Author Topic: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample  (Read 26971 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Robittybob1

Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
« Reply #75 on: August 24, 2016, 09:25:01 AM »
No, I'm not, but we haven't got the fine detail available to us anyway.

DNA analysis produces raw data, the results of which  are subject to interpretation by experts.
In court cases, this interpretation is regularly challenged by other experts.
The general public do not have access to the data and can only rely on what the experts say.
When the DNA has a mixed source 2 or 3 individual contributing the DNA  (as was the case) even the experts can't tell if there is a match.
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

Offline jassi

Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
« Reply #76 on: August 24, 2016, 09:29:31 AM »
Allegedly, though different experts will always give different opinions.

As far as I'm aware, we only have Lowe's reports to go on. If there were ever to be a court case, I'm sure other experts would be produced to dispute his interpretation.
I believe everything. And l believe nothing.
I suspect everyone. And l suspect no one.
I gather the facts, examine the clues... and before   you know it, the case is solved!"

Or maybe not -

OG have been pushed out by the Germans who have reserved all the deck chairs for the foreseeable future

Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
« Reply #77 on: August 24, 2016, 09:49:13 AM »
Allegedly, though different experts will always give different opinions.

As far as I'm aware, we only have Lowe's reports to go on. If there were ever to be a court case, I'm sure other experts would be produced to dispute his interpretation.

This is true. For every expert that says "A" another will say "B".
That's why courts in general like to "do" law not science.
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

Offline Robittybob1

Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
« Reply #78 on: August 24, 2016, 12:34:35 PM »
This is true. For every expert that says "A" another will say "B".
That's why courts in general like to "do" law not science.
There will be debatable points but a strong DNA match is not argued.
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

Offline jassi

Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
« Reply #79 on: August 24, 2016, 01:10:23 PM »
There will be debatable points but a strong DNA match is not argued.

Its significance to the case may well be.

If a person's DNA is found somewhere that it shouldn't be, then that is significant.
If that DNA is not found where it should be, then that is also significant.
DNA found where it would be expected,  to be found , however strong a match, would not be significant.

Added - Everything dependent upon the quality and integrity  of the sample and the analytical procedure .

« Last Edit: August 24, 2016, 01:20:56 PM by jassi »
I believe everything. And l believe nothing.
I suspect everyone. And l suspect no one.
I gather the facts, examine the clues... and before   you know it, the case is solved!"

Or maybe not -

OG have been pushed out by the Germans who have reserved all the deck chairs for the foreseeable future

Offline Robittybob1

Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
« Reply #80 on: August 24, 2016, 01:34:12 PM »
Its significance to the case may well be.

If a person's DNA is found somewhere that it shouldn't be, then that is significant.
If that DNA is not found where it should be, then that is also significant.
DNA found where it would be expected,  to be found , however strong a match, would not be significant.

Added - Everything dependent upon the quality and integrity  of the sample and the analytical procedure .
That was a great post, a bit like the way I do it breaking it down into options.
As I read today it was that when they do DNA tests using the low copy number (LCN) method they can't tell where the DNA comes from.  Like you can't say it came from blood or it came from thaw drip (ex-frozen cadaver) so you can never tell whether it was in the tissue it was supposed to be.
I might have said that wrong for if they found her DNA match in a place where she had never visited that place could be significant.
« Last Edit: August 24, 2016, 01:54:13 PM by Robittybob1 »
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

Offline jassi

Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
« Reply #81 on: August 24, 2016, 02:01:45 PM »
So if, for example, her DNA was found in an apartment where she had not been know to have visited, you would say that was of no significance and wouldn't warrant investigation?
I believe everything. And l believe nothing.
I suspect everyone. And l suspect no one.
I gather the facts, examine the clues... and before   you know it, the case is solved!"

Or maybe not -

OG have been pushed out by the Germans who have reserved all the deck chairs for the foreseeable future

Offline Robittybob1

Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
« Reply #82 on: August 24, 2016, 03:10:21 PM »
So if, for example, her DNA was found in an apartment where she had not been know to have visited, you would say that was of no significance and wouldn't warrant investigation?
Yes in that case it would be significant.
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

Offline Carana

Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
« Reply #83 on: August 25, 2016, 07:32:51 AM »
If the DNA was a full match then the cadaver would have been Madeleine's as you say.
The DNA wasn't a full match, but the cadaver dog still alerted to a cadaver, so to me that means the cadaver was a closely related person to Madeleine using the same logic.

That doesn't necessarily follow.

