Author Topic: Was it all Amaral's fault?  (Read 45365 times)

0 Members and 7 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline G-Unit

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #270 on: September 15, 2016, 03:26:19 PM »
You don't think that evidence given by the parents that they left the window shut and returned to find it open would be evidence of a break in to be considered then?  The once shut, subsequently opened window wouldn't even merit a mention in court in your view?  OK, if you say so.... &%+((£

I've given my opinion. If you disagree feel free to post how you think it might come in useful in a trial.

Defendant is accused of opening the window, shutters, etc..
Answer; I didn't open them.
McCanns; We saw them open.
Defendant's lawyer; That doesn't mean the defendant opened them.

Defender is accused of lifting a child out of the window;
Answer; I didn't.
McCanns; We saw it open.
Defendant's lawyer; So?

Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline Brietta

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #271 on: September 15, 2016, 03:41:14 PM »
He was part of a team, but for some reason he was the one singled out and vilified by the (mostly) UK media;

Conversation among policemen... ASFIC-PJ Blog (union of the PJ)

Thursday, July 3, 2008
Thanks to Astro for translation

Well, approximately one year ago, we all watched, stupefied, a sort of spectacle that had until then been unheard of, among us. Like in the witch hunts of the past, a certain media (mainly English, but unfortunately not only that) destroyed a Man from the Portuguese Polícia Judiciária in public. A high-ranking Criminal Investigation career official. A colleague and a friend to so many of us. A character assassination like no other employee of this House had ever been a victim of, before. And why?

Because, as had always been his hallmark, Dr. Gonçalo Amaral, a Polícia Judiciária Criminal Investigation Coordinator, went to fight, committed himself, faced, bravely and decidedly, the difficulties and the setbacks of a service case that is extremely complex and whose outlines are still undefined, and may remain so forever.

Maybe for the first time in the Polícia Judiciária's History, an investigator is exposed in public and his private life is rummaged. Merely because he was investigating a certain suspicious case. Because he was working. Maybe the Portuguese State, the Public Administration, our Polícia Judiciária, should have mechanisms in place to protect its representatives in situations like this one. In order to safeguard them as they carry out their professional activity for the benefit of Public Service. Maybe all of us, colleagues in profession, should have stood up, and honouring the so famous, so traditional and so bandied about "Esprit de Corps" that they say is characteristic of our "House", should have somehow manifested our support of Dr. Gonçalo Amaral.

None of that happened. Gonçalo was alone.

João Fernandes Figueira
A.S.F.I.C./P.J. member nr. 711

It was precisely due to the lack of support by those above him and the need to defend himself that Amaral resigned and wrote his book. He says so in the Foreword. Perhaps if the media had restrained itself he never would have written it.

Goncalo Amaral was the architect of his own misfortune which would have been fine had he stopped there; unfortunately his undoubted effect on the lives of those others we know about could be considered catastrophic.

His suspicions of all and sundry must surely have had a negative effect on the investigation into Madeleine McCann's case; none more so perhaps than deploying scarce resources to keep an eye on British officers thus taking much needed personnel away from work on the ground was a seriously flawed decision.

His rant to the Portuguese journalist was unprofessional to say the least ... what a pity his feelings that he had to defend himself from "those above him" was the excuse for further unprofessional behaviour.

Who do you think his book was targeting ~ his superiors who had let him down or the McCanns who had refused to roll over and 'confess' which would indeed have been abandoning Madeleine, while doing his career a bit of good.

After all who could have dared to sack him ignominiously with another 'solved' missing child case safely under his belt. 
 


Madeleine McCann chief detective sacked

By Aislinn Simpson in Praia da Luz 5:56PM BST  02 Oct 2007

The Portuguese detective leading the Madeleine McCann investigation has been sacked from the inquiry after launching an astonishing public attack on his British counterparts.

Chief Inspector Goncalo Amaral, 47, was dismissed from the position by the national director of the Judicial Police.

He had accused British detectives of only chasing leads Gerry and Kate McCann want followed up.

The move came after Portugal's Justice Minister Alberto Costa stepped into the row by insisting there is "fruitful cooperation" between the two countries' police forces over the inquiry.

Mr Costa said Portuguese police intend "to increase the collaboration" with their British counterparts and that the important thing is "to concentrate on the job and not on the comments" made by Mr Amaral.

Mr Amaral, who was jointly in charge of the inquiry, was also dismissed from his post as the head of the Judicial Police in the Algarve town of Portimao.

