UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Brietta on May 13, 2014, 01:49:30 AM

Title: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Brietta on May 13, 2014, 01:49:30 AM
Tapas Nine witness says 'Mediterranean man took Madeleine'
By DAVID WILKES and VANESSA ALLEN
Last updated at 10:12 20 November 2007

The woman who believes she saw Madeleine McCann being abducted revealed yesterday that she has never named Robert Murat to police as the man she saw.

Instead, Jane Tanner, 36, thinks he was "Mediterranean looking".

Miss Tanner, one of the so- called Tapas Nine, says she remains "stricken with guilt" over failing to prevent the abduction.

"I felt I could have stopped this all from happening," she said. "I think of that every day. I have to live with it for ever, that guilt is never going to go away."

But she admitted: "I simply don't know if I could identify again the man I saw that night. I've never pointed the finger at Robert Murat because I simply don't know if it was him or not.

"I would say the man I saw was more local, or Mediterranean looking, rather than British. He had dark, almost black, long hair and had swarthy skin.
 
"He was dressed in that sort of smart casual way European people dress."
 
Miss Tanner, a mother of two, said Madeleine's parents Kate and Gerry have told her she shouldn't feel any guilt about what happened.

Though some details of Miss Tanner's interview emerged at the weekend, it was broadcast in full on BBC1's Panorama programme last night.
 
She spoke out as it emerged that the private detectives hired by the McCanns are investigating claims that a witness saw a child who looked like Madeleine with a couple on May 5, two days after the girl disappeared in Portugal.
 
The unnamed witness was said to have identified one of the couple as Michaela Walczuch, the girlfriend of Murat.
In a picture yesterday, she bore an uncanny likeness to a figure drawn by a forensic artist from Miss Tanner's recollections.
 
Although the impression, commissioned by the McCanns, has no facial features, the length of the figure's brown hair is like Miss Walczuch's.
 
The build of Murat's girlfriend and her style of clothing also match the impression.
 
German-born Miss Walczuch, 34, refused to comment when approached outside her home in Lagos, which she shares with her estranged husband Luis Antonio and their eightyearold daughter.
 
Her lawyer later described the allegation against her as ridiculous.
 
Murat, 33, who remains an official suspect in the case, lives in Praia da Luz with his 71-year-old mother Jenny.
He has insisted he was at home the night Madeleine vanished. Miss Tanner appealed to people to "rack their brains" to see if they know the man she saw.
 
Tears welling in her eyes, marketing executive Miss Tanner, of Exeter, said: "Every day I see him there, striding away, carrying Madeleine away and I try desperately to remember more detail.
 
"I think about it over and over again. It's horrible.
 
"He had his face turned away from me, sort of sideways and it was very dark. I just didn't see it properly, I wish to God I had."
 
Miss Tanner, the first of the seven friends who were on holiday with Mr and Mrs McCann to speak out, says she saw the man carrying a child around 9.15pm on May 3 as she made her way back to her apartment at the Mark Warner holiday complex in Praia da Luz.
She was holidaying with her partner Dr Russell O'Brien, 36, Madeleine's parents and five other friends.
The group were taking it in turns to check on their children who they had left in their apartments while they dined together at a nearby tapas bar.

Explaining why the group had left their children in their rooms - something Mr and Mrs McCann, of Rothley, Leicestershire, have been heavily criticised for - Miss Tanner said: "I think we were lulled into a sense of security by the fact that it was very much a family resort and quite quiet."

It was on one of her regular checks to see her two daughters, age two and four, that Miss Tanner saw the suspect, about ten to 15ft in front of her, cross from left to right, carrying a child.
 
She said that when she was later told Madeleine had disappeared "the image of that man carrying the child came into my head and I felt physically sick".
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-495092/Tapas-Nine-witness-says-Mediterranean-man-took-Madeleine.html#ixzz0fQNlbj4t
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Silkywhiskers on May 13, 2014, 03:32:42 AM
Tapas Nine witness says 'Mediterranean man took Madeleine'
By DAVID WILKES and VANESSA ALLEN
Last updated at 10:12 20 November 2007

The woman who believes she saw Madeleine McCann being abducted revealed yesterday that she has never named Robert Murat to police as the man she saw.

Instead, Jane Tanner, 36, thinks he was "Mediterranean looking".

Miss Tanner, one of the so- called Tapas Nine, says she remains "stricken with guilt" over failing to prevent the abduction.

"I felt I could have stopped this all from happening," she said. "I think of that every day. I have to live with it for ever, that guilt is never going to go away."

But she admitted: "I simply don't know if I could identify again the man I saw that night. I've never pointed the finger at Robert Murat because I simply don't know if it was him or not.

"I would say the man I saw was more local, or Mediterranean looking, rather than British. He had dark, almost black, long hair and had swarthy skin.
 
"He was dressed in that sort of smart casual way European people dress."
 
Miss Tanner, a mother of two, said Madeleine's parents Kate and Gerry have told her she shouldn't feel any guilt about what happened.

Though some details of Miss Tanner's interview emerged at the weekend, it was broadcast in full on BBC1's Panorama programme last night.
 
She spoke out as it emerged that the private detectives hired by the McCanns are investigating claims that a witness saw a child who looked like Madeleine with a couple on May 5, two days after the girl disappeared in Portugal.
 
The unnamed witness was said to have identified one of the couple as Michaela Walczuch, the girlfriend of Murat.
In a picture yesterday, she bore an uncanny likeness to a figure drawn by a forensic artist from Miss Tanner's recollections.
 
Although the impression, commissioned by the McCanns, has no facial features, the length of the figure's brown hair is like Miss Walczuch's.
 
The build of Murat's girlfriend and her style of clothing also match the impression.
 
German-born Miss Walczuch, 34, refused to comment when approached outside her home in Lagos, which she shares with her estranged husband Luis Antonio and their eightyearold daughter.
 
Her lawyer later described the allegation against her as ridiculous.
 
Murat, 33, who remains an official suspect in the case, lives in Praia da Luz with his 71-year-old mother Jenny.
He has insisted he was at home the night Madeleine vanished. Miss Tanner appealed to people to "rack their brains" to see if they know the man she saw.
 
Tears welling in her eyes, marketing executive Miss Tanner, of Exeter, said: "Every day I see him there, striding away, carrying Madeleine away and I try desperately to remember more detail.
 
"I think about it over and over again. It's horrible.
 
"He had his face turned away from me, sort of sideways and it was very dark. I just didn't see it properly, I wish to God I had."
 
Miss Tanner, the first of the seven friends who were on holiday with Mr and Mrs McCann to speak out, says she saw the man carrying a child around 9.15pm on May 3 as she made her way back to her apartment at the Mark Warner holiday complex in Praia da Luz.
She was holidaying with her partner Dr Russell O'Brien, 36, Madeleine's parents and five other friends.
The group were taking it in turns to check on their children who they had left in their apartments while they dined together at a nearby tapas bar.

Explaining why the group had left their children in their rooms - something Mr and Mrs McCann, of Rothley, Leicestershire, have been heavily criticised for - Miss Tanner said: "I think we were lulled into a sense of security by the fact that it was very much a family resort and quite quiet."

It was on one of her regular checks to see her two daughters, age two and four, that Miss Tanner saw the suspect, about ten to 15ft in front of her, cross from left to right, carrying a child.
 
She said that when she was later told Madeleine had disappeared "the image of that man carrying the child came into my head and I felt physically sick".
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-495092/Tapas-Nine-witness-says-Mediterranean-man-took-Madeleine.html#ixzz0fQNlbj4t
[/quote]

Jane Tanner positively identified Robert Murat as being the person she saw carrying "Madeleine".

Don't know very much about this case, do you?


Jane Tanner was placed inside a police surveillance van (with windows that allow you to look outside, from the van, without being seen), the van was parked in a strategic position, near apartment 5A, and PJ investigators took Murat with them, making exactly the same walk the man carrying a child had made, according to Jane Tanner.

Jane Tanner looked at Murat walking and told police she was sure he was the same man, she recognised the way he walked, with no doubt.

- 'A Verdade da Mentira', 'Maddie: The Truth of the Lie' by Gonçalo Amaral
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Brietta on May 13, 2014, 10:18:03 AM
Jane Tanner positively identified Robert Murat as being the person she saw carrying "Madeleine".

Don't know very much about this case, do you?


Jane Tanner was placed inside a police surveillance van (with windows that allow you to look outside, from the van, without being seen), the van was parked in a strategic position, near apartment 5A, and PJ investigators took Murat with them, making exactly the same walk the man carrying a child had made, according to Jane Tanner.

Jane Tanner looked at Murat walking and told police she was sure he was the same man, she recognised the way he walked, with no doubt.

- 'A Verdade da Mentira', 'Maddie: The Truth of the Lie' by Gonçalo Amaral


This forum has had a very recent discussion re ~ Topic: The Jane Tanner surveillance of Robert Murat episode, might be well worth revisiting.

As for me, I prefer things to come from the horse’s mouth rather than third party or from blinkered internet hysteria. 
So when Jane Tanner states, "I simply don't know if I could identify again the man I saw that night. I've never pointed the finger at Robert Murat because I simply don't know if it was him or not."


So unless you can come up with a cite from a witness statement stating the contrary, that will be good enough for me, as it obviously was for Mr Murat whose alleged legal action against Jane Tanner seemed to vanish in a puff of smoke.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Alfred R Jones on May 13, 2014, 02:27:16 PM
A positive sighting of Murat carrying Madeleine that night would surely have made the pages of the Police Files wouldn't it?  Or did the police forget to take a statement from JT about this alleged sighting of Murat?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Silkywhiskers on May 13, 2014, 11:59:42 PM
This forum has had a very recent discussion re ~ Topic: The Jane Tanner surveillance of Robert Murat episode, might be well worth revisiting.

As for me, I prefer things to come from the horse’s mouth rather than third party or from blinkered internet hysteria. 
So when Jane Tanner states, "I simply don't know if I could identify again the man I saw that night. I've never pointed the finger at Robert Murat because I simply don't know if it was him or not."


So unless you can come up with a cite from a witness statement stating the contrary, that will be good enough for me, as it obviously was for Mr Murat whose alleged legal action against Jane Tanner seemed to vanish in a puff of smoke.

It is becoming glaringly obvious you have not read Amaral's book, The Truth of the Lie.

Absolutely everything you demand to know, is contained within those pages.

Indeed, I don't know how anyone could call themselves "unbiased" if the only reading they have done is MSM and the publications of the McCann.

So if you want something "out of the horses mouth", then Amaral's book is ESSENTIAL READING before you come on a forum being all superior and dismissive.

Amaral recounts Tanner positively identifying Murat from inside a police vehicle.


Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: misty on May 14, 2014, 01:03:37 AM
It is becoming glaringly obvious you have not read Amaral's book, The Truth of the Lie.

Absolutely everything you demand to know, is contained within those pages.

Indeed, I don't know how anyone could call themselves "unbiased" if the only reading they have done is MSM and the publications of the McCann.

So if you want something "out of the horses mouth", then Amaral's book is ESSENTIAL READING before you come on a forum being all superior and dismissive.

Are you therefore stating that Amaral was in that police van & heard Jane give a positive ID, or was he merely told by a third party? It would be helpful to have a link to the statements officially confirming exactly what was said.
Amaral recounts Tanner positively identifying Murat from inside a police vehicle.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Silkywhiskers on May 14, 2014, 01:15:22 AM
From The Truth of the Lie -

Summary of comments on Robert Murat from Gonçalo Amaral's book 'The Truth of the Lie' Gazeta Digital 
 
29 July 2008
 
* On May 11, Amaral himself walked the path in the same direction where Jane Tanner said she saw a man carrying a child, on the night of May 3
 
* He saw Murat's home and Murat going out, with his mother and asked a police officer who he was. The officer said he knew him and he was translating to police
 
* Back in the crisis room, more information was available (Lorraine' suspicions, a lot of curiosity about the investigation, from Murat, and so on)
 
* Profilers from CEOP start to "work" on Murat's profile, his home was put under close and sophisticated electronic surveillance
 
* Jane Tanner was placed inside a surveillance van from police (windows that allow to look outside, from the van, without being seen), the van was parked in a strategic position, near the A5 apartment, and PJ investigators took Murat with them, making exactly the same walk the man carrying a child has made, according to Jane Tanner
 
* Jane Tanner looked at Murat walking and told police she was sure he was the same man, she recognized the way he walked, with no doubt


http://www.mccannfiles.com/id137.html
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: misty on May 14, 2014, 01:22:06 AM
May we have a statement from the official files, please, not  quote from the book of the ex-Lead Detective?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Brietta on May 14, 2014, 01:41:26 AM
It is becoming glaringly obvious you have not read Amaral's book, The Truth of the Lie.

Absolutely everything you demand to know, is contained within those pages.

Indeed, I don't know how anyone could call themselves "unbiased" if the only reading they have done is MSM and the publications of the McCann.

So if you want something "out of the horses mouth", then Amaral's book is ESSENTIAL READING before you come on a forum being all superior and dismissive.

Amaral recounts Tanner positively identifying Murat from inside a police vehicle.

I am going to be "all superior and dismissive" ... yet again ... and I am going to quote from "the horse's mouth" yet again, or rather from Jane Tanner's rogatory interview.
It is necessary to keep repeating the truth from reliable sources rather than forum myths which are being repeated rather than the truth of the matter.

~~   ~~   ~~   ~~

4078    “I know this seems like an obvious question, which I think I know the answer to, because I’ve seen the artist’s impression, did you see the man’s face?”

Reply    “No, no, not, no, I mean, just the hair, well not, not that I could remember to give details, give details to”.

4078    “Now you are left with that mental image in your head about the man carrying the child”.

Reply    “Umm”.

4078    “And you said, you described his hair quite well.  Having seen MURAT then and obviously in the papers since, could you link the two of those?”

Reply    “I don’t think so.  I mean, I don’t, phew, I don’t, I don’t think it, no, there doesn’t, there’s no, but then the person I see in the paper doesn’t really look like my recollection of the person I met on the way to meet Bob SMALL.  It’s really annoying because normally I would have probably taken more notice but I was so worried about what I was going to do, because I didn’t know at this point at all, I didn’t really take any notice, but I think it was too short and I remember it being, being long into the neck and not so.  Again, I don’t really, when I saw Robert MURAT outside his house he looked quite little to me, but then when you see him on the telly he seems quite bit, so I can’t, again, I don’t think the build, the build was right, I don’t”.

4078    “So you don’t feel, in your heart of hearts”.

Reply    “No”.
4078    “You don’t feel it was the same person?”

Reply    “No, I don’t, no”.
http://www.mccannfiles.com/id222.html

Jane Tanner did not identify Robert Murat as the person she saw carrying a child on the 3rd May 2007.

Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: pegasus on May 14, 2014, 01:54:29 AM
... Jane Tanner did not identify Robert Murat as the person she saw carrying a child on the 3rd May 2007.
A refreshingly pleasant blast of common sense.
She saw and spoke to Robert on her way to the surveillance vehicle.
It seems glaringly obvious that if she thought was the man she saw evening May 3rd, she would have said so even before getting into the surveillance vehicle.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: pegasus on May 14, 2014, 02:07:22 AM
... BE CONSISTENT ...
JT's account is a hundred times more consistent than that of those who still insult this honest witness.
Look at the insulters' claims back then - they claimed she invented seeing a man and child.
But now the insulters' claims, although very vague and difficult to pin down, have changed because of Mr Redwood's statement, and generally admit the possibility that she did see a man and child.
How inconsistent is that? To first claim she didn't see anyone, then admit she did.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Brietta on May 15, 2014, 03:37:35 PM
Jane Tanner’s description of the person she saw carrying a child has been consistent.

