Author Topic: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?  (Read 345067 times)

0 Members and 6 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline slartibartfast

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #525 on: January 10, 2016, 03:56:49 PM »
so the new evidence would be the trigger

Let's look at an example...

Man A has been found guilty of Murder, with CCTV evidence, DNA traces at the scene and the murder weapon in his possession. Man B comes forward an confesses to the crime. Is an appeal allowed?
“Reasoning will never make a Man correct an ill Opinion, which by Reasoning he never acquired”.

Offline Mr Gray

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #526 on: January 10, 2016, 04:02:09 PM »
Let's look at an example...

Man A has been found guilty of Murder, with CCTV evidence, DNA traces at the scene and the murder weapon in his possession. Man B comes forward an confesses to the crime. Is an appeal allowed?

we would need a lot more information than that to make a decision...surely you realise that...does Mr B have a history of mental illness
« Last Edit: January 10, 2016, 04:11:05 PM by davel »

Offline Mr Gray

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #527 on: January 10, 2016, 04:34:33 PM »
Let's look at an example...

Man A has been found guilty of Murder, with CCTV evidence, DNA traces at the scene and the murder weapon in his possession. Man B comes forward an confesses to the crime. Is an appeal allowed?
try this one


Joanna Cipriano found alive....

Offline Mr Gray

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #528 on: January 10, 2016, 09:01:02 PM »
just saw this re Ched evans...

Lawyers for the footballer last year handed a file of new evidence to the Criminal Cases Review Commission in a bid to get his conviction overturned at the Court of Appeal


Offline mercury

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #529 on: January 10, 2016, 09:43:49 PM »
There's a lot of cod psychology out there, but I don't see what corroborates or refutes that alleged "red flag" in terms of expert evidence at the trial.

I only used those detalls as an example... the trial was riddled with uncorroborated / unchallenged statements taken as fact.


I found this interesting on detecting liars:

http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20150906-the-best-and-worst-ways-to-spot-a-liar

It is kind of interesting, but nothing more than clever and common sense interrogation or "free dialogue"

Paul Eckham has had alot of success in honing in on liars based on facial expressions and body language


Was this challenged in court?

How on earth would I know?

There is still the issue that a jury was assessing the evidence along with the judges. I haven't the faintest idea whether there was some from of screening in place (or what form it may have taken) to eliminate those who'd followed the pre-trial, largely pro-PJ, media coverage.

This appears to be an issue all over the world with the advent of 24/7 news coverage.

I have no idea how juries are chosen in Portugal. I cant imagine jurors would be excluded if they had watched the news....there would be no one left much lol

This is all so off topic now. Best discussed on the Cipriano board.


Why Mccann supporters support the convicted mother and uncle - lets be honest,  its not rocket science really.


Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #530 on: January 10, 2016, 10:09:17 PM »
The Rt Hon. Lord Justice Pill said  "The question for [the Court of Appeal’s] consideration is whether the conviction is safe and not whether the accused is guilty".

I kicked off with:
"Grounds for a criminal appeal must be based in law and not facts. In other words, an appeal allows a defendant to attack the judgment of the trial court on legal, not factual grounds".
It would seem to be pretty much the same in many countries.

http://criminal-law.freeadvice.com/criminal-law/criminal-law/grounds-for-criminal-appeal.htm



"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

Offline Mr Gray

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #531 on: January 10, 2016, 10:27:16 PM »
The Rt Hon. Lord Justice Pill said  "The question for [the Court of Appeal’s] consideration is whether the conviction is safe and not whether the accused is guilty".

I kicked off with:
"Grounds for a criminal appeal must be based in law and not facts. In other words, an appeal allows a defendant to attack the judgment of the trial court on legal, not factual grounds".
It would seem to be pretty much the same in many countries.

http://criminal-law.freeadvice.com/criminal-law/criminal-law/grounds-for-criminal-appeal.htm



what that is saying is that the court cannot re judge the facts as presented at the trial....it is a fact that appeals can be made on new evidence......

so if Joanna turned up ....would the fact that she is not actually dead have any relevance

Offline Carana

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #532 on: January 11, 2016, 12:21:29 PM »
My understanding is that

- If she turned up alive, then they could hardly stay in prison for her murder.

- If her remains were ever found, I assume that the investigation would have to be reopened.

However, it's possible (IMO) that any new evidence, per se, may not be sufficient to exonerate them. If it were to be conclusively proven that she had not been chopped up, then there's a problem with the "reconstruction"...

Offline Carana

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #533 on: January 11, 2016, 01:14:02 PM »

Why Mccann supporters support the convicted mother and uncle - lets be honest,  its not rocket science really.

Again, I can't answer for others.

Despite the torture aspect, I had assumed that they may well have been guilty until I started wading through the SC ruling to see what the evidence actually was. And that's when I realised just how flimsy the entire case was.

One could ask the question the other way around: why do so many of the sceptic community insist that they are necessarily guilty without thoroughly examining what the evidence actually was?