The 47-year-old detective not only laid into police but also attacked the McCanns, accusing them of "creating and working on" lines of inquiry which they then pass onto Leicestershire Police to investigate.

Mr Amaral, who headed the Policia Judiciaria in the nearby town of Portimao and is himself under investigation for allegedly concealing evidence about an alleged assault on the mother of another missing child, was speaking to the daily newspaper Diario de Noticias.

The paper said the detective, who has come under fire in the British press for his "boozy" three-hour lunches and allegedly failing to investigate some of the tip-offs his 30-strong team of officers have received, was in an "explosive and indignant" mood during the brief interview.

Sources said his departure follows five months of gripes about the British police involved in the case.

A family friend said it was "just plain wrong" that Kate and Gerry, both 39-year-old doctors from Rothley in Leicestershire, were seeking to exert any influence on the investigation, adding that British police were only involved to act as a liaison between the family and Portuguese detectives.

And one of the McCanns' two Portuguese lawyers, Carlos Pinto Abreu, told Lisbon radio station TSF that Mr Amaral's comments were "in very poor taste" and "unhelpful to the investigation".

"The British police have only been working on that which the McCann couple want them to and which is most convenient for them," he said.

"They have only investigated tips and information developed and worked on for the McCanns, forgetting that the couple are formal suspects in the death of their daughter Madeleine."

Officially, Portuguese detectives say they appreciate British help and expertise - particularly forensic - but unofficially claim they feel patronised and bullied.

Leicestershire Police were reluctant to wade into the developing row, only saying they would "continue to support the Portuguese investigation".

The McCanns' spokesman Clarence Mitchell was equally cautious, saying: "Kate and Gerry consistently said that they wish to cooperate with the Portuguese authorities in the hunt for Madeleine and that remains the case."

Mr Amaral has reportedly investigated only two child murders in his 26-year police career and he is facing a criminal hearing for allegedly concealing evidence, after a woman jailed for the murder of her daughter claimed police officers tortured her into making a confession.

Leonor Cipriano, 36, claims she was forced to kneel on glass ashtrays with a bag over her head as police repeatedly hit her during almost 48 hours of questioning.

She is serving 16 years for the murder of her eight-year-old daughter Joana, even though the body has never been found and she has since retracted her statement.

Mr Amaral, a father-of-three, strenuously denies covering up the alleged abuse said to have been carried out by three of his colleagues.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/1564913/Madeleine-McCann-chief-detective-sacked.html
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #272 on: September 15, 2016, 03:55:18 PM »
Goncalo Amaral was the architect of his own misfortune which would have been fine had he stopped there; unfortunately his undoubted effect on the lives of those others we know about could be considered catastrophic.

His suspicions of all and sundry must surely have had a negative effect on the investigation into Madeleine McCann's case; none more so perhaps than deploying scarce resources to keep an eye on British officers thus taking much needed personnel away from work on the ground was a seriously flawed decision.

His rant to the Portuguese journalist was unprofessional to say the least ... what a pity his feelings that he had to defend himself from "those above him" was the excuse for further unprofessional behaviour.

Who do you think his book was targeting ~ his superiors who had let him down or the McCanns who had refused to roll over and 'confess' which would indeed have been abandoning Madeleine, while doing his career a bit of good.

After all who could have dared to sack him ignominiously with another 'solved' missing child case safely under his belt. 
 


Madeleine McCann chief detective sacked

By Aislinn Simpson in Praia da Luz 5:56PM BST  02 Oct 2007

The Portuguese detective leading the Madeleine McCann investigation has been sacked from the inquiry after launching an astonishing public attack on his British counterparts.

Chief Inspector Goncalo Amaral, 47, was dismissed from the position by the national director of the Judicial Police.

He had accused British detectives of only chasing leads Gerry and Kate McCann want followed up.

The move came after Portugal's Justice Minister Alberto Costa stepped into the row by insisting there is "fruitful cooperation" between the two countries' police forces over the inquiry.

Mr Costa said Portuguese police intend "to increase the collaboration" with their British counterparts and that the important thing is "to concentrate on the job and not on the comments" made by Mr Amaral.

Mr Amaral, who was jointly in charge of the inquiry, was also dismissed from his post as the head of the Judicial Police in the Algarve town of Portimao.

The 47-year-old detective not only laid into police but also attacked the McCanns, accusing them of "creating and working on" lines of inquiry which they then pass onto Leicestershire Police to investigate.