She gave three official statements to the police - 4th May, 2007 - 10th May 2007 and a Rogatory Interview on 8th April 2008.  In none of them was her statement changed. 

Jane Tanner was interviewed by Jeremy Vine for Panorama on 19th November 2007.  She stuck very firmly to the events she had witnessed on 3rd May and did not deviate from the evidence given in her statements to the police.
The transcript of that interview can be read at ~  http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/panorama/7106086.stm
   
The assumption that she deviated from her description is derived from newspaper reports and is made in various internet blogs which have consistently campaigned against the Drs McCann. 

It should be remembered that Jane Tanner received damages from some newspapers in which she had been misrepresented as well as an apology.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on May 15, 2014, 04:29:09 PM
It is becoming glaringly obvious you have not read Amaral's book, The Truth of the Lie.

Absolutely everything you demand to know, is contained within those pages.

Indeed, I don't know how anyone could call themselves "unbiased" if the only reading they have done is MSM and the publications of the McCann.

So if you want something "out of the horses mouth", then Amaral's book is ESSENTIAL READING before you come on a forum being all superior and dismissive.

Amaral recounts Tanner positively identifying Murat from inside a police vehicle.

As all the contents of Amaral's book are alleged to be contained in the files up until he was taken off the investigation, could you point me to which of Jane's two statements states this?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Silkywhiskers on May 15, 2014, 08:01:00 PM
As all the contents of Amaral's book are alleged to be contained in the files up until he was taken off the investigation, could you point me to which of Jane's two statements states this?


*sigh*

I love how Team McCann assume that every single thing from the investigation made it into the archive report.

Clearly, this is ridiculous.

There are thousands of pages in the archive report, but HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS in the investigation.

As the investigation was shelved NOT finalised, why on earth would you think the entire contents would be made public?

Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: sadie on May 15, 2014, 09:31:58 PM
A positive sighting of Murat carrying Madeleine that night would surely have made the pages of the Police Files wouldn't it?  Or did the police forget to take a statement from JT about this alleged sighting of Murat?

Exactly
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Silkywhiskers on May 15, 2014, 09:34:32 PM
Exactly

Did Euclides "make the case file"?

What about Posh Spice?

Hewlett?

The Apartment Managers, the Pedophile Ring, the Portugese Portal or the 3 burglars?

Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: misty on May 16, 2014, 10:16:33 PM
Questioning of & statements provided by "all known sex offenders" were removed from the public files. Euclides, no doubt, fell within that category if he had been questioned previously over other sex offences - assuming the PJ have told the truth that he was questioned & cleared.
Why do you feel that Amaral's word as an author is worth more than that of an investigative journalist who has spoken directly to witnesses like Jane Tanner?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Alfred R Jones on May 16, 2014, 10:38:51 PM
If JT positively id'ed Murat why wasn't he arrested?  What does it take to arrest a man in Portugal  seen carrying away a young child he is not related to at night, why wasn't a positive ID enough?  Surely his alibi was fairly shaky....
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Silkywhiskers on May 16, 2014, 10:58:57 PM
If JT positively id'ed Murat why wasn't he arrested?  What does it take to arrest a man in Portugal  seen carrying away a young child he is not related to at night, why wasn't a positive ID enough?  Surely his alibi was fairly shaky....

Because the investigating officers did not believe them.

They didn't believe any of it.

Nor do SY it seems....who are now about to search for Madeleine's burial place/s.

Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Alfred R Jones on May 16, 2014, 11:03:39 PM
Because the investigating officers did not believe them.

They didn't believe any of it.

Nor do SY it seems....who are now about to search for Madeleine's burial place/s.
And yet they still eventually made Murat an arguido...
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: misty on May 16, 2014, 11:11:15 PM
Because the investigating officers did not believe them.

They didn't believe any of it.

Nor do SY it seems....who are now about to search for Madeleine's burial place/s.

So you're saying they didn't believe any of the Tapas 9, Martin Smith, the Tapas Bar/waiting staff, & all the witnesses who saw people behaving strangely in the days leading up to the abduction?
Yet a man whose only alibi was his mother must be telling the truth?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Silkywhiskers on May 16, 2014, 11:14:36 PM
So you're saying they didn't believe any of the Tapas 9, Martin Smith, the Tapas Bar/waiting staff, & all the witnesses who saw people behaving strangely in the days leading up to the abduction?
Yet a man whose only alibi was his mother must be telling the truth?

Huh?

Murat has been CLEARED in case you haven't noticed.

The digs are not at Casa Murat, are they?

The digs are 100m from 5a's front door.

How do you explain this little uncomfortable fact?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Alfred R Jones on May 16, 2014, 11:24:10 PM
Huh?

Murat has been CLEARED in case you haven't noticed.

The digs are not at Casa Murat, are they?

The digs are 100m from 5a's front door.

How do you explain this little uncomfortable fact?

Murat is as cleared as the McCanns actually.  And Murat had as much access to 100mettres from 5a's front door as the McCanns did (not for one moment saying I think he is in any way involved however).
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: misty on May 17, 2014, 02:12:22 AM
"Feelings" that someone is lying have to be proven.
Someone did come forward & identify themselves as being in the vicinity with their child but the PJ IGNORED it. They ignored a walking, living, potential witness to a crime.
Then they ignored Martin Smith's sighting. Now, it's not as if there were hoards of people milling around the streets of Luz at that time,were there? In fact, there seem to be very few statements from people who were in the vicinity that night between 8.30 & 10pm.
The Met have now interviewed this man themselves & seem pretty sure he was the 9.15 sighting by Jane, hence Tannerman has been ruled out of the list of suspects. So the focus changed. 7 years ago, the PJ could have done the very same thing and maybe reached a conclusion. The PJ chose not to. Wonder why not?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Silkywhiskers on May 17, 2014, 04:59:16 AM
"Feelings" that someone is lying have to be proven.
Someone did come forward & identify themselves as being in the vicinity with their child but the PJ IGNORED it. They ignored a walking, living, potential witness to a crime.
Then they ignored Martin Smith's sighting. Now, it's not as if there were hoards of people milling around the streets of Luz at that time,were there? In fact, there seem to be very few statements from people who were in the vicinity that night between 8.30 & 10pm.
The Met have now interviewed this man themselves & seem pretty sure he was the 9.15 sighting by Jane, hence Tannerman has been ruled out of the list of suspects. So the focus changed. 7 years ago, the PJ could have done the very same thing and maybe reached a conclusion. The PJ chose not to. Wonder why not?


So now you're alleging that mystery dad was exactly where Tanner said he was, and when.

Please provide proof that this is the case.

You will not find proof.  Neither SY nor the mystery dad himself have clarified exactly where he was at what time, yet now you've made him into an EYE WITNESS! No less!

Talk about rewriting history.

Tanner saw A man.  There is absolutely zero to suggest her story is true in any other respect.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: slartibartfast on May 17, 2014, 07:38:25 AM
"Feelings" that someone is lying have to be proven.
Someone did come forward & identify themselves as being in the vicinity with their child but the PJ IGNORED it. They ignored a walking, living, potential witness to a crime.
Then they ignored Martin Smith's sighting. Now, it's not as if there were hoards of people milling around the streets of Luz at that time,were there? In fact, there seem to be very few statements from people who were in the vicinity that night between 8.30 & 10pm.
The Met have now interviewed this man themselves & seem pretty sure he was the 9.15 sighting by Jane, hence Tannerman has been ruled out of the list of suspects. So the focus changed. 7 years ago, the PJ could have done the very same thing and maybe reached a conclusion. The PJ chose not to. Wonder why not?

Innocent man would most likely have been interviewed by LP, was the interview forwarded to the PJ?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: ferryman on May 17, 2014, 01:33:05 PM
I would think that Jane's observation from the van was null-and-void from the point that they met Robert Murat en route to the van from which she made it ...
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Mr Moderator on May 17, 2014, 05:47:03 PM
Posters are reminded to keep within the topic boundaries.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Brietta on May 17, 2014, 07:26:27 PM
Innocent man would most likely have been interviewed by LP, was the interview forwarded to the PJ?

I presume there would have been a record of innocent man's daughter in the night crèche. 
If that information had been checked timeously, he could perhaps have been interviewed before returning home.

If he had returned, I would have expected a request for a rogatory interview to be sent out.

From the information available to us in the PJ files as published on the internet, there doesn't appear to any problem with LP co-operating and sending information to the PJ.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: slartibartfast on May 17, 2014, 10:10:18 PM
I presume there would have been a record of innocent man's daughter in the night crèche. 
If that information had been checked timeously, he could perhaps have been interviewed before returning home.

If he had returned, I would have expected a request for a rogatory interview to be sent out.

From the information available to us in the PJ files as published on the internet, there doesn't appear to any problem with LP co-operating and sending information to the PJ.

Mirror says she was interviewed in UK, but no record in Portugal.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Silkywhiskers on May 17, 2014, 10:52:04 PM
Could you substantiate that from the files please?

I can do one better.

I can provide the book, The Truth of the Lie, in which her identification of Murat is discussed.

The book has been officially sanctioned as an "accurate record" of the investigation, condensed of course.

Jane Tanner was placed inside a police surveillance van (with windows that allow you to look outside, from the van, without being seen), the van was parked in a strategic position, near apartment 5A, and PJ investigators took Murat with them, making exactly the same walk the man carrying a child had made, according to Jane Tanner.

Jane Tanner looked at Murat walking and told police she was sure he was the same man, she recognised the way he walked, with no doubt.


- 'A Verdade da Mentira', 'Maddie: The Truth of the Lie' by Gonçalo Amaral
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Alfred R Jones on May 17, 2014, 10:56:10 PM
Who has sanctioned Amaral's book officially as an accurate record? 
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Alfred R Jones on May 17, 2014, 10:58:21 PM
Why did Jane Tanner never make a statement confirming her identification of Murat?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on May 17, 2014, 11:00:27 PM
I can do one better.

I can provide the book, The Truth of the Lie, in which her identification of Murat is discussed.

The book has been officially sanctioned as an "accurate record" of the investigation, condensed of course.

Jane Tanner was placed inside a police surveillance van (with windows that allow you to look outside, from the van, without being seen), the van was parked in a strategic position, near apartment 5A, and PJ investigators took Murat with them, making exactly the same walk the man carrying a child had made, according to Jane Tanner.

Jane Tanner looked at Murat walking and told police she was sure he was the same man, she recognised the way he walked, with no doubt.


- 'A Verdade da Mentira', 'Maddie: The Truth of the Lie' by Gonçalo Amaral

Thanks. So a book which is part of an ongoing libel trial is superior to the files on which it is supposedly based? Jane's witness statements are in the files... so could you please provide a cite from the files?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on May 18, 2014, 12:54:28 AM
Oh ok, well why don't YOU provide the link to the Case Files.

Not the Archive report, the Case Files.

You were the one who stated that Jane had positively identified Murat. I have seen no such thing in the files, but if you are certain of it, then perhaps you could find it.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: John on May 18, 2014, 03:28:52 AM
Remember there were three others in the tapas group who fingered Murat and one was Jane Tanner's partner.  No doubt the implications of all this were discussed by them at great length.  I have no doubt they changed their minds as time passed.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Silkywhiskers on May 18, 2014, 03:36:25 AM
Lest we forget -   


Tapas Nine 'told police that Murat was man who fled apartment with child in his arms' Daily Mail
 
By VANESSA ALLEN
Last updated at 14:26 16 November 2007
 
Two friends of the McCanns told police they saw British expatriate Robert Murat carrying a child away from the couple's apartment the night Madeleine vanished, it was claimed yesterday.
 
Russell O'Brien and Jane Tanner allegedly identified Mr Murat, 33, during a face-to-face meeting between him, the McCanns and the rest of the so-called Tapas Nine in May, before he was named as an official suspect, Portuguese daily 24 horas claimed.
 
The McCanns' spokesman dismissed the report as "laughable".
 
The couple have said they do not remember ever meeting Mr Murat, who denies any involvement in Madeleine's disappearance.
 
Miss Tanner, 37, has told police she saw a man carrying a child away from the apartment, but never saw his face. Her partner Dr O'Brien, 36, has never claimed he saw a man carrying a child that night.
 
But an insider told the paper: "They were all placed in the same room and two people that left the restaurant pointed to Robert Murat.
 
"They said he was the person they saw next to the apartment where Madeleine was sleeping around the time the alarm was raised about her disappearance."
 
The tabloid added: "24 horas has learnt that the friends who accused Murat are Jane Tanner and Russell O'Brien.
 
"They clearly stated, during the face-to-face meeting, they thought it was him who was carrying a child in his arms.
 
"This is the same couple said to have indicated to Portuguese public prosecutors they intend altering their statements after it was made public that they could become official suspects."
 
Quoting a separate source, 24 horas added: "We know that Robert Murat was next to the apartment, he was pointed out by two witnesses and he is a friend of the McCanns."
 
Last night Francisco Pagarete, Murat's lawyer dismissed the claims as rubbish.
 
He said: "They are lies. "My client doesn't know the McCanns and the day Madeleine disappeared, he was at home with his mum.
 
"We are going to prove this is the case." Criticising Portuguese authorities over their decision not to clear Murat immediately and making him wait until next May to see the case files against him, he added:
 
"We're unhappy that we'll only be able to see the files next May and be in a position to defend ourselves."
 
Mystery has surrounded the identity of the two McCann holiday pals alleged to want to change statements they gave police soon after Madeleine disappeared.
 
Respected Spanish newspaper El Mundo, which made the initial claims, carried quotes from an unnamed lawyer for one of the Tapas Nine this week complaining his client was terrified about speaking out because of the political support for the McCanns.

Portuguese police believe the McCanns and their friends are hiding the truth and fear they may never solve the case if they do not break an alleged pact of silence.

 
The claim Jane Tanner and her partner fingered Murat early on in the investigation - and now want to change their statements - will fuel further speculation he is being made a scapegoat.
 
Jane Tanner helped police produce an E-fit of a man she claimed to have seen runhing away from their Ocean Club holiday complex with a child in a blanket.
 
Today's claim that she identified Murat as that man comes amid reports police are preparing to make her and three other members of the Tapas Nine official suspects because of inconsistencies in their original statements.
 

Murat has always protested his innocence and police have found no DNA evidence linking him to Madeleine's disappearance despite searching the home in the Algarve resort of Praia da Luz he shares with mum Jennifer and digging up their garden.
 
The McCanns have rubbished suggestions they are pressuring their friends into lying and claims any of the Tapas Nine want to change their statements.
 
They insist Madeleine was kidnapped by an intruder and possibly taken across the border into Spain by someone working to the orders of a paedophile gang.

 
Police allegedly failed to send blankets, pillows and mattresses from the McCanns' apartment in Praia da Luz for forensic testing.
 
A source at Portugal's National Institute of Legal Medicine said: "We were only sent a few forensic traces for DNA testing.
 
"It would have been good if they had sent us the blankets, pillows and even the mattress where the girl was sleeping.
 
"We might have found some important clues on them and not just hairs, which was what was sent to the institute.
 
"Speaking hypothetically, there could have been fibres belonging to an abductor, or even a fingerprint." Several items in the apartment are thought to have been cleaned by staff at the Ocean Club days after Maddie's disappearance.
 
The McCanns and their friends are also believed to have damaged vital evidence when they were walking round the crime scene before police arrived.
 
