More possible reasons why PdL may have been chosen.

Quote from Amarals book.


All of the video recordings from the tourist complex - hotels, banks, pharmacies, supermarkets and service stations -, including those from the CCTV cameras of two motorways - one leading to Lagos and one linking Lagos and Spain -, will be viewed.    The Spanish customs service has been asked to increase vigilance at the two ports maintaining links with Morocco,Tarifa and Algeciras. The Algarvian coast, very popular with sailing enthusiasts, is bordered by a large number of marinas.    Pleasure boats from every province berth here.    Situated 120 nautical miles from the African continent, between the Mediterranean and the Atlantic, it is the most accessible coast for entering the continent of Europe.    It attracts many yachtsmen, who appreciate the beauty of its beaches and its inlets, but it also attracts all sorts of traffickers.
Unquote

(Must go out now)
The notion that innocence prevails over guilt – when there is no evidence to the contrary – is what separates civilization from barbarism.    Unfortunately, there are remains of barbarism among us.    Until very recently, it headed the PJ in Portimão. I hope he was the last one.
                                               Henrique Monteiro, chief editor, Expresso, Portugal

Offline ShiningInLuz

Re: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...
« Reply #434 on: October 21, 2015, 01:10:12 PM »
They did go to a lot of trouble. didn't they? I wonder if they investigated all of Europe or just Portugal or just the Algarve before deciding that the Ocean Club was exactly the place to find three year old children. They must then have gone to investigate on the ground, as it were.

Checks revealed little or no CCTV, no police station, and a reluctance by locals to interact with the police. Of course they also revealed that three year old girls didn't wander around on their own like older children. They were either with their parents or in childcare during the day. In the evenings they were either with their parents when dining, in their apartments with a babysitter or at the night creche with childcare workers.

Did these checks take place during the week beginning 28th April or earlier, I wonder? The previous occupant of G5A had a visitor, a charity collector. Was he 'casing the joint'? He only got as far as the roadside gate, so he didn't see much. Would he have gone up the steps to the patio if the occupant wan't in the garden/patio area? Perhaps, but why? All he would have found was a balcony and two locked patio doors.

If the abductor (s) were there all week when the McCanns were there why did they choose G5A? It may have been a burglar's dream, but not during the evening. From 8.30pm to midnight there was a constant stream of people passing back and forth checking on children in Block 5. On Sunday, Tuesday and Wednesday some people stayed in the apartments. On Thursday someone was in the apartments from 9.30pm onwards. In the first floor apartment was a permanent resident who could have heard something and called the authorities at any moment.

Anyone still proceeding in the face of such problems must have been determined to abduct one child in particular in my opinion. There must have been easier targets.
Try reversing this to ask who knew most of the above facts in advance, and could manufacture an optimal kidnap scenario.  Not with absolute certainty but with a high degree of probability.
What's up, old man?