Mr Amaral, who headed the Policia Judiciaria in the nearby town of Portimao and is himself under investigation for allegedly concealing evidence about an alleged assault on the mother of another missing child, was speaking to the daily newspaper Diario de Noticias.

The paper said the detective, who has come under fire in the British press for his "boozy" three-hour lunches and allegedly failing to investigate some of the tip-offs his 30-strong team of officers have received, was in an "explosive and indignant" mood during the brief interview.

Sources said his departure follows five months of gripes about the British police involved in the case.

A family friend said it was "just plain wrong" that Kate and Gerry, both 39-year-old doctors from Rothley in Leicestershire, were seeking to exert any influence on the investigation, adding that British police were only involved to act as a liaison between the family and Portuguese detectives.

And one of the McCanns' two Portuguese lawyers, Carlos Pinto Abreu, told Lisbon radio station TSF that Mr Amaral's comments were "in very poor taste" and "unhelpful to the investigation".

"The British police have only been working on that which the McCann couple want them to and which is most convenient for them," he said.

"They have only investigated tips and information developed and worked on for the McCanns, forgetting that the couple are formal suspects in the death of their daughter Madeleine."

Officially, Portuguese detectives say they appreciate British help and expertise - particularly forensic - but unofficially claim they feel patronised and bullied.

Leicestershire Police were reluctant to wade into the developing row, only saying they would "continue to support the Portuguese investigation".

The McCanns' spokesman Clarence Mitchell was equally cautious, saying: "Kate and Gerry consistently said that they wish to cooperate with the Portuguese authorities in the hunt for Madeleine and that remains the case."

Mr Amaral has reportedly investigated only two child murders in his 26-year police career and he is facing a criminal hearing for allegedly concealing evidence, after a woman jailed for the murder of her daughter claimed police officers tortured her into making a confession.

Leonor Cipriano, 36, claims she was forced to kneel on glass ashtrays with a bag over her head as police repeatedly hit her during almost 48 hours of questioning.

She is serving 16 years for the murder of her eight-year-old daughter Joana, even though the body has never been found and she has since retracted her statement.

Mr Amaral, a father-of-three, strenuously denies covering up the alleged abuse said to have been carried out by three of his colleagues.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/1564913/Madeleine-McCann-chief-detective-sacked.html

Ah, another attack on Amaral.

That won't help the Mccanns.

Just par for the course though.

Offline Brietta

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #273 on: September 15, 2016, 03:56:19 PM »
Amaral, Grime, dogs and Madeleine's Fund: Leaving No Stone Unturned Ltd...............usually.

Regardless of all the old blx so beloved by all, the bottom line as they say is:
In May 2007 a little girl went on holiday then disappeared never to be seen again. The nature of her disappearance to this day is unknown, despite best efforts by two police forces.
Tragically but not unsurprisingly sides are drawn up "Black 'ats and White 'ats" just as in a Hopalong Cassidy movie.
That's the human race for you  8)><(

The only thing I disagree with you there is, " ... but not unsurprisingly sides are drawn up"

I am fairly new to the 'debate' and am continually surprised and even amazed at peoples' invective and inventiveness.  I remain surprised that there are black hats and white hats ... why on earth should there be?
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

Offline G-Unit

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #274 on: September 15, 2016, 03:57:58 PM »
If you leave a room in which the window is shut and you return to find that the window is open, is that evidence of anything at all, or is it a completely worthless piece of information that tells you nothing at all about anything?

The owner of the window/property may deduct something, but that's not evidence; it's just their interpretation of why the window is open. Someone else's interpretation may be equally valid. Fibres, fingerprints, forcing are evidence.
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline Brietta

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #275 on: September 15, 2016, 04:00:04 PM »
Ah, another attack on Amaral.

That won't help the Mccanns.

Just par for the course though.

Please take note of the thread title.

Perhaps you would like to say something in defence of Mr Amaral which would serve to keep your posts on topic.
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #276 on: September 15, 2016, 04:04:56 PM »
Please take note of the thread title.

Perhaps you would like to say something in defence of Mr Amaral which would serve to keep your posts on topic.

Well I'm afraid to remind you Brietta,  what happened is no Amaral's fault.

Likewise, the Cipiano case is dealt with on other threads.


Similarly, this thread will have no impact on the Supreme Court decision, and trying to dish the dirt on Amaral is of course a result of your stance on this case.

Alfie

  • Guest
Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #277 on: September 15, 2016, 04:09:07 PM »
I've given my opinion. If you disagree feel free to post how you think it might come in useful in a trial.