A police source said: "When we returned to the apartment more than 24 hours after the girl vanished, half of the evidence had already disappeared."


http://www.mccannfiles.com/id108.html
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Alfred R Jones on May 18, 2014, 09:47:28 AM
Jane Tanner would not have been confidently able to say she never id'ed Murat if she knew that somewhere in the police files was a signed statement from herself saying that she had.  The end.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on May 18, 2014, 09:50:42 AM
That's an example of when checking the files can be helpful. Jane Tanner wasn't even present at that face-to-face meeting.

It was Russell, Rachel and Fiona.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/ROBERT-MURAT.htm#p8p1957

Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Alfred R Jones on May 18, 2014, 09:52:46 AM
That's an example of when checking the files can be helpful. Jane Tanner wasn't even present at that face-to-face meeting.

It was Russell, Rachel and Fiona.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/ROBERT-MURAT.htm#p8p1957
Yes, an example of Amaral "getting it wrong".
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: ferryman on May 18, 2014, 11:37:14 AM
I can do one better.

I can provide the book, The Truth of the Lie, in which her identification of Murat is discussed.

The book has been officially sanctioned as an "accurate record" of the investigation, condensed of course.

Jane Tanner was placed inside a police surveillance van (with windows that allow you to look outside, from the van, without being seen), the van was parked in a strategic position, near apartment 5A, and PJ investigators took Murat with them, making exactly the same walk the man carrying a child had made, according to Jane Tanner.

Jane Tanner looked at Murat walking and told police she was sure he was the same man, she recognised the way he walked, with no doubt.


- 'A Verdade da Mentira', 'Maddie: The Truth of the Lie' by Gonçalo Amaral

Can you tell us where, from Mark Harrison's report, he states that Madeleine is definitely dead and that her concealed remains lie in close proximity to PdL?

Can you also tell us where Harrison says the culprit is most likely  someone close to Madeleine, and maybe, even, her parents?

And do you think that anything was hidden from the prosecutors, who are on record as stating that there is no evidence against the McCanns of any crime?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: ferryman on May 18, 2014, 11:43:02 AM
(Replying to Silkywhiskers):

You were the one who stated that Jane had positively identified Murat. I have seen no such thing in the files, but if you are certain of it, then perhaps you could find it.

Jane does say in her rogatory interview that, at just the moment she was about to make her sighting, a car pulled out and blocked her view.

She also says that they met Robert Murat* en route to the vehicle from where she would, later, attempt to make her sighting ...

Edited to correct surname, Tanner for Murat with thanks to Alfred R Jones for pointing out the error ...
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: John on May 18, 2014, 05:06:47 PM
BOB SMALL AND THE SPANISH POLICE
After speaking to “the people that Kate and Gerry brought in”, Miss Tanner received a telephone call from Bob Small (a senior Leicestershire Police Officer, who was assisting the PJ in the Algarve) who told her that the “Spanish Police” wanted to see her! Yes: he did say, according to Miss Tanner, “the Spanish Police”. It is likely, by that time, that covert plans had been made (on some pretext) to induce Mr Murat to walk across the top of the road, north of Apartment 5A, where Miss Tanner said she had seen the “abductor” and was thus the precise context in which she believed she could make an identification.
 
Mr Small told Miss Tanner to not to discuss anything with anyone, including her husband. She claims she followed this instruction to the letter: but is it realistic to believe she did not tell him anything: or is she lying on this point? If she is being untruthful, why?
 
Mr Murat was under suspicion but had not been made an “Arguido”. He been around the Ocean Club a lot from 4th May 2007 onwards and had interpreted the PJ’s interviews with Catriona Baker, Stacey Portz , Leanne Wagstaff and Amy Teirney (Folio 457). It is possible that between 6th May 2007 (when his name was mentioned by Lori Campbell) and 13th May 2007 the news that a local suspect had been identified had reached the ears of the “Tapas 9”. It is even conceivable that they knew the suspect was Mr Murat. Unlike her husband and others of the “Tapas 9”, Miss Tanner had never been introduced to Mr Murat.
 
THE ILL JUDGED“PICK UP”
Arrangements were made for Miss Tanner to be collected by Mr Small and his PJ colleagues in a car park near to Mr Murat’s home: this was probably around 7.30pm on Sunday 13th May 2007 while Dr Amaral waited for news in a meeting room at the Public Ministry, preparing to pounce if Miss Tanner’s identification was “successful”.
 
Miss Tanner dramatizes that she was “worried sick” that the “Spanish Police” were about to cart her off to destinations unknown and got her husband to walk with her to the rendezvous with Mr Small. If, as she claims, she did not discuss the identification operation with her husband, what precisely did she say to him? What did he think was going on? Who looked after their kids and what did they tell them? It is beyond belief that Russell O’Brien and some of the other “Tapasniks” did not know what was afoot.
 
Why the police arranged Miss Tanner’s pick up so near to their main suspect’s home was at best foolish and was asking for trouble. On their way to the car park - and just outside his home - Robert Murat (who had met Russell O' Brien on the morning of Friday 4th May 2007) stopped, got out of his green VW van and chatted, showing the couple posters he had made to “Find Madeleine” and generally rattling on about nothing in particular. This was the first time Miss Tanner had been introduced to Mr Murat, but given the events that were about to follow it is amazing she did not cry out “That’s him… that’s the ‘person’ I saw: the abductor”. But she didn’t say a single word.
 
In April 2008 she told the Leicestershire Police that she was concerned that there “was some strange conspiracy going on” (to abduct her) and that Mr Small had “scared the daylights out of her”. She continued: “But that made me even more suspicious because it was like, so I think at that point, I think I actually spoke to Stewart (Stewart Prior the lead UK Police Investigator in Luz)”. She knows she had spoken to Mr Prior and thus had no reason to believe that she was about to be abducted. Her histrionics in this regard are absurd.
 
The discussion Miss Tanner had with her husband about the identification charade are very important. He had already met Mr Murat and would be able to identify him and point him out to her. Was it pure coincidence that he accompanied Miss Tanner to the pick up by Mr Small? Was it bad planning that the pick up was just outside Mr Murat’s house? Was it misfortune that they happened to bump into Mr Murat? Or is the whole sequence far more sinister?
 
Miss Tanner was taken away by Mr Small and the PJ and she says Russell O’Brien wrote down their car registration number, presumably so he could rescue her if the Spanish Police abducted her. Miss Tanner was driven to another location and hidden in the back of an undercover surveillance vehicle (a refrigerated van) which was driven to a position near the side entrance to Apartment 5A, facing north.
 
THE IDENTIFICATION OF MR MURAT AS THE ABDUCTOR
Miss Tanner then, apparently, saw three people walk across the top of the road: but Mr Murat was the first to do so. It is not clear exactly what she told the PJ at the time but, however she would like to spin the story now, it was enough to make them believe Mr Murat was the “abductor”, notwithstanding the fact that he looked nothing like the “Egg Man” or her verbal description. The sighting was reported to Dr Amaral and the Public Ministry and plans made to arrest Mr Murat.  The following day, 14 May 2007, Robert Murat was designated an arguido.

http://thetapas9janetanner.blogspot.co.uk/2012/02/jane-tanner-and-framing-of-robert-murat.html
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Alfred R Jones on May 18, 2014, 05:18:11 PM
As I asked earlier, if Jane Tanner had id'ed Murat why is there no signed statement to that effect?  It's rather an important piece of evidence after all.  And if she did sign a statement that has been squirrelled away in a secret file then she would have to be a very brazen liar indeed to claim she never id'ed him, knowing she could be proven a liar whenever the police chose to remind her of her statement.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: John on May 18, 2014, 05:56:45 PM
The events according to Goncal Amaral.

(http://i.imgur.com/JzEFMry.png)
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on May 18, 2014, 06:02:58 PM
As I asked earlier, if Jane Tanner had id'ed Murat why is there no signed statement to that effect?  It's rather an important piece of evidence after all.  And if she did sign a statement that has been squirrelled away in a secret file then she would have to be a very brazen liar indeed to claim she never id'ed him, knowing she could be proven a liar whenever the police chose to remind her of her statement.

It must be in the secret, secret, secret files... ;) Jane's so-called identification isn't even mentioned in the final PJ report unless I missed it.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Benice on May 18, 2014, 06:04:03 PM
As I asked earlier, if Jane Tanner had id'ed Murat why is there no signed statement to that effect?  It's rather an important piece of evidence after all.  And if she did sign a statement that has been squirrelled away in a secret file then she would have to be a very brazen liar indeed to claim she never id'ed him, knowing she could be proven a liar whenever the police chose to remind her of her statement.

If there had been a signed statement from JT confirming her identification of RM as the abductor it would have been the most compelling evidence against him and would  most certainly have been recorded by the AG in his Final Report - in the section about Robert Murat.   All other reasons for making him an arguido are mentioned but not JT's alleged identification of him.   Surely if it existed it would have been top of the list??     Common sense alone dictates that the reason for that is because there was no statement - and there was no statement because there had been no identification.

IMO a statement from JT confirming that she could NOT identify RM as the abductor would have been of no use to Amaral, but with no statement at all in existence to contradict him - he could say what he liked.  Which is exactly what he went on to do in his efforts to discredit her. 



Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on May 18, 2014, 06:05:41 PM
The events according to Goncal Amaral.

(http://i.imgur.com/JzEFMry.png)

He was also adamant that she'd been to this confrontation meeting... oh, dear.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Alfred R Jones on May 18, 2014, 06:09:13 PM
If there had been a signed statement from JT confirming her identification of RM as the abductor it would have been the most compelling evidence against him and would  most certainly have been recorded by the AG in his Final Report - in the section about Robert Murat.   All other reasons for making him an arguido are mentioned but not JT's alleged identification of him.   Surely if it existed it would have been top of the list??     Common sense alone dictates that the reason for that is because there was no statement - and there was no statement because there had been no identification.

IMO a statement from JT confirming that she could NOT identify RM as the abductor would have been of no use to Amaral, but with no statement at all in existence to contradict him - he could say what he liked.  Which is exactly what he went on to do in his efforts to discredit her.
Precisely right.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on May 18, 2014, 06:35:26 PM
If there had been a signed statement from JT confirming her identification of RM as the abductor it would have been the most compelling evidence against him and would  most certainly have been recorded by the AG in his Final Report - in the section about Robert Murat.   All other reasons for making him an arguido are mentioned but not JT's alleged identification of him.   Surely if it existed it would have been top of the list??     Common sense alone dictates that the reason for that is because there was no statement - and there was no statement because there had been no identification.

IMO a statement from JT confirming that she could NOT identify RM as the abductor would have been of no use to Amaral, but with no statement at all in existence to contradict him - he could say what he liked.  Which is exactly what he went on to do in his efforts to discredit her.

Well, erm, yes.

That's been quite convenient for him over the years.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Benice on May 18, 2014, 09:51:48 PM
Let's try again.

The contents of his book are supposed to correspond to what is in the publicly accessible files. So where, in those files, is the verification that she positively identified Murat?

Who has judged that the book is an "accurate account" of the investigation? The whole investigation, when he was only on it for 5 months?

Did I blink and miss the conclusion of the defamation trial?

Anyone who thinks Amaral's book is 'accurate' cannot possibly have read the files imo.   His book is littered with lies, half truths and wild exaggeration none of which is supported by the information we know from the files  including the downright lie that JT FORMALLY identified Robert Murat.

Kates states in her book that what Amaral claimed about JT's identification of RM as the abductor is' completely untrue'.

So why isn't Amaral shouting it from the rooftops that Kate has lied in her book and there is a witness statement from JT to prove it?   Surely he would be bringing that up during all his TV interviews in order to discredit Kate's book?   But not a peep from him.   

IIRC Amaral has also claimed that JT was one of the people who attended the 'confrontation' meeting with Murat  Another downright lie about her.




Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Alfred R Jones on May 18, 2014, 09:55:15 PM
JT would not claim she hadn't id'ed Murat if there existed a signed statement from her in the PJ's files that she had, now would she?  Really?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Wonderfulspam on May 18, 2014, 10:18:35 PM
“Erm well I think it’s when I’d done the, well I did the surveillance and then the next day after that, I think it came on Sky News about whether they were searching, what the MURAT’s house, so that’s Rachel sort of came running down at that point and sort of said, have you seen this blah, blah and at this point, nobody knew that I’d done the surveillance cos the Portuguese Police were very adamant that I shouldn’t tell anybody and I didn’t tell anybody for days actually, I didn’t even tell them then that it was actually, that I’d done it, I mean it was a couple of days afterwards.  So Rachel came down and sort of said, oh I saw him blah, blah, blah and then I think Russell, I can’t remember who else but then somebody else said oh they, they saw him and etc., so at that point it was, I rang Bob SMALL cos I’d got, I’d got his number from the day before for them and you know, they sort of, you know to say, oh is this, is this relevant and also I wanted to tell him that I’d seen him on the way to the doing the surveillance as well yeah just for that, so I think it’s just to make the point really that I think at that point, they didn’t know that Robert MURAT said he wasn’t there on the night”.

4078    “Right”.

Reply    “You know, or said yeah, had said that he wasn’t there on the night, so you know was immediately, I think it was immediately, I’m not trying to push anything onto Robert MURAT’s door, cos as I say I don’t think it was him that I saw”.

4078    “No”.

Reply    “But I just thought it was”.

 @)(++(*
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: ferryman on May 19, 2014, 09:17:39 AM
The whole (non)-"argument" about Jane Tanner identifying Robert Murat or not stops at the point where Jane met Robert en route to the van from where she attempted her observation.

The whole exercise was nul and void from that point.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: John on May 20, 2014, 05:56:11 AM
“Erm well I think it’s when I’d done the, well I did the surveillance and then the next day after that, I think it came on Sky News about whether they were searching, what the MURAT’s house, so that’s Rachel sort of came running down at that point and sort of said, have you seen this blah, blah and at this point, nobody knew that I’d done the surveillance cos the Portuguese Police were very adamant that I shouldn’t tell anybody and I didn’t tell anybody for days actually, I didn’t even tell them then that it was actually, that I’d done it, I mean it was a couple of days afterwards.  So Rachel came down and sort of said, oh I saw him blah, blah, blah and then I think Russell, I can’t remember who else but then somebody else said oh they, they saw him and etc., so at that point it was, I rang Bob SMALL cos I’d got, I’d got his number from the day before for them and you know, they sort of, you know to say, oh is this, is this relevant and also I wanted to tell him that I’d seen him on the way to the doing the surveillance as well yeah just for that, so I think it’s just to make the point really that I think at that point, they didn’t know that Robert MURAT said he wasn’t there on the night”.

4078    “Right”.

Reply    “You know, or said yeah, had said that he wasn’t there on the night, so you know was immediately, I think it was immediately, I’m not trying to push anything onto Robert MURAT’s door, cos as I say I don’t think it was him that I saw”.

4078    “No”.

Reply    “But I just thought it was”.

 @)(++(*

What she means is that she thought it was him she saw at the time but has since changed her mind. Simples!,
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Wonderfulspam on May 20, 2014, 08:17:29 AM
What she means is that she thought it was him she saw at the time but has since changed her mind. Simples!,

So she did ID him then.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Alfred R Jones on May 20, 2014, 08:25:32 AM
So she did ID him then.
No she didn't as has already been demonstrated.  Your clip of a conversation should include the next few sentences spoken by the questioner and JT - it's obvious to me that she was cut off in mid sentence or about to say something else and was interrupted.  These things happen in conversation you know, but when written down verbatim can look like something else was meant.  It makes absolutely no sense whatsoever for JT to say " I don't think it was him I saw, but I just thought it was", now does it?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Wonderfulspam on May 20, 2014, 08:31:19 AM
No she didn't as has already been demonstrated.  Your clip of a conversation should include the next few sentences spoken by the questioner and JT - it's obvious to me that she was cut off in mid sentence or about to say something else and was interrupted.  These things happen in conversation you know, but when written down verbatim can look like something else was meant.  It makes absolutely no sense whatsoever for JT to say " I don't think it was him I saw, but I just thought it was", now does it?

