Examples of Gerry McCanns Selective Memories

[Vertigo Swirl]

That is how police determine who is being evasive.

So do you think the reconstitution would have to cover pretty much the whole holiday just to see if what each member was saying could actually have happened as they said?

[slartibartfast]

So do you think the reconstitution would have to cover pretty much the whole holiday just to see if what each member was saying could actually have happened as they said?

I am sure they would have been interested in the group dynamic.

[Vertigo Swirl]

I am sure they would have been interested in the group dynamic.

And how would they have tested this in a reconstitution do you think? 

[G-Unit]

you really think they would have been asked to reconstruct events from throughout the day?!

Madeleine was last seen by an independent witness at 17.30. That would have been a good start point imo.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Madeleine was last seen by an independent witness at 17.30. That would have been a good start point imo.

SO talk me through how they would reconstitute bathing the kids and putting them to bed.  Would you have Gerry and Kate quaffing a few drinks at the apartment before setting off for the tapas at 8.30pm?  It's nonsensical and a complete waste of time.

[faithlilly]

SO talk me through how they would reconstitute bathing the kids and putting them to bed.  Would you have Gerry and Kate quaffing a few drinks at the apartment before setting off for the tapas at 8.30pm?  It's nonsensical and a complete waste of time.

The archiving report detailed what the PJ wanted to reconstruct. It was quite clear what specifically Rebelo needed clarified.

[Alice Purjorick]

SO talk me through how they would reconstitute bathing the kids and putting them to bed.  Would you have Gerry and Kate quaffing a few drinks at the apartment before setting off for the tapas at 8.30pm?  It's nonsensical and a complete waste of time.

This post is a classic example of reductio ad absurdum.
No bid.

[Vertigo Swirl]

The archiving report detailed what the PJ wanted to reconstruct. It was quite clear what specifically Rebelo needed clarified.

and I don’t suppose it included tennis matches and the children’s bedtimes.

[Vertigo Swirl]

This post is a classic example of reductio ad absurdum.
No bid.

No, what is absurd are the two suggestions here that the reconstitution should have covered the men playing tennis and everything that happened from5.30pm onwards, which in case you hadn’t noticed, covered the period of putting children to bed and getting ready to go out.

[Robittybob1]

This post is a classic example of reductio ad absurdum.
No bid.

No it is a good point for even GA makes a mention of the wine being consumed.

[Robin Banks]

Madeleine was last seen by an independent witness at 17.30. That would have been a good start point imo.

 

[faithlilly]

and I don’t suppose it included tennis matches and the children’s bedtimes.

No it didn’t but then I didn’t suggest it did.

[Vertigo Swirl]

No it didn’t but then I didn’t suggest it did.

I know you didn’t, others did though.

[faithlilly]

I know you didn’t, others did though.

But your reply wasn’t to anyone else it was to me. Can I suggest if you want to answer a specific question you do so under that question and not under my point.

[Vertigo Swirl]

But your reply wasn’t to anyone else it was to me. Can I suggest if you want to answer a specific question you do so under that question and not under my point.

the post you made was in reply to mine and did not pose any question.   I had the right of reply and did so.  If you don’t like my replies I recommend you don’t respond to any of my posts henceforth.