Author Topic: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?  (Read 345114 times)

0 Members and 4 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Admin

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #1320 on: January 19, 2016, 05:00:57 PM »
I think this thread has strayed significantly. It is not about the Cipiano case as such but the way in which it plays a significant part in some people's view of the McCann case.

It is quite strange how many internet search for cases involving the disappearance or murder of a kid in the last 10 years seems to pull up significant numbers of McCann links. The Swiss case being an example.

It is my intention to edit out the off topic posts on this thread and remove the relevant content to the Cipriano board.

Offline Carana

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #1321 on: January 19, 2016, 05:19:39 PM »
Common Experience as in US law would appear to extend beyond your description.
It is covered in section 6.17 of Criminal Evidence by Jefferson Ingram for anyone who is interested.

I find this to be apposite.
"Observers of criminal trials are often confused by the procedures concerning the admission and exclusion of evidence. The form of the objections offered and the arguments presented only add to the confusion. Logically assuming that the purpose of a trial is to seek the truth, the lay observer is likely to be bewildered by objections to the introduction of apparently relevant evidence. Sometimes evidence that could have a direct bearing on the case, in fact, is excluded at the trial. To understand why certain evidence is admitted and other evidence is excluded, it is necessary to study the history and evolution of the rules of evidence".


That happened in the Jo Yeates case... but I think that we're discussing apples and oranges.

In the UK:
One issue appears to be what can be admitted as evidence for a jury to consider (the fact that Tabak had been viewing extreme pornography just prior to the events was considered to be off limits).

An out-of-date concept appears to be that the media are gagged from mentioning prior convictions - which anyone can google for themselves these days.

The reasoning, I presume, is to make the jury focus on the facts of the trial at hand and to avoid being influenced by potential prejudice.

None of that appears to be relevant to the concept of the "rules of common experience" in PT law, as far as I understand it. That seems to concern what any reasonable person could consider to be established fact. I simpy can't understand how the "facts" deemed to be proven under that premise equate to everyday experience of life.

I can understand one or two, but not the rest.

A body doesn't ooze much blood two hours after death... ok. But no one seems to have considered that, according to the reconstruction, the torso was sawn in half in the middle of the living room.

That would have to be one enormous clean-up job without anyone else noticing...

Does anyone seriously believe that blood would be the only substance to consider if that scenario had happened?

An unidentified and undated speck of blood at the back of a single fridge/freezer drawer is somehow proof of this? Seriously? That none of the occupants / visitors to this small home noticed that the fridge /freezer had been emptied?


Offline Mr Gray

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #1322 on: January 19, 2016, 05:34:14 PM »
I think this thread has strayed significantly. It is not about the Cipiano case as such but the way in which it plays a significant part in some people's view of the McCann case.

It is quite strange how many internet search for cases involving the disappearance or murder of a kid in the last 10 years seems to pull up significant numbers of McCann links. The Swiss case being an example.


the tread title is....Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?....the answer some of us have given is the evidence...that is then challenged...I agree the thread is a complete waste of time


i think an interesting question would be ..."why is there no support for cipriano from mccann sceptics"
« Last Edit: January 19, 2016, 05:38:23 PM by davel »

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #1323 on: January 19, 2016, 05:35:37 PM »
In the majority of missing child cases both parents are complicit so not sure what your point is.

As to your second point, we have an outcome to this trial and the fact that Joao had already been involved in a case of attempted murder simply reinforces that verdict.
Would you kindly expand on this point, with cites please - many thanks.

Offline slartibartfast

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #1324 on: January 19, 2016, 05:40:52 PM »

the tread title is....Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?....the answer some of us have given is the evidence...that is then challenged...I agree the thread is a complete waste of time


i think an interesting question would be ..."why is there no support for cipriano from mccann sceptics"

The argument from supporters is a lack of compelling evidence, the question is why is it predominantly only the supporters who think that?
“Reasoning will never make a Man correct an ill Opinion, which by Reasoning he never acquired”.