She thought it was him, get over it.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Benice on May 20, 2014, 08:47:51 AM
No she didn't as has already been demonstrated.  Your clip of a conversation should include the next few sentences spoken by the questioner and JT - it's obvious to me that she was cut off in mid sentence or about to say something else and was interrupted.  These things happen in conversation you know, but when written down verbatim can look like something else was meant.  It makes absolutely no sense whatsoever for JT to say " I don't think it was him I saw, but I just thought it was", now does it?

I quite agree - in fact I was about to post exactly the same - i.e that she paused in mid sentence.     Especially as she went on to confirm categorically in the same interview that she did not believe Murat was the man she saw - but that part of the interview was not posted. 

Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Wonderfulspam on May 20, 2014, 08:50:56 AM
I quite agree - in fact I was about to post exactly the same - i.e that she paused in mid sentence.     Especially as she went on to confirm categorically in the same interview that she did not believe Murat was the man she saw - but that part of the interview was not posted.

She thought it was him, get over it.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on May 20, 2014, 10:26:22 AM
The first time I read her rog (ages ago), I was a bit puzzled by "I just thought it was". However, on a second - closer - reading, it seems clear to me that she hadn't finished her sentence, and it's just the punctuation (a full stop) that makes it seem as if she had. I've marked in blue other instances of a full stop when clearly she'd been cut off by the officer (there are numerous instances throughout the rog).

The context of that passage is that when the others came to tell her that Murat had said that he wasn't around that night (while they thought he had been), she agreed that it was important to inform Bob Small in case it was relevant. She had been in contact with Bob Small and had his phone number, so she made the call on behalf of the others.


(...) So Rachel came down and sort of said, oh I saw him blah, blah, blah and then I think Russell, I can’t remember who else but then somebody else said oh they, they saw him and etc., so at that point it was, I rang Bob SMALL cos I’d got, I’d got his number from the day before for them and you know, they sort of, you know to say, oh is this, is this relevant and also I wanted to tell him that I’d seen him on the way to the doing the surveillance as well yeah just for that, so I think it’s just to make the point really that I think at that point, they didn’t know that Robert MURAT said he wasn’t there on the night”.

4078 “Right”.

Reply “You know, or said yeah, had said that he wasn’t there on the night, so you know was
immediately, I think it was immediately, I’m not trying to push anything onto Robert MURAT’s door, cos as I say I don’t think it was him that I saw”.

4078 “No”.

Reply “But I just thought it was”.

4078 “Because there had been some dispute as to whether they’ve actually seen him when they’ve said they’ve seen him”.

Reply “Yeah I think, I just want to make it clear that from my own point of view, they gave that information as soon as it came onto Sky and asked and you know they were sort of like, oh let’s ring Bob SMALL to see if it’s relevant at this point and at that point, none of us knew that he wasn’t there on you know, that he didn’t say that he was there on the night and”.

4078 “Yes”.

Reply “And I, I mean I didn’t myself see him on the night at all but somebody did say to me,
who translated for you, was it the lady or the man and it, it was the lady, I said, Sylvie and I hadn’t seen a man but again I don’t know whether that has any relevance that there was somebody else there translating, you know during the night so”.

4078 “Okay, that’s certainly a point worth bringing up when we interview the other people that have seen him there on the night”.

Reply “Yeah exactly, I’m not trying to, cos I feel you know, if he’s not involved, the poor chap’s had as much crap as us really, I feel very, you know, he’s not involved but I do think it’s important that”.

4078 “Get to the truth of the matter”?

Reply “Get to the truth of the matter and the truth is you know they, when they asked me to
ring Bob SMALL to make these statements, we didn’t even know that he’d erm, hadn’t, hadn’t said he was there on the night and they didn’t know that I’d done the surveillance”.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Mr Moderator on May 20, 2014, 02:00:55 PM
Jane Tanner states categorically that, “But I just thought it was” when asked if she had identified Robert Murat as being the carrier.  There is no getting away from this regardless of how she now feels seven years later.

On this basis and the statements of the other three tapas group members who claimed to have seen him loitering around the complex on the night of Madeleine's disappearance plus the comments by reporter Lori Campbell who also made derogatory remarks about him, he was arrested and made an arguido on 14 May 2007.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: icabodcrane on May 20, 2014, 02:17:13 PM
Jane Tanner states categorically that, “But I just thought it was” when asked if she had identified Robert Murat as being the carrier.  There is no getting away from this regardless of how she now feels seven years later.

On this basis and the statements of the other three tapas group members who claimed to have seen him loitering around the complex on the night of Madeleine's disappearance plus the comments by reporter Lori Campbell who also made derogatory remarks about him, he was arrested and made an arguido on 14 May 2007.

I don't know much about the Murat connection to this case and I hadn't realised that he was made Arguido on the strength of the Tapas group's allegations

That is quite remarkable  ...  they  presented the police with a  'suspect'  ?   
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Victoria on May 20, 2014, 02:20:10 PM
I don't know much about the Murat connection to this case and I hadn't realised that he was made Arguido on the strength of the Tapas group's allegations

That is quite remarkable  ...  they  presented the police with a  'suspect'  ?

No.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: icabodcrane on May 20, 2014, 02:30:13 PM
No.

So why  was  Murat made Arguido then   ?  ...   did what the Tapas group said about him play no part in the fact that he became a police suspect  ?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on May 20, 2014, 03:24:27 PM
What about Lori Campbell?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: icabodcrane on May 20, 2014, 03:29:47 PM

What about Lori Campbell?

The journalist who expressed suspicions about Murat's behaviour  ?

Do you think that would have been enough to lead the police into making Murat an Arguido  ?  ...   a journalist's  'intuition'  ? 

Or do you think it was the fact that friends of the McCanns  said they had seen him lurking around the apartment on the night Madeleine went missing  that lead the police to suspect him  ? 
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on May 20, 2014, 03:35:33 PM
The journalist who expressed suspicions about Murat's behaviour  ?

Do you think that would have been enough to lead the police into making Murat an Arguido  ?  ...   a journalist's  'intuition'  ? 

Or do you think it was the fact that friends of the McCanns  said they had seen him lurking around the apartment on the night Madeleine went missing  that lead the police to suspect him  ?

Hard to tell. Her suspicion may have led to a particular focus. Her suspicion may have been based on the Soham case and she may have thought that she was onto a scoop. Bear in mind that that the communication from LP appears to date from 6 May.


02-Processo, Volume 2, Page 307-308
02_VOLUMEIIa_Page_307
02_VOLUMEIIa_Page_308
Letter from Leicester Constabulary
to Portugal Incident Room/Madeleine McCann
 

6th May 2007

Sir,

Lori CAMPBELL a reporter from the Sunday Mirror has contacted Leicestershire Police to report the following.
Lori has been speaking to an interpreter who has been helping authorities with the investigation into Madeleine's disappearance. He has only given his name as 'ROR' (sic) and has not given any background information about himself.
Lori has become suspicious of Rob as he has given conflicting accounts to various people and became very concerned when he noticed his photo being taken by the Mirror's photographer. 'ROB' stated to Lori that he is going through a messy divorce
In the UK at the moment and that he had a three year old daughter just like Madeleine, who he is separated from at the moment. He made a big show of telephoning his daughter in front of reporters, and Lori felt that he was being too loud and making a big thing of speaking to his daughter on the phone. The things that 'ROB' has said to Lori have raised her concerns about him.
Could you please call Lori who is still in Portugal to establish further details to identify 'ROB' in order to eliminate him from your enquiries on 07917 xxxxxx.
Submitted for information
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Angelo222 on May 20, 2014, 03:41:38 PM
Had Murat admitted that he had been out for a walk that morning the PJ's suspicions might not have been raised to the extent they were. In the face of what appeared to be overwhelming witness evidence his denials were seen as highly suspicious.  How could three people have seen him if he wasn't there?

Miss Campbell's suspicions about him were then added to the mix and Tanner's on/off id just added to it.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on May 20, 2014, 03:42:22 PM
I have no problem that she reported her doubt / suspicion... whatever you wish to call it.

However, I do find that this doubt should have remained confidential. It wasn't.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Mr Moderator on May 20, 2014, 03:49:12 PM
Had Murat admitted that he had been out for a walk that morning the PJ's suspicions might not have been raised to the extent they were. In the face of what appeared to be overwhelming witness evidence his denials were seen as highly suspicious.  How could three people have seen him if he wasn't there?

Miss Campbell's suspicions about him were then added to the mix and Tanner's on/off id just added to it.

Lets not forget that Tanner saw the carrier walking in the direction of Murat's home, another factor in the mix.  The poor fellow just couldn't win.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on May 20, 2014, 04:22:46 PM
Had Murat admitted that he had been out for a walk that morning the PJ's suspicions might not have been raised to the extent they were. In the face of what appeared to be overwhelming witness evidence his denials were seen as highly suspicious.  How could three people have seen him if he wasn't there?

Miss Campbell's suspicions about him were then added to the mix and Tanner's on/off id just added to it.


The T3 weren't the only ones.

I find it totally plausible that people got confused about what they actually remembered, possibly enhanced over the sensibility issue, and assumed that anyone who may have resembled him was assumed to be him when he appeared on TV as an arguido.

Any male wearing glasses that night could have been mistaken for him.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Anna on May 20, 2014, 04:41:46 PM

The T3 weren't the only ones.

I find it totally plausible that people got confused about what they actually remembered, possibly enhanced over the sensibility issue, and assumed that anyone who may have resembled him was assumed to be him when he appeared on TV as an arguido.

Any male wearing glasses that night could have been mistaken for him.

There was 6 or 7 witnesses who said they saw him on that night
2 sisters  http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic18525.html#p241493
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Benice on May 20, 2014, 05:15:57 PM
Murat had already been made an Arguido BEFORE the three members of the tapas 7 spoke to the police about him.   It was seeing his face on TV AFTER he had been made an arguido which prompted them to  ring.  Therefore there is no way they could have been instrumental in his being made an argiudo.  This was discussed at length in another thread some time ago. 

Jane Tanner did not identify Murat in the ID parade - otherwise she would have been taken straight to the police station  - where Amaral was waiting -  to sign a statement to that effect.  What else was he waiting for?    That did not happen - she was simply told there was no need for her to sign anything and sent home.  And that can only be because she did not identify Murat.


Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on May 20, 2014, 05:16:42 PM
There was 6 or 7 witnesses who said they saw him on that night
2 sisters  http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic18525.html#p241493

Thanks Anna, but the pressure was on and it is so easy for the tabloid press to file any story, whether it was checked out or not. There was no official way of fact-checking as there was no press service (beyond the poor chap who was shoved in front of the cameras with no information).

Some people may have believed that they'd seen Murat, however some people may have confused Murat with anyone else wearing glasses: David Payne, John Hill... just about anyone else of that vague description who was trying to help that night.

There might also be someone else around that evening who hasn't been eliminated.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Anna on May 20, 2014, 05:39:51 PM
I agree Carana.
          In the poor lighting it could have been anyone and the wrongful person being taken as being Murat could have also been anyone.


Silvia María Correio Ramos Batista

Date: 2007 – 05 – 15 excerpt

When asked, she says that on the night of Madeleine’s disappearance, 3rd May, she was called by her boss at about 22.30. As she lives in Lagos, she arrived shortly afterwards at the resort. There were about 60 people close to apartment 5 A, helping to look for the girl.

She remembers, but is not absolutely certain, given the time that has passed, that from the start, there was an individual helping to look for Madeleine, about 1.70 tall, with sort, light brown hair, with thin framed, brown glasses, who was also helping to search.

She does not remember at what time she saw him. She does not remember how he was dressed. She does not remember whom he was with or know if he arrived on foot or by car.

The same individual, she knew later to be the son of the Murat’s, Robert Murat.


http://themaddiecasefiles.com/post261.html#p261
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on May 20, 2014, 05:42:15 PM

Murat had already been made an Arguido BEFORE the three members of the tapas 7 spoke to the police about him.   It was seeing his face on TV AFTER he had been made an arguido which prompted them to  ring.  Therefore there is no way they could have been instrumental in his being made an argiudo.  This was discussed at length in another thread some time ago. 

Jane Tanner did not identify Murat in the ID parade - otherwise she would have been taken straight to the police station  - where Amaral was waiting -  to sign a statement to that effect.  What else was he waiting for?    That did not happen - she was simply told there was no need for her to sign anything and sent home.  And that can only be because she did not identify Murat.


I'm still trying to work out why Amaral states that Jane positively identified Murat.

When was this supposed to have occurred?

There is no statement concerning her alleged identification of the van episode (either way).

I'm also perplexed as to why Amaral stated that she was at this confrontation with Murat, face-to face with other members of the T9, when there is no record (by the PJ) of her even being present at that event... not in the files, nor even in the press.

He does seem to have a somewhat unique perspective about many issues which don't seem to have been corroborated...

Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on May 20, 2014, 05:56:44 PM
I agree Carana.
          In the poor lighting it could have been anyone and the wrongful person being taken as being Murat could have also been anyone.


Silvia María Correio Ramos Batista

Date: 2007 – 05 – 15 excerpt

When asked, she says that on the night of Madeleine’s disappearance, 3rd May, she was called by her boss at about 22.30. As she lives in Lagos, she arrived shortly afterwards at the resort. There were about 60 people close to apartment 5 A, helping to look for the girl.

She remembers, but is not absolutely certain, given the time that has passed, that from the start, there was an individual helping to look for Madeleine, about 1.70 tall, with sort, light brown hair, with thin framed, brown glasses, who was also helping to search.

She does not remember at what time she saw him. She does not remember how he was dressed. She does not remember whom he was with or know if he arrived on foot or by car.

The same individual, she knew later to be the son of the Murat’s, Robert Murat.


http://themaddiecasefiles.com/post261.html#p261


Something that I've always found a bit odd about that is how could Silvia have lived/worked within 100 m of  the Murat family and not realised that Jenny had a son?

There could be a false assumption recorded in Silvia's statement. There's no way of knowing.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Anna on May 20, 2014, 06:14:08 PM

Something that I've always found a bit odd about that is how could Silvia have lived/worked within 100 m of each other and not realised that Jenny had a son?

There could be a false assumption recorded  in her statement. There's no way of knowing.

I was suggesting that the tapas 3, who thought they saw RM, were not the only people who thought that they saw him, when in fact he had several lookalikes in the area.

http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/madeleine-robert-murat-has-a-double-289449


Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Benice on May 20, 2014, 06:19:21 PM

Something that I've always found a bit odd about that is how could Silvia have lived/worked within 100 m of  the Murat family and not realised that Jenny had a son?

There could be a false assumption recorded in Silvia's statement. There's no way of knowing.

According to Kate's book - Silvia should have been present at the 'confrontation meeting' - but didn't turn up.