The dog MAY have reacted to the scent of a dead person, just as he may have reacted to other substances within his training parameters. Aside from dried blood from a living person, Grime hasn't specified what other decaying human substances he would react to. For instance, he stated that Keela required the physical presence of blood to react, but he doesn't specify whether or not Eddie would react to molecules of blood that were airborne. There is still a question mark (IMO) concerning when Eddie reacted to sex clean-up tissues in Jersey and noted that his reaction was within his "training parameters", whether he meant that Eddie would react to decomposing sex fluids or whether he was referring to a speck of blood found on them (as Keela also reacted).

Therefore... it doesn't seem logical to me to assume that Eddie necessarily reacted to the scent of a deceased human being (whoever that might have been).

Ironically, the place in which the greatest amount of alleles compatible with hers was found is somewhere he didn't even react to.

Offline Carana

Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
« Reply #84 on: August 25, 2016, 07:36:42 AM »
The problem is that no DNA data is available for scrutiny.
All we have are interpretations by the scientists who looked at the results.

There is some (there are 3 profiles in the files), but I agree, not enough relevant profiles. In theory, those profiles shouldn't have been released with the files in the first place.


ETA:

Correction: there is a third profile, besides M's one. A DNA result from the apartment in Burgau. But it also belongs to a male, and can't be Gerry either.
« Last Edit: August 25, 2016, 11:03:09 AM by Carana »

Offline Carana

Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
« Reply #85 on: August 25, 2016, 07:46:55 AM »
So if, for example, her DNA was found in an apartment where she had not been know to have visited, you would say that was of no significance and wouldn't warrant investigation?

Yes, of course, it would be potentially significant. But even then, there might be innocent explanations to explore: her siblings could have been in that other apartment and her siblings' clothes might have been dumped in the same spot for whatever reason, a toy or a piece of clothing could have been lent to the occupant of the other apartment, her parents could have touched the same spot, etc. 

It would be much more significant if a full and uncontaminated match had been found in a place with no known potentially innocent explanation.

Offline jassi

Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
« Reply #86 on: August 25, 2016, 09:02:16 AM »
There is some (there are 3 profiles in the files), but I agree, not enough relevant profiles. In theory, those profiles shouldn't have been released with the files in the first place.

We can't examine these profiles and make our own judgments, only go by what the written report about them says says.
I believe everything. And l believe nothing.
I suspect everyone. And l suspect no one.
I gather the facts, examine the clues... and before   you know it, the case is solved!"

Or maybe not -

OG have been pushed out by the Germans who have reserved all the deck chairs for the foreseeable future

Offline Carana

Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
« Reply #87 on: August 25, 2016, 10:06:17 AM »
We can't examine these profiles and make our own judgments, only go by what the written report about them says says.

Three DNA profiles are posted in the files, Jassi. Madeleine's, the Gordon baby and an unknown male profile found in a car (which I presume to be the Scenic).

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MADELEINES_DNA.htm#oa1v1p275

ETA: And another male DNA profile from a flat in Burgau.
And go right down near the bottom of
 http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/PORTUGUESE-FORENSIC.htm#p11p2983

3- Study of the nuclear DNA

Autosomic STRs results were obtained from the following vestigios: root of one of the hairs collected from the bedroom floor of the Burgau apartment (Vg3) and in the lower zone of te fibre from the car boot. Table 1 includes, also, the profile of the spot from the counterpane, already sent previously.

Table 1 - Autosomic STRs of vestigios.


« Last Edit: August 25, 2016, 05:20:43 PM by Carana »

Offline jassi

Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
« Reply #88 on: August 25, 2016, 10:11:20 AM »
You misunderstand me.

These are merely reports of findings, which we have to accept as true.
 Unless you have managed to hack into the various DNA data banks, you have nothing to compare them with.
I believe everything. And l believe nothing.
I suspect everyone. And l suspect no one.
I gather the facts, examine the clues... and before   you know it, the case is solved!"

Or maybe not -

OG have been pushed out by the Germans who have reserved all the deck chairs for the foreseeable future

Offline Carana

Re: Were the heal prick blood samples of MM used as a reference DNA sample
« Reply #89 on: August 25, 2016, 10:43:44 AM »
You misunderstand me.

These are merely reports of findings, which we have to accept as true.
 Unless you have managed to hack into the various DNA data banks, you have nothing to compare them with.

They look incredibly like actual DNA results to me...

They aren't of much use in terms of the case as the male profiles aren't relevant, but I found them useful for anyone trying to understand the general gist of DNA profiles.