Author Topic: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?  (Read 61882 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Brietta

Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
« Reply #270 on: January 06, 2016, 10:19:52 PM »
I don't need God to see logic and to hold to account which two people are responsible for their own misfortune.

It is good to recognise that torture does not have to be physical to be torture.  However, what I really fail to get is the attitude of those who evidence an obsession with continuing the mental torture of Madeleine McCann's parents and the failure (perhaps ????) to make a connection between that and possible repercussions on a little girl for whom there is a total lack of evidence that she may be dead.
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

Offline slartibartfast

Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
« Reply #271 on: January 06, 2016, 10:30:57 PM »
Can we stop the WWJD arguments, they don't really add to the debate.
“Reasoning will never make a Man correct an ill Opinion, which by Reasoning he never acquired”.

Offline Eleanor

Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
« Reply #272 on: January 06, 2016, 10:36:21 PM »
Can we stop the WWJD arguments, they don't really add to the debate.

What Slarti said.  Back On Topic.

Offline Brietta

Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
« Reply #273 on: January 06, 2016, 10:39:26 PM »
Can we stop the WWJD arguments, they don't really add to the debate.

I'm fine with that I think, but can you please clarify what WWJD arguments are.
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

Offline slartibartfast

Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
« Reply #274 on: January 06, 2016, 10:47:36 PM »
I'm fine with that I think, but can you please clarify what WWJD arguments are.

What Would Jesus Do, it's a bit of an appeal to authority.
“Reasoning will never make a Man correct an ill Opinion, which by Reasoning he never acquired”.

Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
« Reply #275 on: January 06, 2016, 11:01:27 PM »
What Would Jesus Do, it's a bit of an appeal to authority.

Isn't that a propaganda technique?
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

Offline Brietta

Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
« Reply #276 on: January 06, 2016, 11:02:16 PM »
What Would Jesus Do, it's a bit of an appeal to authority.

Thank you.  I really have never heard that before ... I'm sure there will be hundreds of future opportunities to slip it into conversation.
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

Offline slartibartfast

Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
« Reply #277 on: January 06, 2016, 11:17:25 PM »
Isn't that a propaganda technique?

A sort of inverse Godwin.
“Reasoning will never make a Man correct an ill Opinion, which by Reasoning he never acquired”.

Offline Carana

Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
« Reply #278 on: January 07, 2016, 09:50:30 AM »
Every police force will have used heavy-handed interrogation techniques at some point in their history - the PJ is hardly alone.

Torturing a confession out of someone doesn't appear to have been reserved for just the Portuguese, though: Mick Cook was English.

Kidnap, murder and justice in the Algarve
The Guardian
Published August 1993

"...The certainty on Vale Navio that Ray was involved was soon matched by the uncertainty that began to cloud the case against Mick Cook. He said he had never signed any confession, but the police had beaten him until he agreed verbally that he was guilty. Five of them had worked on him, he said, punching him, banging his head against the wall, beating the soles of his feet with sticks, jumping on his back, forcing a gun into his mouth (and chipping a tooth in the process). He had ended up bleeding, semi-conscious, with his trousers full of his own faeces. Finally, as he put it in a letter from jail: “I just wanted the pain to stop. I said ‘if you say that’s how it was, then that’s how it must have been.’”

http://www.nickdavies.net/1993/08/01/kidnap-murder-and-justice-in-the-algarve/


http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm199293/cmhansrd/1992-06-09/Debate-20.html

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=1749.105
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=1354.0


Offline faithlilly

Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
« Reply #279 on: January 07, 2016, 10:25:23 AM »
Every police force will have used heavy-handed interrogation techniques at some point in their history - the PJ is hardly alone.

Torturing a confession out of someone doesn't appear to have been reserved for just the Portuguese, though: Mick Cook was English.