Quote pg 244

........snip.......They waited for a while because the police said Silvia Batista would be joining them.  For some reason she never did.
End quote

Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Brietta on May 20, 2014, 06:31:07 PM
I was suggesting that the tapas 3, who thought they saw RM, were not the only people who thought that they saw him, when in fact he had several lookalikes in the area.

http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/madeleine-robert-murat-has-a-double-289449

An early reconstruction could have enabled these 'lookalikes' who had turned out to search for Madeleine or just to find out what the fuss was all about ~ to have indicated where and why they were in a particular place at a particular time.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Anna on May 20, 2014, 08:48:05 PM
An early reconstruction could have enabled these 'lookalikes' who had turned out to search for Madeleine or just to find out what the fuss was all about ~ to have indicated where and why they were in a particular place at a particular time.

I think there was so many people around that night, that a few of them may have been mistaken for RM including of course DP.
 RM had never met The Real estate owner (his lookalike) although his office was very close to the Ocean Club. The Murats seemed to keep to themselves,
Maybe they were all like that in PDL? 
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Brietta on May 21, 2014, 01:19:36 AM
I think there was so many people around that night, that a few of them may have been mistaken for RM including of course DP.
 RM had never met The Real estate owner (his lookalike) although his office was very close to the Ocean Club. The Murats seemed to keep to themselves,
Maybe they were all like that in PDL?

I believe Mr Murat had many and distinguished family ties in the area and in common with many families he might not have known distant relatives or cousins ... although there would in many cases be a familial resemblance.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: John on May 21, 2014, 12:02:46 PM

Murat had already been made an Arguido BEFORE the three members of the tapas 7 spoke to the police about him.   It was seeing his face on TV AFTER he had been made an arguido which prompted them to  ring.  Therefore there is no way they could have been instrumental in his being made an argiudo.  This was discussed at length in another thread some time ago. 

Jane Tanner did not identify Murat in the ID parade - otherwise she would have been taken straight to the police station  - where Amaral was waiting -  to sign a statement to that effect.  What else was he waiting for?    That did not happen - she was simply told there was no need for her to sign anything and sent home.  And that can only be because she did not identify Murat.

So let's recap.  Russell O'Brien claims to have seen Robert Murat in the front car park of OC Block 5 at 1.00am on the morning after Madeleine's disappearance (4th May) and later that morning asks him for his mobile phone number so that he could contact him if he needed a translator.

That on the day he accompanies partner Jane Tanner to a meeting with PJ detectives (13th May) they bump into Murat and he introduces Jane to him. That later that same day whilst taking part in an undercover surveillance of Murat Jane tells detectives that Murat's walk reminded her of the way the mystery man she saw carrying the child walked.

That on 14th May, Robert Murat was arrested and made an arguido.

That on 16th May, Russell O'Brien made another statement to police advising of events on 4th May with respect to Robert Murat.

So bottom line is O'Brien claims to have seen Murat lurking around the car park just yards from where Madeleine vanished hours earlier yet takes over 2 weeks to advise the police of this fact
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on May 21, 2014, 01:03:07 PM
Russell didn't say he saw him "lurking". Russell had seen someone with glasses helping to interpret between unspecified people and the police that night, presumably not for Russell as he didn't talk to him until late morning. It wasn't until he and the other two saw him on TV that they found it odd that he'd said that he wasn't there that night.


When asked, he says that as far as he can remember, Robert was translating conversations between two officers and various people who were searching for Madeleine. As far as he could make out at that time, it seemed that Robert was trying to help, in the sense that these people were exasperated with some of the officers. He remembers that all the people were quite upset, whilst Robert was very calm. That morning was the first time the witness spoke to Murat, not remembering whether he had approached Murat or whether Robert had addressed him. They had various discussions including the fact that Robert was fluent in Portuguese as he had lived in the country for many years.


It could have been anyone with glasses, possibly even John Hill.

Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: John on May 21, 2014, 01:14:26 PM
Actually...

 When questioned he says that the first time he saw Robert Murat was on the night of the events currently under investigation, in other words, the night upon which Madeleine disappeared, at about 01.00 in the early morning of 4th May.

 That he saw Murat for the first time at this moment in the Rua Silva in front of the apartment where the events occurred, near to the parking area.

Not just any man with glasses but Robert Murat.

www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RUSSELL-OBRIEN.htm
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on May 21, 2014, 03:09:02 PM
Actually...

 When questioned he says that the first time he saw Robert Murat was on the night of the events currently under investigation, in other words, the night upon which Madeleine disappeared, at about 01.00 in the early morning of 4th May.

 That he saw Murat for the first time at this moment in the Rua Silva in front of the apartment where the events occurred, near to the parking area.

Not just any man with glasses but Robert Murat.

www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RUSSELL-OBRIEN.htm

Yes, I'm aware that he was convinced that it was Murat that he saw, no doubt strengthened by the fact that other people believed they'd seen him as well.

A few snippets from his rog:

...Erm, we certainly, the three, you know, the three of us, all immediately thought, when we saw him on the television, that we recognised him and that he was there on the night and the statements that were given were given relatively soon after the event and at the time I had absolutely no doubt that that was, that those were accurate. (He also mentions that Charlotte Pennington and Silvia (originally) thought they'd seen him as well.)

But then he does seem puzzled:
The reason I brought this back up here is because I cannot see what he stood to gain by not, by not being, well by saying he wasn’t there on the night when there was the potential for so many people to have seen him.



And then he wonders if he got mixed up between seeing him in the early hours and when he saw him later that morning - it was, after all, a stressful night without much sleep, possibly compounded by a transference/suggestibility effect.

 Reply    “It just says here ‘What I said in my statement was right at the time’, I think those statements were correct, it’s just with the passage of time and all the other news has made me doubt, has made me doubt whether I’ve got what I saw on the morning and the evening mixed, but I’ll come back to, I can come back to that”


Either Murat was there that night or he wasn't. And I can't see any reason, either, for him to deny being there that night trying to help translate, if indeed he was.

The GNR don't remember him there, but seemingly someone with glasses was. It would have been easy enough for the PJ to check with the police (GNR /PJ, whichever) for a description, and possibly a name, of who did help them and the English-speakers that night, and an appeal for whichever bespectacled kind soul it was to come forward.

Did they try to find out?




Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Victoria on May 21, 2014, 04:01:08 PM
According to Amaral, the PJ had their eyes on Murat before any of the tapas group mentioned him.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: jassi on May 21, 2014, 04:04:43 PM
According to Amaral, the PJ had their eyes on Murat before any of the tapas group mentioned him.


But, of course, one can't believe anything he said   @)(++(*
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Eleanor on May 21, 2014, 11:27:28 PM

Jane Tanner didn't identify Robert Murat.  If she had have done her feet wouldn't have touched the ground before she was signing on the dotted line of a statement.  Amaral would never have missed a chance like that.

Someone identifies the prime suspect and Amaral doesn't get  statement?  How improbable is that?

And then he has the brass neck to lie about it.

Nothing new there then.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Mr Moderator on May 22, 2014, 01:15:07 PM
Jane Tanner was one of the first witnesses interviewed at police HQ on the day after Madeleine disappeared.  She claims that..."she would be able to identify the man she would recognise him from the back by his particular way of walking"  quote Amaral.

Amaral became aware of Murat a week after Madeleine disappeared. On 10 May he arrived in Luz and was walking routes near the apartment block when he noticed a man with glasses arrive in a green vehicle and go into a private villa.  He watched as he emerged with an elderly lady and followed them towards the area of the swimming pools and the tapas bar. He later saw them return and when the man passed the time of day with a GNR officer Amaral enquired of that officer who the man was.  This was Amaral's introduction to Robert Murat.

This chance meeting and the information which had already been furnished by journalist Lori Campbell about Murat set wheels turning. Thus began the investigation of Robert Murat which culminated in the covert id by Jane Tanner three days later and his intervew the following day.

Jane Tanner thought Robert Murat was the man she had seen that night by his particular way of walking.

Whether this can be classed as an identification is open to debate.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on May 22, 2014, 02:16:20 PM
Jane Tanner was one of the first witnesses interviewed at police HQ on the day after Madeleine disappeared.  She claims that..."she would be able to identify the man she would recognise him from the back by his particular way of walking"  quote Amaral.

Amaral became aware of Murat a week after Madeleine disappeared. On 10 May he arrived in Luz and was walking routes near the apartment block when he noticed a man with glasses arrive in a green vehicle and go into a private villa.  He watched as he emerged with an elderly lady and followed them towards the area of the swimming pools and the tapas bar. He later saw them return and when the man passed the time of day with a GNR officer Amaral enquired of that officer who the man was.  This was Amaral's introduction to Robert Murat.

This chance meeting and the information which had already been furnished by journalist Lori Campbell about Murat set wheels turning. Thus began the investigation of Robert Murat which culminated in the covert id by Jane Tanner three days later and his arrest the following day.

Jane Tanner thought Robert Murat was the man she had seen that night by his particular way of walking.

Whether this can be classed as an identification is open to debate.

Which private villa? Was this his home?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Benice on May 22, 2014, 04:00:48 PM
Jane Tanner was one of the first witnesses interviewed at police HQ on the day after Madeleine disappeared.  She claims that..."she would be able to identify the man she would recognise him from the back by his particular way of walking"  quote Amaral.

Amaral became aware of Murat a week after Madeleine disappeared. On 10 May he arrived in Luz and was walking routes near the apartment block when he noticed a man with glasses arrive in a green vehicle and go into a private villa.  He watched as he emerged with an elderly lady and followed them towards the area of the swimming pools and the tapas bar. He later saw them return and when the man passed the time of day with a GNR officer Amaral enquired of that officer who the man was.  This was Amaral's introduction to Robert Murat.

This chance meeting and the information which had already been furnished by journalist Lori Campbell about Murat set wheels turning. Thus began the investigation of Robert Murat which culminated in the covert id by Jane Tanner three days later and his arrest the following day.

Jane Tanner thought Robert Murat was the man she had seen that night by his particular way of walking.Whether this can be classed as an identification is open to debate.

Jane Tanner didn't even get a good enough look at Robert Murat to recognise him as the man she'd seen just an hour before!   If she had identified him in any way shape or form as the man she'd seen on the 3rd May she would have been taken to the police station - where Amaral was waiting for the phone call to hear the results of the ID parade - so that she could give a statement.     Why is that so hard for some people to understand?    She wasn't taken to the police station she was sent home instead.  There can only be one reason for that.       There is no statement by JT identifying Robert Murat - otherwise the AG would have referred to it in his Final Report as probably the prime reason why RM was made an arguido. 

She may have said at an earlier interview that she thought she would be able to recognise the man she saw by his walk - and if so then IMO Amaral has used that true statement and mixed it in with a load of untruths to try to give them authenticity.    As he does so many other times in his book and during his many TV interviews.   Once JT's sighting became an 'inconvenience' to his attempts to pin the crime on the parents his answer to that problem was to discredit her as a witness. 

It seems to me that ruining the characters of witnesses in the publics eye - by conducting smear campaigns against them via the media was a normal part of 'getting a result' for some members of the PJ.   The same treatment was meted out to Leonor Cipriano. who was tried and found guilty by an enraged public as a result of the media, - before the case even got to court. imo.   So much for Judicial Secrecy.   It's a joke imo.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Mr Moderator on May 22, 2014, 04:02:24 PM
Which private villa? Was this his home?

His mothers residence.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Mr Moderator on May 22, 2014, 04:12:11 PM
Jane Tanner didn't even get a good enough look at Robert Murat to recognise him as the man she'd seen just an hour before!   If she had identified him in any way shape or form as the man she'd seen on the 3rd May she would have been taken to the police station - where Amaral was waiting for the phone call to hear the results of the ID parade - so that she could give a statement.     Why is that so hard for some people to understand?    She wasn't taken to the police station she was sent home instead.  There can only be one reason for that.       There is no statement by JT identifying Robert Murat - otherwise the AG would have referred to it in his Final Report as probably the prime reason why RM was made an arguido. 

She may have said at an earlier interview that she thought she would be able to recognise the man she saw by his walk - and if so then IMO Amaral has used that true statement and mixed it in with a load of untruths to try to give them authenticity.    As he does so many other times in his book and during his many TV interviews.   Once JT's sighting became an 'inconvenience' to his attempts to pin the crime on the parents his answer to that problem was to discredit her as a witness. 

It seems to me that ruining the characters of witnesses in the publics eye - by conducting smear campaigns against them via the media was a normal part of 'getting a result' for some members of the PJ.   The same treatment was meted out to Leonor Cipriano. who was tried and found guilty by an enraged public as a result of the media, - before the case even got to court. imo.   So much for Judicial Secrecy.   It's a joke imo.

Tanner never saw the face of the carrier, she only ever saw the side of his head and then the back of it.

She was adamant that she could identify the man by the particular manner of his walk. Nobody coerced her to say this, she offered this suggestion in an attempt to find a live Madeleine in what was those first vital 24 hours. Had she not been able and willing to do so she would not have offered to go on the identification.  She had days to think about it, if she was unsure she could have bailed at any time.

There was no need for her to make any statement about the identification, if the suspect was ever brought to trial she would have had an opportunity to testify.

It is oh so convenient to state several years after the event that she did not identify Robert Murat as the man she saw that night adding that she only thought so at the time.  Self preservation personified!
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on May 22, 2014, 04:15:09 PM
His mothers residence.

Do you have a link to the source for that, or is it your own understanding of events?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on May 22, 2014, 04:21:55 PM
Which private villa? Was this his home?

According to whom?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Benice on May 22, 2014, 04:34:00 PM
Tanner never saw the face of the carrier, she only ever saw the side of his head and then the back of it.

She was adamant that she could identify the man by the particular manner of his walk. Nobody coerced her to say this, she offered this suggestion in an attempt to find a live Madeleine in what was those first vital 24 hours. Had she not been able and willing to do so she would not have offered to go on the identification.  She had days to think about it, if she was unsure she could have bailed at any time.

There was no need for her to make any statement about the identification, if the suspect was ever brought to trial she would have had an opportunity to testify.

Are you actually being serious?   If so I'm gobsmacked.   I mean, why bother to take statements from any witnesses - when you can simply call on them to testify in court if and when required.

 What Jane Tanner said in the days before the ID is irrelevant.   The fact is that on the day of the ID she was not able to identify Robert Murat as the man she'd seen on the 3rd May.     The reasons why Amaral told his officers to send her home when he got that disappointing news - rather than take a witness statement confirming that she was not able to identify RM as the' abductor' are also debatable imo.

Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Mr Moderator on May 23, 2014, 02:37:04 PM
Are you actually being serious?   If so I'm gobsmacked.   I mean, why bother to take statements from any witnesses - when you can simply call on them to testify in court if and when required.

 What Jane Tanner said in the days before the ID is irrelevant.   The fact is that on the day of the ID she was not able to identify Robert Murat as the man she'd seen on the 3rd May.     The reasons why Amaral told his officers to send her home when he got that disappointing news - rather than take a witness statement confirming that she was not able to identify RM as the' abductor' are also debatable imo.

What exactly would be the point of taking a statement from an eye witness who claimed to have identified a suspect by his 'walk'?

Why did Tanner go on the surveillance if she couldn't identify the carrier? 
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on May 23, 2014, 04:43:25 PM
What exactly would be the point of taking a statement from an eye witness who claimed to have identified a suspect by his 'walk'?

Why did Tanner go on the surveillance if she couldn't identify the carrier?

Lori Campbell had reported Murat as suspicious and Tannerman was heading in an easterly direction.

Jane had said that she might be able to identify the man she saw if what she had seen was  reconstructed (my paraphrasing).

I don't see anything odd about that covert operation.

The issue is that operation screwed up and from the little that she could see, she didn't feel confident to make a positive identification.