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #1325 on: January 19, 2016, 05:43:37 PM »
The argument from supporters is a lack of compelling evidence, the question is why is it predominantly only the supporters who think that?
Because the "sceptics" can't bear the thought that Amaral, the PJ and the Portuguese justice system are anything less than perfect. 

Offline slartibartfast

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #1326 on: January 19, 2016, 05:47:08 PM »
Because the "sceptics" can't bear the thought that Amaral, the PJ and the Portuguese justice system are anything less than perfect.

Not true and is the equivalent of ...

...and the supporters can't bear the thought that Amaral, the PJ and the Portuguese justice system got anything right.

Bit of a stalemate really.
“Reasoning will never make a Man correct an ill Opinion, which by Reasoning he never acquired”.

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #1327 on: January 19, 2016, 05:47:19 PM »
Because the "sceptics" can't bear the thought that Amaral, the PJ and the Portuguese justice system are anything less than perfect.

Wrong again alfred.

It is how you view the mccanns.


Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #1328 on: January 19, 2016, 05:47:29 PM »
Apposite in what sense, Alice?   Maybe I have misunderstood but I am not sure what relevance US law has in this context.  The rules of evidence in an inquisitorial system are rather different.

But in any event it underlines the importance of having a good lawyer.
Apposite in the sense that if I said tell us the difference between Euler-Bernoulli theory of beams and that of Tim O'Shenko several of the usual suspects would post reams of learned looking stuff but it's doubtful they would know what they were bleedin' well talking about. Expand along those lines.

I agree with the bold bit. But some would hire Michelangelo to paint the church ceiling then have the choirboys suggest improvements.
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

Offline Mr Gray

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #1329 on: January 19, 2016, 05:47:53 PM »
The argument from supporters is a lack of compelling evidence, the question is why is it predominantly only the supporters who think that?

I think everyone agrees apart from the confessions the evidence is not compelling. The question could also be asked as to why sceptics think she is definitely guilty and there is no chance of a miscarriage of justice. I would feel just the same about the case if amaral was not involved

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #1330 on: January 19, 2016, 05:51:39 PM »
Not true and is the equivalent of ...

...and the supporters can't bear the thought that Amaral, the PJ and the Portuguese justice system got anything right.

Bit of a stalemate really.
You claim it is only McCann supporters who believe that there may have been a potential miscarriage of justice but is that true?  How do we know who suspects a miscarriage of justice in this instance?  Isn't it possible that people with no opinion on the McCann case, or even McCann sceptics in Portugal may believe this case stinks like a kipper?  In fact, I'm sure I have in the past read comments by Portuguese nationals to that effect online, but find them now I cannot.

Offline slartibartfast

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #1331 on: January 19, 2016, 05:56:16 PM »
I think everyone agrees apart from the confessions the evidence is not compelling. The question could also be asked as to why sceptics think she is definitely guilty and there is no chance of a miscarriage of justice. I would feel just the same about the case if amaral was not involved

But would you be interested in it?
“Reasoning will never make a Man correct an ill Opinion, which by Reasoning he never acquired”.

Offline Mr Gray

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #1332 on: January 19, 2016, 05:57:25 PM »
But would you be interested in it?

yes...just as I am interested in a recent case elswhere...

A court in Thailand has convicted a pair of Burmese men of the murder of two young British tourists on the holiday island of Koh Tao, a verdict described as just by one victim’s family but condemned as deeply flawed by human rights groups.
« Last Edit: January 19, 2016, 06:00:28 PM by davel »

Offline slartibartfast

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #1333 on: January 19, 2016, 06:00:28 PM »
yes...just as I am interested in a recent case elswhere

Anything that we could agree on?
“Reasoning will never make a Man correct an ill Opinion, which by Reasoning he never acquired”.

Offline Mr Gray

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #1334 on: January 19, 2016, 06:01:52 PM »
Anything that we could agree on?

perhaps...I have added to the post...they both confessed........staged a reconstruction showing how they did it...then withdrew their confessions.....