Defendant is accused of opening the window, shutters, etc..
Answer; I didn't open them.
McCanns; We saw them open.
Defendant's lawyer; That doesn't mean the defendant opened them.

Defender is accused of lifting a child out of the window;
Answer; I didn't.
McCanns; We saw it open.
Defendant's lawyer; So?

You could apply the above to innumerable situations, it does not make the evidence into non-evidence, simply because the defendant refutes it.   

An open window that was previously closed is evidence that someone  has opened the window.  In a case involving illegal entry of a building and theft, the judge will want to consider the method of entry and whether or not entering through the window is possible or likely - if you think that witnesses giving evidence would not be asked to describe the state of the premises including the window as they found it then that's your prerogative. 

This is getting boring now.  The McCanns evidence and others' includes evidence of an abduction.  If it does not perhaps you can explain why the Met have spent years and considerable expense investigating a stranger abduction when according to you there is not a single shred of evidence for it?

I won't hold my breath for your answer.



Alfie

  • Guest
Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #278 on: September 15, 2016, 04:10:26 PM »
The owner of the window/property may deduct something, but that's not evidence; it's just their interpretation of why the window is open. Someone else's interpretation may be equally valid. Fibres, fingerprints, forcing are evidence.
So tell me why the dog alerts are evidence then.

Offline Brietta

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #279 on: September 15, 2016, 04:18:51 PM »
Well I'm afraid to remind you Brietta,  what happened is no Amaral's fault.

Likewise, the Cipiano case is dealt with on other threads.


Similarly, this thread will have no impact on the Supreme Court decision, and trying to dish the dirt on Amaral is of course a result of your stance on this case.

In what manner does my post "dishes the dirt" on Amaral?  Which part do you think is untrue?
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #280 on: September 15, 2016, 04:27:04 PM »
In what manner does my post "dishes the dirt" on Amaral?  Which part do you think is untrue?

Why do you need to quote the article mentioning the Cipriano case ?

As regards Amaral, he was not the only person who had that thesis, was he ?

As I said, neither you or any other McCann backer on herevwill have any impact on the Portuguese Supreme Court decision.

...as to blame, there are only two people I HD responsible for this case, and that is something you cannot get escape from.

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #281 on: September 15, 2016, 04:29:10 PM »
As to being architects of their of own misfortune, that is what the McCann's are, and Madeleine paid the ultimate price.

Offline G-Unit

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #282 on: September 15, 2016, 05:12:25 PM »
Goncalo Amaral was the architect of his own misfortune which would have been fine had he stopped there; unfortunately his undoubted effect on the lives of those others we know about could be considered catastrophic.

His suspicions of all and sundry must surely have had a negative effect on the investigation into Madeleine McCann's case; none more so perhaps than deploying scarce resources to keep an eye on British officers thus taking much needed personnel away from work on the ground was a seriously flawed decision.

His rant to the Portuguese journalist was unprofessional to say the least ... what a pity his feelings that he had to defend himself from "those above him" was the excuse for further unprofessional behaviour.

Who do you think his book was targeting ~ his superiors who had let him down or the McCanns who had refused to roll over and 'confess' which would indeed have been abandoning Madeleine, while doing his career a bit of good.

After all who could have dared to sack him ignominiously with another 'solved' missing child case safely under his belt. 
 


Madeleine McCann chief detective sacked

By Aislinn Simpson in Praia da Luz 5:56PM BST  02 Oct 2007

The Portuguese detective leading the Madeleine McCann investigation has been sacked from the inquiry after launching an astonishing public attack on his British counterparts.

Chief Inspector Goncalo Amaral, 47, was dismissed from the position by the national director of the Judicial Police.

He had accused British detectives of only chasing leads Gerry and Kate McCann want followed up.

The move came after Portugal's Justice Minister Alberto Costa stepped into the row by insisting there is "fruitful cooperation" between the two countries' police forces over the inquiry.

Mr Costa said Portuguese police intend "to increase the collaboration" with their British counterparts and that the important thing is "to concentrate on the job and not on the comments" made by Mr Amaral.

Mr Amaral, who was jointly in charge of the inquiry, was also dismissed from his post as the head of the Judicial Police in the Algarve town of Portimao.

The 47-year-old detective not only laid into police but also attacked the McCanns, accusing them of "creating and working on" lines of inquiry which they then pass onto Leicestershire Police to investigate.