Poor Jane. From what I've read, she was just trying to be as careful as possible concerning her recollection and seems to have avoided the transference issue. Yet, she was vilified in the press for supposedly never-ending versions.

Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: faithlilly on May 23, 2014, 05:00:55 PM
Lori Campbell had reported Murat as suspicious and Tannerman was heading in an easterly direction.

Jane had said that she might be able to identify the man she saw if what she had seen was  reconstructed (my paraphrasing).

I don't see anything odd about that covert operation.

The issue is that operation screwed up and from the little that she could see, she didn't feel confident to make a positive identification.

Poor Jane. From what I've read, she was just trying to be as careful as possible concerning her recollection and seems to have avoided the transference issue. Yet, she was vilified in the press for supposedly never-ending versions.

I absolutely agree with you, Tanner was wrongly vilified for changing her story, she didn't.

What she should have been vilified for is sticking to her story even when it had been proven to be all but impossible.

Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Alfred R Jones on May 23, 2014, 06:32:53 PM
I absolutely agree with you, Tanner was wrongly vilified for changing her story, she didn't.

What she should have been vilified for is sticking to her story even when it had been proven to be all but impossible.
JT's sighting has been confirmed by Scotland Yard - it happened just as she said it did.   Why don't you vilify them for a change?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on May 23, 2014, 07:25:28 PM
I absolutely agree with you, Tanner was wrongly vilified for changing her story, she didn't.

What she should have been vilified for is sticking to her story even when it had been proven to be all but impossible.

I guess it may be tempting to modify what you thought you'd seen if various other people thought they had seen a specific individual and that you knew that this was the individual that you were asked to try to identify.

It can't be that difficult to question your own memory and think that others may have been right. Even worse when the press is accusing you of lying over a long period of time and making your life hell. 

Imagine all that pressure to cave in? She didn't though, did she? She stuck to what she believes is her recollection. And she didn't positively identify Murat. 
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: icabodcrane on May 23, 2014, 07:44:03 PM
JT's sighting has been confirmed by Scotland Yard - it happened just as she said it did.   Why don't you vilify them for a change?

It is simply not true to say that Scotland Yard have confirmed Jane Tanner's version of events 

They  ( Scotland Yard )  have said that Jane Tanner almost certainly saw an innocent father that night   ...  that is  all  they have said

Scotland Yard have said nothing about the  circumstances   in which they believe Jane Tanner saw the innocent father  ...  and certainly made no reference to Gerry McCann and Jeremy Wilkins having been present at the time 

There has been no  'confirmation'  that  "it happened just as she said it did"

Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Alfred R Jones on May 23, 2014, 08:43:47 PM
It is simply not true to say that Scotland Yard have confirmed Jane Tanner's version of events 

They  ( Scotland Yard )  have said that Jane Tanner almost certainly saw an innocent father that night   ...  that is  all  they have said

Scotland Yard have said nothing about the  circumstances   in which they believe Jane Tanner saw the innocent father  ...  and certainly made no reference to Gerry McCann and Jeremy Wilkins having been present at the time 

There has been no  'confirmation'  that  "it happened just as she said it did"
"Almost certainly" and "a revelation moment" which has changed the focus of the investigation.  And SY made a big thing about it on TV - they wouldn't do that if they weren't as sure as they could be.  And they wouldn't have been almost certain if the account of the innocent holidaymaker who they identified differed substantially in time or location or other detail from JT's statement.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: John on May 23, 2014, 08:56:53 PM
Any investigator worth their salt would have established if Tannerman was indeed an innocent tourist before going on National TV.  The fact that Redwood couldn't state categorically that this was the case leaves a hole big enough to drive a coach and horses through imo.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on May 23, 2014, 08:59:23 PM
"Almost certainly" and "a revelation moment" which has changed the focus of the investigation.  And SY made a big thing about it on TV - they wouldn't do that if they weren't as sure as they could be.  And they wouldn't have been almost certain if the account of the innocent holidaymaker who they identified differed substantially in time or location or other detail from JT's statement.

Would the Met have felt confident in relaying this to the press if this person's account, and possibly that of a partner, had been contradictory to the view of other members of a large family group (even excluding younger children)?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Alfred R Jones on May 23, 2014, 09:00:47 PM
Any investigator worth their salt would have established if Tannerman was indeed an innocent tourist before going on National TV.  The fact that Redwood couldn't state categorically that this was the case leaves a hole big enough to drive a coach and horses through imo.
where you see a huge hole, I see a tiny chink.  It would have been impossible for him to say 100% certain without 3rd party corroborating evidence like cctv.  'Almost certain' is as close as he could feasibly get to describing his certainty imo.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: John on May 23, 2014, 09:38:06 PM
Why wasn't he taken back to the street and a reconstruction carried out?  Too many loose ends for my liking.  As I stated I think there is more wishful thinking than good old fashioned police work going on here.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Benice on May 24, 2014, 01:53:03 AM
What exactly would be the point of taking a statement from an eye witness who claimed to have identified a suspect by his 'walk'?

Why did Tanner go on the surveillance if she couldn't identify the carrier?

IIRC Jane Tanner didn't know she was going to attend an ID parade until she got there.

In view of your comments above  -  can I take it that you don't think she gave a statement?     So do you concede that Amaral lied when he said  she ''formally identified Robert Murat' in his book? 

The truth IMO is that she did not ID Robert Murat or make a statement, but Amaral wanted his readers to think she had- just as he wanted viewers to think she had when he told the same lies during TV  interviews.    He lied, and then escalated his lies about JT when he falsely claimed she was present at the 'confrontation' meeting.  She was not.

If Jane Tanner had identified Robert Murat as the man she saw on the 3rd and made a signed statement confirming that (which would have involved PJ officers and an interpreter ) - then she would have to be insane to deny that happened knowing it could so easily be proved  to be untrue via her own witness statement and the witnesses who were present at the time.   There is not a scrap of evidence that JT is off her head.

Anyone who thinks that if she had identified Murat, Amaral would have sent her home without making a statement about the most important evidence which he had received to date  - to justify making  Murat an Arguido - is seriously in denial IMO.

Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Eleanor on May 24, 2014, 07:28:04 AM

To whom did Jane Tanner "Formally Identify" Robert Murat?  It certainly wasn't Amaral.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Victoria on May 24, 2014, 08:47:39 PM
Why wasn't he taken back to the street and a reconstruction carried out?  Too many loose ends for my liking.  As I stated I think there is more wishful thinking than good old fashioned police work going on here.

Taken back to the street by who? At whose expense? Under which jurisdiction?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Victoria on May 24, 2014, 08:49:39 PM
To whom did Jane Tanner "Formally Identify" Robert Murat?  It certainly wasn't Amaral.

She didn't formally identify him, and even Amaral doesn't claim that Murat was made arguido as a result of the tapas group. The Portuguese police had their own reasons for being interested in Murat - it says as much in Amaral's book. There is a hell of a lot of nonsense being talked on this thread, so much so that it takes me back to the days of the mirror forums.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Mr Moderator on May 25, 2014, 04:18:49 AM
Gonçalo Amaral had an interest in Murat for several reasons.  What is crystal clear however is that had Tanner totally and absolutely failed to identify him then he would not have been investigated any further.  Tanner didn't know what Murat looked like until that fateful encounter with him just before the surveillance was to take place. In her rogatory interview she even admits that she didn't recognise the man in the surveillance as Murat, the man she had met just an hour previously even though this exercise was undertaken in broad daylight.  When she saw the carrier it was in darkness with poor street lighting.  Tanner adds that when she first met Murat outside his house he looked quite little but appeared quite big when she saw him on the telly. Confusion seems to have been the order of the day.

Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Mr Gray on May 25, 2014, 10:29:46 AM
By 11 May, eight days after Madeleine had been reported missing, one of the Portuguese Police team, Inspector Pedro Varanda, had become suspicious enough about Murat to file an urgent memo to his manager. His report, filed that day, included the following observations:

“Sir,

This relates to an informal conversation I’ve had with Robert Murat. As you will know, today at 11.30am, Inspector Patricia Duarte and I interviewed a British citizen called Dianne Webster. We realised she could not speak Portuguese, so we sought an English-speaking interpreter.

We decided to use a fellow British citizen, Robert J.Q.E. Murat, of whom we were aware from his previous translation work. His address is Casa Liliana, Rua Ramalhete, Praia da Luz, Lagos.

 After we’d finished interviewing Dianne Webster, I had an informal conversation in Portuguese with Murat. During this conversation, he displayed an unusual level of curiosity about the investigation that was developing around the disappearance of Madeleine McCann on 3 May.

To give an example, he insistently and repeatedly questioned me about the identity of possible suspects. He also questioned me about the investigation strategy of the head of our investigation. He even asked about what work the investigation team might be considering in the coming days.

 I became highly suspicious. His behavior was absolutely inappropriate for a translator. In response to such an unusual attitude, I played along, ducking the questions. I also reminded him to stick to his contractual role of translating. I pointed out that the whole investigation was still in the initial enquiry phase, and that therefore judicial secrecy rules still applied.

I also need to emphasise that the suspicions I had were reinforced when I became aware that Robert Murat would covertly attempt to catch glimpses of various documents, for example, items being prepared for the case files that make up the present inquiry. 

I noticed that Murat also displayed an enormous knowledge of all kinds of matters relating to the ‘Ocean Club Complex’, where the events under investigation had taken place, and of the routines followed by the McCann family and their companions during their respective stays in Praia da Luz. I would add that he has persistently tried to influence the conduct of the present investigation.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: jassi on May 25, 2014, 10:39:35 AM
Just goes to show how suspicion might ultimately amount to nothing.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Mr Gray on May 25, 2014, 10:48:56 AM
Gonçalo Amaral had an interest in Murat for several reasons.  What is crystal clear however is that had Tanner totally and absolutely failed to identify him then he would not have been investigated any further.  Tanner didn't know what Murat looked like until that fateful encounter with him just before the surveillance was to take place. In her rogatory interview she even admits that she didn't recognise the man in the surveillance as Murat, the man she had met just an hour previously even though this exercise was undertaken in broad daylight.  When she saw the carrier it was in darkness with poor street lighting.  Tanner adds that when she first met Murat outside his house he looked quite little but appeared quite big when she saw him on the telly. Confusion seems to have been the order of the day.

This is the article from the guardian reporting on murats's specch to the Cambridge union....He sys it was a british journalist who caused his problems...


In Murat's case, a British journalist covering the disappearance had been "so anxious to break the story" that she created it. "She tried to convince the Portuguese police that I was acting suspiciously."

He had never been arrested but had been interviewed and made an "arguido", or official suspect. His arguido status unleashed a "torrent of outlandish, untrue and deeply hurtful allegations".


You seem to have several facts wrong...if your basic facts are wrong all your conclusions will be wrong
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on May 25, 2014, 11:49:22 AM
 307 Letter from Leicestershire Police constabulary regarding Lori Campbell's suspicions re: Murat (in English) 2007.05.07
308-Portuguese translation of above letter

THANKS TO KIZZY
02-Processo, Volume 2, Page 307-308
02_VOLUMEIIa_Page_307
02_VOLUMEIIa_Page_308
Letter from Leicester Constabulary
to Portugal Incident Room/Madeleine McCann
 

6th May 2007

Sir,

Lori CAMPBELL a reporter from the Sunday Mirror has contacted Leicestershire Police to report the following.
Lori has been speaking to an interpreter who has been helping authorities with the investigation into Madeleine's disappearance. He has only given his name as 'ROR' (sic) and has not given any background information about himself.
Lori has become suspicious of Rob as he has given conflicting accounts to various people and became very concerned when he noticed his photo being taken by the Mirror's photographer. 'ROB' stated to Lori that he is going through a messy divorce
In the UK at the moment and that he had a three year old daughter just like Madeleine, who he is separated from at the moment. He made a big show of telephoning his daughter in front of reporters, and Lori felt that he was being too loud and making a big thing of speaking to his daughter on the phone. The things that 'ROB' has said to Lori have raised her concerns about him.
Could you please call Lori who is still in Portugal to establish further details to identify 'ROB' in order to eliminate him from your enquiries on 07917 xxxxxx.
Submitted for information
 

308—Portuguese translation of above letter
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/LORRI-CAMPBELL.htm
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: John on May 26, 2014, 07:12:49 PM
Gonçalo Amaral had an interest in Murat for several reasons.  What is crystal clear however is that had Tanner totally and absolutely failed to identify him then he would not have been investigated any further.  Tanner didn't know what Murat looked like until that fateful encounter with him just before the surveillance was to take place. In her rogatory interview she even admits that she didn't recognise the man in the surveillance as Murat, the man she had met just an hour previously even though this exercise was undertaken in broad daylight.  When she saw the carrier it was in darkness with poor street lighting.  Tanner adds that when she first met Murat outside his house he looked quite little but appeared quite big when she saw him on the telly. Confusion seems to have been the order of the day.

It is evident that Robert Murat's curiosity and inquisitory approach to those he encountered in the case was perceived by the Portuguese detectives and reporters as something suspicious. It was indeed unfortunate that he just happened to live a short distance along the road where Tanner saw the carrier heading.  His formal questioning on the 14 May 2007 and the searches of his mothers villa and the other property he had access to which followed was not surprising given what had gone on.  It wasn't helped when three members of the tapas group, Russell, Rachael and Fiona also came forward a few days later to state they had seen him in the OC car park at about 1am on the morning after Madeleine disappeared, a claim which Murat has always hotly denied.

What relevance Jane's surveillance on the 13 May had may never fully be known but Amaral was certainly convinced.

Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on May 26, 2014, 08:08:51 PM
It is evident that Robert Murat's curiosity and inquisitory approach to those he encountered in the case was perceived by the Portuguese detectives and reporters as something suspicious. It was indeed unfortunate that he just happened to live a short distance along the road where Tanner saw the carrier heading.  His formal questioning on the 14 May 2007 and the searches of his mothers villa and the other property he had access to which followed was not surprising given what had gone on.  It wasn't helped when three members of the tapas group, Russell, Rachael and Fiona also came forward a few days later to state they had seen him in the OC car park at about 1am on the morning after Madeleine disappeared, a claim which Murat has always hotly denied.

What relevance Jane's surveillance on the 13 May had may never fully be known but Amaral was certainly convinced.

Lori Campbell started it all off. I have no objection to her reporting her concern to the authorities (on the contrary), but I do have a problem with her reporting it to the world in general in the media. All because someone was trying to be helpful, and it reminded her of the Soham case? One creep (Ian Huntley) does not humanity make. What's the alternative? In a tsunami, you'd just walk away in case anyone thought that you were trying to drown someone as opposed to trying to help them get to safety?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Eleanor on May 27, 2014, 12:15:37 PM
It is evident that Robert Murat's curiosity and inquisitory approach to those he encountered in the case was perceived by the Portuguese detectives and reporters as something suspicious. It was indeed unfortunate that he just happened to live a short distance along the road where Tanner saw the carrier heading.  His formal questioning on the 14 May 2007 and the searches of his mothers villa and the other property he had access to which followed was not surprising given what had gone on.  It wasn't helped when three members of the tapas group, Russell, Rachael and Fiona also came forward a few days later to state they had seen him in the OC car park at about 1am on the morning after Madeleine disappeared, a claim which Murat has always hotly denied.

What relevance Jane's surveillance on the 13 May had may never fully be known but Amaral was certainly convinced.

