"Start by Asking Yourself What is a Supporter and Work on from There”

[Robittybob1]

I find that impossible to believe, sorry Vertigo Swirl. You have already said you post on many fora and for you to have been interested in this case for this long you must have seen these posts. I am not about to share them here but if an impartial moderator such as Robittybob1 would like me to do so I will do my best to find them again and share the posts with them so they can confirm that I am correct in what I say.

Are these photos on other forums unrelated to this one?  If they were I think we'd better drop the discussion for anything is possible elsewhere.

[Sunny]

Are these photos on other forums unrelated to this one?  If they were I think we'd better drop the discussion for anything is possible elsewhere.

They are elsewhere Robittybob1 and thank goodness they are not here.  I mentioned them in my initial post describing my impression of some supporters -not all

[carlymichelle]

a supporter to me is a  person who a  100%  believes the mcanns and wont have anything  said  against  them they get hostile when people  tll them  no one is perfect  and everybody has  flaws they say horrible things about people who disagree about them/the mcanns    all this is   in my  IMO

[Robittybob1]

a supporter to me is a  person who a  100%  believes the mcansn and wont have anything  said  against  them they get hostile when people  tll them  no one is perfect  and everybody has  flaws they say horrible things about people who disagree about them/the mcanns  IMO

With a view like that no wonder there is a great divide. 

[Vertigo Swirl]

I find that impossible to believe, sorry Vertigo Swirl. You have already said you post on many fora and for you to have been interested in this case for this long you must have seen these posts. I am not about to share them here but if an impartial moderator such as Robittybob1 would like me to do so I will do my best to find them again and share the posts with them so they can confirm that I am correct in what I say.

PM me  the names of forums and I’ll take a look myself, meanwhile I would just like to say that as this thread is simply another opportunity for both sides to have a massive barney I am not participating in it any further and recommend that supporters do likewise and not rise to the bait.  Let the sceptics use this thread to vent their spleen but don’t feed them, it’s a mug’s game.  This thread was much friendlier when it was about music  :-(

[Sunny]

PM me  the names of forums and I’ll take a look myself, meanwhile I would just like to say that as this thread is simply another opportunity for both sides to have a massive barney I am not participating in it any further and recommend that supporters do likewise and not rise to the bait.  Let the sceptics use this thread to vent their spleen but don’t feed them, it’s a mug’s game.  This thread was much friendlier when it was about music  :-(

Two things.
Firstly, sorry no I won't pm the names to you I said I would only do that to a moderate moderator (??) such as Robittybob1
Secondly, perhaps the thread about sceptics would have been friendlier if it had all been about music too :)

[Robittybob1]

There is no context that would make your behaviour correct. If you have cause to ask a member to change his behaviour that is between you and him and not the rest of the forum. Have some integrity please.

Using your own argument maybe this ought to be via PM too. 

[Sunny]

With a view like that no wonder there is a great divide.  "the McCanns they drove a  person to suicide"  Now can you provide a cite for that?

You need the entire post Robittybob1 as your snip is not accurate.

IMO Carlymichelle wasn't talking about the McCanns driving anyone to suicide she was referring to the actions of the dossier makers, the ensuing media furore and then Brenda Leyland's suicide.

All of which is well documented elsewhere and it was why I became interested in the case in the first place.

[carlymichelle]

You need the entire post Robittybob1 as your snip is not accurate.

IMO Carlymichelle wasn't talking about the McCanns driving anyone to suicide she was referring to the actions of the dossier makers, the ensuing media furore and then Brenda Leyland's suicide.

All of which is well documented elsewhere and it was why I became interested in the case in the first place.

exactly  sunny they named and shamed brenda   for having a opinion and ruined her life with a dossier

[Robittybob1]

the bullying of  brenda  did    rob and the media attention that  brenda  got  from  supporters    doing the  document they  did

Are you blaming the McCanns or their supporters? 

[carlymichelle]

Are you blaming the McCanns or their supporters?

the supporters and rob i  must say  being a mod you need  to  read everything and not just jump in on things imo

[Brietta]

PM me  the names of forums and I’ll take a look myself, meanwhile I would just like to say that as this thread is simply another opportunity for both sides to have a massive barney I am not participating in it any further and recommend that supporters do likewise and not rise to the bait.  Let the sceptics use this thread to vent their spleen but don’t feed them, it’s a mug’s game.  This thread was much friendlier when it was about music  :-(

Very sensible choice of action ~ in my opinion

[Sunny]

the supporters and rob i  must say  being a mod you need  to  read everything and not just jump in on things imo

I don't blame all supporters for what happened to Brenda Leyland but I do believe that the dossier gatherers were partially to blame for what happened to her.   If they had just gone to the police with their concerns then fair enough but they didn't did they they wanted national media coverage. I have read a particular forum at the time Brenda was exposed by Martin Brunt and the red tops and there appeared to be a lot of back slapping going on between posters.

[Robittybob1]

You need the entire post Robittybob1 as your snip is not accurate.

IMO Carlymichelle wasn't talking about the McCanns driving anyone to suicide she was referring to the actions of the dossier makers, the ensuing media furore and then Brenda Leyland's suicide.

All of which is well documented elsewhere and it was why I became interested in the case in the first place.

OK I see that / has some special meaning.
"a supporter to me is a  person who a  100%  believes the mcansn and wont have anything  said  against  them they get hostile when people  tll them  no one is perfect  and everybody has  flaws they say horrible things about people who disagree about them/the mcanns they drove a  person to sucide and i for one will never forget  that "

Tidied up it could be "The supporters say horrible things about people who disagree about them or the McCanns.  They even drove a  person to suicide".

the supporters and rob i  must say  being a mod you need  to  read everything and not just jump in on things imo

Are you trying to drive me to suicide?

[carlymichelle]

I don't blame all supporters for what happened to Brenda Leyland but I do believe that the dossier gatherers were partially to blame for what happened to her.   If they had just gone to the police with their concerns then fair enough but they didn't did they they wanted national media coverage. I have read a particular forum at the time Brenda was exposed by Martin Brunt and the red tops and there appeared to be a lot of back slapping going on between posters.

it  went  around the world including here in  australia she was named and shamed across the world