Cadaver dogs are unreliable - Eugene Zapata

[Vertigo Swirl]

Did Eddie alert in the toilet?

Was he take into the toilet?

[Angelo222]

Reliable or not, the dog alerts in only an apartment used by the McCanns and to clothing owned by them is a damning result. The only thing missing is an actual cadaver.

[barrier]

Was he take into the toilet?

If as suggested he alerts to urine the toilet is where his nose would have led surely.

[Vertigo Swirl]

If as suggested he alerts to urine the toilet is where his nose would have led surely.

Unless the door was closed and he was dissuaded from showing interest in there?

[barrier]

Unless the door was closed and he was dissuaded from showing interest in there?

It also could be because no one peed on the floor,not forgetting the cleaners,who one would hope do a decent job,unlike cadaver which can't be washed away.


           
"Cadaver scent cannot readily be removed by cleaning as the compounds adhere to surfaces."

[Eleanor]

Reliable or not, the dog alerts in only an apartment used by the McCanns and to clothing owned by them is a damning result. The only thing missing is an actual cadaver.

Goodness, who'd a thought it?  The only thing of any importance wasn't there.

[Eleanor]

It also could be because no one peed on the floor,not forgetting the cleaners,who one would hope do a decent job,unlike cadaver which can't be washed away.


           
"Cadaver scent cannot readily be removed by cleaning as the compounds adhere to surfaces."

Whose Cadaver?

[Montclair]

Reliable or not, the dog alerts in only an apartment used by the McCanns and to clothing owned by them is a damning result. The only thing missing is an actual cadaver.

So right you are. If the dogs were so unreliable and alerted to almost anything with blood, why didn't they alert in any of the other houses, apartments and cars?

[barrier]

Whose Cadaver?

Perhaps I should have made it clear the quotation marks were some one else's words,M Grimes in this instance,as for whose cadaver? whom ever it came from in 5a,yet to be established.

[Eleanor]

Perhaps I should have made it clear the quotation marks were some one else's words,M Grimes in this instance,as for whose cadaver? whom ever it came from in 5a,yet to be established.

Sorry, I thought we were talking about Bianca Jones.  Did they find her corpse?

[Vertigo Swirl]

So right you are. If the dogs were so unreliable and alerted to almost anything with blood, why didn't they alert in any of the other houses, apartments and cars?

Given that Eddie does alert to blood, it's a bloody good question.

[barrier]

Sorry, I thought we were talking about Bianca Jones.  Did they find her corpse?

Unlikely.

"The prosecution claimed Lane took the dead child from his home and disposed of her remains in an incinerator"


https://www.mlive.com/news/detroit/index.ssf/2018/01/years_after_father_convicted_i.html

[Mr Gray]

Reliable or not, the dog alerts in only an apartment used by the McCanns and to clothing owned by them is a damning result. The only thing missing is an actual cadaver.

Ive explained this several times...take the car...the dog ignored the car as he ignored the other cars but was only brought back to the mccanns car.....in the apartment the dog ignored sites until called back...this only happened in teh mccanns apartment...a cadaver is missing because there was never one there.....imo.
when did death occurr and allow time for cadaver odour to develop....between 8.30 and 10....just about impossible...do the math.

[Eleanor]

Unlikely.

"The prosecution claimed Lane took the dead child from his home and disposed of her remains in an incinerator"


https://www.mlive.com/news/detroit/index.ssf/2018/01/years_after_father_convicted_i.html

They know that for a fact, do they?

[Mr Gray]

So right you are. If the dogs were so unreliable and alerted to almost anything with blood, why didn't they alert in any of the other houses, apartments and cars?

note i have expalined this...then we have possible unconcious cuing by Grime