Wandering Off Topic

[Mr Gray]

And he’d be absolutely right to.

The problem for Grime would be that every point I've made about him is backed by solid evidence... Unlike his dog alerts

[faithlilly]

The problem for Grime would be that every point I've made about him is backed by solid evidence... Unlike his dog alerts

Grime has said everything he needed to say in his report.

I’m afraid his expert status trumps some random dog-botherer on the internet every time.

[Mr Gray]

Grime has said everything he needed to say in his report.

I’m afraid his expert status trumps some random dog-botherer on the internet every time.

I don't see that it does... His expert status does not seem to have helped his career much. I'm sure he thought Jersey was the start... Not the end

[faithlilly]

I don't see that it does... His expert status does not seem to have helped his career much. I'm sure he thought Jersey was the start... Not the end

The fact that he’s looked on as an expert proves otherwise.

[Mr Gray]

The fact that he’s looked on as an expert proves otherwise.

doesnt prove anything...maybe evidence...but not proof...post shipman

[Vertigo Swirl]

Grime has said everything he needed to say in his report.

I’m afraid his expert status trumps some random dog-botherer on the internet every time.

Funny how little value some people put on expertise vs random anonymous armchair detectives when it suits them though isn’t it?  Such as the expertise of the German investigators and prosecutor in collecting and assessing evidence.   

[faithlilly]

doesnt prove anything...maybe evidence...but not proof...post shipman

So what do you believe…that Grime said that alerts needed to be corroborated by forensic evidence so was competent or that Eddie alerted to cadaver odour so is incompetent?

[faithlilly]

Funny how little value some people put on expertise vs random anonymous armchair detectives when it suits them though isn’t it?  Such as the expertise of the German investigators and prosecutor in collecting and assessing evidence.

And how’s that collecting and assessing of evidence going? What’s it been now…5 years?

[Vertigo Swirl]

And how’s that collecting and assessing of evidence going? What’s it been now…5 years?

It’s going great guns, don’t you worry.

[faithlilly]

It’s going great guns, don’t you worry.

Good to hear….won’t be long now…tick tock.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Good to hear….won’t be long now…tick tock.

Indeed, oh ye of little faithlilly.

[Mr Gray]

So what do you believe…that Grime said that alerts needed to be corroborated by forensic evidence so was competent or that Eddie alerted to cadaver odour so is incompetent?

I object to him saying Eddie had never given a false positive... I object to him saying he didn't know the Renault was the mccanns car.. I object to him calling back Eddie when he had twice shown no interest.. Same in the apartment... I object to him promoting the alerts as reliable when the idea of using the dogs in this way was relatively new and untried... And more... All objections evidenced based..

[Rossb]

I have a bit of a mental blank here. The EVRD dog which specifically scents cadaver odour, also scented blood. Can someone remind me of the dog made a distinct bark or anything else to separate cadaver from blood. Also if I am right, specific to Madeleines blood was not proved to be hers. And finally how can you theories and accident and be so sure of it over pre meditated murder? Insane.

[Vertigo Swirl]

I have a bit of a mental blank here. The EVRD dog which specifically scents cadaver odour, also scented blood. Can someone remind me of the dog made a distinct bark or anything else to separate cadaver from blood. Also if I am right, specific to Madeleines blood was not proved to be hers. And finally how can you theories and accident and be so sure of it over pre meditated murder? Insane.

I’ve been making that last point for years.  Why are most sceptics convinced Madeleine had an accident and wasn’t murdered in cold blood by her parents?  Only Spam reckons it was murder (but he doesn’t really, he’s just trolling). 

[Rossb]

I’ve been making that last point for years.  Why are most sceptics convinced Madeleine had an accident and wasn’t murdered in cold blood by her parents?  Only Spam reckons it was murder (but he doesn’t really, he’s just trolling).

No one has been given a specific answer to accident. From sedation of a 3 year old who would wake up. Doubt it. Why not murder, no real blood splatter found to indicate how or what happened. They are both sociopaths and psychopaths and have the Illuminati and government secrets! Given their personalities as just mentioned surely that would indicate you could be a child murderer. A suppose it was all a plot for a new kitchen and extension.