Wandering Off Topic

[G-Unit]

The twice translated unreliable statements, you mean?

Which, nevertheless, both the McCanns and SY had translated.

[Mr Gray]

It's means exactly what it says  CB cannot be placed in Luz on the night of 3/05/2007, so what are the odds he wasn't  involved in an alleged abduction.

Your logic is clearly totally flawed. CB may well have been in Luz that night

[Vertigo Swirl]

Your logic is clearly totally flawed. CB may well have been in Luz that night

that's the polite way of putting it. 

[Vertigo Swirl]

Which, nevertheless, both the McCanns and SY had translated.

Yes, and apparently found plenty of errors and discrepancies.  Have you been privy to the properly translated files?

[Vertigo Swirl]

Quite. You 'believe' that they investigated the evidence against the McCanns and dismissed it, because you 'believe' that they are experts. You don't know that's what they did.

Do you think it's wrong to believe the Met are the experts when it comes to investigating crimes, particular when comparing them to someone like yourself?

[Eleanor]

I thought that Scotland Yard and The McCanns had The Files independently translated, each to their own cost.

During the questioning of Kate and Gerry McCann, independently, there was no check on the accuracy.

We still don't know what was asked or what was answered.

[Vertigo Swirl]

To paraphrase Michael Gove "sceptics have had enough of experts".  Who needs 'em when Barrier, Spam and G-Unit are on the case.  We post amongst intellectual giants.  Truly humbled.   

[Wonderfulspam]

To paraphrase Michael Gove "sceptics have had enough of experts".  Who needs 'em when Barrier, Spam and G-Unit are on the case.  We post amongst intellectual giants.  Truly humbled.   

We're all going to left looking pretty foolish when Brueckner is finally prosecuted, shouldn't be much longer now. 

[barrier]

Your logic is clearly totally flawed. CB may well have been in Luz that night

Wolters is on record as saying CB cannot be placed there, so its your logic that is screwed.

[Eleanor]

Wolters is on record as saying CB cannot be placed there, so its your logic that is screwed.

Cannot be placed there does not mean that he wasn't there.

I had begun to hope that the understanding of The English Language was improving.

[Wonderfulspam]

Cannot be placed there does not mean that he wasn't there.

I had begun to hope that the understanding of The English Language was improving.

Do you have any evidence he was there though, or must we just presume so out of necessity?

[Vertigo Swirl]

Wolters is on record as saying CB cannot be placed there, so its your logic that is screwed.

LOL. 

[Eleanor]

LOL.

LOL is about it these days.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Cannot be placed there does not mean that he wasn't there.

I had begun to hope that the understanding of The English Language was improving.

Sceptic logic = if the Germans can’t prove CB was in PdL on the night of 3rd May then it proved Madeleine wasn’t abducted.   

[Eleanor]

Sceptic logic = if the Germans can’t prove CB was in PdL on the night of 3rd May then it proved Madeleine wasn’t abducted.   

LOL.