Incest was given as the motive. It's incredible to think that with the motive itself thrown out of court and no credible forensic evidence - there was still a guilty verdict.
Although IIRC the smear campaign against LC via the press was so successful that a baying mob arrived at the court. It would have been a brave juror IMO who would have given a 'Not guilty' verdict in the face of such massive public outrage. So much for the Secrecy laws.
(from memory so am happy to be corrected if necessary)
I'm not sure whether a proven motive was necessary. In some jurisdictions, it isn't: you just have to prove the facts and the motive is an added extra if there is one.
However, the concepts of incest and a Cinderalla abused waif can easily lead to a collective sense of outrage. The problem is that neither appear to be founded in fact, but it was too late.
The "reconstruction" was obviously the "ace" and it had its effect. The fact that João couldn't quite work out how to get the bits of the doll to fit into the freezer until it was pointed out to him went over the heads of those who were judging.