Author Topic: Thoughts on the case. Setting up familial DNA databases  (Read 25556 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline jassi

Re: Thoughts on the case. Setting up familial DNA databases
« Reply #45 on: December 30, 2018, 12:00:14 PM »
The initial report appeared to confuse Stuart whatshisname as well.

An amended report gave a different interpretation.
I believe everything. And l believe nothing.
I suspect everyone. And l suspect no one.
I gather the facts, examine the clues... and before   you know it, the case is solved!"

Or maybe not -

OG have been pushed out by the Germans who have reserved all the deck chairs for the foreseeable future

Offline Eleanor

Re: Thoughts on the case. Setting up familial DNA databases
« Reply #46 on: December 30, 2018, 12:01:11 PM »
They take to test for phenylketonuria and a thyroid disorder.
This is a national screening program and samples are stored for several years.
Provided that there is sufficient sample, other tests can be carried out if considered necessary.

Thank you, I didn't even know that.  But not a bad thing.

It's what they can do with it later that might bother me.

I was never asked for my consent, which is basically all that I would see fit to complain about.  I would give my consent for my own DNA to be taken.  But it has to be freely given, and not just taken after someone is dead, or when they are first born.

Offline Robittybob1

Re: Thoughts on the case. Setting up familial DNA databases
« Reply #47 on: December 30, 2018, 12:13:32 PM »
Not the same thing, Rob.  If that is your One in a Billion then Amaral was indeed totally ignorant of any understanding of DNA.
No that wasn't the 1 in a billion example.  As I said earlier I've been listening to hundreds of YouTube videos on murder cases and the ratio was mentioned in one (can't recall which one sorry).

https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2016/06/a-reasonable-doubt/480747/
"When a forensic analyst compares alleles at 13 locations—the standard for most labs—the odds of two unrelated people matching at all of them are less than one in 1 billion."

The McCann analysis was based on 10 locations, but I read that some labs are checking 20 locations.
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

Offline Eleanor

Re: Thoughts on the case. Setting up familial DNA databases
« Reply #48 on: December 30, 2018, 12:14:52 PM »
The initial report appeared to confuse Stuart whatshisname as well.

An amended report gave a different interpretation.

So even relatively intelligent people can be confused.  God help us all if it is left to your average Jury.

Perhaps I should have taken up The Law after all.

Offline Eleanor

Re: Thoughts on the case. Setting up familial DNA databases
« Reply #49 on: December 30, 2018, 12:18:24 PM »
No that wasn't the 1 in a billion example.  As I said earlier I've been listening to hundreds of YouTube videos on murder cases and the ratio was mentioned in one (can't recall which one sorry).

https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2016/06/a-reasonable-doubt/480747/
"When a forensic analyst compares alleles at 13 locations—the standard for most labs—the odds of two unrelated people matching at all of them are less than one in 1 billion."

The McCann analysis was based on 10 locations, but I read that some labs are checking 20 locations.

So some people do have the same DNA.  This is what I want to know about.  Why is no one saying?

Offline jassi

Re: Thoughts on the case. Setting up familial DNA databases
« Reply #50 on: December 30, 2018, 12:26:57 PM »
So some people do have the same DNA.  This is what I want to know about.  Why is no one saying?

I very much doubt that people have identical DNA (except identical twins), but analysis does not normally process the whole of the genome, but relies on a limited number of markers.
Using only these markers, there may well be people who appear to have the same DNA
I believe everything. And l believe nothing.
I suspect everyone. And l suspect no one.
I gather the facts, examine the clues... and before   you know it, the case is solved!"

Or maybe not -

OG have been pushed out by the Germans who have reserved all the deck chairs for the foreseeable future

Offline Eleanor

Re: Thoughts on the case. Setting up familial DNA databases
« Reply #51 on: December 30, 2018, 12:33:08 PM »
I very much doubt that people have identical DNA (except identical twins), but analysis does not normally process the whole of the genome, but relies on a limited number of markers.
Using only these markers, there may well be people who appear to have the same DNA

Relying on a limited number of markers is simply not good enough.  DNA is a flawed science.  Especially when someone's life can depend upon it.

Not that I am about to start campaigning.  But I might hope someone would if I was unjustly accused.

I won't bother to go into The American Justice System, but a few DNA mistakes have been made there.

Offline barrier

Re: Thoughts on the case. Setting up familial DNA databases
« Reply #52 on: December 30, 2018, 12:53:54 PM »
Of course there should be more, Rob, and often there is.  But not always.  The lack of an alibi can sometimes hang someone.

Just how many people in the world do have the same DNA?  And why?  No one seems to have addressed this.  It's no good telling me One in a Million, or even One in a Billion.  There is a Doubt however small.


