what that is saying is that the court cannot re judge the facts as presented at the trial....it is a fact that appeals can be made on new evidence......
so if Joanna turned up ....would the fact that she is not actually dead have any relevance
I have found a few points from the SC and the Penal Procedure Code on this, which I'll post later on the Joana board (which hardly anyone reads).
The bottom line seems to be:
- An appeal process in a trial involving a jury goes to the SC (the fact of having a jury is supposed to increase the reliability of the evaluation at the lower level). Fine, in theory, but it hardly takes into account the potential effect of a bombardment of pro-PJ coverage.
- Although normally the SC is only meant to consider matters of law, alleged anomalies in the appreciation of facts leading to the verdict can also be considered. An example given is when counter evidence is presented, but the jury / judges ignore it.
A problem in this case is that the defence appears to have been so sure that the case would be thrown out that little counter evidence was produced.
Although there is the obvious problem of attempting to prove a negative via the presentation of countering evidence, there were quite a few areas (IMO) in which the defence could have mounted a better case.