Kidnap, murder and justice in the Algarve
The Guardian
Published August 1993

"...The certainty on Vale Navio that Ray was involved was soon matched by the uncertainty that began to cloud the case against Mick Cook. He said he had never signed any confession, but the police had beaten him until he agreed verbally that he was guilty. Five of them had worked on him, he said, punching him, banging his head against the wall, beating the soles of his feet with sticks, jumping on his back, forcing a gun into his mouth (and chipping a tooth in the process). He had ended up bleeding, semi-conscious, with his trousers full of his own faeces. Finally, as he put it in a letter from jail: “I just wanted the pain to stop. I said ‘if you say that’s how it was, then that’s how it must have been.’”

http://www.nickdavies.net/1993/08/01/kidnap-murder-and-justice-in-the-algarve/


http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm199293/cmhansrd/1992-06-09/Debate-20.html

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=1749.105
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=1354.0

I think it's telling that you have to go back over 25 years to find a case of police brutality in Portugal before the alleged torture of Cipriano.
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Offline Brietta

Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
« Reply #280 on: January 07, 2016, 11:14:13 AM »
Every police force will have used heavy-handed interrogation techniques at some point in their history - the PJ is hardly alone.

Torturing a confession out of someone doesn't appear to have been reserved for just the Portuguese, though: Mick Cook was English.

Kidnap, murder and justice in the Algarve
The Guardian
Published August 1993

"...The certainty on Vale Navio that Ray was involved was soon matched by the uncertainty that began to cloud the case against Mick Cook. He said he had never signed any confession, but the police had beaten him until he agreed verbally that he was guilty. Five of them had worked on him, he said, punching him, banging his head against the wall, beating the soles of his feet with sticks, jumping on his back, forcing a gun into his mouth (and chipping a tooth in the process). He had ended up bleeding, semi-conscious, with his trousers full of his own faeces. Finally, as he put it in a letter from jail: “I just wanted the pain to stop. I said ‘if you say that’s how it was, then that’s how it must have been.’”

http://www.nickdavies.net/1993/08/01/kidnap-murder-and-justice-in-the-algarve/


http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm199293/cmhansrd/1992-06-09/Debate-20.html

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=1749.105
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=1354.0

There can be no greater evil than such a crime. I would not defend in any way a child murderer, but I will defend my constituent's right to a fair trial. My responsibility and my job tonight is to highlight the possibility that my constituent may be the victim of a gross miscarriage of justice. Some say that Cook is innocent ; some say that the police investigation was inadequate. Some say that the trial verdict was so lacking supporting evidence as to be incredible. Some say that Cook has been tortured and mistreated. Those are not questions which the House can or should decide. In truth, I do not know whether Cook is innocent or guilty. What I do know is that many questions are raised by the case which have the most serious implications, not only for Michael Cook, but for all British subjects travelling abroad.
http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm199293/cmhansrd/1992-06-09/Debate-20.html

Were explanation required for what some deem the extraordinary 'political interference' from the start of Madeleine McCann's case reading the links you have provided clarifies matters.

The British ambassador to the Algarve undoubtedly knew about Michael Cook's case; we know he knew about the sexual assaults on British children; he undoubtedly knew about the Cipriano case.

In my opinion he behaved in an exemplary manner on behalf of British subjects abroad by making his presence known. 

I believe resentment has been shown to be palpable that such a presence in combination with the eyes of the world on Luz was an assurance that the Drs McCann could not be subject to obvious maltreatment.

I think compensation for that restriction was found in the numerous pejorative press leaks which emanated from 'a source close to the investigation'.
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

Offline Carana

Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
« Reply #281 on: January 07, 2016, 11:38:13 AM »
The court did accept that Leonor Cipriano was tortured but what it didnt identify was the reason for that torture.

The Oxford Dictionary defines torture as the action or practice of inflicting severe pain on someone as a punishment or in order to force them to do or say something. 

We know that Leonor admitted to having killed her daughter prior to her arrest, arraignment and detention so on that basis confession can be excluded. It is most unlikely that the Portuguese police would torture Leonor just for the hell of it so this again can be excluded. That only leaves one possible reason why she was tortured and that reason has already been touched on by Angelo earlier. 

The police had a missing child to find, a mother who admitted to killing her and asking her brother to hide the body.  The same brother took the police out on several goose chases but untimately failed to recover the child dead or alive. The emphasis then shifted back to the mother and an attempt to extract information from her which might save the child even at that point. In those terrible circumstances were the police justified in what they did?