Russel Bishop was recently convicted because of the one in a billion chance.

Quote
Karen’s mother Michelle Hadaway, 61, attended every day of both the 1987 and the 2018 trials, and was in court to watch Bishop finally be convicted of killing her daughter, after advances in DNA profiling allowed forensic scientists to link him to the crime with a one-in-a-billion chance of error.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/babes-in-the-wood-murders-russell-bishop-guilty-trial-karen-hadaway-nicola-fellows-court-old-bailey-a8662526.html


With  circa 66 million residing in the uk,what chance it was anyone else?
« Last Edit: December 30, 2018, 12:58:03 PM by barrier »
This is my own private domicile and I shall not be harassed, biatch:Jesse Pinkman Character.

Offline Eleanor

Re: Thoughts on the case. Setting up familial DNA databases
« Reply #53 on: December 30, 2018, 01:30:26 PM »

Russel Bishop was recently convicted because of the one in a billion chance.
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/babes-in-the-wood-murders-russell-bishop-guilty-trial-karen-hadaway-nicola-fellows-court-old-bailey-a8662526.html


With  circa 66 million residing in the uk,what chance it was anyone else?

Thank you for the Cite, Barrier.  But that conviction didn't depend on a One in a Billion hit on Forensic DNA.   More on other Forensics.  So there was much more to it, as there should be.

Offline barrier

Re: Thoughts on the case. Setting up familial DNA databases
« Reply #54 on: December 30, 2018, 02:58:18 PM »
Thank you for the Cite, Barrier.  But that conviction didn't depend on a One in a Billion hit on Forensic DNA.   More on other Forensics.  So there was much more to it, as there should be.


The quoted piece says other wise.

Quote
Karen’s mother Michelle Hadaway, 61, attended every day of both the 1987 and the 2018 trials, and was in court to watch Bishop finally be convicted of killing her daughter, after advances in DNA profiling allowed forensic scientists to link him to the crime with a one-in-a-billion chance of error.
This is my own private domicile and I shall not be harassed, biatch:Jesse Pinkman Character.

Offline Eleanor

Re: Thoughts on the case. Setting up familial DNA databases
« Reply #55 on: December 30, 2018, 03:02:57 PM »

The quoted piece says other wise.

There was more to it, whether you like it or not.

Offline Brietta

Re: Thoughts on the case. Setting up familial DNA databases
« Reply #56 on: December 30, 2018, 03:56:25 PM »
https://www.watersheddna.com/blog-and-news/stemcelltransplantgedmatch


October 29, 2017
DNA Testing After a Stem Cell Transplant: a Fascinating Case
General Information
When you have an allogeneic bone marrow or stem cell transplant, the blood-producing cells in your bone marrow are killed off by radiation or chemotherapy and then replaced with functioning cells from another person. The technical term for this process is allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation.

In allogeneic transplants, DNA from your “donor” (the person donating the replacement cells to you) travels along inside the cells that get transplanted, and you become a chimera at that point. (A transplant with your own cells is called an autologous ["self proportion"] transplant and does not affect your DNA makeup). After a donor’s cell take root in your body, you now have two separate sets of DNA represented in your tissues. Which results come back when you have a DNA test after your transplant depends on which cells get tested. The complexity of this situation makes it easy to understand how this has become the storyline of more than one crime scene investigation show on TV!

This type of acquired chimerism is distinct from the rare form chimerism present at birth -- congenital chimerism. Congenital chimerism happens when someone is born already having two distinct sets of DNA. It is thought to be caused by fraternal twin embryos joining early on in pregnancy to form one person. In a way, it is the inverse of identical twinning, when one egg splits into two. Congenital chimerism has only been documented in a few cases including the well-publicized case of Lydia Fairchild and one case I was involved in professionally just a few years ago, described in this Time magazine article here.

Acquired chimerism is growing more and more common with stem cell transplants being an available treatment for a number of conditions like lymphoma, leukemia, and sickle cell disease. Some hypothesize that the rise in fertility treatments for pregnancy conception might also be increasing the number of individuals born with congenital chimerism (due to increased twinning rates at conception); however, this theory has yet to be studied and tested.

Doing DNA testing on people who have already had a stem cell or bone marrow transplant can get tricky. Because there is interaction between the blood stream and types of cells lining the cheeks and because cells from your blood stream can get into your saliva, we actually can find both sets of DNA when we do a test on saliva or a cheek swab. Per multiple testing companies, this often causes the test to result in “failure” for many people who have been through a transplant.