The whole thing was a hole in the corner affair.  It wasn't even an official identity parade, and Amaral was not present, so he doesn't know what she said.
In fact, Jane Tanner didn't even know what she was supposed to do.  And she certainly never made a statement.
Amaral then twisted the whole thing, made it what he wanted it to be, and then stuck it in his book.  He did this because there was always a chance in his mangled brain that he could link Robert Murat to The McCanns, because he knew that The McCanns could never have disposed of Madeleine without some local help.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: John on May 28, 2014, 08:07:45 PM
The whole thing was a hole in the corner affair.  It wasn't even an official identity parade, and Amaral was not present, so he doesn't know what she said.
In fact, Jane Tanner didn't even know what she was supposed to do.  And she certainly never made a statement.
Amaral then twisted the whole thing, made it what he wanted it to be, and then stuck it in his book.  He did this because there was always a chance in his mangled brain that he could link Robert Murat to The McCanns, because he knew that The McCanns could never have disposed of Madeleine without some local help.

Eleanor, do you think for a second if Jane Tanner had said to her minders on the surveillance that it definitely wasn't Robert Murat she saw that night that the PJ wouldn't have hauled him in for questioning and make him an arguido the very next morning? 

She was the only person who saw the alleged abductor, had she said it definitely wasn't Robert then that would have been an end to it.  Instead, what happens?

I'll tell you.  Instead of quashing the allegation, Jane's partner Russell together with Rachael and Fiona decide to put the boot in too and two days later decide to tell the PJ that they saw Murat lurking around the car park in front of block 5 a matter of hours after Madeleine disappeared.

Now you tell me.  What the hell were they playing at if Jane was positive that it wasn't Robert Murat she saw carrying a child at 9.15 the previous evening?



Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Eleanor on May 28, 2014, 08:19:51 PM
Eleanor, do you think for a second if Jane Tanner had said to her minders on the surveillance that it definitely wasn't Robert Murat she saw that night that the PJ wouldn't have hauled him in for questioning and make him an arguido the very next morning? 

She was the only person who saw the alleged abductor, had she said it definitely wasn't Robert then that would have been an end to it.  Instead, what happens?

I'll tell you.  Instead of quashing the allegation, Jane's partner Russell together with Rachael and Fiona decide to put the boot in too and two days later decide to tell the PJ that they saw Murat lurking around the car park in front of block 5 a matter of hours after Madeleine disappeared.

Now you tell me.  What the hell were they playing at if Jane was positive that it wasn't Robert Murat she saw carrying a child at 9.15 the previous evening?

I don't think she was positive that it wasn't Robert Murat.  I think she just didn't know.

Now you tell me why a statement was not taken from Jane Tanner if she had positively identified Robert Murat.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: John on May 28, 2014, 09:30:00 PM
I don't think she was positive that it wasn't Robert Murat.  I think she just didn't know.

Now you tell me why a statement was not taken from Jane Tanner if she had positively identified Robert Murat.

I agree with your second sentence.  She saw so little of this man in the gloom that she just wasn't sure one way or another and over the years this has morphed into something else.

Truth is we just don't know if a statement was taken.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Silkywhiskers on May 28, 2014, 09:32:28 PM
Truth is we just don't know if a statement was taken.


LOLLL @ Team McCann claiming every word of an Archived Investigation is online.


Yep.... 8-)(--)
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: misty on May 28, 2014, 09:51:59 PM
Jane Tanner said that the man she saw outside Murat's villa seemed a lot smaller than the Murat she viewed on TV. Murat is a fairly tall, well-built man - the question is, was it actually Robert Murat standing outside that villa whom she  was asked to identify?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: icabodcrane on May 29, 2014, 12:48:37 AM
In her book Kate says "Jane was concerned that he  (   Murat )  might have been picked up purely as a result of the amateurish identity parade in which she had unwittingly participated" 

Now why would she think that if she hadn't identified him  ? 

Kate continues  ;  "Jane phoned  Bob Small to tell him she'd encountered Murat before her rendevous with the PJ and mentioned  that Russell and Rachael had said they'd noticed him outside our flat on the night Madeleine vanished, in case either piece of information was important"
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: misty on May 29, 2014, 01:24:23 AM
In her book Kate says "Jane was concerned that he  (   Murat )  might have been picked up purely as a result of the amateurish identity parade in which she had unwittingly participated" 

Now why would she think that if she hadn't identified him  ? 

Kate continues  ;  "Jane phoned  Bob Small to tell him she'd encountered Murat before her rendevous with the PJ and mentioned  that Russell and Rachael had said they'd noticed him outside our flat on the night Madeleine vanished, in case either piece of information was important"

Kate doesn't actually state that Jane identified him as the man she saw with a child.
Nowhere in the PJ case against Murat is it written that anyone made any sort of ID of him. Jane Tanner's name is only mentioned in relation to the route from 5a to Murat's villa.

04_VOLUME_IVa_Page_958
04_VOLUME_IVa_Page_959

External Inquiry Report

Date. 2007-05-11

Place: Ocean Club, P da L.

Responsible Officers: Officers Joao Carlos and Luis Pereira

Description and Result:

Systematically analysed with the elements contained in the investigation that indicate how the action could eventually have occurred, the possibility of placing different valid hypotheses referring to the process of the action was concluded, it being the case that in all the equated scenarios, the direction of the escape route taken by the author (abductor) was questioned.

It should be remembered that Jane Tanner's witness statement confirms having seen and individual carrying a child, who would have left from Block 5 A and turned to the right, walking along Rua Agostinho da Silva and crossing the road at the junction with Rua Direita, where the entrance to the Tapas restaurant is situated, the route used by the parents when checking on the children, in this way placing himself at greater exposure.

In effect, if the action had been planned, the author should have - bearing in mind the physical space - chosen the contrary direction as his escape route, where there was a parking area at a distance of 20 metres, which would have been a discreet way to enable him to leave the scene unnoticed.

Given this reasoning, it was judged appropriate to visit the scene, in order to see the geographical viability of the correct perception of the events, or at least the closest possible approximation regarding their truth.

It was immediately possible to note that the Casa Liliana house, situated in Rua da Ramalhete, P da L, Lagos, owned by Robert Murat, could also de designated as Casa Liliana, situated on Rua Agostinho Silva, or in other words, situated in the same road as Block 5, precisely in the direction taken by the suspicious individual, described in Jane Tanner's witness account.

An image of the site is attached with indications relating to the above description.

Comment by the officer responsible for the inquiry:

Excepting superior opinion, the fact that had not been explained, concerning the abductor's escape route, would be clarified in the case that it were possible to report that the author (abductor) lives or has access to some space next to the site, namely in the direction in which an individual was seen to be leaving.

Signed 

Attached map: 959


Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Silkywhiskers on May 29, 2014, 01:51:34 AM
For a detective to implicate a person he needs proof that they are lying. Jane saw a man carrying a child & Amaral had no evidence that Jane was lying. In fact, she was telling the truth, according to the Met.
But it's OK for him to lie about her identifying Murat as Tannerman, when she hadn't, simply because he was a detective?

She did lie about Murat.

See - "The truth of the Lie".

See - RM being made Arguido based on....what, exactly...?

See - RM planning legal action against JT for libel

Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: icabodcrane on May 29, 2014, 02:05:13 AM
I don't understand the conflict here

Does anyone actually ...  truely ...  believe    that Robert Murat would have been made Arguido even if the McCanns' friends had not implicated him  ?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: misty on May 29, 2014, 02:09:48 AM
I don't understand the conflict here

Does anyone actually ...  truely ...  believe    that Robert Murat would have been made Arguido even if the McCanns' friends had not implicated him  ?

Dear God.....will you please, please go & read McCannpjfiles The Case against Robert Murat & then review your opinion as to why he should be made an arguido.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Benice on May 29, 2014, 02:19:22 AM
I don't understand the conflict here

Does anyone actually ...  truely ...  believe    that Robert Murat would have been made Arguido even if the McCanns' friends had not implicated him  ?

Robert Murat was made an arguido BEFORE the McCanns friends contacted the PJ.   It was seeing his piccie on TV after he had been made an arguido that prompted them to contact the PJ.  They were not implicated in his being made an Arguido.    It was 'evidence' from other quarters which resulted in his being made an arguido -  IIRC mainly reporters who contacted the Leicester police with their concerns, who then passed the info onto the PJ.

 
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Silkywhiskers on May 29, 2014, 02:49:34 AM
Yes ok.

So now we have burglars who steal corpses, dogs who sniff out pig fetuses, people being made arguidos without a single shred of evidence, and of course hovering over it all is Amaral who single handedly harrassed the poor McCann to the point they can't possibly step foot in Portugal this week when the dig for their "darling daughter" is about to start.

People who wanted to leave "no stone unturned" yet are not there for the turning of the first actual stone to be turned.

This is just getting more obscene by the day.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Eleanor on May 29, 2014, 06:44:23 AM
I don't understand the conflict here

Does anyone actually ...  truely ...  believe    that Robert Murat would have been made Arguido even if the McCanns' friends had not implicated him  ?

I thought that Robert Murat asked to be made an Arguido.  This is possible in Portuguese Law.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Brietta on May 29, 2014, 10:34:53 AM
I thought that Robert Murat asked to be made an Arguido.  This is possible in Portuguese Law.

I believe that arguido status allows rights in an investigation. 
For example, access to information on the case and the right to have legal representation when being interviewed. 

If he did make the request IMO it was very sensible of him to do so and I would suggest he took legal advice about it. 

If the Drs McCann had been made arguidos as a matter of course from the beginning of the investigation, they would have enjoyed similar rights without prejudice. 

This would have negated the shock horror of them being made ‘suspects’ at a later date by those of us who did not understand the nuances of Portuguese law.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on May 29, 2014, 11:29:52 AM
I believe that arguido status allows rights in an investigation. 
For example, access to information on the case and the right to have legal representation when being interviewed. 

If he did make the request IMO it was very sensible of him to do so and I would suggest he took legal advice about it. 

If the Drs McCann had been made arguidos as a matter of course from the beginning of the investigation, they would have enjoyed similar rights without prejudice. 

This would have negated the shock horror of them being made ‘suspects’ at a later date by those of us who did not understand the nuances of Portuguese law.

I see what you mean, but I don't think that it would have helped.

Arguido status seems to have a negative connotation even in Portugal: it wasn't just the UK press that had a field day when Murat was made one /or requested it. I don't recall whether he did request it or not, but I wouldn't be at all surprised if he suspected that he was going to be stitched up. At that point, the McCanns didn't.

The McCanns didn't need a lawyer present for the initial interviews (although that might have been an advantage in terms of someone else who could have pointed out any translation issues).

If they had requested it, it would have been a red flag to the media via the original PJ team. They would never have had the public support to help find Madeleine that they have had, IMO, if they had done.

If they had requested it (or were constituted arguidos), it would have meant that the investigation would have been wound up in just 6 months, barring exceptional reasons to prolong it, i.e, either charged or the case shelved.

All in all, I don't think that it would have prevented the media effect that it did, it might well have made it occur earlier. In the meantime, the attention wouldn't have been on trying to help find a missing little girl.

Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: John on May 31, 2014, 01:46:45 AM
Yet again, posters are interpreting the question over the identification or otherwise of Robert Murat the wrong way round.

The question isn't, did Jane Tanner identify Robert Murat?  The question should be, did Jane Tanner rule Robert Murat out?

Apparently the answer to the latter is a resounding NO.   In her own words in her Rogatory Interview she stated that she just thought he was the man she had seen.  Undoubtedly, her three companions assisted in that determination.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on May 31, 2014, 06:44:07 AM
Yet again, posters are interpreting the question over the identification or otherwise of Robert Murat the wrong way round.

The question isn't, did Jane Tanner identify Robert Murat?  The question should be, did Jane Tanner rule Robert Murat out?

Apparently the answer to the latter is a resounding NO.   In her own words in her Rogatory Interview she stated that she just thought he was the man she had seen.  Undoubtedly, her three companions assisted in that determination.

She didn't say the underlined words, John. She said "I just thought it was" and the officer interrupts her. The context was that she was explaining why she felt she ought to call Bob Small about the fact that the other three were convinced they'd seen him that night.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: John on May 31, 2014, 03:13:35 PM
She didn't say the underlined words, John. She said "I just thought it was" and the officer interrupts her. The context was that she was explaining why she felt she ought to call Bob Small about the fact that the other three were convinced they'd seen him that night.

Exact extract from rogatory statement...

Jane Tanner.  I’m not trying to push anything onto Robert MURAT’s door, cos as I say I don’t think it was him that I saw”.
4078    “No”.
Reply    “But I just thought it was”.

www.mccannfiles.com/id222.html


I suppose you also have an excuse for her offering the comment," I’m not trying to push anything onto Robert MURAT’s door"?

Nobody would make such a comment unless they were indeed suggesting such a thing!  When a witness knows something for a fact they state it.  Regardless of how you attempt to blur the issue she wasn't 100% sure.

Back to my original comment, had Jane Tanner told Amaral that the man she saw carrying a child was NOT DEFINITELY 100% Robert Murat then he would not have been hauled in the next morning by the police.

Fact is, Jane's hesitancy and lack of clarity gave the PJ enough scope to label Murat a suspect.

Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: ferryman on May 31, 2014, 03:32:00 PM
They met Robert Murat en route to the van.  If Jane was going to identify him, it would have been then, and in any event the whole exercise was null-and-void from that point.

Another myth that Jane had anything to do with Murat's arguido status.

If you read the separate section detailing how suspicion against Murat arose, there is no mention of Jane Tanner's sighting.

That can only be because she had nothing to do with it.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: John on May 31, 2014, 03:47:49 PM
They met Robert Murat en route to the van.  If Jane was going to identify him, it would have been then, and in any event the whole exercise was null-and-void from that point.

Another myth that Jane had anything to do with Murat's arguido status.

If you read the separate section detailing how suspicion against Murat arose, there is no mention of Jane Tanner's sighting.

That can only be because she had nothing to do with it.

Meeting Murat had no relevance to the surveillance.  Tanner had no inkling what was expected of her when she met Murat, she thought she was being taken away by the [Spanish police] sic.  She was in fact asked to identify the man she had seen 10 days earlier carrying a child, an identification from the rear and based on her observation that he had a particular way of walking. Regardless of what she thought she did NOT rule Murat out as being that man.

Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Alfred R Jones on May 31, 2014, 06:31:02 PM

Fact is, Jane's hesitancy and lack of clarity gave the PJ enough scope to label Murat a suspect.
On its own?  I very much doubt it.  Any police force making someone a suspect on the basis of a witness's hesitancy and lack of clarity is very much grasping at straws imo.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: ferryman on May 31, 2014, 06:34:26 PM
Meeting Murat had no relevance to the surveillance.

Meeting Murat outright invalidated the surveillance ...
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Eleanor on May 31, 2014, 07:04:21 PM
On its own?  I very much doubt it.  Any police force making someone a suspect on the basis of a witness's hesitancy and lack of clarity is very much grasping at straws imo.

All the more reason not to, I would have thought.  That sort of thing wouldn't have gone down very well in Court.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on May 31, 2014, 07:37:14 PM
Exact extract from rogatory statement...

Jane Tanner.  I’m not trying to push anything onto Robert MURAT’s door, cos as I say I don’t think it was him that I saw”.
4078    “No”.
Reply    “But I just thought it was”.

www.mccannfiles.com/id222.html


I suppose you also have an excuse for her offering the comment," I’m not trying to push anything onto Robert MURAT’s door"?

Nobody would make such a comment unless they were indeed suggesting such a thing!  When a witness knows something for a fact they state it.  Regardless of how you attempt to blur the issue she wasn't 100% sure.