Mr Amaral, who headed the Policia Judiciaria in the nearby town of Portimao and is himself under investigation for allegedly concealing evidence about an alleged assault on the mother of another missing child, was speaking to the daily newspaper Diario de Noticias.

The paper said the detective, who has come under fire in the British press for his "boozy" three-hour lunches and allegedly failing to investigate some of the tip-offs his 30-strong team of officers have received, was in an "explosive and indignant" mood during the brief interview.

Sources said his departure follows five months of gripes about the British police involved in the case.

A family friend said it was "just plain wrong" that Kate and Gerry, both 39-year-old doctors from Rothley in Leicestershire, were seeking to exert any influence on the investigation, adding that British police were only involved to act as a liaison between the family and Portuguese detectives.

And one of the McCanns' two Portuguese lawyers, Carlos Pinto Abreu, told Lisbon radio station TSF that Mr Amaral's comments were "in very poor taste" and "unhelpful to the investigation".

"The British police have only been working on that which the McCann couple want them to and which is most convenient for them," he said.

"They have only investigated tips and information developed and worked on for the McCanns, forgetting that the couple are formal suspects in the death of their daughter Madeleine."

Officially, Portuguese detectives say they appreciate British help and expertise - particularly forensic - but unofficially claim they feel patronised and bullied.

Leicestershire Police were reluctant to wade into the developing row, only saying they would "continue to support the Portuguese investigation".

The McCanns' spokesman Clarence Mitchell was equally cautious, saying: "Kate and Gerry consistently said that they wish to cooperate with the Portuguese authorities in the hunt for Madeleine and that remains the case."

Mr Amaral has reportedly investigated only two child murders in his 26-year police career and he is facing a criminal hearing for allegedly concealing evidence, after a woman jailed for the murder of her daughter claimed police officers tortured her into making a confession.

Leonor Cipriano, 36, claims she was forced to kneel on glass ashtrays with a bag over her head as police repeatedly hit her during almost 48 hours of questioning.

She is serving 16 years for the murder of her eight-year-old daughter Joana, even though the body has never been found and she has since retracted her statement.

Mr Amaral, a father-of-three, strenuously denies covering up the alleged abuse said to have been carried out by three of his colleagues.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/1564913/Madeleine-McCann-chief-detective-sacked.html

So detectives speaking off the record felt unhappy with the way the British behaved? Not just Amaral.

Kate and Gerry wished to co-operate? Not quite the same as Kate and Gerry did co-operate, is it?

Did UK police get too involved? Judging by Kate's comments in her book she formed the wrong impression of them and was hurt and surprised when they failed to intervene on her and Gerry's behalf. Whether that was her misunderstanding or whether it was the fault of the police I don't know.

Did the McCanns give leads to LP? IFLG did on the McCann's behalf. Did the McCanns approach witnesses? Yes.

I think there were faults on all sides, and Gamble acknowledged that UK agencies made the Portuguese investigation more difficult.
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline Brietta

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #283 on: September 15, 2016, 06:00:46 PM »
Why do you need to quote the article mentioning the Cipriano case ?

As regards Amaral, he was not the only person who had that thesis, was he ?

As I said, neither you or any other McCann backer on herevwill have any impact on the Portuguese Supreme Court decision.

...as to blame, there are only two people I HD responsible for this case, and that is something you cannot get escape from.

I've no idea to whom you refer, Stephen.
Amaral wrote a book publicising his thesis.  Paulo Pereira Cristóvão was able to write a book voicing an opinion ... but since he apparently did not work on the case, you would probably prefer to forget that connection.
That's all I can come up with.  Maybe you could suggest, with cites, who else you seem to know about who is a like mind to the two I have mentioned?

In my opinion the value of the book he wrote could best have been to an enquiry reviewing his modi operandi and the faults he so disingenuously laid bare within its pages.
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #284 on: September 15, 2016, 06:24:54 PM »
I've no idea to whom you refer, Stephen.
Amaral wrote a book publicising his thesis.  Paulo Pereira Cristóvão was able to write a book voicing an opinion ... but since he apparently did not work on the case, you would probably prefer to forget that connection.
That's all I can come up with.  Maybe you could suggest, with cites, who else you seem to know about who is a like mind to the two I have mentioned?

In my opinion the value of the book he wrote could best have been to an enquiry reviewing his modi operandi and the faults he so disingenuously laid bare within its pages.


....and that is what it is all about, your opinion.

As to the cause/nature of Madeleine's disappearance.

Unless you are going to tell me an abductor or abductors have been identified.