The last video taken of Madeleine McCann.

[G-Unit]

What an accusation in red bold font. A pile of poo ofcourse.

Was it the McCanns who released that particular video and then you say it was dubbed?  wow seriously.

If it was dubbed, how did they manage to dub Gerry's voice onto the first bit and why?

[Robittybob1]

If it was dubbed, how did they manage to dub Gerry's voice onto the first bit and why?

Certainly edited to some extent but the sound track is always the same.

[jassi]

Certainly edited to some extent[/b] but the sound track is always the same.

Unless you have seen an unedited version, how can you know? - and how would you know it was the original in the first place?

[Robittybob1]

Unless you have seen an unedited version, how can you know? - and how would you know it was the original in the first place?

There was a longer version.  Where the camera is focused on another person (a young girl) on the bus, who was not a member of the McCann Payne group, and that footage has been edited out.

[Miss Taken Identity]

If it was dubbed, how did they manage to dub Gerry's voice onto the first bit and why?

They didn't manage- would be the first observation! the why is... there is no reason why. Are we having that push pop up from supporters to remind us that the McCanns are a posh family, with irreproachable etiquette, that they would not use the suggestion  of selected words 'to fornicate under the command of the king' off.


Oh really, and what was it Kate wrote in her book for the twins to read....


It was Gerry, and it was f*** off.

[Robittybob1]

They didn't manage- would be the first observation! the why is... there is no reason why. Are we having that push pop up from supporters to remind us that the McCanns are a posh family, with irreproachable etiquette, that they would not use the suggestion  of selected words 'to fornicate under the command of the king' off.


Oh really, and what was it Kate wrote in her book for the twins to read....


It was Gerry, and it was f*** off.

No swearing please.

[sadie]

Certainly edited to some extent but the sound track is always the same.

Yep, when there is one !!!!!

I am deaf, with hearing aids, so perhaps nopt the best person to judge, but I didn't think the voices were the voices of the people they were supposed to be.  To me they didn't sound genuine.

I feel sure that there must be electronic devices that analyse voices into sound waves etc that definitively can decide whether they are genuine to the person.

Would be good to get all this petty haggling over by using such a device.  Anyone got access to one?

[Miss Taken Identity]

There was a longer version.  Where the camera is focused on another person (a young girl) on the bus, who was not a member of the McCann Payne group, and that footage has been edited out.

and that could have been at the request of the girl/and family. to protect her identity.

[G-Unit]

and that could have been at the request of the girl/and family. to protect her identity.

The Reuters clip still has that child. It has Gerry speaking and, I believe, Dave also. He is the only adult not shown so it makes sense that he was taking the footage, as does the reaction of his wife and mother-in-law.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p1AlT1Jg0fw

[Robittybob1]

The Reuters clip still has that child. It has Gerry speaking and, I believe, Dave also. He is the only adult not shown so it makes sense that he was taking the footage, as does the reaction of his wife and mother-in-law.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p1AlT1Jg0fw

But not to the same extent as what I recall.

[faithlilly]

The Reuters clip still has that child. It has Gerry speaking and, I believe, Dave also. He is the only adult not shown so it makes sense that he was taking the footage, as does the reaction of his wife and mother-in-law.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p1AlT1Jg0fw

I wonder why DP then publicised the hardly flattering ( of Gerry ) piece of video ?

[Brietta]

We have learned on this thread that Madeleine's parents released the video without a soundtrack.  A very simple deduction can be made regarding the appearance of a mischievous soundtrack added sometime later.

[faithlilly]

We have learned on this thread that Madeleine's parents released the video without a soundtrack.  A very simple deduction can be made regarding the appearance of a mischievous soundtrack added sometime later.

If the soundtrack was simply the group having a bit of fun, and no bad language, why not release the soundtrack too ?

[Robittybob1]

We have learned on this thread that Madeleine's parents released the video without a soundtrack.  A very simple deduction can be made regarding the appearance of a mischievous soundtrack added sometime later.

Was that really true though?

[Brietta]

If the soundtrack was simply the group having a bit of fun, and no bad language, why not release the soundtrack too ?

The soundtrack was of zero importance.