Back to my original comment, had Jane Tanner told Amaral that the man she saw carrying a child was NOT DEFINITELY 100% Robert Murat then he would not have been hauled in the next morning by the police.

Fact is, Jane's hesitancy and lack of clarity gave the PJ enough scope to label Murat a suspect.

As I already pointed out, a page or two back, there are numerous times when either Jane or the officer interrupted each other without finishing their sentences.

Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: misty on June 01, 2014, 01:45:57 AM
We don't actually know WHICH man Jane may or may not have identified outside the villa that day as there is no statement available showing how many men were at the location at the time. All Jane did say was that she met Murat on the way to the rendezvous.
Has it ever  crossed your mind that the PJ officers themselves may have put the wrong name to the wrong person?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: icabodcrane on June 05, 2014, 02:16:40 PM
Whether or not Jane Tanner identified Murat as the man she saw carrying a child that night might be questionable, but,  according to the  'The McCanns and the Conman'  programme last night, what is  not in question is that Jane identified Gail Coopers  'creeyman'   as the child carrier   (   you know,  the one with straggly hair, buck teeth, and a Yosemite Sam moustache  ) 

Henri Exton's team had tracked a fellow who looked similar and taken a photo of him  ( without the moustache )

They presented the photo to Jane and she said ;

""That is the guy I saw carrying a child"

The fellow was eventually ruled out

Exton's  team concluded that Jane Tanner was not a credible witness
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Wonderfulspam on June 05, 2014, 02:22:52 PM
Whether or not Jane Tanner identified Murat as the man she saw carrying a child that night might be questionable, but,  according to the  'The McCanns and the Conman'  programme last night, what is  not in question is that Jane identified Gail Coopers  'creeyman'   as the child carrier   (   you know,  the one with straggly hair, buck teeth, and a Yosemite Sam moustache  ) 

Henri Exton's team had tracked a fellow who looked similar and taken a photo of him  ( without the moustache )

They presented the photo to Jane and she said ;

""That is the guy I saw carrying a child"

The fellow was eventually ruled out

Exton's  team concluded that Jane Tanner was not a credible witness

Voice analyst Dr Richard Parton on Jane Tanner identifying George the market trader, as the abductor.


'Everyone wanted to find this guy, dont get me wrong, everyone wanted to find him but, the more she had to describe him, the more inaccurate she became.'

'From the witness statements that I had processed before, there was nothing indicating that he was involved, nothing at all. I think the most exciting thing about finding him was that we could finally rule him out.'



Voice Over: Despite the serious doubts, the files reveal that surveillance was continued on the market trader for the next 3 months, but he was eventually iliminated from all enquiries.

Retired Major Tim Whatsisface: 'My understanding of it is, it was felt that she wasn't as credible a witness as we had hoped'. Witnesses will give evidence thinking that, that is what they saw or understood at the time, which is quite often inaccurate, and so Jane Tanner having said 'this is the guy that I saw', it may just have been that she so wanted to help, that she fooled herself'.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: jassi on June 05, 2014, 02:41:08 PM
Voice analyst Dr Richard Parton on Jane Tanner identifying George the market trader, as the abductor.


'Everyone wanted to find this guy, dont get me wrong, everyone wanted to find him but, the more she had to describe him, the more inaccurate she became.'

'From the witness statements that I had processed before, there was nothing indicating that he was involved, nothing at all. I think the most exciting thing about finding him was that we could finally rule him out.'



Voice Over: Despite the serious doubts, the files reveal that surveillance was continued on the market trader for the next 3 months, but he was eventually iliminated from all enquiries.

Retired Major Tim Whatsisface: 'My understanding of it is, it was felt that she wasn't as credible a witness as we had hoped'. Witnesses will give evidence thinking that, that is what they saw or understood at the time, which is quite often inaccurate, and so Jane Tanner having said 'this is the guy that I saw', it may just have been that she so wanted to help, that she fooled herself'.

Oh, I'm sure she did.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Brietta on June 05, 2014, 02:48:58 PM
Oh, I'm sure she did.

 ... and I am sure the voice analyst knows what he is talking about.  It was from the same recording that he could tell that Halligen was not all that he claimed to be.
In fact closer inquiry revealed he wasn't anything he claimed to be.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on June 05, 2014, 03:24:10 PM
Was there a reference sample of her voice in similar circumstances? If not, how could a wave pattern determine anything without one?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: misty on June 05, 2014, 04:13:09 PM
The market trader/guy Jane Tanner positively identified was NOT the same man the local bar owner Gary Williams??
had seen though, was it - the man they thought was "George"?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: icabodcrane on June 05, 2014, 04:26:08 PM
The market trader/guy Jane Tanner positively identified was NOT the same man the local bar owner Gary Williams??
had seen though, was it - the man they thought was "George"?

That's the point misty,  Exton's team thought the market trader  might  have  been the same man Gary Williams had help compile an e fit of 

When they showed it to him,  though,  he said it was not  the man he had seen that night   ( the George Harrison loolalike )

Gary Williams was right ...  the market trader was eventually cleared of any involvement

Yet when Jane Tanner was shown the same photo of the  ( innocent )  market trader she said :

"That's the man I saw carrying a child"
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Eleanor on June 05, 2014, 04:27:43 PM
That's the point misty,  Exton's team thought the market trader  might  have  been the same man Gary Williams had help compile an e fit of 

When they showed it to him,  though,  he said it was not  the man he had seen that night   ( the George Harrison loolalike )

Gary Williams was right ...  the market trader was eventually cleared of any involvement

Yet when Jane Tanner was shown the same photo of the  ( innocent )  market trader she said :

"That's the man I saw carrying a child"

Dare I ask for a Cite?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: icabodcrane on June 05, 2014, 04:29:48 PM
Dare I ask for a Cite?

That's what was shown on the TV programme last night

Do you doubt it Eleanor  ? 
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Eleanor on June 05, 2014, 04:35:18 PM
That's what was shown on the TV programme last night

Do you doubt it Eleanor  ?

Who said it?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: misty on June 05, 2014, 04:43:11 PM
That's the point misty,  Exton's team thought the market trader  might  have  been the same man Gary Williams had help compile an e fit of 

When they showed it to him,  though,  he said it was not  the man he had seen that night   ( the George Harrison loolalike )

Gary Williams was right ...  the market trader was eventually cleared of any involvement

Yet when Jane Tanner was shown the same photo of the  ( innocent )  market trader she said :

"That's the man I saw carrying a child"

The whole problem with that is that although Gary Williams says it wasn't the man he saw. it doesn't  prove it was not the man Jane Tanner saw. However. the Met seem pretty sure that Tannerman was the innocent tourist, but "George's" identity still remains unknown.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: icabodcrane on June 05, 2014, 04:45:57 PM
Who said it?

Major Tim Craig-Harvey

That nice, well spoken fellow who was deeply sympathetic to the McCanns
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Eleanor on June 05, 2014, 04:47:41 PM
Major Tim Craig-Harvey

That nice, well spoken fellow who was deeply sympathetic to the McCanns

Who is he?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: icabodcrane on June 05, 2014, 04:53:20 PM
Who is he?

One of Henri Exton's operatives on the ground in Portugal
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Benice on June 06, 2014, 12:03:27 PM
Whether or not Jane Tanner identified Murat as the man she saw carrying a child that night might be questionable, but,  according to the  'The McCanns and the Conman'  programme last night, what is  not in question is that Jane identified Gail Coopers  'creeyman'   as the child carrier   (   you know,  the one with straggly hair, buck teeth, and a Yosemite Sam moustache  ) 

Henri Exton's team had tracked a fellow who looked similar and taken a photo of him  ( without the moustache )

They presented the photo to Jane and she said ;

""That is the guy I saw carrying a child"

The fellow was eventually ruled out

Exton's  team concluded that Jane Tanner was not a credible witness

A reason why was also given  i.e.  ''Witnesses will be convinced,  thinking that is what they saw - quite often inaccurately.  She so wanted to help - she fooled herself'') (not strictly verbatim)  - which is in line with the following:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/magazine/8617945.stm

One little quote from it:-
 
In a crime situation memory is influenced by many factors such as stress, the presence of a weapon and even just the desire to help police solve the crime. "Police know how fallible the memory can be," says Steve Retford, a former head of the investigative skills unit at GMP and now specialist interviewing adviser with the force.
Unquote

Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: icabodcrane on June 06, 2014, 12:09:01 PM
A reason why was also given  i.e.  ''Witnesses will be convinced,  thinking that is what they saw - quite often inaccurately.  She so wanted to help - she fooled herself'') (not strictly verbatim)  - which is in line with the following:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/magazine/8617945.stm

One little quote from it:-
 
In a crime situation memory is influenced by many factors such as stress, the presence of a weapon and even just the desire to help police solve the crime. "Police know how fallible the memory can be," says Steve Retford, a former head of the investigative skills unit at GMP and now specialist interviewing adviser with the force.
Unquote

Benice,  the reason Exton's team concluded that Jane Tanner was not a credible witness is that she positively identified a man who was subsequently cleared of involvement

She  positively identified  the  WRONG man !

Whatever motivated her into doing so is incidental  ....   the fact that she  did is what makes her an unreliable and non-credible witness
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Benice on June 06, 2014, 12:31:38 PM
Benice,  the reason Exton's team concluded that Jane Tanner was not a credible witness is that she positively identified a man who was subsequently cleared of involvement

She  positively identified  the  WRONG man !

Whatever motivated her into doing so is incidental  ....   the fact that she  did is what makes her an unreliable and non-credible witness

Which makes her no differerent to thousands of other people.    According to Major Tim(?) and the police - this is a common occurrence and is in no way sinister when it comes to witnesses.

However, there is a big difference between actually seeing a man walking away with a child - and looking at a photograph of someone and thinking you recognise him.    Especially if the idea has already entered your head at the time that the picture you are being shown may be him.

Those are general comments Icab - not aimed at you.






Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: icabodcrane on June 06, 2014, 01:11:02 PM
Which makes her no differerent to thousands of other people.    According to Major Tim(?) and the police - this is a common occurrence and is in no way sinister when it comes to witnesses.

However, there is a big difference between actually seeing a man walking away with a child - and looking at a photograph of someone and thinking you recognise him.    Especially if the idea has already entered your head at the time that the picture you are being shown may be him.

Those are general comments Icab - not aimed at you.

Either Jane Tanner is a reliable witness or not 

It was clearly demonstrated that she was  not reliable when she positively identified an innocent man

That was it ...  that was when her credibility as a witness crashed

We can't cherry-pick which parts of her statements were reliable and which were not because her reliability as a witness, in general,  is now in question
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Eleanor on June 06, 2014, 01:18:14 PM
Either Jane Tanner is a reliable witness or not 

It was clearly demonstrated that she was  not reliable when she positively identified an innocent man

That was it ...  that was when her credibility as a witness crashed

We can't cherry-pick which parts of her statements were reliable and which were not because her reliability as a witness, in general,  is now in question

Jane Tanner was never going to be called as a witness anyway.  And nor were any of The Smith.  None of them were frightfully sure about anything.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: jassi on June 06, 2014, 01:22:18 PM
Maybe not, but her recollections were enough to send the McCanns off in the wrong direction for the best part of 7 years.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Eleanor on June 06, 2014, 01:28:02 PM
Maybe not, but her recollections were enough to send the McCanns off in the wrong direction for the best part of 7 years.

Why do you think that?  It was all in the same time frame and in the same area, and there were similarities between what Jane Tanner said and what The Smiths said.  So no one went off in the wrong direction.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on June 06, 2014, 01:38:00 PM
That's the point misty,  Exton's team thought the market trader  might  have  been the same man Gary Williams had help compile an e fit of 

When they showed it to him,  though,  he said it was not  the man he had seen that night   ( the George Harrison loolalike )

Gary Williams was right ...  the market trader was eventually cleared of any involvement

Yet when Jane Tanner was shown the same photo of the  ( innocent )  market trader she said :

"That's the man I saw carrying a child"

If she had been that sure, why would Clarence only say that she thought there was a "strong resemblance"?

The long-haired man seen by Gail Cooper, 50, three times in late April last year, was said by Jane Tanner, a friend of the McCanns, to bear a "strong resemblance" to the man she saw carrying a child in pink pyjamas and bare feet from the complex on May 3, the night Madeleine vanished.

Clarence Mitchell, Kate and Gerry McCann's official spokesman, said that when shown the sketches, Tanner was struck by the likeness to the man she had seen carrying the child she now believes was Madeleine
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2008/01/20/new-details-in-madeleine-_n_82403.html
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: jassi on June 06, 2014, 01:52:30 PM
Why do you think that?  It was all in the same time frame and in the same area, and there were similarities between what Jane Tanner said and what The Smiths said.  So no one went off in the wrong direction.

As I recall, they never linked to two as the same man and pursued Tannerman at the expense of Smithman.
I believe to this day that their site still features Tannerman and not Smithman.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Wonderfulspam on June 06, 2014, 01:58:05 PM
As I recall, they never linked to two as the same man and pursued Tannerman at the expense of Smithman.
I believe to this day that their site still features Tannerman and not Smithman.

Indeed, there is a cover page with Smithdad, but the main site belongs to Bundleman, Spottyman & Posh Spice.

They don't need help identifying Smithdad, they already know who he is, and exactly what he did with her.

Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Carana on June 06, 2014, 03:30:27 PM
Icabod pointed out on another thread that Cooperman was before Georgephotoman. My mistake on that one.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: pegasus on June 06, 2014, 11:27:43 PM
Re the claims by FP and RO and ROB that RM was at the location that night after the alarm. They actually saw not him but a different man helping the search that night who looks similar IMO. All those four witnesses are honest, one was genuinely not there, the other three genuinely but mistakenly thought he was there, they saw a different man actually. All just IMO.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: John on June 08, 2014, 06:10:44 AM
Re the claims by FP and RO and ROB that RM was at the location that night after the alarm. They actually saw not him but a different man helping the search that night who looks similar IMO. All those four witnesses are honest, one was genuinely not there, the other three genuinely but mistakenly thought he was there, they saw a different man actually. All just IMO.

I go with that, they were simply confused.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: John on June 08, 2014, 06:13:00 AM
Why do you think that?  It was all in the same time frame and in the same area, and there were similarities between what Jane Tanner said and what The Smiths said.  So no one went off in the wrong direction.

Tanner's report of bundleman sent the dog teams off to the north east thus allowing the real perp to get clean away in the south.  This is confirmed by the maps showing the dogs search zones now compared to those searched in 2007.
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Brietta on June 08, 2014, 08:09:35 AM
Tanner's report of bundleman sent the dog teams off to the north east thus allowing the real perp to get clean away in the south.  This is confirmed by the maps showing the dogs search zones now compared to those searched in 2007.

The police decided which areas would be searched. 
It is entirely their responsibility and nothing at all to do with Jane Tanner, who was a civilian. 

IMO it would have been logical to check out locations close to each sighting for the purposes of elimination.  Perhaps that had been the original intent ... but time was spent in trying to prove the Dr McCanns' guilt ... and perhaps Mr Murat's ... rather than investigating other suspects 
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: slartibartfast on June 09, 2014, 01:41:47 AM
The police decided which areas would be searched. 
It is entirely their responsibility and nothing at all to do with Jane Tanner, who was a civilian. 



Are you seriously suggesting that the police should ignore witnesses and do heir own thing?
Title: Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
Post by: Brietta on June 09, 2014, 02:20:01 AM
Are you seriously suggesting that the police should ignore witnesses and do heir own thing?

I have suggested no such thing.