Here's what 23andMe wrote in response to a customer question on the topic:

"If you have received a bone marrow transplant, we cannot recommend that you use the 23andMe® Personal Genetic Service (Ancestry Service or Health & Ancestry Service).

The saliva sample required to receive the 23andMe Personal Genetic Service includes DNA from multiple cell sources, including epithelial cells from your cheeks and mouth and white blood cells from your saliva. As a bone marrow recipient, your blood cells will contain the DNA from your marrow donor, while your epithelial cells contain your own DNA. The combination of DNA sources frequently results in analysis failure. In the event that the analysis was successful, it still would be unclear whether the results were based on DNA from you or from your donor."

What I recently learned is that in some cases, the sample doesn’t fail! I had a gentleman ("Tom") reach out to me who had tested both prior to and after his stem cell transplant. When he took the raw data from his pre- and post-transplant DNA tests to the website GEDmatch.com and ran analysis of his DNA against other people in his family, the results were surprising. And yet, knowing the history of his transplant and who in his family was his donor, the results were not surprising. They actually made a lot of sense!

I am going to show you how this gentleman matched two people in his family along chromosome number 1, and I want you to guess which family member -- his sister or his son -- was his stem cell donor.

If you are new to learning about GEDmatch, this is going to be more challenging for you! But hang around and give it a try. You might be able to figure it out even if you’ve never used GEDmatch before.

Tom and his sister before the transplant

Screen Shot 2017-10-26 at 11.16.02 PM.png
Tom and his sister after the transplant

Screen Shot 2017-10-26 at 11.22.02 PM.png
Tom and his son before the transplant

Screen Shot 2017-10-26 at 11.25.02 PM.png
Tom and his son after the transplant

Screen Shot 2017-10-26 at 11.25.59 PM.png
Here's a key to understanding the color coding in GEDmatch:

Screen Shot 2017-10-26 at 11.16.15 PM.png
Did you figure it out?

Tom’s sister was his donor! So now Tom is a chimera, with some of the DNA he was born with and his own sister’s DNA present in some of his cells. All that we see in his raw data file now, however, is his sister's DNA.

Tom was happy to share his story but has a word of advice:

“
If I had one thing to tell people going through a transplant, it would be to have a DNA test done prior to the transplant for history’s sake.
If you wait until after a transplant and then try to do a DNA test like 23andMe or AncestryDNA, you might forever lose the opportunity to have a true reflection of the DNA you were born with. This also means you may lose out on the opportunity to explore how your DNA matches other people, including your children, siblings, and future generations.
Fascinating!

So logical when you think about it.
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

Offline barrier

Re: Thoughts on the case. Setting up familial DNA databases
« Reply #57 on: December 30, 2018, 05:01:28 PM »
There was more to it, whether you like it or not.


The court of appeal allowed a new trial because of new DNA evidence, this new DNA evidence convicted him.


Quote
The Court of Appeal had ordered a fresh trial in light of new DNA evidence after Bishop was cleared of the girls' murders in 1987.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2018/10/30/man-accused-murdering-two-school-girls-1986-points-finger-blame/

Quote
A sweatshirt discarded on his route home linked him to the scene while a sample from Karen's left forearm revealed a "one in a billion" DNA match, his second trial was told.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-sussex-46528206
This is my own private domicile and I shall not be harassed, biatch:Jesse Pinkman Character.

Offline Robittybob1

Re: Thoughts on the case. Setting up familial DNA databases
« Reply #58 on: December 30, 2018, 05:39:21 PM »
So some people do have the same DNA.  This is what I want to know about.  Why is no one saying?

The ratios are based on unrelated people having the same DNA.  I was beginning to think that in small locations and communities there could be a degree of relatedness that is not accounted for in the overall incidence of the alleles.

You have probably heard jokes about the amount of inbreeding going on in the smaller communities.  Since they are only looking at a few points of DNA difference there can be more than 1 match e.g cousins could match as happened in one case.

« Last Edit: December 30, 2018, 05:51:14 PM by Robittybob1 »
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

Offline jassi

Re: Thoughts on the case. Setting up familial DNA databases
« Reply #59 on: December 30, 2018, 06:03:14 PM »

The court of appeal allowed a new trial because of new DNA evidence, this new DNA evidence convicted him.


https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2018/10/30/man-accused-murdering-two-school-girls-1986-points-finger-blame/

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-sussex-46528206

So it would appear that the new DNA analysis was conclusive and nailed him.
I believe everything. And l believe nothing.
I suspect everyone. And l suspect no one.
I gather the facts, examine the clues... and before   you know it, the case is solved!"

Or maybe not -

OG have been pushed out by the Germans who have reserved all the deck chairs for the foreseeable future