       

Offline jassi

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #534 on: January 11, 2016, 01:30:11 PM »
Again, I can't answer for others.

Despite the torture aspect, I had assumed that they may well have been guilty until I started wading through the SC ruling to see what the evidence actually was. And that's when I realised just how flimsy the entire case was.

One could ask the question the other way around: why do so many of the sceptic community insist that they are necessarily guilty without thoroughly examining what the evidence actually was?

One reason might be that they are not particularly interested in the case and are content to accept the verdict of the court.

     
I believe everything. And l believe nothing.
I suspect everyone. And l suspect no one.
I gather the facts, examine the clues... and before   you know it, the case is solved!"

Or maybe not -

OG have been pushed out by the Germans who have reserved all the deck chairs for the foreseeable future

Offline Carana

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #535 on: January 11, 2016, 01:42:30 PM »
@ Jassi


"One reason might be that they are not particularly interested in the case and are content to accept the verdict of the court."

As is their right. However, if they are not prepared to examine the evidence, it would be nice if the few who do bother were not assumed to be supporters of child murderers.

Offline Carana

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #536 on: January 11, 2016, 02:10:30 PM »


what that is saying is that the court cannot re judge the facts as presented at the trial....it is a fact that appeals can be made on new evidence......


so if Joanna turned up ....would the fact that she is not actually dead have any relevance

I have found a few points from the SC and the Penal Procedure Code on this, which I'll post later on the Joana board (which hardly anyone reads).

The bottom line seems to be:

- An appeal process in a trial involving a jury goes to the SC (the fact of having a jury is supposed to increase the reliability of the evaluation at the lower level). Fine, in theory, but it hardly takes into account the potential effect of a bombardment of pro-PJ coverage.

- Although normally the SC is only meant to consider matters of law, alleged anomalies in the appreciation of facts leading to the verdict can also be considered. An example given is when counter evidence is presented, but the jury / judges ignore it.

A problem in this case is that the defence appears to have been so sure that the case would be thrown out that little counter evidence was produced.

Although there is the obvious problem of attempting to prove a negative via the presentation of countering evidence, there were quite a few areas (IMO) in which the defence could have mounted a better case.


« Last Edit: January 11, 2016, 02:12:37 PM by Carana »

Offline Carana

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #537 on: January 11, 2016, 02:27:49 PM »
Let's look at an example...

Man A has been found guilty of Murder, with CCTV evidence, DNA traces at the scene and the murder weapon in his possession. Man B comes forward an confesses to the crime. Is an appeal allowed?

I don't see how that would automatically lead to the right to an appeal in PT.

It's a little far from the Cipriano case in any event, as in the case of "Man A" in the Cipriano case there was no CCTV evidence, no incriminating DNA found, and no murder weapon.

All there was was a "reconstruction", supposedly done of his "own free will".
« Last Edit: January 11, 2016, 02:32:35 PM by Carana »

Offline Brietta

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #538 on: January 11, 2016, 02:53:06 PM »
Again, I can't answer for others.

Despite the torture aspect, I had assumed that they may well have been guilty until I started wading through the SC ruling to see what the evidence actually was. And that's when I realised just how flimsy the entire case was.

One could ask the question the other way around: why do so many of the sceptic community insist that they are necessarily guilty without thoroughly examining what the evidence actually was?

My introduction to the Cipriano case was as a result of a septic (sic) on a Yahoo comment thread who attacked me with my 'support for child murderers' ... absolute nonsense since I had never heard of Joana ...

The description I was given was of a blood saturated scene with drag marks across the floor with the child's little bloody hand prints on the door jamb with one of her nails embedded in it such was her struggle to survive.

I thought "Wow!".

When I looked for information on the case, amongst the little I was able to locate, I discovered that the septic advice I had been given was so far from the truth that it ranks as being delusional if believed.

I decided at that point that there were people out there so stupid they were mouthing off on propaganda about which they knew nothing and cared even less whether it was accurate or not.

Which merely adds yet another layer to the parallels between the Cipriano and McCann cases which shrink the seven miles between them to a hairsbreadth.   
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

Offline Carana

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #539 on: January 11, 2016, 03:01:03 PM »
try this one...there are many more...
Suzanne Holdsworth served three years of a life sentence after she was convicted in 2005 of murdering Kyle Fisher, a neighbour's two-year-old son, by repeatedly banging his head against a wooden bannister at her home in Hartlepool. She was found not guilty in 2008 by the Court of Appeal after new medical evidence suggested Kyle may have died from an epileptic seizure.[59]

Just reading up and saw this.

I really don't know whether that would be sufficient in a PT court at this stage. As no trace of the child was ever found, there is no way of ascertaining what she may have died of - if ever she did indeed die (of which there is no proof, either).

The irrefutable fact in this case is that João took part in this "reconstruction", and there was no evidence to support that it was against his will.

As he apparently implicated Leonor in this, she was deemed present and guilty as well - even though she didn't take part in it.