The Cipriano case differs from that of Madeleine McCann in that in the latter, neither parent admitted at any time to having had an involvement in their child's disappearance, unlike the Cipriano case.

In the Cipriano case the police were acting on what they assumed to be reliable information from a parent which led them to believe the child could be recoverable.  In the McCann case, no such admission was made.

In those circumstances therefore I can see no reason why torture would have been used against the McCanns had they been Portuguese and not from the British Isles.

There is no way of knowing whether she was beaten or browbeaten into an initial confession or not.
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=3030.0

What does appear to be fact is that she was taken in for questioning on 21 Sept and was charged by a judge sometime late on 24 Sept and held on remand.

On 27 Sept she was taken to Faro hospital complaining of intense stomach pain as a result of having been beaten. Bizarrely, the blood on a chair was apparently "medically examined" to conclude that it was "menstrual flow".

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=2977.msg123753#msg123753

This would coincide with Leandro saying that when he talked to her while she was in police detention - presumably in that 3rd week of September - she told him that she'd slapped Joana and that João had "finished her off", because she'd caught them having incestuous sex (a fact not proven). Later, when he visited her in Odemira prison, she told him that what she had confessed to wasn't true, but that she had been beaten into it.

Declarou ainda a testemunha que numa altura em que se encontrou com a arguida BB nas instalações da Polícia Judiciária, a pedido daquela Polícia, mas numa altura em que se encontravam só os dois, a testemunha perguntou à BB o que tinha acontecido e ela então contou-lhe que "tinha dado uma chapada na CC e que o irmão acabou de a matar", tudo "porque ela os tinha visto a ter relações" e também contou que "tinham posto o corpo numa casa velha e que tinha sido o AA a levá-la às costas". Posteriormente, quando a testemunha foi visitar a arguida BB à cadeia de Odemira, ela negou o que tinha dito e referiu-lhe que só tinha afirmado aquelas coisas porque a Polícia Judiciária lhe tinha batido. Questionado sobre se no dia em que a BB lhe tinha confessado ter agredido CC, a mesma apresentava marcas de ter sido batida, nomeadamente se tinha a cara ou os olhos inchados ou vermelhos, a testemunha disse que não.

An extract from the SC ruling.

I find it tenuous, to say the least, to assume that she had initially "confessed" voluntarily, if at all. Others claimed that they had been beaten / handled roughly during their own interrogations during this initial period, and as she was Amaral's prime suspect due to the fact that she appeared on TV appealing for help wearing a dark top and red trousers, this was seemingly a sure-fire subliminal message that she knew that the child was dead and was responsible, depite the fact that photos show that she had worn this ensemble prior to the disappearance of the child.

She was formally charged at some point on 24 Sept.... but based on what?

Between 21 and late evening 24 September, has her legal representative at the time ever stated that he/she was present throughout that period 24/7? How likely is that?

There would seem to be few possibilities regarding the charges:

- specks of unidentifiable blood of human and animal origin (the PJ hadn't got round to the fridge at that point).

In fact, the PJ only examined the (unsealed) house on 22 Sept, waving a black torch around, up until which time all the occupants (minus poor Joana, and João) continued to live there, plus contamination by various other visitors during that period.

and / or

- a confession (coerced or spontaneous).

IMO, on the balance of probability, I suspect that there may well have been an initial "confession" as I don't see what other legal basis there could have been for charges at the time.

Equally, on a balance of probabilities, I find it unlikely that any confession obtained in such murky circumstances could be deemed to be "spontaneous".
« Last Edit: January 07, 2016, 12:19:34 PM by Carana »

Offline Carana

Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
« Reply #282 on: January 07, 2016, 12:17:56 PM »
I think it's telling that you have to go back over 25 years to find a case of police brutality in Portugal before the alleged torture of Cipriano.

Erm, one doesn't.

- The allegations of torture concerning the Cipriano case date back to 2003.

