Do the sceptics simply misunderstand the evidence

[slartibartfast]

no one knows...thats the whole point..even grime doesnt know

See post #475

[Lace]

Do you think that Suzanne is still alive ?

They found her body.

There was other evidence against Gilroy.

[Mr Gray]

See post #475

that wasnt my post

[Carana]

Does Martin Grime say, or does he just say Eddie alert to the key fob?
And since there was blood found on the key fob.  Adding 2 and 2 seems reasonable.

No, there was no formal identification of blood by the FSS. Eddie alerted to the fob, and as Keela also alerted to it, it was therefore assumed to have been blood.

[ShiningInLuz]

They found her body.

There was other evidence against Gilroy.

Wiki says they never found her body.

There was other evidence against Gilroy, including the dog alerts.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Suzanne_Pilley

[Mr Gray]

Wiki says they never found her body.

There was other evidence against Gilroy, including the dog alerts.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Suzanne_Pilley

lots of evidence...but  the evidence provided by the dog handler was deemed unreliable

[Lace]

Wiki says they never found her body.

There was other evidence against Gilroy, including the dog alerts.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Suzanne_Pilley

No,  they haven't found her body,  my mistake thank you SIL.    I saw an headline from last year saying her body had been found,  there was a body found in a wood, but it wasn't her,  misleading headline.

[G-Unit]

attention to detail is somethng I deal with every day...assessing evidence is something I deal with everyday and is something I have been taught to do...

Looking at the evidence on this thread, your attention to detail leaves a lot to be desired in my opinion. If you were careful about details this;

 They concluded that the evidence given by the dog handler was unreliable.” (your post #376)

wouldn't have become this;

the SCCRC ruled that the dog alerts were unreliable (your post #431)

[slartibartfast]

that wasnt my post

Didn’t say it was.

[Mr Gray]

Didn’t say it was.

didnt say you did..i dont see its relevant to my post

[faithlilly]

A soup of DNA from up to five people,  hardly cadaver scent is it?

But certainly blood identified as Gerry's on the key fob.

[Mr Gray]

But certainly blood identified as Gerry's on the key fob.

add that to  the cadaver alerts...the statistics from yvonne martin and youve got a pretty strong case

[ShiningInLuz]

lots of evidence...but  the evidence provided by the dog handler was deemed unreliable

Presumably you have a cite?

Given that it is relevant.

[Mr Gray]

Presumably you have a cite?

Given that it is relevant.

it was given yesterday

[Carana]

But certainly blood identified as Gerry's on the key fob.

It wasn't though.