Author Topic: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?  (Read 345116 times)

0 Members and 4 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Mr Gray

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #720 on: January 13, 2016, 06:46:23 PM »
Incest was given as the motive.   It's incredible to think that with the motive itself  thrown out of court and no credible forensic evidence - there was still a guilty verdict.

Although IIRC the smear campaign against LC via the press was so successful that a baying mob arrived at the court.   It would have been a brave juror IMO who would have given a 'Not guilty' verdict in the face of such massive public outrage.   So much for the Secrecy laws.

(from memory so am happy to be corrected if necessary)



 

so how fair was the verdict when the jurors may well have read all the lies written in the papers

Offline Carana

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #721 on: January 13, 2016, 06:48:48 PM »
Guilhermino da Encarnação: "This is extremely difficult because, in 30 years of criminal investigation, I've never seen the confession of such a serious crime without the arguidos saying they were tortured, attacked or raped so that this, for us police officers, and I tell you, unfortunately, it has become the norm, natural. Therefore I don't give it a lot of credence."

does this statement not confirm that the confession was a result of the beating

I doubt it.

What he seems to be saying is the opposite: anyone who confesses then backtracks.

As there is no CCTV of time in custody, there is no way of determining what transpired during interrogations.

Offline Eleanor

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #722 on: January 13, 2016, 06:50:06 PM »
Incest was given as the motive.   It's incredible to think that with the motive itself  thrown out of court and no credible forensic evidence - there was still a guilty verdict.

Although IIRC the smear campaign against LC via the press was so successful that a baying mob arrived at the court.   It would have been a brave juror IMO who would have given a 'Not guilty' verdict in the face of such massive public outrage.   So much for the Secrecy laws.

(from memory so am happy to be corrected if necessary)


 

No.  You are absolutely right.  The Media Campaign, from details leaked by The PJ, well took care of The Jury.

Offline Carana

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #723 on: January 13, 2016, 06:56:41 PM »
so the court accepted as proved that the blood was Joanna's even though there was no DNA match...bizarre

The general idea of accepting something as fact under the rules of  "common experience" is that you don't need to present an astrophysicist to testify that under normal conditions of natural light that midnight is likely to be darker than midday.


Fine.

By extension, it can extend to other details that can be assumed to be true without the need for expert testimony.

However.... one may question just how elastic this degree of latitude should be.
« Last Edit: January 13, 2016, 07:03:30 PM by Carana »

Offline Mr Gray

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #724 on: January 13, 2016, 07:02:45 PM »
The general idea of accepting something as fact under the rules of  "common experience" is that you don't need to present an astrophysicist to testify that under normal conditions of natural light that midnight is likely to darker than midday.


Fine.

By extension, it can extend to other details that can be assumed to be true without the need for expert testimony.

However.... one may question just how elastic this degree of latitude should be.

would that explain the list of proven facts in the libel trial

Offline Carana

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #725 on: January 13, 2016, 07:05:17 PM »
would that explain the list of proven facts in the libel trial

Not ALL are listed as facts under the rules of common experience, but some of the ones that were defy my best attempts at deciphering the logic.


ETA: Don't forget the trial only lasted for 20 hours...


ETA2. Re the libel trial... I can't remember anything out of the ordinary in terms of common experience in that one.
« Last Edit: January 13, 2016, 07:09:06 PM by Carana »

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #726 on: January 13, 2016, 07:21:41 PM »
This thread really emphasises all roo well, how mccann supporters support the verdict against Amaral, but not against a convicted murderer and perjured.

Fascinating.

Offline Carana

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #727 on: January 13, 2016, 07:24:06 PM »
Incest was given as the motive.   It's incredible to think that with the motive itself  thrown out of court and no credible forensic evidence - there was still a guilty verdict.

Although IIRC the smear campaign against LC via the press was so successful that a baying mob arrived at the court.   It would have been a brave juror IMO who would have given a 'Not guilty' verdict in the face of such massive public outrage.   So much for the Secrecy laws.

(from memory so am happy to be corrected if necessary)

 


I'm not sure whether a proven motive was necessary. In some jurisdictions, it isn't: you just have to prove the facts and the motive is an added extra if there is one.

However, the concepts of incest and a Cinderalla abused waif can easily lead to a collective sense of outrage. The problem is that neither appear to be founded in fact, but it was too late.

The "reconstruction" was obviously the "ace" and it had its effect. The fact that João couldn't quite work out how to get the bits of the doll to fit into the freezer until it was pointed out to him went over the heads of those who were judging.

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #728 on: January 13, 2016, 07:32:06 PM »
What has been made quite evident in the Cipriano case, is that her word can't be trusted.

She has told numerous lies and been found out.
« Last Edit: January 13, 2016, 11:44:19 PM by Admin »

Offline Carana

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #729 on: January 13, 2016, 07:35:44 PM »
This thread really emphasises all roo well, how mccann supporters support the verdict against Amaral, but not against a convicted murderer and perjured.

Fascinating.

I find that it points out why it shouldn't be assumed that a miscarriage of justice can be dismissed in the Cipriano case.

I most certainly haven't laid all the blame at Amaral's door.

 As far as I can see, the case should not have been accepted for trial in the first place, whatever his "evidence", and a murder trial lasting only 20 hours with such flimsy evidence appears to be more than dodgy. But Amaral isn't responsible for all of that.

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #730 on: January 13, 2016, 07:38:36 PM »
I find that it points out why it shouldn't be assumed that a miscarriage of justice can be dismissed in the Cipriano case.

I most certainly haven't laid all the blame at Amaral's door.

 As far as I can see, the case should not have been accepted for trial in the first place, whatever his "evidence", and a murder trial lasting only 20 hours with such flimsy evidence appears to be more than dodgy. But Amaral isn't responsible for all of that.

That can also be replied to Amaral's conviction.
« Last Edit: January 13, 2016, 11:55:27 PM by Admin »

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #731 on: January 13, 2016, 07:41:48 PM »
Well it was proved that all her shoes were at home, if I recall correctly it was an aunt who went through the house checking.  Maybe she went out barefeet?

How do you prove that?

How do you prove that there was not one pair of shoes, not at home, that she was wearing when she went missing?

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #732 on: January 13, 2016, 07:48:53 PM »
I doubt it.

What he seems to be saying is the opposite: anyone who confesses then backtracks.

As there is no CCTV of time in custody, there is no way of determining what transpired during interrogations.

Well, the bruising was either imposed by make-up artists or, inflicted by torture ....

Offline Carana

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #733 on: January 13, 2016, 07:58:23 PM »
Well, the bruising was either imposed by make-up artists or, inflicted by torture ....

I think that the reference to a comment made by the former head of Faro was in general terms.

Until every moment that a person is in custody is recorded audiovisually, anyone can claim anything.

A recommendation was issued fairly recently (a few years ago) to make an audio recording of formal interviews of arguidos. A step forward, if that's put into practice, but what about the "non-formal" ones?

Offline Carana

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #734 on: January 13, 2016, 08:00:56 PM »
That  an also be replied to Amaral's conviction.

Which conviction?