Although Cristovão was acquitted of torturing Leonor due to a lack of proof, he got 120 days of suspension from duties following an investigation by the equivalent of the IPPC. His appeal against that suspension (which can have financial consequences) was rejected. He resigned / retired shortly thereafter to write a book about the case, many aspects of which don't appear to be founded in the available factual evidence to double-check.

He is currently involved in trials involving numerous, serious, but unrelated allegations, regarding his subsequent activities related to a PT football club.

- There is also the issue of Vitor Tavares de Almeida in the Virgolino Borges torture case (which dates back to 2000), for which he got a suspended sentence and a daily fine to be paid to the victim of the beating. For some reason, this took 13 years to resolve.

http://www.dnoticias.pt/actualidade/pais/366745-dois-inspectores-da-pj-condenados

http://expresso.sapo.pt/sociedade/dois-inspetores-da-pj-condenados-por-tortura=f782292

IMO, the Portuguese authorities have made valiant attempts to move forward from past practices of a dubious nature in the past few years, so all kudos to their efforts. Changing institutional culture is complex and takes time.
« Last Edit: January 07, 2016, 12:25:49 PM by Carana »

Offline Brietta

Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
« Reply #283 on: January 07, 2016, 12:45:38 PM »
Erm, one doesn't.

- The allegations of torture concerning the Cipriano case date back to 2003.

Although Cristovão was acquitted of torturing Leonor due to a lack of proof, he got 120 days of suspension from duties following an investigation by the equivalent of the IPPC. His appeal against that suspension (which can have financial consequences) was rejected. He resigned / retired shortly thereafter to write a book about the case, many aspects of which don't appear to be founded in the available factual evidence to double-check.

He is currently involved in trials involving numerous, serious, but unrelated allegations, regarding his subsequent activities related to a PT football club.

- There is also the issue of Vitor Tavares de Almeida in the Virgolino Borges torture case (which dates back to 2000), for which he got a suspended sentence and a daily fine to be paid to the victim of the beating. For some reason, this took 13 years to resolve.

http://www.dnoticias.pt/actualidade/pais/366745-dois-inspectores-da-pj-condenados

http://expresso.sapo.pt/sociedade/dois-inspetores-da-pj-condenados-por-tortura=f782292

IMO, the Portuguese authorities have made valiant attempts to move forward from past practices of a dubious nature in the past few years, so all kudos to their efforts. Changing institutional culture is complex and takes time.

THE disgraced ex-boss of the Madeleine McCann probe has been charged with torturing a witness in another missing child case.

Goncalo Amaral, 49, is accused of punching and slapping Leandro Silva — who wants £430,000 compensation — during the 2004 hunt for Joana Cipriano, eight.
http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/madeleine/2512208/Maddie-cop-torture-rap.html


Portugal has indeed made huge strides in sorting out attitudes which appear to have been endemic in the culture of policing and public life.
Some of it down to 'the old order changeth ...' but mainly concerted effort and determination with people who once must have been untouchable facing the full force of the law and being prosecuted.

I think it is against much of the backdrop of the old culture that Madeleine's case was conducted with many of the old order still in positions of influence.
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

Offline Carana

Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
« Reply #284 on: January 07, 2016, 01:05:31 PM »
THE disgraced ex-boss of the Madeleine McCann probe has been charged with torturing a witness in another missing child case.

Goncalo Amaral, 49, is accused of punching and slapping Leandro Silva — who wants £430,000 compensation — during the 2004 hunt for Joana Cipriano, eight.
http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/madeleine/2512208/Maddie-cop-torture-rap.html


Portugal has indeed made huge strides in sorting out attitudes which appear to have been endemic in the culture of policing and public life.
Some of it down to 'the old order changeth ...' but mainly concerted effort and determination with people who once must have been untouchable facing the full force of the law and being prosecuted.

I think it is against much of the backdrop of the old culture that Madeleine's case was conducted with many of the old order still in positions of influence.


Yes, I agree that institutional change is a long process...

Concerning the allegations or charges mentioned in the press or in court rulings that I have mentioned above have nothing to do with the arrival on the scene of Aragão, who appears to be a somewhat controversial figure.